Bakers...help!
#1
Original Poster




Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Here and There
Programs: Delta Gold, Hilton Honors Gold, All on my own dime.
Posts: 6,043
Bakers...help!
My mom, God rest her soul, couldn't bake a cake from a box to save her life. She could, however, make a cake from scratch in her sleep. She had a recipe for one of my dad's favorite cakes, a coconut cake baked in a "Bundt" pan. (If there is a better term for the pan, feel free to correct me...it's that pan that makes the cake into a big ring). Anyhoo, there is no information on the recipe for time or temperature (F) for this cake. I haven't had it in years (it's about the only coconut thing I'll eat) and I would love to take a crack at it.
Suggestions?
Suggestions?
#2
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: OAK SFO SJC
Programs: DL, AA, UA, AS
Posts: 1,028
Almost all cakes bake @ 350°, and are done at about 35 - 45 minutes. Set the timer for 30" to be safe and start testing. Cake is done when a cake tester (or toothpick) is inserted ino the middle of the cake and comes out clean.
Bundt cakes often take a little longer than layer cake pans because the cake is deeper.
Bundt cakes often take a little longer than layer cake pans because the cake is deeper.
#3




Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: BOS
Programs: SPG Gold
Posts: 620
I like to make most of my cakes using a bundt pan. A safe starting point is 350 degrees for 42 to 45 minutes.
Last edited by ghia74; Sep 22, 2008 at 4:26 pm Reason: Adjusted my time based on recent experience
#4
Original Poster




Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Here and There
Programs: Delta Gold, Hilton Honors Gold, All on my own dime.
Posts: 6,043
Okay. I am with the two of you on the 350 issue, but with such a wide range of times, "start checking" after 30 minutes, and a range of 30" to 52," what is the likelihood of my making this puppy fall by skewering it with a knife every five minutes? I figure the table knife test for doneness would be more accurate than a toothpick since the cake is deeper.
#5
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Orange County and oftentimes London
Programs: Marriott Bonvoy, HH Diamond, AA EXP, VS Gold, BAEC Silver, Global Entry, UK RT
Posts: 539
I just baked a cake tonight. 
Another method to check that it is done or nearing done is when the edges are slightly brown and are slightly detached from the sides of the pan. I would definitely start checking it at about 30 minutes. I think anymore time than 40 minutes may be too long.

Another method to check that it is done or nearing done is when the edges are slightly brown and are slightly detached from the sides of the pan. I would definitely start checking it at about 30 minutes. I think anymore time than 40 minutes may be too long.
#6
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Home
Programs: AA, Delta, UA & thanks to FTers for my PC Gold!
Posts: 7,674
but with such a wide range of times, "start checking" after 30 minutes, and a range of 30" to 52," what is the likelihood of my making this puppy fall by skewering it with a knife every five minutes? I figure the table knife test for doneness would be more accurate than a toothpick since the cake is deeper.

The cake tester/toothpick is used to make sure there's no more "raw" batter inside. You want the tester near the center to come out clean. You don't want to "cut" the cake and test for "firmness", as table knife is your choice of "weapon."
I would suggest you not use the knife but a thin & sharp subject, even a BBQ skewer will work better than a table knife.

In terms of baking time, well, it takes practice and experience. Other than judging by the brownness of your cake, use your nose as well. You should be able to smell the differences between underbaked and overbaked.
You don't want to open the oven too often to check on your creation. After 30-35 minutes, you can start checking maybe every 3-5 minutes. I like my cakes "brownier", so I sometimes just turn off the oven and let the cake sit a minute (or two) more after it's done.
You may google some similar recipes so you can experiment and compare notes. This recipe I just googled requires 350F for 60 to 70 minutes.
So if this is going to be your 1st try of your mother's homemade recipe, don't expect perfect for the 1st time around. Instead, use it as a baseline, so next time you'll know an extra 10 minutes is needed (if underbaked) or something.
Good luck!
#7
Original Poster




Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Here and There
Programs: Delta Gold, Hilton Honors Gold, All on my own dime.
Posts: 6,043
Table Knife? Well, you know you are baking a CAKE instead of steak or chicken, right? 
The cake tester/toothpick is used to make sure there's no more "raw" batter inside. You want the tester near the center to come out clean. You don't want to "cut" the cake and test for "firmness", as table knife is your choice of "weapon."
I would suggest you not use the knife but a thin & sharp subject, even a BBQ skewer will work better than a table knife.
In terms of baking time, well, it takes practice and experience. Other than judging by the brownness of your cake, use your nose as well. You should be able to smell the differences between underbaked and overbaked.
You don't want to open the oven too often to check on your creation. After 30-35 minutes, you can start checking maybe every 3-5 minutes. I like my cakes "brownier", so I sometimes just turn off the oven and let the cake sit a minute (or two) more after it's done.
You may google some similar recipes so you can experiment and compare notes. This recipe I just googled requires 350°F for 60 to 70 minutes.
So if this is going to be your 1st try of your mother's homemade recipe, don't expect perfect for the 1st time around. Instead, use it as a baseline, so next time you'll know an extra 10 minutes is needed (if underbaked) or something.
Good luck!

The cake tester/toothpick is used to make sure there's no more "raw" batter inside. You want the tester near the center to come out clean. You don't want to "cut" the cake and test for "firmness", as table knife is your choice of "weapon."
I would suggest you not use the knife but a thin & sharp subject, even a BBQ skewer will work better than a table knife.

In terms of baking time, well, it takes practice and experience. Other than judging by the brownness of your cake, use your nose as well. You should be able to smell the differences between underbaked and overbaked.
You don't want to open the oven too often to check on your creation. After 30-35 minutes, you can start checking maybe every 3-5 minutes. I like my cakes "brownier", so I sometimes just turn off the oven and let the cake sit a minute (or two) more after it's done.
You may google some similar recipes so you can experiment and compare notes. This recipe I just googled requires 350°F for 60 to 70 minutes.
So if this is going to be your 1st try of your mother's homemade recipe, don't expect perfect for the 1st time around. Instead, use it as a baseline, so next time you'll know an extra 10 minutes is needed (if underbaked) or something.
Good luck!
I think I have presented my topic giving the impression that I have never baked a cake before. Actually, I've baked more than my fair share of layer cakes (99% of them from a box, I didn't have mom's talent with cake flour), but making a bundt type cake is a new one for me, I believe.
Thanks for all the feedback, though. I'm going to try the cake this weekend.
#8




Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: YOW
Programs: AC E75K *G
Posts: 7,242
A table knife is more reliable tester than a what is essentially a thick pin, which could easily be wiped clean by the exposed dry cake surface.
The knife will do no damage at all to a cake made with a batter. In any event, anything in a bundt pan will be flipped over and the knife slit hidden from view.
If your round pan has any kind of molded decoration built into it, make sure you are not cheap with greasing it (even if the instructions don't call for it) or it'll be a biatch to get out.
The knife will do no damage at all to a cake made with a batter. In any event, anything in a bundt pan will be flipped over and the knife slit hidden from view.
If your round pan has any kind of molded decoration built into it, make sure you are not cheap with greasing it (even if the instructions don't call for it) or it'll be a biatch to get out.
#9
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: El Paso, TX, USA
Programs: Kicked out of all of them
Posts: 32,554
#10
FlyerTalk Evangelist, Ambassador: World of Hyatt


Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: New Jersey
Programs: Hyatt Globalist, Fairmont Lifetime Plat, UA Silver, dirt elsewhere
Posts: 47,401
They still make Baker's Joy. I believe you can get it at
http://www.kingarthurflour.com/
If not, they definitely carry a professional strength baking release spray.
This is one catalog you will want to get, but avoid the website - it's hazardous to your money
Oh, the lava cakes are out of this world ^^
http://www.kingarthurflour.com/
If not, they definitely carry a professional strength baking release spray.
This is one catalog you will want to get, but avoid the website - it's hazardous to your money

Oh, the lava cakes are out of this world ^^
#12
Original Member


Join Date: May 1998
Location: Detroit, MI
Posts: 2,682
Depending on how scientific you want to get...if it's a cast aluminum Bundt pan (feels heavy) you'll need the longer baking time. A formed (stamped...feels light) you need the shorter baking time.
Probably better to NOT keep poking with a knife---not for visibility but every time you cut into the cake you make it tougher to get out of the pan whole. A skewer (or piece of spaghetti) works well
Let cool for 5-10 mins before turning out onto a rack. You still want to have the pan greasing warm so it slides right out.
Grease heavily with a solid shortening or butter/margarine. Flour the pan as well. Bakers' Joy works well. Even if the pan is Teflon/nonstick, grease.
Probably better to NOT keep poking with a knife---not for visibility but every time you cut into the cake you make it tougher to get out of the pan whole. A skewer (or piece of spaghetti) works well
Let cool for 5-10 mins before turning out onto a rack. You still want to have the pan greasing warm so it slides right out.
Grease heavily with a solid shortening or butter/margarine. Flour the pan as well. Bakers' Joy works well. Even if the pan is Teflon/nonstick, grease.

