Is a child allowed in the cockpit while the plane is in flight?
#61
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: May 2000
Location: أمريكا
Posts: 26,931
#62
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: May 2000
Location: أمريكا
Posts: 26,931
Originally Posted by closecover
After the Aeroflot accident referenced in this thread, how could anyone justify allowing minors in the cockpit?
Originally Posted by mre5765
That can't be true. I learned on FT that ``odds of a kid falling into a "button" or something to that effect are almost nil.''
#63
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: LAX/TPE
Programs: United 1K, JAL Sapphire, SPG Lifetime Platinum, National Executive Elite, Hertz PC, Avis PC
Posts: 47,227
It is not a false dichotomy. It's a sentence containing two factually accurate statements. No causation or association was ascribed.
I'm a libertarian, so I completely agree with the general precept of resisting government expansion, however, I just don't think that a rule restricting access to the flight deck is in any way irrational, expansive, or remotely restrictive of civil liberties. I have spoken with literally several hundred commercial pilots and hundreds of other civil aviation professionals in the past few years and without exception they all agree that a closed and secure cockpit door is the single most important element in securing the flight deck. If you actually think they are all sheeple and that it's more important for little Johnny to get a pin from the pilot while in flight, then your sense of entitlement is really overinflated.
I'm a libertarian, so I completely agree with the general precept of resisting government expansion, however, I just don't think that a rule restricting access to the flight deck is in any way irrational, expansive, or remotely restrictive of civil liberties. I have spoken with literally several hundred commercial pilots and hundreds of other civil aviation professionals in the past few years and without exception they all agree that a closed and secure cockpit door is the single most important element in securing the flight deck. If you actually think they are all sheeple and that it's more important for little Johnny to get a pin from the pilot while in flight, then your sense of entitlement is really overinflated.
Part of the deal here is assuming the crew has sufficient common sense to know who to let in and when. The Aeroflot tragedy was NOT a result of letting a child into the flight deck - it was the result of exceptionally poor judgment on the part of the crew who allowed the boy to actually get near the seat and touch things. Even my closest friends who fly, and who know my own flying skills, would never let me touch a thing on their flight, nor would I want to. The only button I ever touched, under instruction from the Captain, was enabling and disabling the O2 flow to my jumpseat mask.
It should be left up to each country to decide how to handle this issue - and as customers, we can choose to patronize or avoid airlines which have rules we're not comfortable with.
#64
Join Date: May 2006
Location: SNA/LAX... somewhere sunny and warm, but crowded.
Programs: AA/UA/UR/MRP/IHG Plat
Posts: 916
based on recent news reports and Congressional hearings, I'm thinking a 5 year old in the cockpit is better than an FAA inspector...but I could be wrong : )


