Bulkhead vs. Exit Row
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 422
Bulkhead vs. Exit Row
I'm a UA flyer and don't get to NW much, so I have a few questions about seating preferences on NW flights. I'm traveling domestic coach on a DC9-50 and A320.
I noticed that SeatGuru says that the bulkheads are just a curtain and you can stretch your feet into first class (hopefully accurate - can anyone confirm?). There is also a window and aisle last exit row available (ie, full recline also, and leg room since it's an exit row).
Which do you prefer on NW flights - curtain bulkheads (near the front of plane, full recline, supposed leg room) or last exit rows (full recline, leg room)?
Thanks for suggestions... I want to make this transcon as comfortable as I can without using up my miles for overpriced upgrades.
I noticed that SeatGuru says that the bulkheads are just a curtain and you can stretch your feet into first class (hopefully accurate - can anyone confirm?). There is also a window and aisle last exit row available (ie, full recline also, and leg room since it's an exit row).
Which do you prefer on NW flights - curtain bulkheads (near the front of plane, full recline, supposed leg room) or last exit rows (full recline, leg room)?
Thanks for suggestions... I want to make this transcon as comfortable as I can without using up my miles for overpriced upgrades.
#2
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: MSP; SM with status & many BIS miles
Programs: AA, WN & many Hotels... avoids UA like the plague!
Posts: 1,019
Originally Posted by drtravix
I'm a UA flyer and don't get to NW much, so I have a few questions about seating preferences on NW flights. I'm traveling domestic coach on a DC9-50 and A320.
I noticed that SeatGuru says that the bulkheads are just a curtain and you can stretch your feet into first class (hopefully accurate - can anyone confirm?). There is also a window and aisle last exit row available (ie, full recline also, and leg room since it's an exit row).
Which do you prefer on NW flights - curtain bulkheads (near the front of plane, full recline, supposed leg room) or last exit rows (full recline, leg room)?
Thanks for suggestions... I want to make this transcon as comfortable as I can without using up my miles for overpriced upgrades.
I noticed that SeatGuru says that the bulkheads are just a curtain and you can stretch your feet into first class (hopefully accurate - can anyone confirm?). There is also a window and aisle last exit row available (ie, full recline also, and leg room since it's an exit row).
Which do you prefer on NW flights - curtain bulkheads (near the front of plane, full recline, supposed leg room) or last exit rows (full recline, leg room)?
Thanks for suggestions... I want to make this transcon as comfortable as I can without using up my miles for overpriced upgrades.
#4


Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: RST
Programs: Delta Diamond; Hilton Diamond; Accor Gold
Posts: 4,845
I love bulkhead seating in the DC9, in particular seat 5F. Far enough away from the aisle and if 5E is empty you will have more room than in FC. You can easily put things away under the seat in front of you and stretch out for a good sleep. Also, you are close to the front for a quick exit when at your destination.
#5
Original Poster
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 422
Thanks for the info!
Last edited by drtravix; Jan 11, 2005 at 6:21 pm
#6



Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Anywhere but home
Programs: AA EXP, UA Gold/MM, DL Plat/2MM, HH Dia, PC Plat, MR Gold, ALL Sil
Posts: 4,679
Avoid window exit row seats on A320
You should avoid the window exit row seats on the Airbus 319 and 320, as the seats are less cushioned than the rest of the seats on the plane. I found this out the hard way (no pun intended). It really makes for a long flight.
The other exit row seats on both planes are fine, and probably better than bulkhead on the Airbi (plural of Airbus -- is it Airbuses?).
The other exit row seats on both planes are fine, and probably better than bulkhead on the Airbi (plural of Airbus -- is it Airbuses?).
#7
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 1,955
I am a bulhead guy. But you have to be able to deal with slightly less width due to table in seat.
#8
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: DFW
Programs: AA (ExPlat).DL,UA Hertz (Pres Circle); Avis (First), Hilton (Diamond), Marriott (Gold)
Posts: 452
Originally Posted by drtravix
I'm a UA flyer and don't get to NW much, so I have a few questions about seating preferences on NW flights. I'm traveling domestic coach on a DC9-50 and A320.
I noticed that SeatGuru says that the bulkheads are just a curtain and you can stretch your feet into first class (hopefully accurate - can anyone confirm?). There is also a window and aisle last exit row available (ie, full recline also, and leg room since it's an exit row).
Which do you prefer on NW flights - curtain bulkheads (near the front of plane, full recline, supposed leg room) or last exit rows (full recline, leg room)?
Thanks for suggestions... I want to make this transcon as comfortable as I can without using up my miles for overpriced upgrades.
I noticed that SeatGuru says that the bulkheads are just a curtain and you can stretch your feet into first class (hopefully accurate - can anyone confirm?). There is also a window and aisle last exit row available (ie, full recline also, and leg room since it's an exit row).
Which do you prefer on NW flights - curtain bulkheads (near the front of plane, full recline, supposed leg room) or last exit rows (full recline, leg room)?
Thanks for suggestions... I want to make this transcon as comfortable as I can without using up my miles for overpriced upgrades.
\
#9
Original Member
Join Date: May 1998
Location: Niceville, FL, USA
Posts: 2,792
I am a little out of date on the Airbuses, but others above seem to have covered that.
I would add that on the DC-9s, row 5 is just as good as the exit rows, but since you're further forward, you get off the plane earlier.
Further, on the DC-9s, if you can possibly get 6-D, there is no corresponding 5-D in front of you...your legroom extends all the way to the cockpit door.
Two caveats about this: One, since there is no seat in front of you, you will have to put everything into the overheads; Two, since this is a premium seat, you probably won't get it unless you are an elite and therefore get to board early so there won't be an issue with overhead space.
Oh, just thought of a number three: over 90% of the time I try to get this seat, it is already taken....still, it won't hurt to look for it.
Good luck and enjoy!
I would add that on the DC-9s, row 5 is just as good as the exit rows, but since you're further forward, you get off the plane earlier.
Further, on the DC-9s, if you can possibly get 6-D, there is no corresponding 5-D in front of you...your legroom extends all the way to the cockpit door.
Two caveats about this: One, since there is no seat in front of you, you will have to put everything into the overheads; Two, since this is a premium seat, you probably won't get it unless you are an elite and therefore get to board early so there won't be an issue with overhead space.
Oh, just thought of a number three: over 90% of the time I try to get this seat, it is already taken....still, it won't hurt to look for it.
Good luck and enjoy!
#10
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Rochester Hills, MI
Programs: NW, MR SE,
Posts: 385
Bulkhead vs. Exit Row
My only suggestion would be to make sure you don't select the front of the two exit rows in the DC9 (Row numbers vary depending on which model). Especially the window seat since it does NOT recline. Therefore, my exit row seat of choice is the aisle seat of the second exit row in DC9 and A320/A319.
My first choice seat is the 6D on DC9 since there is no one in front of you and you have all the leg room. Only minor negative is no storage room under the front seat since there is no front seat. So you have to store everything in the overhead compartment.
I'm sure you've checked SeatGuru's seating chart and wanted some other opinions. If you haven't, make sure to check it.
HJ
My first choice seat is the 6D on DC9 since there is no one in front of you and you have all the leg room. Only minor negative is no storage room under the front seat since there is no front seat. So you have to store everything in the overhead compartment.
I'm sure you've checked SeatGuru's seating chart and wanted some other opinions. If you haven't, make sure to check it.
HJ
#11
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 129
Things to Consider
I would generally take the bulkhead, although a handicapped passenger can trump you out of the seat. I was speaking to an agent the other day and she told me that this was a possibility, so she suggested the exit row. I have rarely seen anyone bumped out of the seat, but I have seen it. Just an FYI.
Last edited by whisprwave; Jan 11, 2005 at 8:46 pm Reason: typo
#12


Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: NYC
Posts: 8,691
Originally Posted by whisprwave
I would generally take the bulkhead, although a handicapped passenger can trump you out of the seat. I was speaking to an agent the other day and she told me that this was a possibility so she suggested the exit row. I haver rarely seen anyone bumped out of the seat. Just an FYI.
#13
Original Member
Join Date: May 1998
Location: Niceville, FL, USA
Posts: 2,792
Just a minor note about row 5 on the DC9:
It is a 2-3 configuration--
On the left (port) side of the plane, the rows are 5A and 5B; these are the usually designated handicapped seats;
On the right (starboard) side of the plane, the rows are 5E and 5F; these are usually open to any elites;
There is no 5D, hence the unlimited leg space for those in 6D.
It is a 2-3 configuration--
On the left (port) side of the plane, the rows are 5A and 5B; these are the usually designated handicapped seats;
On the right (starboard) side of the plane, the rows are 5E and 5F; these are usually open to any elites;
There is no 5D, hence the unlimited leg space for those in 6D.
Last edited by hnechets; Jan 12, 2005 at 3:19 pm
#14
Original Poster
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 422
Good point on the handicap note. I hadn't considered that.
On another NW trip, I have a 757-300 and a A319. I currently have seat 14B (one of the better seats on SeatGuru) on the 757, but from the looks of it, I might be bumped the day-of-flight if a handicap person needs it? These notes should be added to SeatGuru.
On another NW trip, I have a 757-300 and a A319. I currently have seat 14B (one of the better seats on SeatGuru) on the 757, but from the looks of it, I might be bumped the day-of-flight if a handicap person needs it? These notes should be added to SeatGuru.
#15
Original Poster
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 422
Nevermind - I see on NW's site that for their 757 they list:
Designated Disability Seats: Seats 16DE, 17BC, 17DE
Designated Disability Seats: Seats 16DE, 17BC, 17DE

