Granny speaks!
#33
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: ...way out in the weeds
Posts: 97
Some of you pass the idea that any form of security is an infringement on your rights...No ID checks, no BP checks, no detectors, nothing.
Big 'ol giant open building that planes park at and anyone can come and go as they please.
If I got that wrong, it's the fault of the messenger
Big 'ol giant open building that planes park at and anyone can come and go as they please.
If I got that wrong, it's the fault of the messenger
just a thought...
#34
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: HH Diamond, Marriott, IHG, Hyatt something
Posts: 34,516
#35
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 728
While the nature of the evil they do is lesser (owing simply to the fact that Americans currently have more economic liberty and therefore power to defend themselves from their government, for now), the root mentality is the same.
#38
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 728
A gang comes to your place of business with guns. Its leaders tell you they will protect you. You don't want them to do this. They insist and by force remain in the area and demand that you pay them. You don't want to, but in order to not be encaged or attacked, you pay them so that you obey and pay them so you can go about your business.
Is it moral for the gang to do this? Would you object to their doing it?
Is it moral for the gang to do this? Would you object to their doing it?
#40
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 728
It is.
It starts with the idea that a human being has the right to forcibly make another human being do what he wants, against that person's will.
No one is equating the evil done by Nazis with that done by the TSA workers. What the TSA workers do is still immoral and destructive though.
It starts with the idea that a human being has the right to forcibly make another human being do what he wants, against that person's will.
No one is equating the evil done by Nazis with that done by the TSA workers. What the TSA workers do is still immoral and destructive though.
#41
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: HH Diamond, Marriott, IHG, Hyatt something
Posts: 34,516
I know nothing. Hoooogggggaaaaaaan!
Do you have relatives that were guards? 
The mentality, "We just did what we were told", has been used to defend some of the most heinous acts in this world.
I flew to dozens of countries last year, almost 200,000 miles in total. I see how security is run, how logical it can be done. Pretending that the TSA is going to be your savior is just ostrich-like behavior.
I've flown domestic flights in countries where I didn't show ID to check in. I didn't take my shoes off. I brought liquids on the plane. Strangely enough, the planes aren't falling out of the sky in this country.
As I recall, the US didn't even start to do any security checks on passengers until 1970 or so, after a plane was hijacked. Do we need security screening? Sure. Do we need hundreds of stupid rules that don't really make a difference? No. When very few of the items in the hold have been x-rayed, or checked it's quite ridiculous to say that the plane is secure.
The emperor has no clothes.

The mentality, "We just did what we were told", has been used to defend some of the most heinous acts in this world.
I flew to dozens of countries last year, almost 200,000 miles in total. I see how security is run, how logical it can be done. Pretending that the TSA is going to be your savior is just ostrich-like behavior.
I've flown domestic flights in countries where I didn't show ID to check in. I didn't take my shoes off. I brought liquids on the plane. Strangely enough, the planes aren't falling out of the sky in this country.
As I recall, the US didn't even start to do any security checks on passengers until 1970 or so, after a plane was hijacked. Do we need security screening? Sure. Do we need hundreds of stupid rules that don't really make a difference? No. When very few of the items in the hold have been x-rayed, or checked it's quite ridiculous to say that the plane is secure.
The emperor has no clothes.
#43
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: CLT
Posts: 7,249
Where there's a will there's a way. If an attack happens why would they do something we are already on alert for?
Instead of being retroactive (shoes, liquids) TSA should be more proactive at finding things that actually may be a threat. Puffers aren't even being used at most airports and I haven't been to any airport that used the puffer to screen everyone. That naked picture thing won't solve the problem either.
Has anyone tried to make a shoe bomb since Reid?
I don't understand why people blow up planes to begin with. Seems kinda wimpy to me.
Instead of being retroactive (shoes, liquids) TSA should be more proactive at finding things that actually may be a threat. Puffers aren't even being used at most airports and I haven't been to any airport that used the puffer to screen everyone. That naked picture thing won't solve the problem either.
Has anyone tried to make a shoe bomb since Reid?
I don't understand why people blow up planes to begin with. Seems kinda wimpy to me.
#44
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: HH Diamond, Marriott, IHG, Hyatt something
Posts: 34,516
How many countries to you fly to? Do you go through all the normal security procedures that we do? I think not.
#45
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 728
The TSA is a gang of thugs out to enrich themselves. Nothing more.





