Last edit by: RichardInSF
List of Higher End Munich Hotels in Alphabetical Order
but I, RichardInSF (not speaking as mod), think it's pretty darn clear that the MO and Charles are a step above the other three.
- Bayerischer Hof
- Kempinski Vier Jahreszeiten
- Mandarin Oriental
- Sofitel Bayerpost
- The Charles Hotel
but I, RichardInSF (not speaking as mod), think it's pretty darn clear that the MO and Charles are a step above the other three.
Munich Hotels (consolidated thread)
#227
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Here there and everywhere
Posts: 6,303
#228
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: SEA
Posts: 311
3 nights at VJ - FHR booking
Mixed opinions about VJ.
Some staff are awesome. All the ladies in red are great. Concierge team is outstanding. One bar staff - young whippersnapper needs a kick in the rear or two - Wienerschnitzel order delivered in 90 minutes - they had to buy flour first maybe ... ? The restaurant bfast is good but the maitre’d attitude during dinner time turned us off. Unfortunately the bar was even worse - read above. The last morning we ordered room service bfast and we got enough food to feed 4 people!
Room is ok, bit on the small side but we had issues with the do not disturb sign.
One staff at the lounge really stood out. He arranged tea tasting for the wife, some dessert samplings and very quick with all kinds of request.
Their AMG partnership though is awesome. We got a free use of an AMG GT C roadster for a day, just need to fill up the gas. We ended up driving it to Schwangau and back - and listening to the snap, pop and crackles of the twin turbo v8 - much better sound than any car stereo can offer.
Not sure if we will come back. If they keep their AMG partnership we would - maybe. We complained to the fo manager on checkout and she comped all the extra charges outside of FHR benefit and the GM wrote me personally offering his apology.
Some staff are awesome. All the ladies in red are great. Concierge team is outstanding. One bar staff - young whippersnapper needs a kick in the rear or two - Wienerschnitzel order delivered in 90 minutes - they had to buy flour first maybe ... ? The restaurant bfast is good but the maitre’d attitude during dinner time turned us off. Unfortunately the bar was even worse - read above. The last morning we ordered room service bfast and we got enough food to feed 4 people!
Room is ok, bit on the small side but we had issues with the do not disturb sign.
One staff at the lounge really stood out. He arranged tea tasting for the wife, some dessert samplings and very quick with all kinds of request.
Their AMG partnership though is awesome. We got a free use of an AMG GT C roadster for a day, just need to fill up the gas. We ended up driving it to Schwangau and back - and listening to the snap, pop and crackles of the twin turbo v8 - much better sound than any car stereo can offer.
Not sure if we will come back. If they keep their AMG partnership we would - maybe. We complained to the fo manager on checkout and she comped all the extra charges outside of FHR benefit and the GM wrote me personally offering his apology.
Last edited by r0m8470; Jan 17, 2019 at 12:56 am
#229
Review: Mandarin Oriental
Last week I stayed at Mandarin Oriental. I like the location near Maximilianstraße, it´s in the heart of the city.
The arrival was very good and friendly. I had booked a Superior Junior Suite and received an upgrade to a Deluxe Junior Suite. Here are pictures from the public spaces, which are nice:
As the hotel is relative small it feels very intimate. During our hole stay Service was great, only one excemption was a desoriented guy who wanted to deliver a blanket to our room shortly bevore departure.
So far so nice but most important part for me is still the room. Our Junior Suite was quite small and simply felt dated. Beside an unpleasant stay (like cold smoke) I simply didn´t like it. Also I don´t like to Sleep near a door which leads direct to the public hallway including light which come through it.
The weakest part of the room was the bathroom. Small and not very appealing to me. Also I don´t like black joints.
There was also a terrace, pretty useless in November.
Breakfast was really good with high quality items.
We also had dinner at Matushisa, but I don´t include pictures. Food was pretty good but not great. Therefore prices were quite high. I wouldn´t dine here again, Munich has much much better choices.
Bottom line:
MO has a great soft product with world class Service. If I compare it to the Charles it´s miles ahead. Chales can be good, but during the majorities of my stays I had at least one heavy service issue.So regarding Service Hands down MO. Therefore the rooms at MO are not my taste, especially if I consider I Paid 925 € per nicht and the Deluxe Junior Suite would have been 1125 €. Room wise you don´t get what you pay, not even far. I like the rooms at Charles much more and if I consider I normally get an upgrade from a Junior Suite to a Classic Suite and pay often half the price it´s a simple choice. Perhaps a Major renovation at MO could change the game, I´m also looking forward to the new Rosewood.
The arrival was very good and friendly. I had booked a Superior Junior Suite and received an upgrade to a Deluxe Junior Suite. Here are pictures from the public spaces, which are nice:
As the hotel is relative small it feels very intimate. During our hole stay Service was great, only one excemption was a desoriented guy who wanted to deliver a blanket to our room shortly bevore departure.
So far so nice but most important part for me is still the room. Our Junior Suite was quite small and simply felt dated. Beside an unpleasant stay (like cold smoke) I simply didn´t like it. Also I don´t like to Sleep near a door which leads direct to the public hallway including light which come through it.
The weakest part of the room was the bathroom. Small and not very appealing to me. Also I don´t like black joints.
There was also a terrace, pretty useless in November.
Breakfast was really good with high quality items.
We also had dinner at Matushisa, but I don´t include pictures. Food was pretty good but not great. Therefore prices were quite high. I wouldn´t dine here again, Munich has much much better choices.
Bottom line:
MO has a great soft product with world class Service. If I compare it to the Charles it´s miles ahead. Chales can be good, but during the majorities of my stays I had at least one heavy service issue.So regarding Service Hands down MO. Therefore the rooms at MO are not my taste, especially if I consider I Paid 925 € per nicht and the Deluxe Junior Suite would have been 1125 €. Room wise you don´t get what you pay, not even far. I like the rooms at Charles much more and if I consider I normally get an upgrade from a Junior Suite to a Classic Suite and pay often half the price it´s a simple choice. Perhaps a Major renovation at MO could change the game, I´m also looking forward to the new Rosewood.
#231
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Enroute to ? & likely flying in ' A ':)
Programs: TPPS, UA, EK ...; Marriott BONVOY , HH, GP, GC..
Posts: 4,217
Will be staying next spring , April & May , planning on it along with Zoe pre & post Armenia & Georgia . Good to recuperate after a potentially strenuous trip
#232
Last week I stayed at Mandarin Oriental. I like the location near Maximilianstraße, it´s in the heart of the city.
The arrival was very good and friendly. I had booked a Superior Junior Suite and received an upgrade to a Deluxe Junior Suite
As the hotel is relative small it feels very intimate. During our hole stay Service was great, only one excemption was a desoriented guy who wanted to deliver a blanket to our room shortly bevore departure.
So far so nice but most important part for me is still the room. Our Junior Suite was quite small and simply felt dated. Beside an unpleasant stay (like cold smoke) I simply didn´t like it. Also I don´t like to Sleep near a door which leads direct to the public hallway including light which come through it.
.
Bottom line:
MO has a great soft product with world class Service. If I compare it to the Charles it´s miles ahead. Chales can be good, but during the majorities of my stays I had at least one heavy service issue.So regarding Service Hands down MO. Therefore the rooms at MO are not my taste, especially if I consider I Paid 925 € per nicht and the Deluxe Junior Suite would have been 1125 €. Room wise you don´t get what you pay, not even far. I like the rooms at Charles much more and if I consider I normally get an upgrade from a Junior Suite to a Classic Suite and pay often half the price it´s a simple choice. Perhaps a Major renovation at MO could change the game, I´m also looking forward to the new Rosewood.
The arrival was very good and friendly. I had booked a Superior Junior Suite and received an upgrade to a Deluxe Junior Suite
As the hotel is relative small it feels very intimate. During our hole stay Service was great, only one excemption was a desoriented guy who wanted to deliver a blanket to our room shortly bevore departure.
So far so nice but most important part for me is still the room. Our Junior Suite was quite small and simply felt dated. Beside an unpleasant stay (like cold smoke) I simply didn´t like it. Also I don´t like to Sleep near a door which leads direct to the public hallway including light which come through it.
.
Bottom line:
MO has a great soft product with world class Service. If I compare it to the Charles it´s miles ahead. Chales can be good, but during the majorities of my stays I had at least one heavy service issue.So regarding Service Hands down MO. Therefore the rooms at MO are not my taste, especially if I consider I Paid 925 € per nicht and the Deluxe Junior Suite would have been 1125 €. Room wise you don´t get what you pay, not even far. I like the rooms at Charles much more and if I consider I normally get an upgrade from a Junior Suite to a Classic Suite and pay often half the price it´s a simple choice. Perhaps a Major renovation at MO could change the game, I´m also looking forward to the new Rosewood.
That bathroom looks like it came from 2000. Old and worn. This is probably the most underwhelming MO hardware that I've seen in a long time. You'd think the 2015 refurbishment would have done the rooms as well.
#233
Unfortunately not really and the bathroom looked indeed worn. It can be they changed furniture as sofa looked pretty new.
#234
Thanks for sharing , offerendum
Will be staying next spring , April & May , planning on it along with Zoe pre & post Armenia & Georgia . Good to recuperate after a potentially strenuous trip
Will be staying next spring , April & May , planning on it along with Zoe pre & post Armenia & Georgia . Good to recuperate after a potentially strenuous trip
Service is their strength.
#235
Suspended
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Canada, USA, Europe
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 31,452
Yes, that bathroom looks very worn and dated, not like the one in my recent stay. I do like the new bar downstairs, though. Had some fantastic cocktails there.
Last edited by LondonElite; Nov 8, 2019 at 2:29 am
#236
#237
Was sydakllon
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: SYD
Programs: Virtuoso, Rosewood Elite, FSPP, Bellini, Dorchester, MO Fan Club, Oetker Pearl, etc.
Posts: 709
I got in early (!) and grabbed some points award seats into Munich before I go to Salzburg and Vienna for Christmas. Figure I should spend a night for the Christmas markets. Is Mandarin Oriental the best choice for this? Looking, I think it is the closest to Marienplatz. Or perhaps Bayerischer Hof or Kempinski? Probably not interested in the Charles for this trip as will only be one night.
Thanks!
Thanks!
#238
Suspended
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Canada, USA, Europe
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 31,452
I got in early (!) and grabbed some points award seats into Munich before I go to Salzburg and Vienna for Christmas. Figure I should spend a night for the Christmas markets. Is Mandarin Oriental the best choice for this? Looking, I think it is the closest to Marienplatz. Or perhaps Bayerischer Hof or Kempinski? Probably not interested in the Charles for this trip as will only be one night.
Thanks!
Thanks!
#239
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: May 2015
Location: BOS, YVR, ZRH
Programs: *G
Posts: 17,399
Any noteworthy updates to this thread in the last 2 years? I see there's also a new-ish Andaz in a neighborhood a bit north (Schwabinger Tor) as a Virtuoso property. Quieter, more walkable streets and cafes, maybe? Has anyone been?
#240
Moderator: Luxury Hotels and FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Palo Alto, California,USA
Posts: 17,856
The negative of the Andaz is that the location, while in a nice, safe, walkable part of Munich, isn't that convenient to many attractions Their restaurants are limited, although the breakfast was very good and I also liked their small coffee shop Bicicletta which is, you guessed it, bicycle themed. But the food is not anywhere near a Michelin star level.
I didn't try any other restaurants in the immediate neighborhood as they didn't look that inviting. However, a five minute tram or bus ride away (or 20 minutes walk) is the thriving area of Munich Freiheit, which has numerous (possibly a hundred or more) choices at the intermediate-price level.
Despite the location issue, I'd definitely stay again. I am also a bit of a public transit fanatic when it's good, and found a way to get from MUC to the front door of the hotel with only one transfer (S bahn train 8 to Ostbahnof, followed by 54 bus -- which changes to 142 at Munich Freiheit -- and then stops literally 100m from the front door of the hotel).
The hotel offers local transport in a BMW on a first come/first served basis, but I never tried this so don't know about availability.
It's a great choice if you have a car or are willing to otherwise deal with the transport issues. I'd say that the upper suite categories are quite reasonably priced at rack compared to the Charles and MO.