FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   DiningBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz-371/)
-   -   Thoughts on Five Guys (the hamburger place) (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz/874380-thoughts-five-guys-hamburger-place.html)

WildEyedRighty Aug 29, 2010 7:52 pm

I used their web ordering for the first time this weekend, and I have to say, it saved a lot of time. The Five Guys I was in was completely packed... 30+ people in line. I just skipped to the front and was out in 6 minutes.

jackal Sep 3, 2010 12:16 am


Originally Posted by Steph3n (Post 14566950)
Give me fuddruckers, you can have your welldone five guys :D

since I am in a town with both now, I can freely pick.

Fuddruckers let's me have a wheat bun that doesn't get soggy in 5 min or less as well.

Mmm. Nearly forgot about them...

El Cochinito Sep 7, 2010 11:41 am

Tried a Five Guys cheeseburger when I was in Silver Spring MD a couple of weeks ago. Had absolutely no clue going in about this place whatsoever - I thought it was a local burger joint and it didn't dawn on me until I got in there that it was a chain. The reviews plastered all over the walls raved about the burgers so I figured it had to be good.

On the plus side the crew was friendly and I liked the ability to custom order a wide variety of toppings for the burger. The free peanuts were another nice touch while you are waiting for your food.

To be honest I didn't care for my cheeseburger very much and I did not finish it. The meat itself was somewhat lacking in flavor which surprised me given the high grease factor. And I like my fries crispy, which these were not.

Granted I'm a fan of In-And-Out (there is one only 10 minutes from the house). I think what separates the two, at least for me, is the flavor of the meat. And I think In-And-Out fries are also too limp most of the time, so the fry factor isn't a differentiating factor for me.

Next time I'm back east I'll give Five Guys another try, perhaps the hot dogs are better.

PFKMan23 Sep 7, 2010 12:23 pm


Originally Posted by El Cochinito (Post 14616024)

Next time I'm back east I'll give Five Guys another try, perhaps the hot dogs are better.

Not quite nearby, but there is a location in Fremont if you want to give it another go.

1worldtrader Sep 7, 2010 12:34 pm


Originally Posted by El Cochinito (Post 14616024)
And I think In-And-Out fries are al'so too limp most of the time, so the fry factor isn't a differentiating factor for me.

You can order your fries more crispy at In-N-Out if you so desire. "Well Done" is the term, but I think there may also be something between their normal cooking time and "Well Done"

United747 Sep 7, 2010 5:36 pm

I am not really a fan of Five Guys but in Chicago M Burger is my favorite. At Five Guys the burger was great but the cajun fries just taste weird to me.
Just my 2¢

Delta747

jackal Sep 11, 2010 5:58 am


Originally Posted by El Cochinito (Post 14616024)
To be honest I didn't care for my cheeseburger very much and I did not finish it. The meat itself was somewhat lacking in flavor which surprised me given the high grease factor.

The meat is kinda bland, but it is juicy. What I like best is the variety of good toppings you can add. If you just order a plain burger, you won't be satisfied. Add on grilled onions and a bunch of other things, and it becomes a very yummy sandwich.


Originally Posted by 1worldtrader (Post 14616322)
You can order your fries more crispy at In-N-Out if you so desire. "Well Done" is the term, but I think there may also be something between their normal cooking time and "Well Done"

According to Wikipedia:


* Fries "Light" - Decreased cooking time for a softer product.
* Fries "Well" - Increased cooking time for a crispier product.
* Fries "Extra-Well" - Further increased cooking time for a very crispy product.
* "Animal Fries" - Melted cheese, spread, and grilled onions.
* Cheese fries - called fries with cheese
The inimitable DavisWiki has even more detail:


Custom Fries
*Fries well-done are extra crispy fries.
*Fries light well are a little more done than regular fries, but not as crispy or greasy as the well-done fries.
*Fries lite are fries that have been cooked less than normal.
*Fries animal style include two slices of melted cheese, grilled onions, and spread as toppings. You'll need a fork to eat them.
*Cheese Fries are fries with one or two slices of melted cheese.
*Fries no-salt have no salt added to them.
*Lemon fries you can make your own lemon fries—just grab a lemon slice from next to the ice tea machine, and squeeze it on your fries. It really livens things up.

bk3day Sep 11, 2010 8:07 pm

I've only been to Five Guys a few times while at IAD & each time the bacon cheeseburger was great.

I think a large part of what it is that I appreciate about FG is that the burgers are hot, juicy & most of all, the bacon is served crispy.

All too often bacon is served up luke warm & reheated into a rubber/jerky type consistency.

Finally,my first visit to the new Five Guys at LGA was disappointing 'cause they screwed up my order. Since I didn't open the bag til I was airside & couldn't return it & had my twitter page open, I happened to tweet about it.

I soon heard back from the owner of the LGA Five Guys who apologized & offered me a $20 GC as an apology. ^

davidavid237 Sep 15, 2010 9:52 pm

I finally had my first Five Guys meal last night during a brief layover at Dulles. The greasy bacon cheeseburger and greasy under-cooked fries really hit the spot after a couple of drinks on my short inbound flight.

I kind of felt like I needed a shower afterward, however.

cblaisd Sep 20, 2010 7:12 pm

Had my first Five Guys today.

Hamburger was good, but the fries were extremely mediocre to nasty. (Limp and cool -- and this was at a busy time). The restaurant also ran out of salt. How do you run out of salt?

Unless this was a one-off experience, I would still very, very much prefer an In-N-Out burger with an order of well-done fries.

CMK10 Sep 22, 2010 12:33 pm

The new part of RDU's Terminal 2 (set to open January 23, 2011) will feature a Five Guys. Sadly, I doubt there will be free peanuts as the mall locations don't have them.

BearX220 Sep 22, 2010 12:38 pm

I have eaten one sack of Five Guys in my life. In DC, last fall. Took it back to my hotel room and ate it watching NFL. It was delicious, but I felt like I was sweating gravy afterwards. I thought I might die and it would serve me right. I fell asleep feeling spherical and did not regain energy for hours.

violist Sep 22, 2010 4:27 pm


Originally Posted by cblaisd
the fries were extremely mediocre to nasty.

My consistent experience as well, though it seems to be
a minority one.

DTS Oct 2, 2010 4:38 pm

First 5 Guys visit recently (Birmingham, AL): Liked it a lot, but compared to In-n-Out you really have to be hungry the burgers and fries are huge!

cblaisd Oct 2, 2010 7:05 pm

Gave another location a shot this week. Burger better than last time. Skipped the fries. Still prefer In-N-Out :)


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 1:30 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.