Miles for throw away segment ticket on a through flight
#1
Original Poster




Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: SJC
Programs: AS MVP
Posts: 2,131
Miles for throw away segment ticket on a through flight
Does anyone have experience with throw away segment on a through flight?
MSY-SFO-LAX on a through flight. I intend to fly only MSY-SFO. Would I still get miles for MSY-SFO? MSY-SFO is actually longer than MSY-LAX. There's a change of aircraft, but I believe UA probably issues one coupon for the through flight.
MSY-SFO-LAX on a through flight. I intend to fly only MSY-SFO. Would I still get miles for MSY-SFO? MSY-SFO is actually longer than MSY-LAX. There's a change of aircraft, but I believe UA probably issues one coupon for the through flight.
#3
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: May 2001
Posts: 11,703
I guess the possibilities (in the order likelihood in my guess) are:
1 - no credit - segment in PNR marked no show
2 - MSY-LAX (full credit)
3 - MSY-SFO (segment flown)
#4




Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: LAX
Programs: UA-1K, Hertz-Gold, Marriott-Gold, PC-Platinum, SPG
Posts: 2,777
Does anyone have experience with throw away segment on a through flight?
MSY-SFO-LAX on a through flight. I intend to fly only MSY-SFO. Would I still get miles for MSY-SFO? MSY-SFO is actually longer than MSY-LAX. There's a change of aircraft, but I believe UA probably issues one coupon for the through flight.
MSY-SFO-LAX on a through flight. I intend to fly only MSY-SFO. Would I still get miles for MSY-SFO? MSY-SFO is actually longer than MSY-LAX. There's a change of aircraft, but I believe UA probably issues one coupon for the through flight.
If two segments, then, yes, will get the MSY-SFO credit.
If one single segment on the PNR, then, most likely not. YMMV.
#5
Moderator: United Airlines




Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: SFO
Programs: UA LT Plat 2MM, Hyatt Discoverist, Marriott LT Gold, Hilton Silver, IHG Plat
Posts: 73,134
If ticketed MSY-SFO-LAX but getting off at SFO, you will be credited for MSY-SFO but not SFO-LAX. The single flight number has no impact (on UA).
(note if continued to LAX, the credit would be MSY-SFO + SFO-LAX.)
Regardless if there is a plane change in SFO, all passengers will leave the plane at SFO and those continuing will then board the new flight. If passagner does not board the SFO-LAX flight, there will be no credit for that flight.
(note if continued to LAX, the credit would be MSY-SFO + SFO-LAX.)
Regardless if there is a plane change in SFO, all passengers will leave the plane at SFO and those continuing will then board the new flight. If passagner does not board the SFO-LAX flight, there will be no credit for that flight.
#6
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: PSM
Posts: 69,232
The OP will get credit for MSY-SFO and not for SFO-LAX so long as it is credited to UA, just like I wrote above. :-:
#7
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: May 2001
Posts: 11,703
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/unite...l-mileage.html
The OP will get credit for MSY-SFO and not for SFO-LAX so long as it is credited to UA, just like I wrote above. :-:
The OP will get credit for MSY-SFO and not for SFO-LAX so long as it is credited to UA, just like I wrote above. :-:
The system must keep track of the 2 boardings to perform this logic. If the OP boards at MSY but does not board at SFO, would the system:
1 - consider the single segment in the PNR no show and award no miles?
2 - award only the MSY-SFO miles?
3 - award the PNR's MSY-LAX miles?
#8
Moderator: United Airlines




Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: SFO
Programs: UA LT Plat 2MM, Hyatt Discoverist, Marriott LT Gold, Hilton Silver, IHG Plat
Posts: 73,134
To me, the question IS the throw-away segment. I just went through that whole thread and I don't see any discussion on the situation.
The system must keep track of the 2 boardings to perform this logic. If the OP boards at MSY but does not board at SFO, would the system:
1 - consider the single segment in the PNR no show and award no miles?
2 - award only the MSY-SFO miles?
3 - award the PNR's MSY-LAX miles?
The system must keep track of the 2 boardings to perform this logic. If the OP boards at MSY but does not board at SFO, would the system:
1 - consider the single segment in the PNR no show and award no miles?
2 - award only the MSY-SFO miles?
3 - award the PNR's MSY-LAX miles?
#9
Suspended
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: DCA
Programs: UA US CO AA DL FL
Posts: 50,253
Presuming one flight #, but aircraft change @ SFO, OP will receive two BP. The second BP will be marked "through passenger MSY-LAX." Either way, remember no checked luggage as UA won't short-check to SFO.
#10
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: May 2001
Posts: 11,703
Yes but there is only 1 segment in the PNR and if he flew the entire trip, only 1 credit consisting of the MSY-SFO+SFO-LAX miles. So:
PNR/Ticket Coupon segment = MSY-LAX
Boarded/flown segment = MSY-SFO
No show segment = SFO-LAX
What will the system do?
I hear that you are saying the skipped SFO-LAX will not be revelent.
What I wonder is that if the SFO-LAX no show will end up marking MSY-LAX as no show - thus no credit.
PNR/Ticket Coupon segment = MSY-LAX
Boarded/flown segment = MSY-SFO
No show segment = SFO-LAX
What will the system do?
I hear that you are saying the skipped SFO-LAX will not be revelent.
What I wonder is that if the SFO-LAX no show will end up marking MSY-LAX as no show - thus no credit.
#11
Moderator: United Airlines




Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: SFO
Programs: UA LT Plat 2MM, Hyatt Discoverist, Marriott LT Gold, Hilton Silver, IHG Plat
Posts: 73,134
all evidence suggest UA handles this as separate segments -- besides the 2 BPs, and the accumulated mileage, there is another thing to consider is prior to day of travel, direct flights require both segments to clear for upgrades but day of travel either segment can clear separately. So day of travel the system see a direct flight as two separate segments.
#12
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: May 2001
Posts: 11,703
and why do you think this will happen? Anything to based the question on?
all evidence suggest UA handles this as separate segments -- besides the 2 BPs, and the accumulated mileage, there is another thing to consider is prior to day of travel, direct flights require both segments to clear for upgrades but day of travel either segment can clear separately. So day of travel the system see a direct flight as two separate segments.
all evidence suggest UA handles this as separate segments -- besides the 2 BPs, and the accumulated mileage, there is another thing to consider is prior to day of travel, direct flights require both segments to clear for upgrades but day of travel either segment can clear separately. So day of travel the system see a direct flight as two separate segments.
I have the assumption that PNR segments correspond to FFP segments. Obviously there is some kind of parent-child segment structure in the reservation/DCS side to support multi-leg single flight number flights. I just don't know how they get rolled back into the FFP system for crediting if the OP only does 1 leg of the flight and it does not match the ticket and PNR.
On the system I know, the DCS generates a file for the FFP when the flight is closed. Unfortunately, that is all I know and it is not UA's system.
In this case, would FastAir generate the file (or the equivalent) for MSY-SFO or MSY-SFO+MSY-LAX when the flight is closed at MSY? To me, the MSY-LAX file should not be generated until SFO departure and the OP would not be in the MSY-SFO file.
#13




Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Los Angeles, CA; Philadelphia, PA
Programs: FA
Posts: 6,483
Just out of curiosity, what if OP decides to claim credit for the throw-away segment? How can UA prove that he/she wasn't on the flight? How can OP prove that he/she was on the flight?
LAX
LAX
#14
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Bay Area, CA
Programs: UA Plat 2MM; AS MVP Gold 75K
Posts: 35,092
I have two (2) conflicting data points on this, but not using throwaway, rather VDB and authorized reroute. I suspect that this was a function of how the respective agents handled it.
Example 1: MUC-SFO (1-stop ORD). VDB on ORD-SFO, rebooked ORD-SMF, all miles posted MUC-ORD-SMF.
Example 2: STT-IAD (1-stop SJU). VDB on SJU-IAD, rebooked next day SJU-IAD. Got miles SJU-IAD, but never got miles STT-SJU.
So I think there's some merit behind what username is trying to say, in that the lack of presence on SFO-LAX may void the entire coupon (and the mileage posting entirely).
Example 1: MUC-SFO (1-stop ORD). VDB on ORD-SFO, rebooked ORD-SMF, all miles posted MUC-ORD-SMF.
Example 2: STT-IAD (1-stop SJU). VDB on SJU-IAD, rebooked next day SJU-IAD. Got miles SJU-IAD, but never got miles STT-SJU.
So I think there's some merit behind what username is trying to say, in that the lack of presence on SFO-LAX may void the entire coupon (and the mileage posting entirely).
#15




Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: AA Gold/Million Miler,DL dirt,UA1K/Million Miler;Honors Silver,Marriott Gold;Avis Preferred,Hertz Prez Circle, Nat'l Exec Elite
Posts: 1,429
If you go ahead with that scenerio and all for just 500 miles/1 seg, then wouldn't you run the risk of being charged extra for skipping the last segment?(If there was much of a price difference btw MSY-SFO vs LAX). The credit for the last segment will only show after you hand over your BP to the GA and they scan it, so I don't see how you can try to claim credit on a "no-show".

