FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   DiningBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz-371/)
-   -   Your personal food rules..... (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz/578818-your-personal-food-rules.html)

CMK10 Sep 4, 2012 4:49 pm

It's amazing what a little hot sauce can do to an otherwise bland meal.

tfar Sep 5, 2012 1:51 am

Wow, just WOW! I didn't read everyone of the 600+ posts in this 46 page thread (so far) but is there not one of you who finds all this very strange?

I mean so many specific like and dislikes and whims, mostly whims and dislikes. How come?

Does this have to do with the other thread where someone asked what your mother's most loathed dish was?

I have to think really, really hard and I still can't come up with a single one of these "rules". I mean, yes, I am allergic to some things and thus normally avoid those. And even those things I actually like and will sometimes just deal with the consequences or take medicine so that I can eat these things.

There are things that I am not particularly fond of like caviar or things that I would find gross like testicles or eyes but stuff like having absolutely nothing on a burger except the meat and the bacon or eating food at room temperature, nope.

You guys are strange. ;) But I guess I might be the strange one because the strange guys seem to be in the majority. LOL!

Till

China Clipper Sep 8, 2012 6:29 am

Oooh I keep coming back to this thread http://i74.photobucket.com/albums/i2...ile_tongue.gif


Originally Posted by Chris Teifke (Post 19099084)
Crunchy is always better.

Word up, it's all about the texture ^


Originally Posted by rjque (Post 19144881)
Totally disagree - American cheese has one purpose and one purpose only: cheeseburgers.

I think it works better as a coaster for your beverage.


Originally Posted by SQmepls (Post 19147017)
i have no idea how i keep living here....

my "home" rules:

- no sandwiches not even fancy ones
- no raw veggies, not even salads
- no cold food or drinks until evening and even then I'll take a hot meal over a cold one
- no sour foods, including eastern NC bbq and vinegar based anything
- no fresh water fish, tilapia is sewer fish to me in particular
- seafood is preferred if it met its death in my kitchen by my hands
- no sirloin steak or cuts, tastes like blood/iron to me
- no margarine, canned whipped cream
- no white meat chicken ever

We are almost polar opposites


Originally Posted by McGoogles (Post 19149715)
Cheese - blue is the best and going in/on anything when it's an option.

Agree but Stilton & Swiss are right behind


Originally Posted by jsmeeker (Post 19226133)
I am wholly unimpressed by restaurants whose claim to fame is large portion sizes. If you tell me "Let's go to <some place>. They have really huge portion sizes", I won't want to go.

I won't even want to eat with them. I avoid Texas.


Originally Posted by kerflumexed (Post 19230582)
Smoked Salmon appetizer on an airplane. Coming back from Europe with OH, non-rev in F, it was so good I asked for seconds. I made it to JFK and could tell then that something bad was cooking. Never again. Luckily the evening flight back to Austin was half full and I had a seat in the back next to the blue room.

Perhaps a rare occurrence? I ask only because I have the smoked salmon often on planes, figuring that it's safer than most fish, having been cured etc. Now I wonder.


Originally Posted by headhunterke (Post 19237640)

- Only 2 rules: don't take any risks in warmer countries and ALWAYS eat as much as you can off stuff you can't get back home (and of course, bring some back home, if possible)

So many people do this--most are breaking the law, and it's a law with a good purpose.

998R Sep 8, 2012 6:48 am

I hate surimi, and I don't like snails (except small sea-snails).

emma69 Sep 10, 2012 1:34 pm


Originally Posted by China Clipper (Post 19276146)


So many people do this--most are breaking the law, and it's a law with a good purpose.

Hmmm, I wonder about the 'good purpose'. If I want really good cheese, I will sometimes buy it in Europe and bring it back with me (entirely allowed). However, I can only bring $20 worth. Now I suspect this is to prevent trade - but really, I could easily bring back 10 times that for my personal consumption (given cheese doesn't have an especially short shelf life). I think it should have the same sorts of rules as in the EU 'personal consumption quantitles' - and I could easily explain $200 (especially if I can also include French butter!)

I am also not sure confiscating an airplane cheese sandwich (when the beagle has once again ascertained that my airline lunch went into my bag unopened rather than consumed) has any good reason behind it.

lkar Nov 30, 2012 8:32 pm

Great thread. I don't have many but the oneS I have are weird.

1) Nothing that has or had a pit. Except guacamole.

2) "Sundried" tomatoes? No.

3) Nothing made of soy, except soy sauce or tofu. I will not eat pizza from a restaurant that promotes its use of soy "cheese". (If they merely serve soy cheese plus cheese cheese, it's fine. If they brag about it, no thanks.) Soy beans are not mammals and do not otherwise have nipples. Accordingly, I object to "soy milk" (and its cousin "rice") as misleading marketing. I guess "soy juice" wouldn't sell as well, but I object.

4) Thanksgiving leftovers are best enjoyed as a single combined open-faced creation in particular order: bread, mashed potatoes, turkey, stuffing, dollop of cranberry sauce. The layers of starch are very thin. There should be more turkey than the other things combined. Gravy is repulsive. Mashed potatoes should be simple: butter, milk, salt, and pepper. They should be whipped enough to be light but not "fluffy".

5) When making s'mores, never use a microwave and only heat the marshmallow.

6) Don't mix things into my ice cream. If it comes that way, fine. If the rocky part of the rocky road or chunky monkey or cookie dough has made the journey with the ice cream from factory, on the truck, to the store, to the table, great. They belong together. But if it's not in the carton, I am not interested. I like chocolate ice cream enough as it is. Hold the kit kat. No sherbet except rainbow should be eaten unless they are out of rainbow. (Sherbet should always be incorrectly pronounced, as though it includes a second r. For similar reasons, it's ok to use "literally" when you mean exactly not literally. And I am ok if you want to call whales and dolphins fish. Throw the ignorant a bone or two. It's hard being ignorant. And no matter what anyone says, a tomato is not a freaking fruit. I love scientists, but they're not the boss of me. Pluto isn't a planet, though. Sorry.)

7) Whomever had the bright idea to put raisins in bread pudding should get the fourth circle of hell, but not the fifth, which is reserved for the one who put nuts in chocolate chip cookies and brownies.

8) Mayonaise and merengue are disgusting and not fit for consumption by any creatures with internal skeletal systems.

nkedel Nov 30, 2012 11:07 pm


Originally Posted by lkar (Post 19775129)
And no matter what anyone says, a tomato is not a freaking fruit.

The plain English and culinary distinction of fruit vs. vegetable vs. starch is different from the botanical distinction of leaf vs. root vs. fruit (etc.)

Knowing when to use plain English vs. terms of art is something pretty much any scientist learns very early; correcting people is the sign of an amateur or know-it-all rather than a professional.

(If you feel like one-upping them instead, you can point out that not only is a tomato a fruit, it's a berry -- while a strawberry is in fact NOT a berry, but rather an "aggregate accessory fruit".)

BuildingMyBento Dec 2, 2012 7:48 pm


Originally Posted by lkar (Post 19775129)
Great thread. I don't have many but the oneS I have are weird.

1) Nothing that has or had a pit. Except guacamole.

2) "Sundried" tomatoes? No.

3) Nothing made of soy, except soy sauce or tofu. I will not eat pizza from a restaurant that promotes its use of soy "cheese". (If they merely serve soy cheese plus cheese cheese, it's fine. If they brag about it, no thanks.) Soy beans are not mammals and do not otherwise have nipples. Accordingly, I object to "soy milk" (and its cousin "rice") as misleading marketing. I guess "soy juice" wouldn't sell as well, but I object.

4) Thanksgiving leftovers are best enjoyed as a single combined open-faced creation in particular order: bread, mashed potatoes, turkey, stuffing, dollop of cranberry sauce. The layers of starch are very thin. There should be more turkey than the other things combined. Gravy is repulsive. Mashed potatoes should be simple: butter, milk, salt, and pepper. They should be whipped enough to be light but not "fluffy".

5) When making s'mores, never use a microwave and only heat the marshmallow.

6) Don't mix things into my ice cream. If it comes that way, fine. If the rocky part of the rocky road or chunky monkey or cookie dough has made the journey with the ice cream from factory, on the truck, to the store, to the table, great. They belong together. But if it's not in the carton, I am not interested. I like chocolate ice cream enough as it is. Hold the kit kat. No sherbet except rainbow should be eaten unless they are out of rainbow. (Sherbet should always be incorrectly pronounced, as though it includes a second r. For similar reasons, it's ok to use "literally" when you mean exactly not literally. And I am ok if you want to call whales and dolphins fish. Throw the ignorant a bone or two. It's hard being ignorant. And no matter what anyone says, a tomato is not a freaking fruit. I love scientists, but they're not the boss of me. Pluto isn't a planet, though. Sorry.)

7) Whomever had the bright idea to put raisins in bread pudding should get the fourth circle of hell, but not the fifth, which is reserved for the one who put nuts in chocolate chip cookies and brownies.

8) Mayonaise and merengue are disgusting and not fit for consumption by any creatures with internal skeletal systems.

I wish there was a guacamole fruit...

I'm mostly in agreement with you on the mayonnaise bit though, thanks to East Asia. It's used on too many things over there, particularly in bread and on fruit. I still like to use a bit of it on a blt though. Anything to make that sandwich even less healthy...

tcl Dec 3, 2012 4:41 pm

At home:
1) Garlic, onions, shallots, chives and other stinkies have their own chopping board and may not ever be cut on any other board even if their dedicated board is in the dishwasher. Only stinkies may be cut on the stinkies cutting board. Nothing ruins a homemade passionfruit pavlova or strawberry shortcake quicker than getting that tang of garlic from flavour cross contamination. :td:
2) There is a cheese tupperware in the fridge and all cheese goes in there to prevent the fridge and its other contents from smelling like cheese. Maytag Blue-scented mango moussecake and St. Albans-scented chocolate-coconut squares are gross. :td:

On the road:
1) Drink water
2) Buy water as soon as possible when landed.
3) Drink water
4) Make sure there is enough drinking water the night before for the next day.
5) Drink water

Reminding myself to drink water constantly has helped prevent getting ill on the road. I have a Platypus water bottle tucked into each travel bag and one in my tote ready to be filled from a larger bottle I buy at a convenience store (or from the plane's refreshment trolley). You can never have too many Platys (though I dislike Vapur) :p I find that once I get dehydrated on the road, it's almost guaranteed that I will fall ill. :(

ryanthekiwi Jan 18, 2013 12:27 am

It's funny, this thread has very little to do with travel but it screams "FLYERTALK" more than any other I've read. Never change FTers!

3Greyhounds Jan 19, 2013 2:26 pm

When eating at a Chinese restaurant for the first time, order a shrimp dish.

Chefs can't make anything look like shrimp except shrimp.

KurtVH Jan 20, 2013 9:30 am


Originally Posted by beachmouse (Post 19247793)
Part of the problem with eggs is the smell of them when they're cooking- it just turns my stomach. And part of it is the 'egginess' that I find to be unpleasant. It's a food aversion that I've had since about age 4, and I know it's totally irrational, but it just is, even as I recognize the value of the egg as a building block in many other things I do like.

I have an aversion to egg whites. I can eat eggs whites in scrambled eggs, especially if the eggs are scrambled "dry", but never on their own (either fried or boiled).

KurtVH Jan 20, 2013 9:49 am


Originally Posted by McGoogles (Post 19145405)
Eat at the dirtiest BBQ places.

An ancillary rule: Eat at barbecue places whose sign shows a pig in an unpiglike act. Especially a pig in a chef's hat cooking up what is presumably pig.

luxtrvlwrks Jan 21, 2013 3:11 pm

- No meat ever, unless I can't see it (e.g. chicken broth, Cesar salad dressing) and there is nothing else appealing on the menu.
- Mayonnaise is only good with canned tuna fish. Therefore, I do not eat mayonnaise.
- Whipped cream should be avoided since ice cream is so much better.
- Vegetables should never be allowed in desserts.
- Lettuce should never be shredded.
- Grape juice and wine are good, grape candy and grape jelly are gross. Raisins are the worst.

Kate_Canuck Jan 21, 2013 6:10 pm

1) I might be the only person in the world who loathes chives. I always feel like a pathetically fussy person when I tell the waiter not to put chives on my food (and I always have to mention it because restaurants think chives are so innocuous they never mention in them in menus).

2) Leftover pizza is best eaten just slightly warmer than refrigerated (about 10 seconds in the microwave is about right).

Other people's rules:

1) It drives me batty that my in-laws insist that salad can only be eaten after the main course is finished. But I want salad with my main course (and sometimes the only vegetable is a salad), and my MIL leaves me feeling like I'm uncouth.

2) Another MIL rule: champagne for the Christmas toast must be served in those old-style glasses that have a hollow stem and wide shallow bowl (which results in the bubbles disappearing too quicky). The glasses were stylish 50 years ago. They're not functional. Get over it.

nkedel Jan 21, 2013 6:17 pm


Originally Posted by Kate_Canuck (Post 20096553)
1) I might be the only person in the world who loathes chives. I always feel like a pathetically fussy person when I tell the waiter not to put chives on my food (and I always have to mention it because restaurants think chives are so innocuous they never mention in them in menus).

I grew up loathing them. I'm not sure what changed in particular, and I don't think I'll ever LIKE them but they're part of a (pretty broad) group of vegetables that I realized in my mid-20s that I no longer cared about one way or the other.

One of my coworkers still hates chives/green onion -- and any other kind of onion; also cilantro -- AFAIK the two aren't related, but because they (or something close enough to cilantro to not matter) go into the Pho most places, hearing him ask for it without either brings them to mind together.

BuildingMyBento Jan 22, 2013 5:55 am

Oh right, another of my rules- don't eat local fare when in Hong Kong, unless there is a place only selling har gow.

There was a small discussion about tomatoes and whether or not they are to be considered a vegetable. Whatever you consider them, they're a fruit to me, and to the Chinese as well- over in the mainland, they are frequently served at the end of a meal with other fruit, or sliced and topped with granulated sugar.

Dr Jabadski Aug 10, 2013 11:24 am

Wow, I just found this thread, terrific stuff. While I’ve only read about 100 of the 697 posts I can say that it is highly entertaining.
(Disturbing, but very interesting nonetheless. :D )

There are a few things which I didn’t see mentioned:

- No squash or zucchini :td: ; cooked, raw, fried, whatever, they just FEEL weird in your mouth.

- No peppers :td: ; red, green, yellow, whatever, they are an assault on the taste buds.

- Dessert should never include fruit or vegetables or anything else that could even remotely be considered “healthy”. Dessert should have absolutely no nutritional value whatsoever. Invariably desserts with chocolate are vastly superior to all others. ^

- Dinner leftovers, be it pizza or chicken or pasta or whatever, served hot or cold, are generally more appealing as breakfast than the majority of traditional breakfast foods. @:-)


And of course I haven’t read any proper listings of the 5 basic food groups, which SHOULD be:
- Candy and Chocolate
- Ice Cream
- Cake and Cookies
- Salty Crunchy Processed
- Pizza
- Bacon (Cooked medium to medium well, chewy, definitely NOT crispy, if I wanted it crispy I’d eat a piece of charcoal. :eek: )
(Yeah, I know, that’s 6. What’s wrong with 6? ;) )

Mauibaby2008 Aug 10, 2013 9:44 pm

Your personal food rules.....
 
Anything but fish soup. Yes, some people boil fish bones and drink it as soup. Stinks and tastes bad!!!

BuildingMyBento Aug 11, 2013 1:43 pm


Originally Posted by Dr Jabadski (Post 21248618)
- No peppers :td: ; red, green, yellow, whatever, they are an assault on the taste buds.

No bell peppers (capsicum) either?

frontrangeFF Aug 12, 2013 2:29 pm

Pudding (the american kind) is disgusting, as are ripe bananas. When drinking a soda, admittedly a rare event, the soda can must be pre-chilled and poured into a glass 2/3 full of ice.

ILuvParis Aug 15, 2013 1:51 pm


Originally Posted by Kate_Canuck (Post 20096553)
1) I might be the only person in the world who loathes chives. I always feel like a pathetically fussy person when I tell the waiter not to put chives on my food (and I always have to mention it because restaurants think chives are so innocuous they never mention in them in menus).

You are not. My partner hates them and anything else green (mint ice cream might be the only exception I can think of). :)

exilencfc Aug 16, 2013 5:37 am


Originally Posted by KurtVH (Post 20087217)
I have an aversion to egg whites. I can eat eggs whites in scrambled eggs, especially if the eggs are scrambled "dry", but never on their own (either fried or boiled).

Me too. I don't like scrambled eggs, although I do eat egg mayo provided the egg is well mashed up. No objection to omlettes either.

I won't eat mushrooms on their own but I don't mind them as an ingredient provided they're either in big bits I can pull out or tiny pieces that are hard to detect - I like the taste but I can't stand the texture. Ironically frying mushrooms is one of my favourite smells.

Sweet Willie Aug 16, 2013 12:20 pm

well I finally read this whole thread

Originally Posted by Stefferdoos (Post 11391228)
re: Cilantro
I too think it tastes like soap. I read a few months back its some genetic thing that causes some of us to get the soap taste and others don't.

you are correct, approx 20% of people think cilantro has a soapy taste.

Many have made statements that echo my own, I very much agree with the following:

Originally Posted by jimcfsus (Post 6067180)
As a native of the "north", I hate having to specifically ask for "unsweet tea" here south of the Mason-Dixon... (I am now Pavlovian trained and do so even north of it too, by habit) and then half the time, they still give you sweet tea. No sugar, no equal, no pink stuff... perhaps a fresh wedge of lemon is all it needs. Oh, lots of ice too. Iced tea isn't lukewarm tea.


Originally Posted by adelauro (Post 12773730)
OK, one more -- cheez whiz is not cheese, therefore should not be on a cheesesteak sandwich


Originally Posted by stut (Post 16694918)
Mild cheddar isn't cheese, it's a form of edible rubber. Give me crumbly, crystally, pungent


Originally Posted by MKEbound (Post 6064588)
If you come to dinner at my house, don't salt the food I present to you without tasting it first, it's insulting. Steak, hamburgers and brats should only be cooked on the grill. Outside Temperatures below 0 are not an excuse to skip this rule.


Originally Posted by Analise (Post 6065887)
8. A good hotdog has that snap.


Originally Posted by Duhey2 (Post 6067533)
2) "New England" or "Boston" (an iteration usually found west of the Continental Divide) clam chowder shall NEVER, EVER contain carrots, pimentos, or any vegetables whose colors are found in the ROY(edited to add GBIV) part of the spectrum;

4) No Miracle Whip, ever


Originally Posted by seattletravelguy (Post 19153344)
No taco shells, ever. - ...taco shells are the anti-Christ. You just don't allow these outside forces into your home.


Originally Posted by stupidhead (Post 11389065)
26. Margerine is henceforth permanently banned from my kitchen.


Originally Posted by braslvr (Post 12577827)
Cold cereal MUST be eaten with a large (soup) spoon. It is impossible to attain the correct milk-to-cereal ratio per bite with a teaspoon. For this reason, I rarely ever eat cereal anywhere but home. It must also be eaten in small "batches" so it stays crispier.


Originally Posted by ILuvParis (Post 16647077)
If the people who maintain the restroom aren't smart enough to have a trash barrel inside the door, so I can open the door and deposit my paper towel, it goes on the floor. They'll get the message eventually. :)


Originally Posted by deniah (Post 17808933)
5. tilapia is not a 'real' fish.


Originally Posted by MikeFromTokyo (Post 18498499)
No farmed or frozen shrimp from Thailand

not just from Thailand, no farmed shrimp from anywhere, only farmed seafood I eat (that I know of) are oysters or mussels.

Originally Posted by ale.penazzi (Post 17781684)
PS I always thought "well-done" was a compliment, not a a way to cook a steak..


Originally Posted by venice4504 (Post 6835937)
Mashed potatoes must come from a potato, not a box.


Originally Posted by MBS MillionMiler (Post 11326555)
If I'm in a restaurant, and lamb is on the menu, there's a 90% chance that's what I'm ordering.


Originally Posted by stupidhead (Post 11333415)
14. The recipe may be law, but they're still my groceries. As the cook, I reserve the right to include/exclude/modify the proportions of/substitute/improvise ingredients in any way I see fit.


Originally Posted by Green Dragon (Post 7026516)
16. Cold pizza is a perfectly nutritious and delicious breakfast.


Originally Posted by t325 (Post 16652393)
I'm one of the few people who think the diet version of sodas tastes better than their non-diet counterparts. So no sugared up soda for me.


Originally Posted by jimbob (Post 7029666)
- Locally grown food when practical.

- Fresh food when practical.


Originally Posted by carpboy (Post 6838847)
13) Olives of any sort are banned. Olive oil is to be encouraged.

only olives that pass my lips is the olive tapenade on a muffuletta sandwich

Originally Posted by redbeard911 (Post 6061697)
Meat goes on a pizza, vegetables go in a salad.

I will also add an additional caveat, if having pizza (thick or thin) in Chicago, that meat shall be Italian Sausage which is what most pizzas in Chicago are ordered with, NOT pepperoni (which is reserved for the rest of the U.S.)

Then there are statements that are downright wrong:

Originally Posted by ILuvParis (Post 6063947)
French fries are not worth eating without Ketchup.

what about frites mit mayo, or sometimes they are so good they don’t need anything added.

Originally Posted by 53flyer (Post 6063988)
2. Never eat anything black (black is nature's way of shouting "stay away!")

there’s a number of delicious black items: black beans, mole negro, blood sausage, etc.

Originally Posted by Analise (Post 6065887)
10. Never eat bagels outside the NYC metropolitan area.

bagels in Montreal are fantastic.

Originally Posted by jimcfsus (Post 6840569)
Or a Friday Fish Fry (as you can only get in the western NY area... I'm originally from near Olean).

(bolding mine) nonsense, There are amazing Friday Fish Fry in a number of locations, N Wisconsin being one of them.

Originally Posted by notsosmart (Post 7029833)
One simple rule, which works 95% of the time: no matter what the food, no matter where I am, if I apply myself, I can make it better myself.

you are one of 3 things: 1) have limited cuisine(s) that you cook 2) a liar (or delusional) 3) an AMAZING chef with quite a bit of #1 thrown in.

Originally Posted by KNRG (Post 11389004)
Meat in a salad can be good but it should not be hot/warm and introduced to an otherwise cold salad. Warm lettuce is gross.

a quick summer meal is a big salad with some fresh grilled meat put on it. I make a grilled lettuce dish that everyone I’ve made it for loves.

Originally Posted by braslvr (Post 12577827)
Everything else being equal, a hamburger will always be MUCH better with multiple thin (1/4 inch) patties than one thick one.

you are an In-N-Out fan:), for me a thicker patty cooked no more than a medium rare trumps a thin patty, no matter how many thin patties you have.

Originally Posted by SomeGuy (Post 16906966)
Don't eat at a restaurant in a gas station.

Oklahoma Joe's in KC certainly is an exception as well as some Puerto Rican place outside Orlando (name escapes me) which made delicious mofongo or even some of the Iowa truckstops that make amazing pork tenderloin sandwiches.


Statement I'm most puzzled by:

Originally Posted by jimbob (Post 7029666)
- I don't like onions. I must love onion flavor because I love lots of soups and Indian dishes where it's the #1 or #2 ingredient, but I still avoid them when possible.

why avoid onions if you love onion flavor?

The statements I agree with most however are:

Originally Posted by happymob (Post 6838899)
4) Try anything local.


Originally Posted by Princess1 (Post 17782247)
My travel rule is to eat local.


Originally Posted by General_Flyer (Post 16609841)
8. Eat what the locals eat

I'll do so even if this means going against what I normally like, ya never know what will be good.

Originally Posted by Jailer (Post 11391392)
My number one rule is, when travelling, none of the following rules apply; my number two rule is don’t be an assbite about it, and at parties/dinners, or whatever, eat what is served.

Amen !

Originally Posted by violist (Post 13907976)
As far as sharing and stuff, I feel it almost mandatory, and if you don't subscribe to this, tell me right away and I'll respect that

another Amen !
--
-

ILuvParis Aug 16, 2013 1:44 pm


Originally Posted by ILuvParis
French fries are not worth eating without Ketchup.


Originally Posted by Sweet Willie
what about frites mit mayo, or sometimes they are so good they don’t need anything added.

I stand by my original statement. And Ketchup means Heinz. :)

Not a big fan of the mayo and I find plain fries boring, as are baked without butter or sour cream and boiled or mashed without gravy (or, at a minimum, lots of butter).

nkedel Aug 16, 2013 8:32 pm


Originally Posted by Sweet Willie (Post 21285223)
Statement I'm most puzzled by:why avoid onions if you love onion flavor?

Not who you were responding to, but I find most onions to have a very unpleasant texture when raw or lightly cooked. Cooked to mushiness in french onion soup or spaghetti sauce is fine for me.

OTOH, I like the taste in a lot of things, so getting those thing with the onions and then removing them (or eating around them) is a standard MO of mine.

braslvr Aug 16, 2013 10:34 pm


Originally Posted by Sweet Willie (Post 21285223)
you are an In-N-Out fan:), for me a thicker patty cooked no more than a medium rare trumps a thin patty, no matter how many thin patties you have.

Actually, I am a fan of the independent (mostly Greek owned) hamburger joints all over the greater Los Angeles area which In-N-Out attempts to copy. Also the remaining independent "Drive In" hamburger joints up and down California's central valley. In-N-Out is good for a chain, and I use the name to describe the basic type of burger I like to people who have not had the fortune of experiencing real California drive in burgers.

A thick medium rare patty might be fine eaten separately, but the soft texture of such ruins the hamburger experience completely. IMHO of course.:)

nkedel Aug 17, 2013 12:21 am


Originally Posted by braslvr (Post 21287629)
A thick medium rare patty might be fine eaten separately, but the soft texture of such ruins the hamburger experience completely. IMHO of course.:)

A thick, but not-too-thick medium well patty (diner-style -- 1/4-1/3lb depending on diameter, not over-thick gourmet or chain-restaurant style) is just about perfect.

Medium-rare is for (really good) steaks, not hamburgers IMO, and even for cheaper steaks medium is a better call.

Has anyone here tried grinding their own? I've been wanting to since reading this a few years ago: http://aht.seriouseats.com/archives/...s-of-beef.html

jackal Aug 17, 2013 8:15 am


Originally Posted by nkedel (Post 21287847)
Has anyone here tried grinding their own? I've been wanting to since reading this a few years ago: http://aht.seriouseats.com/archives/...s-of-beef.html

I have. It's a completely different ballgame. You'll never want to go back.

Ancien Maestro Aug 17, 2013 1:45 pm


Originally Posted by nkedel (Post 21287847)
A thick, but not-too-thick medium well patty (diner-style -- 1/4-1/3lb depending on diameter, not over-thick gourmet or chain-restaurant style) is just about perfect.

Medium-rare is for (really good) steaks, not hamburgers IMO, and even for cheaper steaks medium is a better call.

Has anyone here tried grinding their own? I've been wanting to since reading this a few years ago: http://aht.seriouseats.com/archives/...s-of-beef.html

Hamburgers medium rare? This is the first time I've heard of this. I've never thought you can order burgers to order in this manner.

I do enjoy a good gourmet burger. One I received on Captain Andy's cruise to the Na Pali cost, on the Southern Star in Kauai. Personal chef on board and served a great all beef burger. Ended up having two, even with all of the ocean motion going on.

Best burger in Calgary is at the #3 nationally rated Notables which I happen to be a landlord. IIRC melted provolone or cheddar, on a grilled 60/40 beef/pork patty. Not that big, but melts in my mouth. Better than Smash burger and Five Guys bar none.. the Stockmans restaurant by my house makes their burger with the same beef/pork combination.. and I love the sauteed mushrooms on the burger topped off. But these burgers I don't think you can do medium rare with the beef/pork combination.

nkedel Aug 17, 2013 6:52 pm


Originally Posted by Ancien Maestro (Post 21289933)
Hamburgers medium rare? This is the first time I've heard of this. I've never thought you can order burgers to order in this manner.

Has been normal at diners and nicer restaurants as long as I've been ordering my own food -- since the mid-1980s at least; fast food places and other skinny-patty burgers, not so much.


I do enjoy a good gourmet burger. One I received on Captain Andy's cruise to the Na Pali cost, on the Southern Star in Kauai. Personal chef on board and served a great all beef burger. Ended up having two, even with all of the ocean motion going on.

Best burger in Calgary is at the #3 nationally rated Notables which I happen to be a landlord. IIRC melted provolone or cheddar, on a grilled 60/40 beef/pork patty. Not that big, but melts in my mouth. Better than Smash burger and Five Guys bar none.. the Stockmans restaurant by my house makes their burger with the same beef/pork combination.. and I love the sauteed mushrooms on the burger topped off. But these burgers I don't think you can do medium rare with the beef/pork combination.
That sounds tasty... I've had all-pork burgers, and been unimpressed, but never a blend. And yeah, I'd steer clear of medium-rare for pork. :)

You might check out the "Best Burgers" thread even though it technically is entitled "in the US."

Sweet Willie Aug 17, 2013 8:37 pm


Originally Posted by Ancien Maestro (Post 21289933)
Hamburgers medium rare? This is the first time I've heard of this. I've never thought you can order burgers to order in this manner.

I don't know of a fast food chain that will cook a burger to a MR doneness, it is all well done in the essence of food safety. (Because the meat is ground, there is a greater chance for product contamination). There are even townships that have decreed by law that ground meat must be cooked to well done. (In the town next to me, one can't order a MR burger, but in my town, perfectly fine to do so).

However if a restaurant (or market) is purchasing (or making from scratch) high quality ground beef, I have zero concerns about contamination.

A medium rare burger (for me anyways) is what I really crave in a burger.

jackal Aug 17, 2013 9:16 pm


Originally Posted by Sweet Willie (Post 21291243)
I don't know of a fast food chain that will cook a burger to a MR doneness, it is all well done in the essence of food safety. (Because the meat is ground, there is a greater chance for product contamination). There are even townships that have decreed by law that ground meat must be cooked to well done. (In the town next to me, one can't order a MR burger, but in my town, perfectly fine to do so).

However if a restaurant (or market) is purchasing (or making from scratch) high quality ground beef, I have zero concerns about contamination.

A medium rare burger (for me anyways) is what I really crave in a burger.

I just discovered this last trip to L.A. that In-N-Out will cook to medium-rare. It's hard to see in the thin burgers, but there is definitely a pink hue to the center of the patty.

In-N-Out grinds all meat in-house (probably not in each store, but they grind it themselves before sending to each restaurant), so the chances of contamination are greatly reduced.

That said, there are few things in this world better than a thick hamburger patty with good, fresh-ground beef grilled to medium-rare. Mmm! :)

nkedel Aug 17, 2013 9:26 pm


Originally Posted by Sweet Willie (Post 21291243)
I don't know of a fast food chain that will cook a burger to a MR doneness,

Depending on your definition of "fast food," Nations would as a of a few years ago.

braslvr Aug 18, 2013 12:57 am


Originally Posted by jackal (Post 21291355)
I just discovered this last trip to L.A. that In-N-Out will cook to medium-rare. It's hard to see in the thin burgers, but there is definitely a pink hue to the center of the patty.

But that would no doubt eliminate the crispy edges which make In-N-Out patties rock.

Sweet Willie Aug 18, 2013 9:39 am


Originally Posted by braslvr (Post 21291808)
But that would no doubt eliminate the crispy edges which make In-N-Out patties rock.

I was thinking along those lines as well, the crispy/caramelized patty is one of the prime benefits of a thin patty.

Originally Posted by jackal (Post 21291355)
I just discovered this last trip to L.A. that In-N-Out will cook to medium-rare. It's hard to see in the thin burgers, but there is definitely a pink hue to the center of the patty.

that is some pretty amazing timing to cook a thin patty w/some pink in it with everything else a grill cook would have going on.:eek: And if this is the case, I stand corrected about a major fast food chain not cooking to a MR.

jackal Aug 18, 2013 12:06 pm


Originally Posted by Sweet Willie (Post 21293128)
that is some pretty amazing timing to cook a thin patty w/some pink in it with everything else a grill cook would have going on.:eek: And if this is the case, I stand corrected about a major fast food chain not cooking to a MR.

I think the INO folks hate me when I show up. The latest version of my "perfect INO order" is something like this:

Double Meat (no cheese, aka a 2x0)
Medium-rare (just discovered this!)
No salt
Extra-toasted patty
Animal style
No pickles
Extra whole grilled onion

and a root beer float. Mmm!

(And if I'm in the mood for fries, I order "fries well done." That makes absolutely nothing in my order part of the standard menu. :p)

Ancien Maestro Aug 18, 2013 1:39 pm


Originally Posted by nkedel (Post 21290964)
Has been normal at diners and nicer restaurants as long as I've been ordering my own food -- since the mid-1980s at least; fast food places and other skinny-patty burgers, not so much.



That sounds tasty... I've had all-pork burgers, and been unimpressed, but never a blend. And yeah, I'd steer clear of medium-rare for pork. :)

You might check out the "Best Burgers" thread even though it technically is entitled "in the US."

The blend is a tenderness, and the taste to me is of pure perfection. The burger I received on the Na Pali Souther Star Captain Andy's burger was pure perfection for an all beef burger. But the 60/40 blend is my preference, and drizzled with goat cheese.. Out of this world.

But dining at Notables the #3 rated restaurant in Canada for fine dining, and having a burger there is an abnormal treat. They do it so perfect, and so deep in flavors that it really is the best burger I've ever tasted.

With pork in the mix, I believe that the entire burger would have to be cooked well done.


Originally Posted by jackal (Post 21291355)
I just discovered this last trip to L.A. that In-N-Out will cook to medium-rare. It's hard to see in the thin burgers, but there is definitely a pink hue to the center of the patty.

In-N-Out grinds all meat in-house (probably not in each store, but they grind it themselves before sending to each restaurant), so the chances of contamination are greatly reduced.

That said, there are few things in this world better than a thick hamburger patty with good, fresh-ground beef grilled to medium-rare. Mmm! :)

I'm used to pink hues and I think that's would be normal in a thick patty. I guess I'm surprised you can cook this to order. I'm not used to this, but will definitely keep my eyes open for any possibility of a request when ordering.

braslvr Aug 18, 2013 9:12 pm


Originally Posted by Ancien Maestro (Post 21294055)

I'm used to pink hues and I think that's would be normal in a thick patty. I guess I'm surprised you can cook this to order. I'm not used to this, but will definitely keep my eyes open for any possibility of a request when ordering.

I think the shocking thing here is that as much as you eat out, you have never been asked how you want your burger cooked. When I order a hamburger anywhere in the US other than fast-food places, 90+% of the time they ask me how I want it cooked. Even in many other countries this is the norm.

Dr Jabadski Aug 19, 2013 4:34 am


- No peppers :td: ; red, green, yellow, whatever, they are an assault on the taste buds.

Originally Posted by BuildingMyBento (Post 21253937)
No bell peppers (capsicum) either?


Correct, none of those either. And absolutely no ja-lap-a-nos! In addition to the assault on the taste buds they even assault the sinuses! :eek:


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 4:05 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.