On Tipping
#151


Join Date: Jul 1999
Programs: QF WP, AA EXP
Posts: 3,655
I generally keep and leave my room pretty neat every day. Sometimes, I'll leave a couple of bucks, depending if I have singles on me. The other weekend in Vegas after a bachelor party in my room, however, was a different story. I had no problem leaving housekeeping a 10 spot... For me, it depends on how much clean up they have to do.
#152
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: WashDC
Programs: UA, AA
Posts: 635
<font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Originally posted by fastflyer:
. . . Tips of 15% are currently so standard in the US as to be commonplace. If service is bad, of course they deserve less. This should drive the people in and out of the business as appropriate to their service skills.
Tipping is however on its way out in the US, just as it has already departed most sectors in Europe. </font>
. . . Tips of 15% are currently so standard in the US as to be commonplace. If service is bad, of course they deserve less. This should drive the people in and out of the business as appropriate to their service skills.
Tipping is however on its way out in the US, just as it has already departed most sectors in Europe. </font>
I agree that 15% is standard and one tips more or less according to the level of service. But I took Rover's comment differently -- meaning that he doesn't believe in tipping, and the fact that waitstaff do not make a minimum wage is not his concern. That comment is what I was referring to -- if I misunderstood, than I am sorry. Otherwise, I stand by my earlier comment.
RE: tipping on the way out in the US -- not in my experience. 'Twould that it were true. It would be a lot easier all the way around.
#153
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 156
I think that it is remarkable that so many people put so much emotional effort into this subject. Whether or not one should tip, and just how much this should be, seems to be the source of almost never ending debate, and sometimes vitriol. One would have thought the comments would have been...'I give so much in this situation'...' In Australia, we usually give so much'.... 'We never tip in Patagonia'... and so on. Some people seem to base their philosophy of life on tipping practise. Curious.
#154
Original Member




Join Date: May 1998
Location: PDX
Programs: TSA Refusenik charter member
Posts: 16,126
I don't see how anyone should be obliged to subsidize someone else's lifestyle. If someone chooses to be a waiter, that's their choice. It's as simple as that.
As to the tipping backlash, I never tip at places such as coffee places, pizza-by-the-slice walk-ups, street food, etc., anymore. I just can't see the justification for it.
<font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Originally posted by DaDOKin DC:
That is a pretty narrow-minded attitude -- put the blinders on and look at only what you want to look at. The fact of the matter is, in the great majority, waiters do not make a living wage and tips are expected to make up the difference</font>
That is a pretty narrow-minded attitude -- put the blinders on and look at only what you want to look at. The fact of the matter is, in the great majority, waiters do not make a living wage and tips are expected to make up the difference</font>
As to the tipping backlash, I never tip at places such as coffee places, pizza-by-the-slice walk-ups, street food, etc., anymore. I just can't see the justification for it.
#155
FlyerTalk Evangelist

Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Greener Pastures
Posts: 10,515
wow - this is a long thread!
here's a tip -
do what you feel is right! i personally hate tipping the pizza delivery guy because they add a 1.50 delivery fee into it & the guy makes a rack-load. My current roommate delivers food - makes about 100 bucks a night on a full shift - his company delivers food from about 30 or so restaurants in Arlington, VA, and they charge a 5.00 delivery fee & people still tip him on top of that! That shocks the hell out of me.
I personally prefer not to tip above 10-15% but if the service is good, then I'll give 20 or if there are a lot of us eating & it's good service or if there are separate checks, I'll give 20-25% (especially when the server brings free drinks or doesn't charge for them). But I really hate the "A gratuity of 18% will be added to the bill automatically for parties of 6 or more" that's at some places. It makes me give only an 18% tip when it could have been more & it just annoys me. I have been a waiter at several restaurants & I've gotten the 25 cent tips before (worked the "geriatric" AM shift at Friendly's on the weekends in highschool) & i've also gotten the 20.00 tips on a 60.00 dinner. But I do think that the expected 20% is too much if the service is mediocre - if a waiter doesn't like what he/she makes, get a new job there isn't anyone holding you back. As far as housekeepers go, if they really do a good job of cleaning, then yeah, maybe 2/day is fine - but if all they are doing is picking up my towels (which some chains don't do any more to save water) & emptying my trash, then no tip - if i've left a room in an utter mess (which i don't do - i've worked in a hotel so i have more respect than that) then maybe i would leave a few bucks - but for a stay that's less than a week with standard service, no tips...
here's a tip -
do what you feel is right! i personally hate tipping the pizza delivery guy because they add a 1.50 delivery fee into it & the guy makes a rack-load. My current roommate delivers food - makes about 100 bucks a night on a full shift - his company delivers food from about 30 or so restaurants in Arlington, VA, and they charge a 5.00 delivery fee & people still tip him on top of that! That shocks the hell out of me.
I personally prefer not to tip above 10-15% but if the service is good, then I'll give 20 or if there are a lot of us eating & it's good service or if there are separate checks, I'll give 20-25% (especially when the server brings free drinks or doesn't charge for them). But I really hate the "A gratuity of 18% will be added to the bill automatically for parties of 6 or more" that's at some places. It makes me give only an 18% tip when it could have been more & it just annoys me. I have been a waiter at several restaurants & I've gotten the 25 cent tips before (worked the "geriatric" AM shift at Friendly's on the weekends in highschool) & i've also gotten the 20.00 tips on a 60.00 dinner. But I do think that the expected 20% is too much if the service is mediocre - if a waiter doesn't like what he/she makes, get a new job there isn't anyone holding you back. As far as housekeepers go, if they really do a good job of cleaning, then yeah, maybe 2/day is fine - but if all they are doing is picking up my towels (which some chains don't do any more to save water) & emptying my trash, then no tip - if i've left a room in an utter mess (which i don't do - i've worked in a hotel so i have more respect than that) then maybe i would leave a few bucks - but for a stay that's less than a week with standard service, no tips...
#156
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Chicago,IL.
Posts: 3,022
<font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Originally posted by anonplz:
usually a 20% tip at a minimum. IF the service is bad, 15%. </font>
usually a 20% tip at a minimum. IF the service is bad, 15%. </font>
If service is truly bad I will a) let them know and b) tip accordingly i.e. I'd leave 60$ if the bill was $59.95.
I am not necessarily picky, but if service is truly bad/rude..etc..I will 100% let them know about and clearly state my displeasure.
[This message has been edited by JohnG (edited 08-15-2003).]
#157
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: WashDC
Programs: UA, AA
Posts: 635
I have a different question on tipping, not strictly travel-related, alhough it could be ---
For the past year of so, I have been getting regular massages. Initially, the massage therapist worked out of a tanning salon (I assume he rented space there). The salon would take care of the charges, and they accepted credit, check, or cash. I usually tipped $10 for a $65 session (15%).
About 2 months ago, he said he was scaling back his time at the tanning salon and was doing more work out of his home. No probem -- he has a very professional setup there. BUT, now he accepts only cash or (get this) checks made out to 'cash'. Of course, I think he is now taking the money and not declaring it for taxes.
So, my question is: would you still tip? And if so, the same as befoe?
Thanks
------------------
Da DOK
For the past year of so, I have been getting regular massages. Initially, the massage therapist worked out of a tanning salon (I assume he rented space there). The salon would take care of the charges, and they accepted credit, check, or cash. I usually tipped $10 for a $65 session (15%).
About 2 months ago, he said he was scaling back his time at the tanning salon and was doing more work out of his home. No probem -- he has a very professional setup there. BUT, now he accepts only cash or (get this) checks made out to 'cash'. Of course, I think he is now taking the money and not declaring it for taxes.
So, my question is: would you still tip? And if so, the same as befoe?
Thanks
------------------
Da DOK
#158
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: jfk area
Programs: AA platinum; 2MM AA, Delta Diamond, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 10,291
(1)I live in the NYC area, and a usual "rule of thumb" is to tip double the sales tax for restuarant tips. I have seen the sales tax steadly rise (do sales taxes ever go down?) to the now nearly 9%. It is still easier to leave the double tax (about 18%) than computing 15% exactly.
(2) I eat in a fair number of buffets [the waiter may bring a drink at the end of the meal and remove used plates]; should he be entitled to the full 15%+ tip? I usually leave only 10% in buffets.
(3) Some buffets, have special stations: omelets made to order; pancake and/or waffle people, Mongolian, Chineese, Mexican etc.--I've seen people leave $1 tips at each of these...
(4) In Las Vegas (a very touristy place), there are various magazines describing what to do there. These have an area devoted to tipping--it is a long document! If one followed their suggestions, a 3 day stay could put a big dent in a vaction budget. Some examples: shuttle bus drivers (as opposed to taxi drivers), bell desk people, chamber maids, casino dealers, waiters, maiter d's at restaurants, maiter d's who seat you at shows, ushers at shows, cocktail waitresses, bar tenders, valet parking at hotels, restuarant and room service...this list is just a starting point. There are suggested amounts for each.
I stayed at the Bellagio hotel in Vegas. In addition to (day) chamber maids, they have "turn down" service in the evening--if one were the "tipping kind", BOTH day and night people should be tipped also.
(5) I've seen discussions in usenet groups devoted to Las Vegas vacations re the "$20 trick"--leaving a tip of $20 with the person who checks you in at the hotel on arrival, may secure an upgraded room.
(2) I eat in a fair number of buffets [the waiter may bring a drink at the end of the meal and remove used plates]; should he be entitled to the full 15%+ tip? I usually leave only 10% in buffets.
(3) Some buffets, have special stations: omelets made to order; pancake and/or waffle people, Mongolian, Chineese, Mexican etc.--I've seen people leave $1 tips at each of these...
(4) In Las Vegas (a very touristy place), there are various magazines describing what to do there. These have an area devoted to tipping--it is a long document! If one followed their suggestions, a 3 day stay could put a big dent in a vaction budget. Some examples: shuttle bus drivers (as opposed to taxi drivers), bell desk people, chamber maids, casino dealers, waiters, maiter d's at restaurants, maiter d's who seat you at shows, ushers at shows, cocktail waitresses, bar tenders, valet parking at hotels, restuarant and room service...this list is just a starting point. There are suggested amounts for each.
I stayed at the Bellagio hotel in Vegas. In addition to (day) chamber maids, they have "turn down" service in the evening--if one were the "tipping kind", BOTH day and night people should be tipped also.
(5) I've seen discussions in usenet groups devoted to Las Vegas vacations re the "$20 trick"--leaving a tip of $20 with the person who checks you in at the hotel on arrival, may secure an upgraded room.

