Are some topics now off-limits on FT?
#1
Original Poster
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Newport Beach, California, USA
Posts: 36,062
Are some topics now off-limits on FT?
This is not a complaint about moderators, only a question about FT policy.
Lately, I've noticed a number of otherwise relevant travel-related threads get closed within hours of their being started. The threads are civil and on-topic though usually (but not aways) touch on what are frequently hot-button issues (one that comes to mind was a complaint about a noisy family in the DEN RCC). However, I've also seen a number of what seemed, at least to me, relatively innocuous topics that, nonetheless, were closed quite early in the discussion.
Is there some new, unannounced policy that FT travel discussion is going to become more vanilla and not include discussions of on-topic issues about which people have strong and divergent opinions? I understand that to long-time FT regulars, these topics may seem like rehashing old themes, but FT has a constant flow of new members and, even for old members, these topics obviously have some appeal or they wouldn't keep turning up.
Lately, I've noticed a number of otherwise relevant travel-related threads get closed within hours of their being started. The threads are civil and on-topic though usually (but not aways) touch on what are frequently hot-button issues (one that comes to mind was a complaint about a noisy family in the DEN RCC). However, I've also seen a number of what seemed, at least to me, relatively innocuous topics that, nonetheless, were closed quite early in the discussion.
Is there some new, unannounced policy that FT travel discussion is going to become more vanilla and not include discussions of on-topic issues about which people have strong and divergent opinions? I understand that to long-time FT regulars, these topics may seem like rehashing old themes, but FT has a constant flow of new members and, even for old members, these topics obviously have some appeal or they wouldn't keep turning up.
Last edited by PTravel; Jul 26, 2007 at 12:39 pm
#2
FlyerTalk Evangelist

Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Greener Pastures
Posts: 10,515
There's been no such policy discussed anywhere that I'm aware of & I, as a member of FlyerTalk, would be disappointed if there were & wouldn't support such a policy.
If you find that some threads were prematurely closed, then I would encourage you to contact the moderator that closed it to ask why via PM (it's not a TOS violation to discuss moderation if its done in private versus the public forum). If the answer you receive doesn't make sense to you, then I would encourage yout to contact Randy Petersen directly.
If you find that some threads were prematurely closed, then I would encourage you to contact the moderator that closed it to ask why via PM (it's not a TOS violation to discuss moderation if its done in private versus the public forum). If the answer you receive doesn't make sense to you, then I would encourage yout to contact Randy Petersen directly.
#3
Moderator: Avianca, Travel Photography, Travel Technology & USA




Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Far western edge of the La-La Land City limits
Programs: Emeritus VIP Fromins Deli Encino grandfathered successor program - UA MM & HH Diamond
Posts: 3,812
I think bhatnasx' suggestions sum it up. This is not a TalkBoard agenda or empowerment, so I'll retire this thread.

