Is Global Entry worthwhile?
#3151
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: WAS
Programs: AMEX Platinum, Global Entry, Priority Pass, SPG Gold, HHonors Gold
Posts: 1,594
The one thing that I am not sure about is how identity is verified for the new program. GlobalEntry members use biometrics captured during the interview (namely, fingerprints). But the new program kiosks do not seem to use fingerprinting. So, what would prevent somebody from inserting somebody else's passport, running through the questions, and printing a receipt with that person's details and then walking through? (especially if the officers at the Customs exit do not always check the kiosk receipt against the passport ID page) Global Entry members could not get away with it because of the fingerprint check, but the average traveler is different...no biometrics on file for many travelers.
#3152
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: May 2002
Location: NYC, USA
Programs: AA EXP 3MM, Lifetime Platinum, Marriott Titanium, HH Gold
Posts: 11,049
How is that any different from what happens already at Primary? As I remember from going through inspection before I became GE, here is how it went:
1) Primary officer takes and swipes passport. (2 seconds)
2) Officer glances at screen to look at my record (3 seconds)
3) Officer writes a "1" and circles it on my paper declaration form. (1 second)
4) Officer stamps passport (sometimes, sometimes not) and customs form. (1-2 seconds)
5) Officer says "welcome back." (1 second)
Seriously! In the vast majority of cases, once I reached an officer, I was through in 10-15 seconds or less. VERY occasionally, the officer might ask "how long were you away?" or "what is your occupation?" But usually just Swipe, Glance at screen, Write a 1, Stamp, Welcome back.
Not sure how the kiosk is saving time, unless the Primary inspections have become more involved in the past five years. I also wonder if it might add to headaches for weary travelers just getting off long flights who might not be tech-savvy in using a kiosk. Especially for older travelers, or those with a language barrier.
#3153




Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: London; Bangkok; Las Vegas
Programs: AA Exec Plat; UA MM Gold; Marriott Lifetime Titanium; Hilton Diamond
Posts: 8,880
How is that any different from what happens already at Primary? As I remember from going through inspection before I became GE, here is how it went:
1) Primary officer takes and swipes passport. (2 seconds)
2) Officer glances at screen to look at my record (3 seconds)
3) Officer writes a "1" and circles it on my paper declaration form. (1 second)
4) Officer stamps passport (sometimes, sometimes not) and customs form. (1-2 seconds)
5) Officer says "welcome back." (1 second)
Seriously! In the vast majority of cases, once I reached an officer, I was through in 10-15 seconds or less. VERY occasionally, the officer might ask "how long were you away?" or "what is your occupation?" But usually just Swipe, Glance at screen, Write a 1, Stamp, Welcome back.
Not sure how the kiosk is saving time, unless the Primary inspections have become more involved in the past five years. I also wonder if it might add to headaches for weary travelers just getting off long flights who might not be tech-savvy in using a kiosk. Especially for older travelers, or those with a language barrier.
1) Primary officer takes and swipes passport. (2 seconds)
2) Officer glances at screen to look at my record (3 seconds)
3) Officer writes a "1" and circles it on my paper declaration form. (1 second)
4) Officer stamps passport (sometimes, sometimes not) and customs form. (1-2 seconds)
5) Officer says "welcome back." (1 second)
Seriously! In the vast majority of cases, once I reached an officer, I was through in 10-15 seconds or less. VERY occasionally, the officer might ask "how long were you away?" or "what is your occupation?" But usually just Swipe, Glance at screen, Write a 1, Stamp, Welcome back.
Not sure how the kiosk is saving time, unless the Primary inspections have become more involved in the past five years. I also wonder if it might add to headaches for weary travelers just getting off long flights who might not be tech-savvy in using a kiosk. Especially for older travelers, or those with a language barrier.
#3154




Join Date: May 2011
Location: SFO
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 721
Are the line wardens at ORD ensuring general US passport holders aren't trying to use the GE kiosks? (I'm not sure of the locations of the different kiosks as I have not cleared at ORD since the new kiosks were installed.)
#3155
Join Date: Jan 2013
Programs: UA 1K, Hilton Gold, Marriott Gold
Posts: 304
Thus far, I can't say I'm terribly impressed with the program
#3156



Join Date: May 2009
Location: Washington, DC
Programs: UA Plat & 1MM, AA, DL
Posts: 8,707
#3157



Join Date: May 2009
Location: Washington, DC
Programs: UA Plat & 1MM, AA, DL
Posts: 8,707
Unless the signs are new, there used to be a gate that looked like something you shouldn't go through, but above there's a sign that says "Global Entry and Crew" (or something) - you just have to push through the swinging gate.
#3158
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Danville, CA, USA;
Programs: UA 1MM, WN CP, Marriott LT Plat, Hilton Gold, IC Plat
Posts: 18,104
Not sure how the kiosk is saving time, unless the Primary inspections have become more involved in the past five years. I also wonder if it might add to headaches for weary travelers just getting off long flights who might not be tech-savvy in using a kiosk. Especially for older travelers, or those with a language barrier.
As for older travelers I have relatives in their 70s and none have complained about the complexity of the machine, which is probably easier to use than an ATM. They all have iPhones too.

The only time I have seen a queue (extremely rare) was when 2 or more of the SFO kiosks were out of service. At IAH I saw something like a dozen kiosks so no line even with higher passenger volume.
#3159




Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: PHX
Posts: 4,815
Our family did our global entry all at once. For the kids, they did not take fingerprints or do a kiosk demonstration. They said it wasn't "necessary.". Seemed weird, but they were insistent.
Sure enough, when entering the USA for the first time and trying to use the kiosks, the kds were bounced and told to see an officer. It was a bit of a mess, because nobody knew the procedure for what to do when part of a family clears at the kiosk, but some don't. They made me fill out a card for the whole family and then stapled our two GE receipts to it. The guy at customs was befuddled when he saw that but ultimately let us through.
Any advice what to do? The kids are definitely GE enrolled, because they have GE cards and tsa pre gives them three beeps. Should we just try to wlk in to an interview location and see if they can take biometric data or otherwise get it so the kiosks work?
Sure enough, when entering the USA for the first time and trying to use the kiosks, the kds were bounced and told to see an officer. It was a bit of a mess, because nobody knew the procedure for what to do when part of a family clears at the kiosk, but some don't. They made me fill out a card for the whole family and then stapled our two GE receipts to it. The guy at customs was befuddled when he saw that but ultimately let us through.
Any advice what to do? The kids are definitely GE enrolled, because they have GE cards and tsa pre gives them three beeps. Should we just try to wlk in to an interview location and see if they can take biometric data or otherwise get it so the kiosks work?
#3160




Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: PDX (wish I was in HNL)
Programs: 1K
Posts: 1,692
Our family did our global entry all at once. For the kids, they did not take fingerprints or do a kiosk demonstration. They said it wasn't "necessary.". Seemed weird, but they were insistent.
Sure enough, when entering the USA for the first time and trying to use the kiosks, the kds were bounced and told to see an officer. It was a bit of a mess, because nobody knew the procedure for what to do when part of a family clears at the kiosk, but some don't. They made me fill out a card for the whole family and then stapled our two GE receipts to it. The guy at customs was befuddled when he saw that but ultimately let us through.
Any advice what to do? The kids are definitely GE enrolled, because they have GE cards and tsa pre gives them three beeps. Should we just try to wlk in to an interview location and see if they can take biometric data or otherwise get it so the kiosks work?
Sure enough, when entering the USA for the first time and trying to use the kiosks, the kds were bounced and told to see an officer. It was a bit of a mess, because nobody knew the procedure for what to do when part of a family clears at the kiosk, but some don't. They made me fill out a card for the whole family and then stapled our two GE receipts to it. The guy at customs was befuddled when he saw that but ultimately let us through.
Any advice what to do? The kids are definitely GE enrolled, because they have GE cards and tsa pre gives them three beeps. Should we just try to wlk in to an interview location and see if they can take biometric data or otherwise get it so the kiosks work?
#3161
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Southern CT & Phoenix, AZ
Programs: UA Premier Gold, Hyatt Plat, Hilton Silver, Marriott Gold
Posts: 237
GOES document updates
I am in the process of getting my passport renewed and see that I can update the document number and expiry dates online in my GOES account.
My driver license also needs to be renewed in the next few months but I don't see a similar place to update that document in GOES. What will happen when my current license expires in GOES and how do I update it? Will this block me from using GE or TSA_Pre? Do I have to go to an enrollment center with my new license - hope not?
Thanks to anyone who can offer guidance from experience.
My driver license also needs to be renewed in the next few months but I don't see a similar place to update that document in GOES. What will happen when my current license expires in GOES and how do I update it? Will this block me from using GE or TSA_Pre? Do I have to go to an enrollment center with my new license - hope not?
Thanks to anyone who can offer guidance from experience.
#3162



Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: BUR/LAX
Programs: UA 1K/2MM, HHonors Diamond, IHG Diamond Elite
Posts: 2,510
I am in the process of getting my passport renewed and see that I can update the document number and expiry dates online in my GOES account.
My driver license also needs to be renewed in the next few months but I don't see a similar place to update that document in GOES. What will happen when my current license expires in GOES and how do I update it? Will this block me from using GE or TSA_Pre? Do I have to go to an enrollment center with my new license - hope not?
Thanks to anyone who can offer guidance from experience.
My driver license also needs to be renewed in the next few months but I don't see a similar place to update that document in GOES. What will happen when my current license expires in GOES and how do I update it? Will this block me from using GE or TSA_Pre? Do I have to go to an enrollment center with my new license - hope not?
Thanks to anyone who can offer guidance from experience.
#3163




Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: PHX
Posts: 4,815
How old are your kids? Mine were 12 and 8 when they got GE, and they had to give their fingerprints at the interview. They use the kiosk fine (well, except for the youngest with the kiosk picture. He's short, and has to back up quite a distance). I would get an appointment (doesn't PHX have an interview site?) and bring the kids.
#3164


Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: AMS
Programs: A number, but no status no more
Posts: 3,050
GenevaFlyer

