TSA to require birthdate at time of reservation
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 1,236
TSA to require birthdate at time of reservation
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,155541,00.html
This will allow them make sure you are not confused with a terrorist with the same name.
In reality it will give terorist the opportunity to give a false date of birth since it won't be verified and hassle hundreds of millions of honest folks.
This will allow them make sure you are not confused with a terrorist with the same name.
In reality it will give terorist the opportunity to give a false date of birth since it won't be verified and hassle hundreds of millions of honest folks.
#2


Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: BWI
Programs: AA PLT and that's that!
Posts: 8,350
As part of the Transportation Security Administration's (search) effort to implement Secure Flight, the agency will, within weeks, require airlines to solicit passengers' full names and birth dates. Passengers do not have to provide it, but if they don't there's a better chance they'll have to undergo more stringent screening at the airport, said Justin Oberman, the TSA official who heads the program.
What a crock of s**t! It isn't supposed to happen until later this year but they are going to start asking for the information now. If you don't comply, you get extra screening.
This organization needs to be stopped!
Last edited by tazi; May 5, 2005 at 8:25 am
#3
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: May 2000
Location: أمريكا
Posts: 26,931
Originally Posted by jerry crump
In reality it will give terorist the opportunity to give a false date of birth since it won't be verified and hassle hundreds of millions of honest folks.
#4




Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Los Angeles, CA; Philadelphia, PA
Programs: FA
Posts: 6,484
Full name I can understand (I actually didn't know one can purchase a domestic ticket without providing his/her full name until now), but DOB?? How is that going to help with security? How are they going to verify the DOB provided? Besides, I would imagine a real terrorist carrying out an order wouldn't be foolish enough to provide his/her real name and DOB when purchasing a ticket. In addition, whatever ID (most likely fake) he/she produces at the checkpoint would certain match the name and DOB on the ticket.
Ahhh! Can the TSA ever implement something that would actually increase air traffic security, not air traffic-related hassle??
By the way, I will continue to provide my full name on all the tickets I book (domestically and internationally), but I will refuse to provide my DOB. They treat me (and a majority of flyers nowadays) like a criminal every time I fly already anyway, what more are they going to do now? Take me into an isolated room and interrogate me for reasons not to provide them my DOB??
LAX
Ahhh! Can the TSA ever implement something that would actually increase air traffic security, not air traffic-related hassle??
By the way, I will continue to provide my full name on all the tickets I book (domestically and internationally), but I will refuse to provide my DOB. They treat me (and a majority of flyers nowadays) like a criminal every time I fly already anyway, what more are they going to do now? Take me into an isolated room and interrogate me for reasons not to provide them my DOB??
LAX
#5




Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: Palm Beach/ New England
Programs: AA EXP 3MM, DL GM, Marriott Platinum
Posts: 4,459
More business for AMTRAK. IIRC the Library of Congress ID as well as many other federal photo IDs do not show a birthdate, so how will a TSA screener validate that the name corresponds to the given birthdate?
#6




Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Los Angeles, CA; Philadelphia, PA
Programs: FA
Posts: 6,484
Originally Posted by fastflyer
More business for AMTRAK. IIRC the Library of Congress ID as well as many other federal photo IDs do not show a birthdate, so how will a TSA screener validate that the name corresponds to the given birthdate?
LAX
#7


Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Cambridge MA (BOS)
Programs: MP 1K - 2MM
Posts: 2,241
It might help improve the selection process for extra screening
While I don't think it will directly help stop/capture/deture terrorists, it may have a beneficial side effect. Let me explain....
Yesterday I picked up the boarding passes at IAD for a vacation week in PHX. I got them at the airport on the way home from a quick 96 hour MR/biz trip (IAD/LAX/SEA/NRT/SIN/NRT/SEA/LAX/IAD) which had gone extremely smoothly with not a single "extra search" or delay at any customs point. Examining the boarding passes I noticed that one of us had been selected for extra screaning. OUR SEVEN YEAR OLD SON! When we got (back) to the airport later that day, Benjamin went through the magetometer handed his BP and school ID to the TSA agent, who looked at, looked at me says "your kidding...", I said "I know...pretty crazy", he shakes his head and says.... "ok stand here... which is your back pack...." The whole routine.
So if at least using the year of birth avoids silly situations like this, it would be better. One might fudge the date by a couple of years, or give the wrong month/day, but some one who puts down that they are 7 years old to avoid screening isn't going to get through when they present their drivers license for ID.
Yesterday I picked up the boarding passes at IAD for a vacation week in PHX. I got them at the airport on the way home from a quick 96 hour MR/biz trip (IAD/LAX/SEA/NRT/SIN/NRT/SEA/LAX/IAD) which had gone extremely smoothly with not a single "extra search" or delay at any customs point. Examining the boarding passes I noticed that one of us had been selected for extra screaning. OUR SEVEN YEAR OLD SON! When we got (back) to the airport later that day, Benjamin went through the magetometer handed his BP and school ID to the TSA agent, who looked at, looked at me says "your kidding...", I said "I know...pretty crazy", he shakes his head and says.... "ok stand here... which is your back pack...." The whole routine.
So if at least using the year of birth avoids silly situations like this, it would be better. One might fudge the date by a couple of years, or give the wrong month/day, but some one who puts down that they are 7 years old to avoid screening isn't going to get through when they present their drivers license for ID.
Last edited by yogi; May 5, 2005 at 10:07 am
#9
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Toronto
Programs: AC, AA, DL, UA
Posts: 1,604
Originally Posted by Analise
When I think of the grenades which went off at the British Consulate this morning four blocks from my building in New York, I wonder exactly how birthdays would have prevented these explosions.
#10
Suspended
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Desert city where Venice, Paris and NY are within walking distance
Programs: Delta and Hilton make a lot of $$ off me
Posts: 671
Originally Posted by Analise
When I think of the grenades which went off at the British Consulate this morning four blocks from my building in New York, I wonder exactly how birthdays would have prevented these explosions.
Amazing to me how much hatred of the TSA there is on FT. You all ***** and whine but never offer alternatives. Exactly what should they do? You don't like showing ID. You don't like giving DOB. You don;t like pat-downs. You don't like taking off your shoes. You don't like that they make you wait in line to go through.
So what is the alternative? Do we all just get on a plane like we do on a bus and hope for the best?
Last edited by da_guy; May 5, 2005 at 12:18 pm
#11
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Mar 2001
Posts: 55,213
Originally Posted by da_guy
What does one have to do with the other? You are talking about DOB to get on a plane, not to walk in front of the embassy.
Amazing to me how much hatred of the TSA there is on FT. You all ***** and whine but never offer alternatives. Exactly what should they do? You don't like showing ID. You don't like giving DOB. You don;t like pat-downs. You don't like taking off your shoes. You don't like that they make you wait in line to go through.
So what is the alternative? Do we all just get on a plane like we do on a bus and hope for the best?
Amazing to me how much hatred of the TSA there is on FT. You all ***** and whine but never offer alternatives. Exactly what should they do? You don't like showing ID. You don't like giving DOB. You don;t like pat-downs. You don't like taking off your shoes. You don't like that they make you wait in line to go through.
So what is the alternative? Do we all just get on a plane like we do on a bus and hope for the best?
That said, the TSA is a joke. Let's have the kind of security available in Frankfurt. You have to go through security when you walk into the airport and again later on toward the gate. You don't have to be strip searched and fondled because the equipment is excellent. I'm sick of the long TSA lines and when you can have two bombs go off in the middle of the night 3 blocks from my building, I have to wonder why we are tinkering with halfwits who want to fondle breasts at the airport or strip search grandma because you can't focus on those who might fit the category of terrorist better because it's not PC.
#12
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: May 2000
Location: أمريكا
Posts: 26,931
Originally Posted by da_guy
Amazing to me how much hatred of the TSA there is on FT. You all ***** and whine but never offer alternatives. Exactly what should they do? You don't like showing ID. You don't like giving DOB. You don;t like pat-downs. You don't like taking off your shoes. You don't like that they make you wait in line to go through.
So what is the alternative? Do we all just get on a plane like we do on a bus and hope for the best?
So what is the alternative? Do we all just get on a plane like we do on a bus and hope for the best?
All of this non-security or security theater stuff they do makes us less safe by diverting resources from looking for bombs and guns to wishing people happy birthday!! and taking away their lighters.
#13
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Right here
Posts: 2,940
Originally Posted by yogi
Examining the boarding passes I noticed that one of us had been selected for extra screaning. OUR SEVEN YEAR OLD SON! When we got (back) to the airport later that day, Benjamin went through the magetometer handed his BP and school ID to the TSA agent, who looked at, looked at me says "your kidding...", I said "I know...pretty crazy", he shakes his head and says.... "ok stand here... which is your back pack...." The whole routine.
So if at least using the year of birth avoids silly situations like this, it would be better. One might fudge the date by a couple of years, or give the wrong month/day, but some one who puts down that they are 7 years old to avoid screening isn't going to get through when they present their drivers license for ID.
So if at least using the year of birth avoids silly situations like this, it would be better. One might fudge the date by a couple of years, or give the wrong month/day, but some one who puts down that they are 7 years old to avoid screening isn't going to get through when they present their drivers license for ID.
If someone is insane enough to believe that killing themselves and potentially thousands of other people in an attack is the right thing to do/will make them an honored martyr/etc., do you think they would really hesitate to use their own child to carry a bomb onto a plane if they knew children were expempt from searches? (As for nuns, there are costume shops in every city where you can rent a nun's habit--do you think a female terrorist wouldn't dress in a rented nun's habit to avoid being SSSSd?)
Ask someone who works 'loss prevention' from a retail operation, and you'll find it's quite a common tactic for adult shoplifters to use childern as "accomplices"--bring your six-year-old child into the store with you, shove the product under junior's jacket, and then if junior gets caught, it looks like a six-year-old did it, and who's going to prosecute a six-year-old for shoplifting? (The adults get caught on camera shoving the items under the child's jacket/shirt, which is how retail security people are well aware of this tactic).
Terrorists are people who are so deluded that they think what they are doing is right. If someone is that crazy, what is there to stop them from putting a bomb in their own child's backpack? Nothing that I can think of. If they know it will make the carry-on with bomb exempt from additional screening because it's being carried by a child, this will inspire them to go this route. Again, I'm not trying to defend every TSA policy, but I don't think SSSSing children is stupid.
Last edited by clarence5ybr; May 5, 2005 at 1:54 pm
#14
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: A Capital City on The East Coast
Programs: CO-Dirt,SPG-Nothing,Marriott-Gold, Hilton-Blue, Hyatt-Plat, HI-Plat
Posts: 6,872
Originally Posted by da_guy
Do we all just get on a plane like we do on a bus and hope for the best?
But stop giving "the man" ideas about bus travel

