Originally Posted by guywhocan
(Post 30824312)
Personal.
In retrospect, maybe it wasn't the volume that got me shut down. I had cancelled and requested a replacement debit card a couple of weeks earlier. Maybe that put risk dept. eyes on the account. I had a great relationship with the WF branch folks. Will try switching to more mobile deposits/ATMs and less tellers in the future. |
Arrival Plus Closure by Barclay
1. It was shutdown by Barclay due to "Account Useage". Not sure what that means.
2. Had card for 2 years and $30K CL 3. Average balance about $10K, but month of closure it was about $20K. 4. Average $10-15K per month in MS 5. Last month I paid balance 6x during month. Typically I would do this 2-3x per month. 6. Never did BP except from another bank. WF and Chase 7. Not sure of this question. |
Originally Posted by coasttal
(Post 30835998)
1. It was shutdown by Barclay due to "Account Useage". Not sure what that means.
2. Had card for 2 years and $30K CL 3. Average balance about $10K, but month of closure it was about $20K. 4. Average $10-15K per month in MS 5. Last month I paid balance 6x during month. Typically I would do this 2-3x per month. 6. Never did BP except from another bank. WF and Chase 7. Not sure of this question. |
No, I did not drain the cashback frequently. In fact I was building up points to wipe out a $600 travel cost that was about to disappear. I got a $475 credit and that was the last thing to hit the account. Just paid $9k of the 14K balance and waiting on balance of debit cards to pay off the balance.
|
Originally Posted by coasttal
(Post 30837010)
I got a $475 credit and that was the last thing to hit the account.
|
Originally Posted by coasttal
(Post 30837010)
No, I did not drain the cashback frequently. In fact I was building up points to wipe out a $600 travel cost that was about to disappear. I got a $475 credit and that was the last thing to hit the account. Just paid $9k of the 14K balance and waiting on balance of debit cards to pay off the balance.
|
Which card are you using now for your MS?
|
Originally Posted by coasttal
(Post 30837484)
Which card are you using now for your MS?
|
Originally Posted by littlewinglet
(Post 30837579)
A bunch of 2x cards at giftcardmall, and I had a Discover 3x that just hit 12 months, and I'll have to sign up for another one of those in a few months :)
|
Originally Posted by wyogold
(Post 30837604)
Discover has gotten much tighter recently. I also need to renew my miles it but got turned down twice. Fico of 800 but to many recent inquiries and new accounts. Lol/24 ofc but never expected discover to turn me down ... Same situation as last year but it was no prob then.
|
Greetings, I signed up my mother for a spend bonus promo on her Bonvoy personal CC, but she has only 3k CL. So to be meeting the bonus requirements ($25k a month) she would have to cycle the CL more than 8 times !! And thus three more times during the year. That's quite a bit of cycling. I definitely don't want AMEX to shut down her accounts, but also don't mind taking SOME risk. The question is, how much? Does anybody have a good sense to estimate the risk here? I know excessive cycling is risky but also curious if the low CL makes a diference, meaning cycling 50k CL 5 times is not the same as cycling 2k CL the same amount. Thanks!
|
Originally Posted by DjRocket
(Post 30837789)
Greetings, I signed up my mother for a spend bonus promo on her Bonvoy personal CC, but she has only 3k CL. So to be meeting the bonus requirements ($25k a month) she would have to cycle the CL more than 8 times !! And thus three more times during the year. That's quite a bit of cycling. I definitely don't want AMEX to shut down her accounts, but also don't mind taking SOME risk. The question is, how much? Does anybody have a good sense to estimate the risk here? I know excessive cycling is risky but also curious if the low CL makes a diference, meaning cycling 50k CL 5 times is not the same as cycling 2k CL the same amount. Thanks!
|
Originally Posted by DjRocket
(Post 30837789)
Greetings, I signed up my mother for a spend bonus promo on her Bonvoy personal CC, but she has only 3k CL. So to be meeting the bonus requirements ($25k a month) she would have to cycle the CL more than 8 times !! And thus three more times during the year. That's quite a bit of cycling. I definitely don't want AMEX to shut down her accounts, but also don't mind taking SOME risk. The question is, how much? Does anybody have a good sense to estimate the risk here? I know excessive cycling is risky but also curious if the low CL makes a diference, meaning cycling 50k CL 5 times is not the same as cycling 2k CL the same amount. Thanks!
So if your mother has a CL of $3k, you can bet that as soon as she starts spending $25K a month, rat's eyes are going to bulge :o: Amex didn't give a CL of $3K/month for no reason at all. I would be very cautious pursuing this line of MS. |
Just a data point not a recommendation as your CL is very low. I have 30k+ limit on several amex cards. Amex lets me charge over 100k on these cards on one shot. I regularly go over 2 times my limit. (I do not think this is cycling because I am not paying it down, but I could be wrong) . I primarly do this on the Bus Blue because they let you carry balance interest free up to your credit limit, so I do this to earn the free interest. Plus you get 2x up to 50k spend each year, so I max that out also. You just get a warning that you are over your CL. In the begging they would just automatically raise your limit. Now I see an option to click here if you want your limit raised. I do nothing and just pay amount over limit plus minimum. They have a tool on their website to check spending power. You can see how much over you are allowed.
|
thanks for the data points folks. And yes, looks like that offer doesn't limit you to a month window. I guess signing up for my business Hilton card offer (10k a month) made me think of the same condition for mom's personal card. Good deal, makes a difference, still will have to "cycle" but not as much. Thanks.
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 9:40 pm. |
This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.