Airplane Mode Workaround?
#16


Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: LGA - JFK
Programs: UA, AA, DL, B6, CX, KE, Latitude, VIFP, Crown & Anchor, etc.
Posts: 2,589
Q for OP out of curiosity - what over-sized device with a stylus are you issued with (corporate ?) that don't have a quick-access widget and/or on-screen button for switching Airplane Mode on/off
I've seen, used & supported a pretty broad range of popular devices from Moto, HTC, Samsung, LG and of course, pure Google ones - both stock/unmod'd and customized that have the functionality, after & before OTA updates from 2.3.1 to 4.4.3
If yours is doing so and restarting your phone, I consider those FC'd or crashed that aren't supposed to happen so time to REPLACE or trade-up your device if you can. And, unless you are hopping on & off planes all day/week long - or, going into courtrooms or health care facilities that mandate devices to be switched off, etc. - it still shouldn't be a "big" issue. Switching off your WiFi, Location Service & Google Now with active listening, and checking for Apps that wakelock are better strategies for getting more usable battery life out of your "gear"
I've seen, used & supported a pretty broad range of popular devices from Moto, HTC, Samsung, LG and of course, pure Google ones - both stock/unmod'd and customized that have the functionality, after & before OTA updates from 2.3.1 to 4.4.3
If yours is doing so and restarting your phone, I consider those FC'd or crashed that aren't supposed to happen so time to REPLACE or trade-up your device if you can. And, unless you are hopping on & off planes all day/week long - or, going into courtrooms or health care facilities that mandate devices to be switched off, etc. - it still shouldn't be a "big" issue. Switching off your WiFi, Location Service & Google Now with active listening, and checking for Apps that wakelock are better strategies for getting more usable battery life out of your "gear"
#17
Suspended
Join Date: May 2014
Posts: 3,445
You can from the power button, but that restarts things on the phone. I just want a simple switch.
My problem is I now have umpteen different places to go and different methods to do everything. Have to use fingers to do the double fingered menu, so put the stylus down...plus then once you are in setting you have to get to where the airplane menu is. why can't we set this thing up like we want? Isn't that why you go with Android over an iPhone? Android is getting to e too much like the iPhone - more entertainment than useful.
My problem is I now have umpteen different places to go and different methods to do everything. Have to use fingers to do the double fingered menu, so put the stylus down...plus then once you are in setting you have to get to where the airplane menu is. why can't we set this thing up like we want? Isn't that why you go with Android over an iPhone? Android is getting to e too much like the iPhone - more entertainment than useful.
#18
Original Poster


Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Central Mass
Programs: Independent
Posts: 4,863
Wow! Never saw so much hatred for a simple toggle! Actually, I am talking about using dual devices. Which is one of the reasons I like a quick switch - I can use that with a simple thumb swipe instead of having to use two hands for the phone (and thus have to put whatever else I am holding down).
Personally, I also use Airplane Mode for when I know I am going to be someplace where I wont get signal anyways, don't need radio functionality, and want to extend battery life. Radios hunting for signal still use up power, as do all those little behind the scenes apps that are running just o push out adds, give you useless updates, or simply track your location and usage habits. Then again there ARE some apps that I want to keep the document open in.
This is a new phone I am trying to customize. I have been a holdout for a while with my old HTC, but we all agreed that we were going to standardize on the Samsungs, so it really looked bad when I myself had an HTC. As it turns out that one bit wasn't Samsung but Android itself.
Now, if they would only allow me to change the font color on the lock screen so I could read it with the wallpaper I want to use...
Personally, I also use Airplane Mode for when I know I am going to be someplace where I wont get signal anyways, don't need radio functionality, and want to extend battery life. Radios hunting for signal still use up power, as do all those little behind the scenes apps that are running just o push out adds, give you useless updates, or simply track your location and usage habits. Then again there ARE some apps that I want to keep the document open in.
This is a new phone I am trying to customize. I have been a holdout for a while with my old HTC, but we all agreed that we were going to standardize on the Samsungs, so it really looked bad when I myself had an HTC. As it turns out that one bit wasn't Samsung but Android itself.
Now, if they would only allow me to change the font color on the lock screen so I could read it with the wallpaper I want to use...
#19
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Democratic People's Republic of the UK
Programs: Lifetime Gold, Global Entry, Hertz PC, and my wallet
Posts: 21,914
See if you can find a local kid that has the same phone and give it to them. They will sort you out in about 2 minutes tops.
#20
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Dec 2009
Programs: UA, LY
Posts: 13,179
OP, what device are you using? And with all the responses in agreement and you still posting, it seems none of us are getting what your real issue is. Can you (given all the info in the thread) repeat your question please so we can better understand?
#21
Original Poster


Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Central Mass
Programs: Independent
Posts: 4,863
My question, or rather my comment, is pretty straight forward. I want to be able to put a toggle switch on my android home screen to go into Airplane mode, instead of having to go to settings, use the power switch, or combination key command to do so. In a nutshell, I want my device to allow me to work the way i want to work, and not force me to work the way that designers like to work.
Which is why I am hoping to keep this thread open - so that we can discuss how to make our devices do what we want them to, and not what other people want them to.
Which is why I am hoping to keep this thread open - so that we can discuss how to make our devices do what we want them to, and not what other people want them to.
#22
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Exclusively OMNI/PR, for Reasons
Posts: 4,186
My question, or rather my comment, is pretty straight forward. I want to be able to put a toggle switch on my android home screen to go into Airplane mode, instead of having to go to settings, use the power switch, or combination key command to do so. In a nutshell, I want my device to allow me to work the way i want to work, and not force me to work the way that designers like to work.
Which is why I am hoping to keep this thread open - so that we can discuss how to make our devices do what we want them to, and not what other people want them to.
Which is why I am hoping to keep this thread open - so that we can discuss how to make our devices do what we want them to, and not what other people want them to.
I've rooted my phone and installed a custom ROM; it works the way I like to work. It's a shame that's not an option for you.
#23
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Dec 2009
Programs: UA, LY
Posts: 13,179
My question, or rather my comment, is pretty straight forward. I want to be able to put a toggle switch on my android home screen to go into Airplane mode, instead of having to go to settings, use the power switch, or combination key command to do so. In a nutshell, I want my device to allow me to work the way i want to work, and not force me to work the way that designers like to work.
Which is why I am hoping to keep this thread open - so that we can discuss how to make our devices do what we want them to, and not what other people want them to.
Which is why I am hoping to keep this thread open - so that we can discuss how to make our devices do what we want them to, and not what other people want them to.
Out of curiosity, is there a reason you don't like the pulldown option? Depending on how many screens you have and where you place the toggle, the pull-down may be even less time
#24
Join Date: Jul 2013
Location: DAY/CMH
Programs: UA MileagePlus
Posts: 2,474
This is just one example of many: Airplane Mode Toggle (Google Play). What phone are you using? There may even be pre-installed options based on your device and/or launcher.
Out of curiosity, is there a reason you don't like the pulldown option? Depending on how many screens you have and where you place the toggle, the pull-down may be even less time
Out of curiosity, is there a reason you don't like the pulldown option? Depending on how many screens you have and where you place the toggle, the pull-down may be even less time
#26
Join Date: Jul 2013
Location: DAY/CMH
Programs: UA MileagePlus
Posts: 2,474
Hmm, apparently it's device-dependent. I repeated received wisdom (always a dangerous practice) in my previous post. Given your results, I tried the widget myself. All it does is force close on my Motorola Droid Maxx. Recalling that other widgets have had issues until they'd been through a restart, I rebooted the phone and got the same result.
#27
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Democratic People's Republic of the UK
Programs: Lifetime Gold, Global Entry, Hertz PC, and my wallet
Posts: 21,914
#28
Join Date: Jul 2013
Location: DAY/CMH
Programs: UA MileagePlus
Posts: 2,474
That widget hasn't been updated since January 21, 2011, though. I looked at some of the others, like this one, which are more actively supported. Its description says "***From Android 4.2 on - cannot toggle airplane mode with widget. This will now take users to the settings screen to change airplane mode. Will look into allowing this with root."
#29
Original Poster


Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Central Mass
Programs: Independent
Posts: 4,863
It's something Google had disabled in Android 4.2 and above. I don't know the reason - something about security but I have yet to figure out exactly what kind of security issue there is.
I am a major customizer of my devices. There are several reasons why I want a main screen switch, but an overriding design goal for me is being able to do things one handed, particularly one thumbed. Fat hands, large phone, means that holding the phone comfortably for me to use my thumbs for most things means that I have to move the phone in my hand or use my other hand to operate the side power switch. Likewise, hard to use two fingers to do something.
I did manage to get the flight mode switch to appear in my notification drop down, so while that is a bit of a thumb stretch it is doable. I am currently trying to find a radio off switch (my old, old HTC had one) which will essentially do the same thing I need to.
As for root, this is a work owned device. And our policy is to not allow users to root the phones. Hard enough supporting them stock! My personal device I would be willing to, but I have so far avoided going to 4.2 anyways and avoided the situation altogether.
I am a major customizer of my devices. There are several reasons why I want a main screen switch, but an overriding design goal for me is being able to do things one handed, particularly one thumbed. Fat hands, large phone, means that holding the phone comfortably for me to use my thumbs for most things means that I have to move the phone in my hand or use my other hand to operate the side power switch. Likewise, hard to use two fingers to do something.
I did manage to get the flight mode switch to appear in my notification drop down, so while that is a bit of a thumb stretch it is doable. I am currently trying to find a radio off switch (my old, old HTC had one) which will essentially do the same thing I need to.
As for root, this is a work owned device. And our policy is to not allow users to root the phones. Hard enough supporting them stock! My personal device I would be willing to, but I have so far avoided going to 4.2 anyways and avoided the situation altogether.
#30
Join Date: Jul 2013
Location: DAY/CMH
Programs: UA MileagePlus
Posts: 2,474

