FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   DiningBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz-371/)
-   -   Thoughts on Five Guys (the hamburger place) (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz/874380-thoughts-five-guys-hamburger-place.html)

MSchott Jan 7, 2011 2:44 pm


Originally Posted by richinaz (Post 15596689)
They recently opened several locations in Scottsdale (and possibly other areas). My impressions are:
1. Significantly more expensive than In-N-Out.
2. I prefer Five Guys fries
3. In-N-Out does an exceptional job in keeping their restaurants clean and their employees are very polite. So far I don't see the same with In-N-Out.

Even getting the "little" burger at Five Guys I end up spending around $8. Getting the double burger at In-N-Out runs around $6. This includes drink and fries. Obviously you get more fries at Five guys but it is more of an order for two people to share.

Personally I don't think In-N-Out has anything to worry about.

Slightly OT but do you know if Ricky's Big Philly which closed last year on Indian School Road due to a landlord dispute has moved or reopened? Their Philly style cheese steaks were wonderful.

FLgrr Jan 7, 2011 2:46 pm

It is just a burger
 
Five guys is nothing special. Big portion, better than McD's and Bugger Death. No where near as good as Cheeburger Cheeburger. Sadly many CCs I know have died in FL. I wonder if it is cause of 5G? I am in Tampa. it is a local company. I wont go - Square One here is far better. But if I was somewhere and it was about the only choice, like I said in the beginning, better than others.

mjcewl1284 Jan 7, 2011 2:58 pm


Originally Posted by richinaz (Post 15596689)
They recently opened several locations in Scottsdale (and possibly other areas). My impressions are:
1. Significantly more expensive than In-N-Out.
2. I prefer Five Guys fries
3. In-N-Out does an exceptional job in keeping their restaurants clean and their employees are very polite. So far I don't see the same with In-N-Out.

Even getting the "little" burger at Five Guys I end up spending around $8. Getting the double burger at In-N-Out runs around $6. This includes drink and fries. Obviously you get more fries at Five guys but it is more of an order for two people to share.

Personally I don't think In-N-Out has anything to worry about.

Lots of my west coast friends swore by In-N-Out Burger, but me being from the east coast, it just seems different. The fresh cut from potato fries are just utterly disappointing in my opinion. Every time it just tastes like it's been sitting a bit too long in the fryer. And they don't serve much of it for a single portion. Five Guys serves you a more than generous portion, almost filling half a bag full of Five Guys Fries. The burger there doesn't blow me away, but it's quite good. For me though, I'll take Five Guys over In-N-Out any day.

Jimgotkp Jan 7, 2011 5:46 pm

Personally I think Five Guys is overrated and overpriced. I would rather save some money by grilling my own custom burger up outside. It's tastes a lot better and is as fresh as it can be.

Cholula Jan 7, 2011 6:23 pm


Originally Posted by Jimgotkp (Post 15608058)
It's tastes a lot better and is as fresh as it can be.

You must be grinding your own beef.

braslvr Jan 7, 2011 9:18 pm


Originally Posted by Cholula (Post 15608262)
You must be grinding your own beef.

And have a 5 or 6" patty press.

Pizzaman Jan 7, 2011 9:54 pm


Originally Posted by Cholula (Post 15608262)
You must be grinding your own beef.

What's the matter with that? I grind my beef all the ti.....Uh, er, never mind.

For those asking, there are 2 Five Guys in IAD. One is located across from gate B71 in the "new" part of the B terminal.

The other is located in the A terminal, where the majority of the United Express flights leave from.

As to Reagan, there's one in C past security, all the way down the end on the left.

ssb2045 Feb 10, 2011 9:57 am

I've been known to hit up the Five Guys at DCA and LGA for breakfast before a 7am flight. Something about it still hits the spot that early in the morning.

I agree that it's not the "best" burger in the world, but for a fast food burger it's definitely up there. The variety of toppings and generous portions of fries are a big plus, as are the made-on-the-spot burgers compared to the heatlamp, premade kind you get at McDonalds or BK.

greg0ire Feb 10, 2011 11:12 am

I wrote many pages ago how inferior it was to In N Out. I went a second time with the family and actually had a much better experience. The burger wasn't as greasy and is still second to the chain mentioned above, but it does not deserve my harsh criticism. The fries are way better than In N Out.

dchristiva Feb 10, 2011 11:41 am

Given that they seem to have expanded to just about every neighborhood, I shouldn't be surprised, but I hear that they are opening a location in downtown White Plains. Good news for me, given that I like Five Guys, and it'll be much better than the goofy Westchester Burger joint that opened a few months ago.

mjcewl1284 Feb 11, 2011 2:09 am

Question about 5G Fries- Can anyone finish a regular serving of their fries by themselves? Maybe I just can't eat like I used to, but I find it pretty difficult to finish the whole regular serving by myself. I don't have help either, SO won't touch them (veg/vegan, but she comes along because I ask her too ;) )

ILuvParis Feb 11, 2011 8:00 am


Originally Posted by mjcewl1284 (Post 15843742)
Question about 5G Fries- Can anyone finish a regular serving of their fries by themselves? Maybe I just can't eat like I used to, but I find it pretty difficult to finish the whole regular serving by myself. I don't have help either, SO won't touch them (veg/vegan, but she comes along because I ask her too ;) )

Even two people who finish one regular order of their fries are pigs (meant in the nicest way).

Steph3n Feb 13, 2011 8:20 am

I can't eat more than 5-6 fries....and that is dipping them in malt vinegar.

now they are better than the fries at McD, BK, Whataburger, etc, but I just can't do fries much these days.

there is a local joint that does sweet potato fries that I can handle a lot better, but even they get old after a couple.

Darren Feb 13, 2011 9:18 am

Sigh....what I wouldn't give for a big, juicy burger with salty, malty fries right now.

In fact, I would be happy with beef that came from an animal that at least moo'd through it's hopefully happy but short life or beef that doesn't need quotation marks ("Beef").

brendog Feb 13, 2011 10:07 am


Originally Posted by mjcewl1284 (Post 15843742)
Question about 5G Fries- Can anyone finish a regular serving of their fries by themselves? Maybe I just can't eat like I used to, but I find it pretty difficult to finish the whole regular serving by myself. I don't have help either, SO won't touch them (veg/vegan, but she comes along because I ask her too ;) )

Actually, I can, but there's a caveat. The closest 5G to me is a 16 mile bike ride on my fixie, so I have a 32 mile RT with several steep hills to ameliorate the disturbing caloric intake. This is the only way i allow myself to partake is the salty, meaty deliciousness of 5G.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 4:55 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.