FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   MilesBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/milesbuzz-370/)
-   -   MilesBuzz: Canada (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/milesbuzz/1466579-milesbuzz-canada.html)

emilio911 Apr 24, 2016 3:40 pm


Originally Posted by jix (Post 26529311)
AMEX gold, but that's if you took the retention offer and then transferred points afterwards to other accounts where they cannot be brought back.

.

Thanks for your answer. :)

But is there a card that will not refund in normal conditions? (I'm not talking about gimmicks to get more points or anything...)

mahasamatman Apr 24, 2016 3:46 pm


Originally Posted by emilio911 (Post 26528849)
I meant one that doesn't refund you the annual fee even when you ask to cancel the card.

They should all do that if you're within the grace period, which I believe is typically 30 days.

Vit007 Apr 24, 2016 3:57 pm

Hello,

My credit score is 730+, last cc application (BMO AirMiles World Elite) was at the end of January. I am in Ontario. I would like to apply for a couple of Cards and would like some opinions.

1. The American Express® AIR MILES®* Platinum Credit Card w/ 2,000 AIR MILES bonus. I presently have two Amex cards: Starwood and plain AirMiles card (had this for 10+ years). Will Amex approve me for the 3rd card? Would I be able to self refer to this card, and if not, what is the best sign up additional money I can get? I do not believe I can change my plain AirMiles card to AIR MILES®* Platinum and get a sign up bonus.
2. Chase Marriott Rewards® Premier Visa® Card. I've got this card in November 2014, cancelled in October 2015. I should be able to get 50K sign up bonus now (minus free night certificate), correct? I've read about Chase being strict with accepting applications with >5 credit pulls in the past 5 years; not sure if it is for US or applies to Canada as well.

Do Amex and Chase do credit pulls from different bureaus? Any preference to which card I should apply first?

Thanks!

msNJV Apr 24, 2016 4:34 pm


Originally Posted by Vit007 (Post 26529533)
Hello,

My credit score is 730+, last cc application (BMO AirMiles World Elite) was at the end of January. I am in Ontario. I would like to apply for a couple of Cards and would like some opinions.

1. The American Express® AIR MILES®* Platinum Credit Card w/ 2,000 AIR MILES bonus. I presently have two Amex cards: Starwood and plain AirMiles card (had this for 10+ years). Will Amex approve me for the 3rd card? Would I be able to self refer to this card, and if not, what is the best sign up additional money I can get? I do not believe I can change my plain AirMiles card to AIR MILES®* Platinum and get a sign up bonus.
2. Chase Marriott Rewards® Premier Visa® Card. I've got this card in November 2014, cancelled in October 2015. I should be able to get 50K sign up bonus now (minus free night certificate), correct? I've read about Chase being strict with accepting applications with >5 credit pulls in the past 5 years; not sure if it is for US or applies to Canada as well.

Do Amex and Chase do credit pulls from different bureaus? Any preference to which card I should apply first?

Thanks!

You can only have a maximum of 2 personal credit cards and I think the platinum airmiles is a credit and not a charge card, you'll have to drop your SPG in order to apply for the Air Miles Platinum :) You're better off with one of the charge cards (Gold, Platinum)

Vit007 Apr 24, 2016 6:14 pm


Originally Posted by msNJV (Post 26529652)
You can only have a maximum of 2 personal credit cards and I think the platinum airmiles is a credit and not a charge card, you'll have to drop your SPG in order to apply for the Air Miles Platinum :) You're better off with one of the charge cards (Gold, Platinum)

Thanks for the reminder of credit vs charge cards :) I will keep SPG for now and will worry about Amex Air Miles later on.

I cancelled Business Gold in January, had it since February 2015 - is it too early to reapply?

I am mildly interested in Platinum charge card with 75K sign up bonus since many of the airports where I will be do not have a Priority Pass lounge. How does car rental get charged when booked via portal for $200 credit - when the car is booked or when it is dropped off? It looks like to me it is charged when it is booked.

JJonahJ Apr 25, 2016 9:55 am


Originally Posted by Vit007 (Post 26529899)
I cancelled Business Gold in January, had it since February 2015 - is it too early to reapply?

The general rule is to wait about 3 months after cancelling, before reapplying for an Amex card. That said I've reapplied for the Biz Gold Rewards card within a week after cancelling without issues. However, I may have been lucky, as there were others in the past (look in the older 2013/2014 Amex Canada threads) who have reported that a newly cancelled account was re-opened when applying too soon, such as within a month after cancelling.

grandgourmand Apr 26, 2016 9:14 am

I don't know if this is the right forum so please move mods if appropriate.

I have a refundable flight that I charged to my SPG Amex a couple of months ago. I need to refund it and book a new one. Can I just book the new one, incurring the charge (and earning the SPG points) and then cancel hte other one to offset the new charge?

I wouldn only do this once as I don't want to raise any red flags with Amex, but if i can do this legitimately I could get a nice new bunch of SPG points.

jerryhung Apr 26, 2016 9:23 am


Originally Posted by grandgourmand (Post 26537321)
I don't know if this is the right forum so please move mods if appropriate.

I have a refundable flight that I charged to my SPG Amex a couple of months ago. I need to refund it and book a new one. Can I just book the new one, incurring the charge (and earning the SPG points) and then cancel hte other one to offset the new charge?

I wouldn only do this once as I don't want to raise any red flags with Amex, but if i can do this legitimately I could get a nice new bunch of SPG points.

Probably belongs in SPG thread :P
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/starw...press-123.html

but I don't see why not
although, how is it different than cancel first + re-book?

You'll miss the original SPG points from original booking refund, but gain new SPG points on new booking

grandgourmand Apr 26, 2016 9:26 am


Originally Posted by jerryhung (Post 26537377)
Probably belongs in SPG thread :P
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/starw...press-123.html

but I don't see why not
although, how is it different than cancel first + re-book?

You'll miss the original SPG points from original booking refund, but gain new SPG points on new booking

It's not really a SPG-card issue. Could be any card, really. On the refund to they put my account into a -ve SPG transfer balance? They can't exactly claw back points from my SPG account. I was wondering if I get the points twice, really. Sounds too good to be true, which leads me to believe it isn't.

Hyacinthe Apr 26, 2016 3:36 pm


Originally Posted by grandgourmand (Post 26537404)
It's not really a SPG-card issue. Could be any card, really. On the refund to they put my account into a -ve SPG transfer balance? They can't exactly claw back points from my SPG account. I was wondering if I get the points twice, really. Sounds too good to be true, which leads me to believe it isn't.

Let me put it that way
-Statement 1:
  • 1 flight, $5000
Puchases-returns on statement, $5000 -> 5000 points earned.
-Statement 2:
  • 1 flight, $5000
  • 1 flight refund, -$5000
Purchases-returns on statement, $0 -> 0 points earned.

No matter how you do it. If you return a purchase of X dollars, you will get X points deducted from your new purchases.
It can help fast track to make a refundable large purchase but you won't get free points for an item later returned/refunded.

grandgourmand Apr 26, 2016 5:35 pm


Originally Posted by Hyacinthe (Post 26539282)
Let me put it that way
-Statement 1:
  • 1 flight, $5000
Puchases-returns on statement, $5000 -> 5000 points earned.
-Statement 2:
  • 1 flight, $5000
  • 1 flight refund, -$5000
Purchases-returns on statement, $0 -> 0 points earned.

No matter how you do it. If you return a purchase of X dollars, you will get X points deducted from your new purchases.
It can help fast track to make a refundable large purchase but you won't get free points for an item later returned/refunded.

D-uh...makes sense now. Thanks for the illustration.

Pseudo Nim Apr 27, 2016 12:10 am


Originally Posted by Hyacinthe (Post 26539282)
Let me put it that way
-Statement 1:
  • 1 flight, $5000
Puchases-returns on statement, $5000 -> 5000 points earned.
-Statement 2:
  • 1 flight, $5000
  • 1 flight refund, -$5000
Purchases-returns on statement, $0 -> 0 points earned.

No matter how you do it. If you return a purchase of X dollars, you will get X points deducted from your new purchases.
It can help fast track to make a refundable large purchase but you won't get free points for an item later returned/refunded.

... unless you never use the card again. But then, they might charge you for the negative balance.

grandgourmand Apr 27, 2016 6:54 am

Both TD and CIBC are offering 50k Aeroplan points on the Privilege versions of their cards. $399 annual fees on both, so definitely not cheap. But I like the card for zone 2 boarding. When it comes up for renewal I don't know if I'll keep it. Probably threaten to cancel (legitimately) and if they don't play ball get the competing product (hopefully it still offers 50k points).

mikeycanuk Apr 27, 2016 6:58 am

I've got credits back from Aeroplan redemptions to cards that were cancelled in the meantime. I've got cheques back (Amex/TD) and a transfer to another card (TD). Only in one case did TD (no surprise) claw back the points from my AP account.

zer0k1 Apr 27, 2016 9:57 am


Originally Posted by grandgourmand (Post 26541893)
Both TD and CIBC are offering 50k Aeroplan points on the Privilege versions of their cards. $399 annual fees on both, so definitely not cheap. But I like the card for zone 2 boarding. When it comes up for renewal I don't know if I'll keep it. Probably threaten to cancel (legitimately) and if they don't play ball get the competing product (hopefully it still offers 50k points).

This is fantastic :D


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:45 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.