To post or not to post tricks
#1
Original Poster

Join Date: Mar 2008
Programs: AP, UA, AA
Posts: 709
To post or not to post tricks
I myself like to share these tricks and treats, but as you all can see..They are being VULTURED off of FT and posted everywhere...The people that are posting these fares to other sites are ruing it for ALL flyertalkers including themselves...Maybe it is better just to post the TRICKED fare and say TRICK-IT without giving any other details...Saying that.. KARMA CAN BE A BICH ..What do you other flyertalkers think ?
#2
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: DeKalb, IL
Posts: 87
"trick it" works for me. I'd just keep the caps off to keep it from standing out.
BTW, I'll be taking my second trip to LHR this week. Thanks to you!!!
The last trick allowed me to visit my daughter twice rather than once.
Thanks again
BTW, I'll be taking my second trip to LHR this week. Thanks to you!!!
The last trick allowed me to visit my daughter twice rather than once.
Thanks again
#3
Suspended
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Canada
Programs: UA*1K MM SK EBG LATAM BL AC*E50
Posts: 23,584
If its a mistake fare, I would post all details.
If its a trickable fare, I would hesitate, maybe post it and just say TRICK IT, do the rest by PMs?
Tough call.
I dont travel with OneWorld, so I should just post that trick up since I wont use it anyway, but if it ends up on some other forum within minutes

that ruins it for future use..
If its a trickable fare, I would hesitate, maybe post it and just say TRICK IT, do the rest by PMs?
Tough call.
I dont travel with OneWorld, so I should just post that trick up since I wont use it anyway, but if it ends up on some other forum within minutes
#6
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: PSM
Posts: 69,232
One is a typo in the fare filing (e.g. CDN39.00 instead of CDN3900 for a ticket in J from YYZ to LCA) and one is a situation where one of the ticketing agencies is not correctly reading the various fare components and therefore is not applying some component - almost always a YQ fuel surcharge - correctly.
#8
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: PSM
Posts: 69,232
And it would also have prevented some of the best "mega" deals. Quite a few have come from folks with very few posts. And enough people have enough posts that things posted would still be open to "pilferage" if you want to call it that.
#9
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Seat 2A
Programs: AA EXP LT GLD 1MM, BA GLD, NH/UA*G, Hyatt GLB, Marr Tit LT PLT, IHG Dia, HH Dia, MGM NOIR, Hertz PC
Posts: 10,595
As long as other longterm members who maybe have several handles because of previous suspension post these fares on their blog this is obviously not effective.
#10
formerly known as Frugal Travel Guy


Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Greenville, SC
Programs: UA Gold, HH Gold, SPG Gold, Marriott Silver, Hyatt Platinum
Posts: 1,925
Public Forums = Public Knowledge
The entire online population can see these posts.
How can anybody really expect these deal not to be screwed up is beyond me.
I've watched for 7 years people call to get their seat assignments, ask the airline if the deal was real, can they make a change once ticketed and every other lame reason to call the airline while the deal is still live. And then be dumb enough to post on here what they did, even seasoned FT'ers.
We have tried pledges, signature tags, talked about restrictions until we are blue in the face. If it hits a public forum, here, fatwallet, slickdeals or Mary's Home Cooking Blog, the deal is soon to be over. Just accept it.
If you don't want the information spread to the world; Don't post it.
I even watched a private group deal get screwed up a couple weeks ago because a member leaked it to somebody they thought they could trust. They couldn't or shouldn't have
If you have any information that you want to keep to yourself, keep it to yourself.
The issue is old news. Public Forum = Public Knowledge= End of Deal
And if you don't lay it out in a public forum, I'm going to PM you privately for the information I need. And you then decide to share it with me or anybody else on your terms. "Yes you can pass it on" or "No, keep it to yourself for 24 hours" or what ever you want to do. When you put it here, your options are over, done and Kaputt.
Beaubo, put it best and I'll paraphrase: "When you come to the Mileage Run Forum, come with your credit card in hand, and work out the details later"
When information hits here, the Fat Lady is walking across the stage.
How can anybody really expect these deal not to be screwed up is beyond me.
I've watched for 7 years people call to get their seat assignments, ask the airline if the deal was real, can they make a change once ticketed and every other lame reason to call the airline while the deal is still live. And then be dumb enough to post on here what they did, even seasoned FT'ers.
We have tried pledges, signature tags, talked about restrictions until we are blue in the face. If it hits a public forum, here, fatwallet, slickdeals or Mary's Home Cooking Blog, the deal is soon to be over. Just accept it.
If you don't want the information spread to the world; Don't post it.
I even watched a private group deal get screwed up a couple weeks ago because a member leaked it to somebody they thought they could trust. They couldn't or shouldn't have
If you have any information that you want to keep to yourself, keep it to yourself.
The issue is old news. Public Forum = Public Knowledge= End of Deal
And if you don't lay it out in a public forum, I'm going to PM you privately for the information I need. And you then decide to share it with me or anybody else on your terms. "Yes you can pass it on" or "No, keep it to yourself for 24 hours" or what ever you want to do. When you put it here, your options are over, done and Kaputt.
Beaubo, put it best and I'll paraphrase: "When you come to the Mileage Run Forum, come with your credit card in hand, and work out the details later"
When information hits here, the Fat Lady is walking across the stage.
#11
Original Poster

Join Date: Mar 2008
Programs: AP, UA, AA
Posts: 709
If its a mistake fare, I would post all details.
If its a trickable fare, I would hesitate, maybe post it and just say TRICK IT, do the rest by PMs?
Tough call.
I dont travel with OneWorld, so I should just post that trick up since I wont use it anyway, but if it ends up on some other forum within minutes

that ruins it for future use..
If its a trickable fare, I would hesitate, maybe post it and just say TRICK IT, do the rest by PMs?
Tough call.
I dont travel with OneWorld, so I should just post that trick up since I wont use it anyway, but if it ends up on some other forum within minutes
#12

Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: BNA
Posts: 2,076
I myself like to share these tricks and treats, but as you all can see..They are being VULTURED off of FT and posted everywhere...The people that are posting these fares to other sites are ruing it for ALL flyertalkers including themselves...Maybe it is better just to post the TRICKED fare and say TRICK-IT without giving any other details...Saying that.. KARMA CAN BE A BICH ..What do you other flyertalkers think ?
#13
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: BEG/DUS/FCO - YYZ/MRY
Programs: LH G, CO G, BA B, HH G, PC P, SW G, Sixt P, Hertz G and YES A|Club G :)
Posts: 800
Even that I am a newbie, I would like to learn about those deals as well, so I don't think these deals should be available for senior FTs.
I am really looking forward to all the things I can learn from the forum! ^
I am really looking forward to all the things I can learn from the forum! ^
#14



Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: ORD, MKE
Programs: UA, Hyatt and regular member of everything else
Posts: 1,535
Perhaps the MR forum could stay and a restricted MR "strategy" forum could serve as a place to share tricks without the whole world hearing about it.
#15
Suspended
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: MSP
Programs: DL MM (thanks PMNW!), DL PM, UA PLT, just about every darn hotel program-generally GOLD type level
Posts: 783
Wasn't there just a vote about this very issue?
I believe the modest proposal was that members had to be signed on in order to see the deals. Seems reasonable to me as it would restrict the info to members, including newbies, while providing a small shield from global web search engines.
I believe the modest proposal was that members had to be signed on in order to see the deals. Seems reasonable to me as it would restrict the info to members, including newbies, while providing a small shield from global web search engines.

