is it a TOS violation to be creative with swearing?
#1
Original Poster
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: NYC (formerly BOS/DCA)
Programs: UA 1K, IC RA
Posts: 60,745
is it a TOS violation to be creative with swearing?
We all know that the software will delete words like ...., ...., ...., etc.
But is it a TOS violation to be creative and get the swear-word across without actually saying it? I'm talking about things like $h..
But is it a TOS violation to be creative and get the swear-word across without actually saying it? I'm talking about things like $h..
#2


Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: YUL-YQB-BTV
Programs: SPG-Marriott Titanium Elite
Posts: 4,356
Must be a boring day today to wonder about such trivial things..
#3
Original Poster
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: NYC (formerly BOS/DCA)
Programs: UA 1K, IC RA
Posts: 60,745
Originally Posted by Super Larry
Must be a boring day today to wonder about such trivial things.. 

#4
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: DCA
Programs: AMC MovieWatcher, Giant BonusCard, Petco PALS Card, Silver Diner Blue Plate Club
Posts: 22,314
In case it's helpful, allow me to point to an item from the Flyertalk TOS
(Emphasis mine.)
Any posts containing communications or hyperlinks that are knowingly false and/or defamatory, inaccurate, obscene, profane, threatening, harassing, offensive, vulgar, abusive, hateful or bashing - especially those aimed at sexual orientation, gender, race, color, religious views, political orientation, national origin, or disability - will not be tolerated and will be removed. Individuals who post offensive material or links to such will be subject to disciplinary action.
There is no public list of prohibited words; if you believe a word is questionable, don't use it. If you find a questionable message in any of the forums, contact a moderator who will determine whether the message meets our objective of offering a friendly and flame-free community for frequent travelers. Using spaces, symbols, acronyms and other methods to express vulgarities while avoiding FlyerTalk's censors is still a violation.
There is no public list of prohibited words; if you believe a word is questionable, don't use it. If you find a questionable message in any of the forums, contact a moderator who will determine whether the message meets our objective of offering a friendly and flame-free community for frequent travelers. Using spaces, symbols, acronyms and other methods to express vulgarities while avoiding FlyerTalk's censors is still a violation.
#5
Original Poster
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: NYC (formerly BOS/DCA)
Programs: UA 1K, IC RA
Posts: 60,745
Originally Posted by gleff
In case it's helpful, allow me to point to an item from the Flyertalk TOS (Emphasis mine.)
#6


Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: YUL-YQB-BTV
Programs: SPG-Marriott Titanium Elite
Posts: 4,356
Originally Posted by magiciansampras
LOL, I guess that answers my question! Gracias!
#7
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: May 1998
Location: Digital Nomad Wandering the Earth - Currently in PARIS, FRANCE!
Posts: 61,972
If it were not a TOS violation and strictly verbotten to talk about moderation, I would point out that in my VAST experience in dealing with this question, it all depends on the moderator. I would tell you that I have been issued week-long suspensions for using astrisks by one moderator and yet in another forum a moderator regularly uses them himself, if I were allowed.
One thing I definitely WOULD point out, though, were it allowed, is that questioning a moderator on this issue will a fast-track to suspend-ville 100% of the time...
One thing I definitely WOULD point out, though, were it allowed, is that questioning a moderator on this issue will a fast-track to suspend-ville 100% of the time...
#8
Founder of FlyerTalk
Join Date: May 1998
Location: Colorado Springs, CO
Posts: 6,540
Actually I might argue your point (all without using banned words or trying to circumvent the words....). As is known, the Mods in the Delta Forum have actually set up a thread in which comments about Moderation are welcome and I've taken on several questions about Moderation within this forum.
As you might know, virtually every major respectable bulletin bard like FlyerTalk as well limits discussions about Moderation. Based on the types of things I've seen posted, it's easy to see why - almost 100% of the time a member conveniently leaves out the their actions, thus creating an unbalanced view for others to judge. As well, many of the decisions are simply judgment calls.
But I did want to correct your statement "One thing I definitely WOULD point out, though, were it allowed, is that questioning a moderator on this issue will a fast-track to suspend-ville 100% of the time..."
There's probably more to this than we have time for today. What about how thew words are used. For instance, calling out another member using words from the gutter probably has less impact than referring to an act by a non-member. And of course using the words in a title of the thread vs. within post #34 might make differences as well. And some words simply stay on FT because no one bothered to report the infraction, and surely we are not here to mandate that our volunteers are required to read each and every post word for word.
The way i see it, if you have to use such words to make your point, your point isn't all that important to FlyerTalk.
As for the original poster, we're glad that one of our volunteers was able to point you in the right direction for the answer. It might be worthy of a few members here on FlyerTalk to actually read the TOS one of these days, it might save everyone a few problems.
As you might know, virtually every major respectable bulletin bard like FlyerTalk as well limits discussions about Moderation. Based on the types of things I've seen posted, it's easy to see why - almost 100% of the time a member conveniently leaves out the their actions, thus creating an unbalanced view for others to judge. As well, many of the decisions are simply judgment calls.
But I did want to correct your statement "One thing I definitely WOULD point out, though, were it allowed, is that questioning a moderator on this issue will a fast-track to suspend-ville 100% of the time..."
There's probably more to this than we have time for today. What about how thew words are used. For instance, calling out another member using words from the gutter probably has less impact than referring to an act by a non-member. And of course using the words in a title of the thread vs. within post #34 might make differences as well. And some words simply stay on FT because no one bothered to report the infraction, and surely we are not here to mandate that our volunteers are required to read each and every post word for word.
The way i see it, if you have to use such words to make your point, your point isn't all that important to FlyerTalk.
As for the original poster, we're glad that one of our volunteers was able to point you in the right direction for the answer. It might be worthy of a few members here on FlyerTalk to actually read the TOS one of these days, it might save everyone a few problems.
Originally Posted by kokonutz
If it were not a TOS violation and strictly verbotten to talk about moderation, I would point out that in my VAST experience in dealing with this question, it all depends on the moderator. I would tell you that I have been issued week-long suspensions for using astrisks by one moderator and yet in another forum a moderator regularly uses them himself, if I were allowed.
One thing I definitely WOULD point out, though, were it allowed, is that questioning a moderator on this issue will a fast-track to suspend-ville 100% of the time...
One thing I definitely WOULD point out, though, were it allowed, is that questioning a moderator on this issue will a fast-track to suspend-ville 100% of the time...

