FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   MilesBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/milesbuzz-370/)
-   -   Preparing for Churn Oct 5th (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/milesbuzz/1263763-preparing-churn-oct-5th.html)

mrx900 Sep 27, 2011 4:21 pm

Preparing for Churn Oct 5th
 
With the news of the Chase United Explorer card available to everyone with the bonus 60K bonus, I have marked these for the churn:

USAir MasterCard World Elite (barclays)..........40,000 miles after 1st use
CHase INK Business VISA (chase)...................50,000 UR points
United Explorer VISA (chase)..........................60,000 miles
AAdvantage VISA (citibank)............................75,000 miles
AAdvantage BUSINESS VISA (citibank)..............75,000 miles

I do have a USAir Mastercard already, and currently hold ONE Chase card (Sappphire Preferred), and TWO CITI ThankYOu card (VISA & Amex)...

would like to get your thoughts on my plan......ideas? tips? :D

Daggett76 Sep 27, 2011 4:26 pm

I don't think you can churn them. Most of the offers today have a clause "bonus offer applies to first time card holders only" or similar, so it's a one-time deal.

mrx900 Sep 27, 2011 4:29 pm


Originally Posted by Daggett76 (Post 17183515)
I don't think you can churn them. Most of the offers today have a clause "bonus offer applies to first time card holders only" or similar, so it's a one-time deal.

are you sure?

dinosims Sep 27, 2011 4:34 pm

Instead of AA Visa and AA Business Visa, I'd go for the AA Visa with the AA Amex for this round. Since both are personal cards, once you get one (without concurrently getting the other) you can't get the bonus until (people are reporting) 18 months after application on another personal card. Therefore getting 2 at the same time circumvents that and allows both personal bonuses to be received. Then, in your next round of churning you can include the AA Visa business.

Any particular reason why you include the USAir? The bonus doesn't seem that lucrative and they can sometimes give you a lesser card with a lower bonus.

Stoughton Sep 27, 2011 4:35 pm


Originally Posted by Daggett76 (Post 17183515)
I don't think you can churn them. Most of the offers today have a clause "bonus offer applies to first time card holders only" or similar, so it's a one-time deal.

AA's work if you do you're timing correctly

For the OP, I'd pass on the AA business, get the AA Amex instead and then get the business in 65 days

Daggett76 Sep 27, 2011 4:38 pm


Originally Posted by Stoughton (Post 17183564)
AA's work if you do you're timing correctly

For the OP, I'd pass on the AA business, get the AA Amex instead and then get the business in 65 days

That's good to know. Is it 18 months after closing the "old" card?

Stoughton Sep 27, 2011 4:39 pm


Originally Posted by Daggett76 (Post 17183574)
That's good to know. Is it 18 months after closing the "old" card?

Opening

Post #2 in the AA card thread (thisi forum) has the skinny

mrx900 Sep 27, 2011 4:49 pm


Originally Posted by dinosims (Post 17183554)
Any particular reason why you include the USAir? The bonus doesn't seem that lucrative and they can sometimes give you a lesser card with a lower bonus.

this card to my understanding is churnable...and you dont have to cancel the first card....granted, I do realize they can screw you over (as they did with my wife and gave her only 10K)...but its worth it, as these US miles can be used on any staralliance carrier...

mrx900 Sep 27, 2011 4:56 pm

AAdvantage Cards
 
just a side note, the last time i had the AAdvantage cards was 2009..I believe i got them (both personal Amex + Visa) in 11 or 12 of 2009...so I should be good to go..

HOWEVER (not sure this makes a difference) ...I did get the *CITIBANK* ThankYou cards in July...but they are NOT the AAdvantage cards...so I should be okay..yeah?

AlohaDaveKennedy Sep 27, 2011 5:25 pm

To everything (Churn, Churn, Churn)
There is a season (Churn, Churn, Churn)

And it is Grand Slam season now where you could piggy back a pile of miles onto that USAirways card.:p


Originally Posted by mrx900 (Post 17183487)
I have marked these for the churn:

USAir MasterCard World Elite (barclays)..........40,000 miles after 1st use


Stoughton Sep 27, 2011 6:23 pm


Originally Posted by mrx900 (Post 17183649)
just a side note, the last time i had the AAdvantage cards was 2009..I believe i got them (both personal Amex + Visa) in 11 or 12 of 2009...so I should be good to go..

HOWEVER (not sure this makes a difference) ...I did get the *CITIBANK* ThankYou cards in July...but they are NOT the AAdvantage cards...so I should be okay..yeah?

That won't affect the decision on the AA cards.

scwam Sep 27, 2011 6:28 pm


Originally Posted by mrx900 (Post 17183616)
...but its worth it, as these US miles can be used on any staralliance carrier...

How do you redeem the miles on other carriers? For example I have 150k American miles and 50k Continental miles. But I've found no way to use those miles on other star alliance carriers.

Tpa-flyer Sep 27, 2011 6:32 pm


Originally Posted by AlohaDaveKennedy (Post 17183768)
To everything (Churn, Churn, Churn)
There is a season (Churn, Churn, Churn)

And it is Grand Slam season now where you could piggy back a pile of miles onto that USAirways card.:p

Hilarious! This song forevermore will have a whole new meaning.

sadd Sep 27, 2011 7:25 pm


Originally Posted by scwam (Post 17183998)
How do you redeem the miles on other carriers? For example I have 150k American miles and 50k Continental miles. But I've found no way to use those miles on other star alliance carriers.

AA is OW.

sadd Sep 27, 2011 7:27 pm


Originally Posted by Stoughton (Post 17183564)
AA's work if you do you're timing correctly

For the OP, I'd pass on the AA business, get the AA Amex instead and then get the business in 65 days

It is said AA biz card ($1500 spending) was dead.

kendenton Sep 27, 2011 7:37 pm


Originally Posted by sadd (Post 17184272)
It is said AA biz card ($1500 spending) was dead.

Applied 9/23, approved instantly. Card arrived yesterday, agent confirmed 75k miles with $1500 spend.

Stoughton Sep 27, 2011 7:38 pm


Originally Posted by sadd (Post 17184272)
It is said AA biz card ($1500 spending) was dead.

The $4,000 version is still working fine

kendenton Sep 27, 2011 7:42 pm

Glad I got in on the $1500 version (again) in its final days ^

tpat Sep 27, 2011 8:25 pm


Originally Posted by mrx900 (Post 17183649)
just a side note, the last time i had the AAdvantage cards was 2009..I believe i got them (both personal Amex + Visa) in 11 or 12 of 2009...so I should be good to go..

HOWEVER (not sure this makes a difference) ...I did get the *CITIBANK* ThankYou cards in July...but they are NOT the AAdvantage cards...so I should be okay..yeah?


Originally Posted by Stoughton (Post 17183577)
Opening

Post #2 in the AA card thread (thisi forum) has the skinny

It has been well over 18 months since I applied for an AAdvantage personal card (I have an active Citi AA Personal MC that was opened in 9/2008). However, I opened a Citi AA Business Visa 11 months ago.

Do I have a good chance of getting approved for the 75K offers if I apply for the Citi AA personal Visa and Amex cards within the next few weeks...or do I need to wait at least 7 more months?

apuraja Sep 27, 2011 8:37 pm

Here is my list for around the same timeframe

Amex Gold Biz 50k
Amex SPG Biz 30k (this link i bookmarked weeks ago is live .. i'll obviously keep print outs of screen shots https://www201.americanexpress.com/s...TD&om_lid=axp5)

(are two Amex apps on a single day possible?)

chase ink business 50k
United 60K Chase

(are two Chase apps on a single day possible?)

bank of Hawaii Hawaii air (70k points via xfer to Hilton)
BOA Hawaii (70k points via xfer to Hilton)

(I've successfully done two BOA apps on a single day)


Citi thank U 50 k Preferred (no fee)
Citi Business AA 75k

(two Citi apps on a single day i.e. two browser trick)

thexfactor Sep 28, 2011 12:31 am


Originally Posted by apuraja (Post 17184584)
(are two Amex apps on a single day possible?)

Yes, I have been approved for both the plat and BGR in the same day.


(are two Chase apps on a single day possible?)
Yes, I have been approved for both the Hyatt and SW in the same day.

22calbr Sep 28, 2011 4:07 am

Are the chase ink biz 50k and the citi thank you 50k targeted offers? If not, can you please share the links. I'm looking for a similar credit card roundup, but looking forward to the new united mileage explorer card.


Originally Posted by apuraja (Post 17184584)
Here is my list for around the same timeframe

Amex Gold Biz 50k
Amex SPG Biz 30k (this link i bookmarked weeks ago is live .. i'll obviously keep print outs of screen shots https://www201.americanexpress.com/s...TD&om_lid=axp5)

(are two Amex apps on a single day possible?)

chase ink business 50k
United 60K Chase

(are two Chase apps on a single day possible?)

bank of Hawaii Hawaii air (70k points via xfer to Hilton)
BOA Hawaii (70k points via xfer to Hilton)

(I've successfully done two BOA apps on a single day)


Citi thank U 50 k Preferred (no fee)
Citi Business AA 75k

(two Citi apps on a single day i.e. two browser trick)


ddallas Sep 28, 2011 4:31 am


Originally Posted by 22calbr (Post 17185786)
Are the chase ink biz 50k and the citi thank you 50k targeted offers? If not, can you please share the links.

Chase ink biz 50k is the current offer on the Chase website:
https://www.chase.com/online/busines...s/ink-bold.htm

freezone Sep 28, 2011 10:17 am


Originally Posted by dinosims (Post 17183554)
Instead of AA Visa and AA Business Visa, I'd go for the AA Visa with the AA Amex for this round. Since both are personal cards, once you get one (without concurrently getting the other) you can't get the bonus until (people are reporting) 18 months after application on another personal card. .



The 18month rule is the bare minimum as only sometimes people can get the AA cards again, but the more realistic time is 22-24months. I applied for AA at 20 months and got the "denied" for not being a new member. I took another chance and applied again at 24months and got the AA personal cards. So, AA cards are churnable but must wait about 2 yrs to happen.

Never did any for Chase cards so Not sure if the 1st timer rule is written in stone for Chase cards or if they are churnable after a long waiting period. Perhaps someone can clarify how long I have to wait to churn Chase cards again as I'll mark that on my calender.

scwam Sep 28, 2011 12:26 pm


Originally Posted by freezone (Post 17187250)
Never did any for Chase cards so Not sure if the 1st timer rule is written in stone for Chase cards or if they are churnable after a long waiting period. Perhaps someone can clarify how long I have to wait to churn Chase cards again as I'll mark that on my calender.

My CO churn was 15 months, but then I'm not quite sure that we would call it a churn as I changed a lot of data along with new FF#, and different bonus amounts. So they may not have caught it (thus not being a churn in Chase's eyes).

x712xdamx Sep 29, 2011 1:14 am


Originally Posted by apuraja (Post 17184584)
(are two Amex apps on a single day possible?)

Yes, I've done this twice - this year.

iridium Sep 29, 2011 7:57 am


Originally Posted by 22calbr (Post 17185786)
Are the chase ink biz 50k and the citi thank you 50k targeted offers? If not, can you please share the links. I'm looking for a similar credit card roundup, but looking forward to the new united mileage explorer card.

What is the best way to use the thank you points? I don't see anything of worth except for maybe the gift cards.

iridium Sep 29, 2011 10:45 am

I am tempted to get the hawaiian air cards just for the transfer to hilton. I just got the 2 citi aa personal cards (applied 2 days back), is it wise to apply for these cards too?

tassojunior Sep 30, 2011 11:47 am

Don't forget the Chase CO Biz card (as well as personal card). They disappear very soon. I had the personal so this month I got the biz card- 25K on first spend, no first year fee.

You have to think far ahead on churns.

Most of the other ones will still be there in the future. Last chance for CO.

civico Oct 1, 2011 4:20 am

App-O-Rama, what do you think?
 
In a similar situation and looking to do an app-o-rama as soon as my 65 days clears and I can get the AA/Visa Biz card.

Here is what I already have:

Citi AA/Visa Personal- 75k on 7/29
BOA Alaska Airlines Visa- 40k on 8/2
Chase Sapphire Preferred- 50k on 8/3
AmEx Premier Gold- 75k (still fighting for the extra 60k) on 8/21
Barclays USAir Mastercard- 40k on 9/25
Barclays USAir Biz MC- 25k on 9/25 (still waiting approval)

The USAir Biz was probably a mistake but I hoped applied for that and the personal at the same time would be one pull (still seeing if that will be the case). Also, I got screwed out of the Citi AA/Amex personal (long story).

Here is what I'm hoping to include in the app-o-rama:

Citi/AA Visa Biz- 75k
Chase Ink Bold Biz- 50k
Virgin Atlantic- 50k
BOA Hawaiian- 35k
Hawaiian- 35k
United Explorer- 40k

Looking for some advice, as I'm not really sold on any of the cards completely other than the AA Visa Biz and the Chase Ink Bold Biz but there doesn't seem to be too many major offers out there. The Virgin Atlantic, the BOA Hawaiian, and the Hawaiian all have no annual fees, which is a little annoying, and I'm not sure when I'd use any of those miles (although it is nice to have a stash). I was hoping to include the United Explorer when it was 60k for everyone, but that seems to be on hold for now, right?

Am I missing any good cards? Should I wait on some better offers? And if better offers come, what is the usual wait time between app-o-ramas, 90 days? I don't want to get these and screw myself out of some that come later, although the big offers that were hanging around last year seem to be gone.

Thanks.

AlohaDaveKennedy Oct 1, 2011 10:47 am

Incorrectomundo - the Virgin Atlantic, the BOA Hawaiian, and the Hawaiian all HAVE annual fees. BOAHA+HOAHA=HA from the left coast or interisland hopping, VA=use a partner (Aloha Bonaire! in my case). In the case of BOAHA+HOAHA, Churn and meet the straaaange caaaases as one can never have enough Hawaiian Miles and they can be transferred with no fee (think Swaparama). VA is less churnworthy - like BA you don't wanna go there (at least on their overpriced metal).


Originally Posted by civico (Post 17202559)
The Virgin Atlantic, the BOA Hawaiian, and the Hawaiian all have no annual fees, which is a little annoying, and I'm not sure when I'd use any of those miles (although it is nice to have a stash). .


nabeelj Oct 1, 2011 3:03 pm


Originally Posted by civico (Post 17202559)
Virgin Atlantic- 50k
BOA Hawaiian- 35k
Hawaiian- 35k

That's 3 cards all from FIA - you sure you'll get 3 approvals?

The good thing is those three offers would results in 240K HHonors.

tassojunior Oct 1, 2011 9:42 pm


Originally Posted by AlohaDaveKennedy (Post 17203650)
Incorrectomundo - the Virgin Atlantic, the BOA Hawaiian, and the Hawaiian all HAVE annual fees. BOAHA+HOAHA=HA from the left coast or interisland hopping, VA=use a partner (Aloha Bonaire! in my case). In the case of BOAHA+HOAHA, Churn and meet the straaaange caaaases as one can never have enough Hawaiian Miles and they can be transferred with no fee (think Swaparama). VA is less churnworthy - like BA you don't wanna go there (at least on their overpriced metal).

Other than Hilton, I haven't found any use for Hawaiian miles. BofA gave me a credit line where I could have gotten that card but I decided not worth it. OTOH VA miles can be used on CO, UA, and US and are more valuable on Hawaiian than Hawaiian miles (6K RT inter-island vs. 15K). Plus VA will likely join *A.

AlohaDaveKennedy Oct 2, 2011 11:28 am

Swaparamability
 
As noted VA can do HA, but can't we all just get along? My VA and BoH HA and BoA HA cards all played nice together. Why use VA for HA when more optimal on CO, UA, and US? Get the BoH HA and BoA HA, stipmine the HA miles then properly dispose of the cards and move on. Ya gotta admit the BoH HA and BoA HA feed HA miles which, like Flexperks, can transfer to other parties with no fees - they definitely have Swaparamability!:p



Originally Posted by tassojunior (Post 17205789)
Other than Hilton, I haven't found any use for Hawaiian miles. BofA gave me a credit line where I could have gotten that card but I decided not worth it. OTOH VA miles can be used on CO, UA, and US and are more valuable on Hawaiian than Hawaiian miles (6K RT inter-island vs. 15K). Plus VA will likely join *A.


ddfr Oct 2, 2011 3:56 pm

hilton
 
Can someone please confirm for me that the 35,000 Hawaiian Airline miles earned can be converted to 70k Hilton points.

I am very interested in this, but saw someone verbiage today regarding "no transfers with 3rd party miles" and just wanted to confirm that these 35K Miles can in fact be converted to 70,000 Hilton points.

Could someone please confirm this for me?

Stoughton Oct 2, 2011 5:16 pm


Originally Posted by ddfr (Post 17208788)
Can someone please confirm for me that the 35,000 Hawaiian Airline miles earned can be converted to 70k Hilton points.

I am very interested in this, but saw someone verbiage today regarding "no transfers with 3rd party miles" and just wanted to confirm that these 35K Miles can in fact be converted to 70,000 Hilton points.

Could someone please confirm this for me?

http://www.hawaiianair.com/hawaiianm...ther-partners/

ddfr Oct 2, 2011 6:11 pm

confirm
 
Originally Posted by ddfr
Can someone please confirm for me that the 35,000 Hawaiian Airline miles earned can be converted to 70k Hilton points.

I am very interested in this, but saw someone verbiage today regarding "no transfers with 3rd party miles" and just wanted to confirm that these 35K Miles can in fact be converted to 70,000 Hilton points.

Could someone please confirm this for me?

http://www.hawaiianair.com/hawaiianm...ther-partners/


Thanks for the link below. I had seen it.

However, if you look below, when mentioning Hilton, it mentions an exclusion regarding points recieved from a third party or something like that which is why I posed the question. Has anyone sucessfully transferred the Hawaiian Miles to Hilton Points.

Any help would be very much appreciated.

PatMike Oct 2, 2011 6:28 pm


Originally Posted by ddfr (Post 17208788)
Can someone please confirm for me that the 35,000 Hawaiian Airline miles earned can be converted to 70k Hilton points.

I am very interested in this, but saw someone verbiage today regarding "no transfers with 3rd party miles" and just wanted to confirm that these 35K Miles can in fact be converted to 70,000 Hilton points.

Could someone please confirm this for me?

Check out Daraius' million mile secrets post

http://millionmilesecrets.com/2011/0...honors-points/

TennisPro Oct 2, 2011 6:50 pm


Originally Posted by ddfr (Post 17209329)
[I]Originally Posted by ddfr
Can someone please confirm for me that the 35,000 Hawaiian Airline miles earned can be converted to 70k Hilton points.


It worked for me. And the Million Mile Secrets post confirmed it for me before I did it.

kdoughboy Oct 2, 2011 6:58 pm


Originally Posted by ddfr (Post 17209329)
Originally Posted by ddfr
Can someone please confirm for me that the 35,000 Hawaiian Airline miles earned can be converted to 70k Hilton points.

I am very interested in this, but saw someone verbiage today regarding "no transfers with 3rd party miles" and just wanted to confirm that these 35K Miles can in fact be converted to 70,000 Hilton points.

Could someone please confirm this for me?

http://www.hawaiianair.com/hawaiianm...ther-partners/


Thanks for the link below. I had seen it.

However, if you look below, when mentioning Hilton, it mentions an exclusion regarding points recieved from a third party or something like that which is why I posed the question. Has anyone sucessfully transferred the Hawaiian Miles to Hilton Points.

Any help would be very much appreciated.

There IS an exclusion, and the verbiage is correct in that it applies to "third-party" miles. In essence, if you were to transfer points from Amex MR to Hawaiian Miles, you wouldn't be able to transfer those miles to HH. Since the miles from these sign-up bonuses are "first party" miles, if you will, you can indeed transfer them to HH. Hope that makes sense.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 8:37 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.