FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   External Miles and Points Resources (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/external-miles-points-resources-723/)
-   -   Which miles and points blogs censor comments? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/external-miles-points-resources/1459294-miles-points-blogs-censor-comments.html)

thepointsguy Jun 24, 2013 10:06 pm


Originally Posted by jsmithv (Post 20983448)
The Points Guy - when a commenter said they drove 5 hours roundtrip to visit a chase branch for a united personal card, my comment linking to the united personal offer thread got moderated out twice. Not sure if they just don't like links in comments or what. I was pointing out that heading to a branch for the offer is unnecessary, contrary to the article.

I don't approve comments- they post instantly, so if you never saw it post, it's likely it got flagged as SPAM. Posting it again would likely have the same effect.

I've written many times about the targeted United 55k+ offer- it was even a part of my last round of applications. However, it is targeted and the link to that Flyertalk is useless for someone who isn't targeted for the offer.

The Chase branch tip (which clearly isn't my referral link) was just a tip for people who were not targeted for the 55k, but still wanted it since anyone can go into a Chase branch and get that offer.

amolkold Jun 24, 2013 10:57 pm


Originally Posted by jsmithv (Post 20983448)
The Points Guy - when a commenter said they drove 5 hours roundtrip to visit a chase branch for a united personal card, my comment linking to the united personal offer thread got moderated out twice. Not sure if they just don't like links in comments or what. I was pointing out that heading to a branch for the offer is unnecessary, contrary to the article.

I think it's a problem with Disqus ... it seems not to like certain links.

TPG, you need to update your program swag! Delta DM???

jsmithv Jun 25, 2013 7:48 am


Originally Posted by thepointsguy (Post 20983673)
I don't approve comments- they post instantly, so if you never saw it post, it's likely it got flagged as SPAM. Posting it again would likely have the same effect.

I've written many times about the targeted United 55k+ offer- it was even a part of my last round of applications. However, it is targeted and the link to that Flyertalk is useless for someone who isn't targeted for the offer.

The Chase branch tip (which clearly isn't my referral link) was just a tip for people who were not targeted for the 55k, but still wanted it since anyone can go into a Chase branch and get that offer.

I disagree that the offer is only valid for those targeted. Using the steps in post 1654 will get anyone the offer, targeted or not. That said, I'm glad it was just caught as spam. Thanks for clarifying and i read your blog daily.

kokonutz Jun 25, 2013 9:10 am


Originally Posted by HikerT (Post 20976879)
Too funny. MrPickles keeps moving his blog to the "does not censor" list.

And the wiki battle of the 76 characters wages on!


18:38, 24 June 2013 Edited by: amolkold (76 chars removed)
12:24, 22 June 2013 Edited by: mrpickles (76 chars added | 76 chars removed)
19:56, 20 June 2013 Edited by: HikerT (76 chars added | 76 chars removed)
18:39, 20 June 2013 Edited by: mrpickles (76 chars added | 76 chars removed)
15:02, 19 June 2013 Edited by: yerffej201 (76 chars added | 64 chars removed)
:D

HikerT Jun 25, 2013 1:32 pm

It would appear amolkold has redacted mrpickles comment for 24 hours. ;)

ma91pmh Jun 25, 2013 1:44 pm


Originally Posted by HikerT (Post 20987909)
It would appear amolkold has redacted mrpickles comment for 24 hours. ;)

so is that censorship? :)

amolkold Jun 25, 2013 3:47 pm


Originally Posted by HikerT (Post 20987909)
It would appear amolkold has redacted mrpickles comment for 24 hours. ;)

Meta censorship :D

kokonutz Jun 25, 2013 6:12 pm

Tee hee, I just edited the wiki in a manner that perhaps can serve as a compromise between the warring factions in the great 76 character war!

Let's see who can figure out what I did first! :D

HikerT Jun 25, 2013 7:11 pm

Looks like another version of hide the pickle. Suggest just making it really small.

dhammer53 Jun 26, 2013 8:37 pm


Originally Posted by gpapadop (Post 20962303)

Let me tell you all a secret: You can transfer Chase Ultimate Rewards points to United AND Hyatt, wow!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Funny you should mention this. While the repetition does get annoying, it can be incredibly useful if all of a sudden, one day you need the information. I know about UA and Starwood. I've learned about Hilton and ICH over the years.

I never knew a thing about BA Avios until I got the 100,000 point credit card bonus.
I never knew a thing about Southwest.

Thanks to TPG and MMS, the repetition came on a day that I needed to learn about those programs. @:-)

And FYI TBB, I never paid attention to Chase UR until I got those Chase credit cards. The repetition is annoying, but it certainly is helpful for a newbie to a program. :o

Speaking of repetition, your loyal readers are anxiously waiting for cc links to appear on your blog. :p

yerffej201 Jun 26, 2013 11:09 pm


Originally Posted by dhammer53 (Post 20996540)
Funny you should mention this. While the repetition does get annoying, it can be incredibly useful if all of a sudden, one day you need the information. I know about UA and Starwood. I've learned about Hilton and ICH over the years.

I never knew a thing about BA Avios until I got the 100,000 point credit card bonus.
I never knew a thing about Southwest.

Thanks to TPG and MMS, the repetition came on a day that I needed to learn about those programs. @:-)

And FYI TBB, I never paid attention to Chase UR until I got those Chase credit cards. The repetition is annoying, but it certainly is helpful for a newbie to a program. :o

Speaking of repetition, your loyal readers are anxiously waiting for cc links to appear on your blog. :p

Strangely enough I would say that is true in only half of the cases.
Sure there was huge repetition with the Miles & More Card, but at least with readers like me who reads every post, I absorb a lot of the information. So had the coverage not gone up about the program I wouldn't have written the post today (you can see at the bottom of my siggy and I think is quite good IMHO) which might be useful to lots of people.

But I'm sure there are a lot of people who are just turned off by the credit card posts because I'm surprised from the number of comments who kept on thinking that domestic awards were only for Germany and Austria. ;)

gpapadop Jun 27, 2013 6:46 am


Originally Posted by dhammer53 (Post 20996540)
Funny you should mention this. While the repetition does get annoying, it can be incredibly useful if all of a sudden, one day you need the information. I know about UA and Starwood. I've learned about Hilton and ICH over the years.

I never knew a thing about BA Avios until I got the 100,000 point credit card bonus.
I never knew a thing about Southwest.

Thanks to TPG and MMS, the repetition came on a day that I needed to learn about those programs. @:-)

And FYI TBB, I never paid attention to Chase UR until I got those Chase credit cards. The repetition is annoying, but it certainly is helpful for a newbie to a program. :o

Speaking of repetition, your loyal readers are anxiously waiting for cc links to appear on your blog. :p

Yes you make a valid point. But I still think it is way too much overkill:D

Thanks for the encouragement...moving like a turtle. Higher priorities, u know, like answering blog comments lol

toomanybooks Jun 30, 2013 8:54 am

Does it count as censoring if the blog changes one's comment w/o notice?

Gary changed a word I used that was very mildly disparaging of a third person. I called the fellow a "goof" and it was changed to "guy."

EDIT: Gary and I have had a cordial exchange via PM wherein he says he did not edit my post. I am equally confident that I remember the exact word I purposely used, and it's different now. I suggested that perhaps Boarding Area changed it and he does not think that is possible.

So there you have it.

kokonutz Jun 30, 2013 8:05 pm


Originally Posted by toomanybooks (Post 21015753)
Does it count as censoring if the blog changes one's comment w/o notice?

Gary changed a word I used that was very mildly disparaging of a third person. I called the fellow a "goof" and it was changed to "guy."

EDIT: Gary and I have had a cordial exchange via PM wherein he says he did not edit my post. I am equally confident that I remember the exact word I purposely used, and it's different now. I suggested that perhaps Boarding Area changed it and he does not think that is possible.

So there you have it.

iPhone/pad auto-correction that you didnt notice when you posted???? @:-)

yerffej201 Jun 30, 2013 9:04 pm


Originally Posted by kokonutz (Post 21018550)
iPhone/pad auto-correction that you didnt notice when you posted???? @:-)

Goof autocorrects to good on my iphone.

brooklynmatt Jun 30, 2013 9:18 pm


Originally Posted by yerffej201 (Post 21018789)
Goof autocorrects to good on my iphone.

Goof autocorrects to canadadian on my iPhone.

HMPS Jul 3, 2013 7:34 pm


Originally Posted by dhammer53 (Post 20996540)
Funny you should mention this. While the repetition does get annoying, it can be incredibly useful if all of a sudden, one day you need the information. I know about UA and Starwood. I've learned about Hilton and ICH over the years.

I never knew a thing about BA Avios until I got the 100,000 point credit card bonus.
I never knew a thing about Southwest.

Thanks to TPG and MMS, the repetition came on a day that I needed to learn about those programs. @:-)

And FYI TBB, I never paid attention to Chase UR until I got those Chase credit cards. The repetition is annoying, but it certainly is helpful for a newbie to a program. :o

Speaking of repetition, your loyal readers are anxiously waiting for cc links to appear on your blog. :p

+1
MMS & TPG ( so I think the pics with dog are cheesy, but I am not a pet person, so I disregard and scan the subject matter) both may repeat at times. Who among us is going to read everything from day one when we chance upon a blog or a thread.? So a repritions is OK, besides it does take repetition for a human to remember !

Reading the quoted post, can any & ALL of us hereby commit that we will NEVER profit from posting any links ?;)

ffI Jul 3, 2013 9:25 pm

Censors - wild about travel
 
I saw this post for 300k points.
http://boardingarea.com/wildabouttra...r-70/#comments

I linked it to the RTw beer tasting thread on FT
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/ameri...pers-like.html

Comments were deleted

restonva Jul 5, 2013 12:12 pm

Thanks to this thread, I have stopped moderating comments on my Fishing4Deals blog. When I set up Fishing4Deals, I was holding comments for moderation, but now that the blog has picked up steam, I can see how that can discourage commenters. People want to see their comments posted right away so they can get immediate feedback from other readers. The WordPress spam filter is excellent and has always been right! The only discouraging thing is that I have ten times more spam than real comments.

yerffej201 Jul 5, 2013 12:24 pm


Originally Posted by restonva (Post 21045669)
Thanks to this thread, I have stopped moderating comments on my Fishing4Deals blog. When I set up Fishing4Deals, I was holding comments for moderation, but now that the blog has picked up steam, I can see how that can discourage commenters. People want to see their comments posted right away so they can get immediate feedback from other readers. The WordPress spam filter is excellent and has always been right! The only discouraging thing is that I have ten times more spam than real comments.

Problem for me is akismet is a bit wonky as it will filter out any comments that have links in them, even though they are legit. Quite annoying actually.

restonva Jul 5, 2013 12:29 pm

I have not run into that with Askimet. No problems whatsoever.

Raffles Jul 5, 2013 1:12 pm


Originally Posted by yerffej201 (Post 21045731)
Problem for me is akismet is a bit wonky as it will filter out any comments that have links in them, even though they are legit. Quite annoying actually.

Doesn't happen to me.

There is a WordPress setting under Setting / Discussion which says 'Hold a Comment for moderation if it contains more than [x] links'. By default it is set to 2, but you can change this. Perhaps this is the issue?

yerffej201 Jul 5, 2013 2:43 pm


Originally Posted by Raffles (Post 21045984)
Doesn't happen to me.

There is a WordPress setting under Setting / Discussion which says 'Hold a Comment for moderation if it contains more than [x] links'. By default it is set to 2, but you can change this. Perhaps this is the issue?

Oooh, that's why! Fixed, thanks!

sbm12 Jul 5, 2013 7:29 pm


Originally Posted by kokonutz (Post 20989822)
Tee hee, I just edited the wiki in a manner that perhaps can serve as a compromise between the warring factions in the great 76 character war!

Let's see who can figure out what I did first! :D

You know there is an edit history log which allows anyone to quickly see what was changed, right??

kokonutz Jul 6, 2013 1:10 am


Originally Posted by sbm12 (Post 21047470)
You know there is an edit history log which allows anyone to quickly see what was changed, right??

Well that's just cheating! :D

HikerT Aug 16, 2013 12:11 pm

The latest addition to BoardingArea, "Michael W Travels" should just change his name to "Michael W Censors". How dare anyone beg to differ with Randy Petersen's claim that BoardingArea is "a great family of bloggers who respect their readers and the information and advice they publish."

MichaelWTravels Aug 16, 2013 12:44 pm


Originally Posted by HikerT (Post 21285176)
The latest addition to BoardingArea, "Michael W Travels" should just change his name to "Michael W Censors". How dare anyone beg to differ with Randy Petersen's claim that BoardingArea is "a great family of bloggers who respect their readers and the information and advice they publish."

Hey Tom,

First of all, I do not censor but I will if it is a personal attack, rude or vulgar comment.
When you start a blog, you can make whatever rules you feel are appropriate.

Have a great weekend!

Michael W.

HikerT Aug 16, 2013 12:48 pm

What part of my comment was rude, vulgar or a personal attack? I basically said BoardingArea had become a massive affiliate billboard for FlexOffers (aka BentOffers) but that new bloggers could make it more respectable.

MichaelWTravels Aug 16, 2013 3:27 pm


Originally Posted by HikerT (Post 21285391)
What part of my comment was rude, vulgar or a personal attack? I basically said BoardingArea had become a massive affiliate billboard for FlexOffers (aka BentOffers) but that new bloggers could make it more respectable.

None of your remarks were and nothing was censored. I was saying that if I feel the need to in the future for those reasons stated, I would.

Have a great weekend.

HikerT Aug 16, 2013 6:14 pm

Thanks for clarifying. Could be something related to the moderation queue. Normally when comments are held for approval they still show up to the person that posted, but my comment went away, so I assumed it had been censored.

MichaelWTravels Aug 16, 2013 9:18 pm


Originally Posted by HikerT (Post 21286903)
Thanks for clarifying. Could be something related to the moderation queue. Normally when comments are held for approval they still show up to the person that posted, but my comment went away, so I assumed it had been censored.

I am new to Wordpress so there will be some hiccups along the way. It was never censored or tampered with so to speak.

I just don't get why people are so quick to attack and for nothing to be honest.

gpapadop Aug 16, 2013 11:37 pm

I learned this the hard way when Delta Points accused me of censoring when his comment went into spam by itself:D

Michael: Check Pending and Spam. Now with BA you should get the spam under control. It took me a while but now it is fine. At first, I was drowning in spam!!
Man, you are so jumpy...get it?

lacuadra Aug 16, 2013 11:42 pm

We should be able to share our thoughts and from time to time, our concerns and comments. Rule #1 of rhetoric is never to attack the author but the subject. Lately it seems that personal attacks are common and hurtful

However, a few bloggers get offended when one provides either a different point of view or questions the offers they post as best value out there. I have learned to skip them altogether.

MichaelWTravels Aug 17, 2013 7:48 am


Originally Posted by gpapadop (Post 21287773)
I learned this the hard way when Delta Points accused me of censoring when his comment went into spam by itself:D

Michael: Check Pending and Spam. Now with BA you should get the spam under control. It took me a while but now it is fine. At first, I was drowning in spam!!
Man, you are so jumpy...get it?

It's definitely a fun (not really) process learning Word Press. Blogger was just so simple to use. There is quite a bit of spam getting through so I have to skim each one. If the message is debatable then I wait and still most likely send to spam. There has got to be some better filters for this!

Guilty I am- of being jumpy! It's rubbing off on my 19 month old now. Lots of fun!


Originally Posted by lacuadra (Post 21287787)
We should be able to share our thoughts and from time to time, our concerns and comments. Rule #1 of rhetoric is never to attack the author but the subject. Lately it seems that personal attacks are common and hurtful

However, a few bloggers get offended when one provides either a different point of view or questions the offers they post as best value out there. I have learned to skip them altogether.

I totally agree with you however I don't really see a need or place for personal attacks. I've personally never had an issue with what a particular blogger posts or tries to sell. I can choose however if I'd like to continue reading the blogs Ive stopped reading a bunch of blogs where the content completely changed course.

Blogging every day is a ton of work and I do not see why there is an issue with bloggers getting paid with CC links. When the content is only geared to the CCs, that's when the problems arise.

My opinion and others are free to disagree.

gpapadop Aug 17, 2013 10:15 am

Michael:

You need the plugin Akismet.

Raffles suggested it to me and SAVED me from the spam! It has been a lifesaver!

Be careful in Albania & Kosovo, it can be quite a rough crowd over there!

I can't believe I am giving blogging advice, lol at myself:D

MichaelWTravels Aug 17, 2013 10:20 am


Originally Posted by gpapadop (Post 21289218)
Michael:

You need the plugin Akismet.

Raffles suggested it to me and SAVED me from the spam! It has been a lifesaver!

Be careful in Albania & Kosovo, it can be quite a rough crowd over there!

I can't believe I am giving blogging advice, lol at myself:D

Thanks for the rec. I am waiting for some more plug-ins and other site maintenance to be worked on. I certainly don't know what to do!

lacuadra Aug 17, 2013 4:35 pm


Originally Posted by MichaelWTravels (Post 21288749)
It's definitely a fun (not really) process learning Word Press. Blogger was just so simple to use. There is quite a bit of spam getting through so I have to skim each one. If the message is debatable then I wait and still most likely send to spam. There has got to be some better filters for this!

Guilty I am- of being jumpy! It's rubbing off on my 19 month old now. Lots of fun!


I totally agree with you however I don't really see a need or place for personal attacks. I've personally never had an issue with what a particular blogger posts or tries to sell. I can choose however if I'd like to continue reading the blogs Ive stopped reading a bunch of blogs where the content completely changed course.

Blogging every day is a ton of work and I do not see why there is an issue with bloggers getting paid with CC links. When the content is only geared to the CCs, that's when the problems arise.

My opinion and others are free to disagree.

I agree, we should never attack the blogger, never ever say things like:"you are too greedy and $%$%$ for providing mediocre links etc etc."

One should strive for civility and point issues, more like: " by the way, [blogger xxxx], there is a much more rewarding offer on XX. Can you check it out and see if your affiliate source can provide you with an updated link?"

I look forward to reading you.

milesforfamily Aug 31, 2013 10:05 am

Duplicate

milesforfamily Aug 31, 2013 10:08 am

When I had my interview with MMS about my blog, Rom from "Romsdeals" commented, that it's a tough crowd out there. Boy, was he right! Michael W, I agree on Wordpress. I thought maybe it was just me, but I am having a hard time figuring it out. Still don't know how to add Twitter button, my husband is in IT and can't get it to work!!! Oh, and I do sensor comments, if there is profanity or offensive stuff. Though I did let a funny comment about Mennonite miler through, because Amish most likely don't read my blog.
Keep on jumping, that's your niche, man!

milesforfamily Aug 31, 2013 10:22 am

Also, crazy question. How do I add my blog to the fine collection of sensor blogs? I can't figure it out, sorry.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 3:58 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.