FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   MilesBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/milesbuzz-370/)
-   -   Best card for foreign exchange? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/milesbuzz/401958-best-card-foreign-exchange.html)

allen074 Apr 15, 2006 6:31 pm

fyi, my schwab visa still charges no fee and all my charges for this upcoming trip - the rates are better than whats on xe.com.

themicah Apr 17, 2006 6:21 am


Originally Posted by allen074
Natalie - welcome to the scam of all scams -- yes, you probably were charged a currency ripoff fee even though the purchase was in US$. The merchant located overseas and therefore they charged you a fee. Ain't that great.

I disagree. Many, many hotels and resorts advertise their rates in US$, then convert them into local currency for billing and charge your card in local currency. I recently stayed at two of Francis Ford Coppola's resorts in Guatemala and Belize, for example, and all deposit costs were advertised in US$, but billed in Belize dollars, costing me approximately 5% more than the advertised price once they had converted US$ to BZ$ and then my credit card converted back (including the 3% Citi charge, since I didn't realize I would be charged in BZ$).

susaboo Apr 17, 2006 4:41 pm

I have a Bank Direct online checking with interest account (AA miles for opening and on interest - thanks FT!) and it has the best deal out of all my cards and banks (I don't have a Capital One) - the ATM fee is only for whatever the foreign ATM fee is (they reimburse up to 4 for US transactions), and their Visa debit card just passes along the Visa 1 percent. If I wanted another CC I would get the Fidelity MBNA, but I don't.

I'm imagining that foreign ATM fees aren't going to be over $10 US, so at worst I would be charged 1 percent for $100. Oh, that's not right. That would be 10 %! I wouldn't get just $100, but I wouldn't get $1000 either, which would get it down to 1%. Maybe not such a good deal. But my other ATM card (Chase) charges $3 plus 3%, which just seems exorbitant.

Can someone tell me the range of ATM fees I might encounter?

lilla Apr 17, 2006 4:43 pm


Originally Posted by fun888
Just returned from Japan.. did some charges on the CitiBank cards.

Exchange rate is about 1% surcharge... there is another column showing the 4% charges making a total cost of 4 % to me.

another interesting things is, some local bank charges 1 % while other charges 2 or 3 % in the exchange rate, in addition to the CitiBank 3 %. The total cost of using your credit card can be as high as 6%.

From the ATM, Citibank ATM is 1.2% and Bank of America ATM is about 1.5% in getting cash.

There is no way out from the greedy banks.


themicah Apr 17, 2006 4:53 pm


Originally Posted by susaboo
Can someone tell me the range of ATM fees I might encounter?

I have never seen an owner-imposed ATM fee in continental Europe, the UK, China, Hong Kong, or Israel. The only place I've ever seen such fees outside the USA was in Canada, and it was CAD1.75, I believe, and my bank (umbrellabank.com) reimbursed me for it after I requested the reimbursement.

susaboo Apr 17, 2006 6:17 pm

If that's the case, it IS a good deal.

pinniped Apr 17, 2006 7:40 pm

Both of the popular new Juniper cards - US Airways and Midwest Airlines - follow the typical 1+2% method.

I use SPG Amex as my primary and my credit union's debit card as my backup while abroad.

I figure I'm still coming out a smidge ahead buying Starpoints for 2 cents, and my credit union debit card doesn't seem to pass through any charges that I can tell (vs. that day's interbank rates). I also get three free ATM hits per month worldwide with the debit card, which is plenty unless I'm hitting a lot of different countries.

fun888 Apr 19, 2006 3:46 pm

greedy CitibAnk -- NEW atm charges
 

Originally Posted by fun888
I did two experiments in hong Kong with my b of a ATM card and the citi ATM at their respective bank owned ATM machine... both without any aTM fee charge.

the exchange rate for HK$500 at each terminal on the same day, within 2 minutes (3/2 and 3/13 twice). BofA has the best rate of $7.76 (at the official exchange rate published by the Asia Wall Street Journal) while citi is only $7.68 which is 1% less than the official rate.

If you need Chinese YMB$, the best way is to get it from the bofA ATM in hong kong, the exhange rate is at the official rate too... Y$8.02. I can only get $7.9 inside China using cash. ATM rate are usually lower at Y$7.8 Citi has ATM at all major cities within China.

As to credit card, I get the offical rate of Y$8.02 and HK$7.76 using my charless Schwab credit card without any surcharge.


Just returned from China and used the citi ATM at the PVG AIRPORT TO GET CASH. When I returned, I found out that there is a surcharge of $5, or 1%, on my statement. The exhange rate is about 0.7% less than the official exchange rate as listed on the Asia Wall street Journal.

Call to Citibank, the lady answered cannot give me an answer. talked to a supervisor: It is Citi new policy to charge 1% on all foreign aTM transactions. If you use a non-Citi ATM, there will be another $5 to 7 surcharge per transaction.

Bank of America has a better exchange rate than Citi and they do not charge the extra 1% on their own aTM machines.

the moral of the story is ; stop using an citi credit card and ATM oversea.

sy7 Apr 19, 2006 6:02 pm


Originally Posted by pinniped
I use SPG Amex as my primary and my credit union's debit card as my backup while abroad.

I figure I'm still coming out a smidge ahead buying Starpoints for 2 cents, and my credit union debit card doesn't seem to pass through any charges that I can tell (vs. that day's interbank rates). I also get three free ATM hits per month worldwide with the debit card, which is plenty unless I'm hitting a lot of different countries.

Actually, you're buying SPG points at 3 cents. If you used the Capitol One 1% cashback card, you're in effect gaining an additional 1% of charges on top of the no conversion fee. However, I can also see not wanting to have yet another credit card to keep track of.

I guess I'm also leery of using AMEX for foreign transactions given the class action lawsuit (from which I got all of 3 cents). For some countries, they apparently had terrible conversions, and I don't want to waste the time calling up customer service to dispute the conversion rate. In this case, I think the class action lawsuit settlement probably had the opposite effect of what AMEX hoped for--I'm now very unlikely to use them for overseas transactions except under special circumstances.

QuietLion Apr 19, 2006 11:03 pm

Bank of America has informed me that they no longer waive the forex fees for Premier Banking Customers, so it's back to the Harvard Alumni Association MasterCard.

QL

Jumpcut Apr 21, 2006 9:12 am

The free ride on the Fidelity Investments Rewards MC has come to an end. Just got a notice that, effective June 30, 2006, a 3% 'transaction fee" will be added to all foreign transactions.

fastflyer Apr 21, 2006 9:49 am

Capital One MasterCard still has 0% foreign currency transaction fees.

themicah Apr 21, 2006 9:54 am


Originally Posted by fastflyer
Capital One MasterCard still has 0% foreign currency transaction fees.

Which particular CapitalOne MC do you have? If you wouldn't mind, please add this info to the wiki:

http://www.flyertalk.com/wiki/index....hange#The_List

Otherwise, let me know the details by PM and I'll do it for you.

Wolverine Apr 21, 2006 12:26 pm

For all of you that want to test out you card for foreign fee transactions before your next trip, try:

www.allofmp3.com

Buy $10 worth of downloadable MP3s (the current minimum), the bill is in Rubles so you can check your credit card bill online after 2 days to see if there is an extra charge......(BTW, allofmp3.com is the cheapest place on the net to get songs and it's very reliable, so it's at least a good investment for the ole' Ipod.)

I recently did this with my MBNA Amtrak MC only to find out that it's now 3%. :(

Wolverine Apr 21, 2006 12:30 pm


Originally Posted by fastflyer
Capital One MasterCard still has 0% foreign currency transaction fees.

Other websites on the net are rumoring this is going to change this year. So the Capitol One card will lose this advantage soon.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 5:30 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.