Any good frying pan recommendations?
#16
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: ORD
Posts: 14,772
If economy is the object in your frying pan search, cast iron certainly fills the bill and will serve you well if you properly maintain it and know its limitations. I'd look for sales on All Clad stainless. They frequently have a 10 or 12 inch frying pan for well under $100 in special promotions. You could supplement that with a $12 Lodge cast iron from World Market or Target.
#17
In memoriam
Join Date: Aug 2002
Programs: AA EXP "Life is good! Really good.""
Posts: 4,923
BTW, realizing how cheap these are (I have about 6 in various sizes and condition) I started putting them in the dishwasher and after about 6 months there have been no problems at all.
The All-Clad never leaves the cupboard on my watch. Same for the inherited Revere Ware. And the too-heavy cast iron doesn't work on new stove.
#18



Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Denver
Posts: 2,396
I'm a die-hard fan of All-Clad Stainless. Started switching out my Calphalon Commerical Anodized a few years ago, and have never looked back. I'm up to about 9-10 pieces so far, and have gotten rid of all but one anodized pan! Durable, beautiful, versatile (not ruined by high-BTU ranges, great in the oven, induction compatible, dishwasher safe), made in the USA and a lifetime warranty. Well worth the cost provided you stick with the USA-made standard cookware, and avoid most of the bakeware and specialty items, most of which are not necessarily "clad" or "ply" construction, often made in Asia. Read the labels before buying these items!
Mauviel's stainless line is also very good, but even more costly than AC.
That said, if you're looking for a very high quality product that is surprisingly inexpensive, check out Tramontina. Their better product lines are on a par with All-Clad, including the lifetime warranty. I don't think they make this product any longer, I picked up a 5-qt copper-core multi-ply saut pan at Costco about four or five years ago for less than $50 (an AC copper-core would have run 5x that). It weighs a ton, works beautifully, and looks like it's just another one of my AC stainless pieces. I also have a 12-in nonstick aluminum skillet by Tramontina that has only just recently begun to wear out after about five years of heavy use and abuse.
A professional chef turned me on to Tramontina -- apparently it's popular in commercial kitchens for its durability, affordability and NSF rating. You may have to search for it, but it's usually available at good resto supply stores. I've seen it at Walmart, too, but not consistently.
~mrs
Mauviel's stainless line is also very good, but even more costly than AC.
That said, if you're looking for a very high quality product that is surprisingly inexpensive, check out Tramontina. Their better product lines are on a par with All-Clad, including the lifetime warranty. I don't think they make this product any longer, I picked up a 5-qt copper-core multi-ply saut pan at Costco about four or five years ago for less than $50 (an AC copper-core would have run 5x that). It weighs a ton, works beautifully, and looks like it's just another one of my AC stainless pieces. I also have a 12-in nonstick aluminum skillet by Tramontina that has only just recently begun to wear out after about five years of heavy use and abuse.
A professional chef turned me on to Tramontina -- apparently it's popular in commercial kitchens for its durability, affordability and NSF rating. You may have to search for it, but it's usually available at good resto supply stores. I've seen it at Walmart, too, but not consistently.
~mrs
#19
Suspended
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: UK
Posts: 11,968
Bit suprised at some of the posts and it makes me wish I was marketing expensive pans! For example, some use of language is either unwittingly imprecise or denotes a lack of experience and knowledge in these things as saying that "There isn't such a thing as an all-purpose, high-quality, inexpensive pan" is simply incorrect. I have dozens of high qaulity inexpensive all purpose pans.
For an enthusiatic cook there's every reason to invest in good quality knives which sadly normally means spending a chunk of cash. Knives can be a life long investment and to me there is a real relationship between price and quality. Many highly branded pans give a sense to the owner of proximity to a revered chef and some are pieces of elegance that confer a pride of ownership. Some pans are a work of art! And in the days when they were hand crafted or when made of copper they were something that were "passed down". But today machines make wonderful pans even if it takes a craftsman to make a knife. A pan simply needs a good thick heat dispursant base, a good non-stick hard-wearing cooking surface and a safe handle. And most people don't know how to look after them ie keeping some pans back that are not allowed anywhere near soap and are kept permanently "conditioned", and ensure they are never stacked without say old tea-towels used as seperators to protect the surface.
However the pans that most chefs actually use and bash around in real kitchens that are not generally available in retail shops but are available to restuarants from catering suppliers are what chefs choose to use day in and day out in pursuit of their profession. They are not objects of desire or elegance - they have to be hard working. But they are 100% functional. I'm fortunate enough to have more than one kitchen! I have a couple of dozen Nisbets sourced Vogue pans that I had bought with the idea of replacing them every year or two, but the buggers are black underneath but still have a prestine surface. I have often been dissapointed with expensive pans I previously bought. But with the Vogue pans the only one's that are needing replacing after 3 or 4 years or so are the enormous ones I use in wok mode on my 6kw wok burner. But they aren't quite ready for replacement yet and I can't bring myself to replace them simply because I like shiney new things.
I wouldn't make any adverse judgment about people that choose to spend their hard-earned cash on expensive brands but don't knock what the professionals use every day in their kitchens unless you have first hand knowledge of them!
For an enthusiatic cook there's every reason to invest in good quality knives which sadly normally means spending a chunk of cash. Knives can be a life long investment and to me there is a real relationship between price and quality. Many highly branded pans give a sense to the owner of proximity to a revered chef and some are pieces of elegance that confer a pride of ownership. Some pans are a work of art! And in the days when they were hand crafted or when made of copper they were something that were "passed down". But today machines make wonderful pans even if it takes a craftsman to make a knife. A pan simply needs a good thick heat dispursant base, a good non-stick hard-wearing cooking surface and a safe handle. And most people don't know how to look after them ie keeping some pans back that are not allowed anywhere near soap and are kept permanently "conditioned", and ensure they are never stacked without say old tea-towels used as seperators to protect the surface.
However the pans that most chefs actually use and bash around in real kitchens that are not generally available in retail shops but are available to restuarants from catering suppliers are what chefs choose to use day in and day out in pursuit of their profession. They are not objects of desire or elegance - they have to be hard working. But they are 100% functional. I'm fortunate enough to have more than one kitchen! I have a couple of dozen Nisbets sourced Vogue pans that I had bought with the idea of replacing them every year or two, but the buggers are black underneath but still have a prestine surface. I have often been dissapointed with expensive pans I previously bought. But with the Vogue pans the only one's that are needing replacing after 3 or 4 years or so are the enormous ones I use in wok mode on my 6kw wok burner. But they aren't quite ready for replacement yet and I can't bring myself to replace them simply because I like shiney new things.
I wouldn't make any adverse judgment about people that choose to spend their hard-earned cash on expensive brands but don't knock what the professionals use every day in their kitchens unless you have first hand knowledge of them!
Last edited by uk1; Dec 4, 2011 at 10:47 am
#20




Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Northern California
Programs: UA Premier Gold, 1.5 Million Mile Flyer
Posts: 3,696
Ross or TJ Maxx has what you want. Get the heaviest and most expensive 8" model there - about $12.99. Buy two, they don't always have good quality ones, and you definitely don't want the really cheap ones. I bought a really small one, perhaps 4-5" because it was cute, but it's too small to flip or turn two eggs. Sunny-side up it does very well.
#21





Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: Houston, TX
Posts: 4,330
http://www.amazon.com/Emeril-Anodize.../dp/B00284B9QK
I have had it for about 3 years and make eggs every Saturday morning and nothing ever sticks in these pans!
#22
In memoriam
Join Date: Aug 2002
Programs: AA EXP "Life is good! Really good.""
Posts: 4,923
It is also heavy enough that it stays in contact with the stove top despite it's normal size handle. Think it was $5.99, never use it. http://www.baccarat.com.au/frypans/n...02483_1001304/Regarding brand names at Target and Wal-mart be aware that mfgrs often make more than one line of cookware under the similar names. Kitchen Essentials by Calphalon are perfectly fine for my use, but not the Calphalon you are thinking of. Be sure you are comparing apples to apples.
Last edited by lili; Dec 4, 2011 at 11:26 am
#24




Join Date: Jan 2010
Programs: AA Exec Plat | Bonvoy Lifetime Plat
Posts: 131
For eggs, I just buy a TFal at Target and replace it when needed. No point in spending $$ on an expensive Teflon pan as it WILL wear out within 10 years.
I have All Clad Stainless 5 piece set (bought w/ AmEx points) and a few Calphalon Andonized for other purposes.
I have All Clad Stainless 5 piece set (bought w/ AmEx points) and a few Calphalon Andonized for other purposes.
#25
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Formerly HPN, but then DCA and IAD for a while, and now back to HPN!
Programs: Honestly, I've been out of the travel game so long that I'm not even sure. Maybe Marriott Gold?
Posts: 10,677
I have two choices for frying pans in the house, and I love them both.
1) Calphalon Anadonized pans. We get them at the outlets like Williams and Sonoma when they are on sale. Love these pans, the downside is they should not go in the dishwasher, and you can't use cooking spray on them. They come in just about every size you would need, if you treat them well, they will do the same, if you don't, they will last a few months.
2) Cast Iron. For many years it was a simple cast iron skillet, when we redid the kitchen it could not be used on the new stove, so we got another one (enameled) that can be used on the stove. For bacon I would always reach for the cast iron.
We also have a no name non stick large fry pan from a restaurant supply house, no brand name, made in Korea, non stick over aluminum. I want to say twelve years or so now, and it's still in great shape.
If you have a choice, the professional pans usually do a much better job if you stove can handle them.
1) Calphalon Anadonized pans. We get them at the outlets like Williams and Sonoma when they are on sale. Love these pans, the downside is they should not go in the dishwasher, and you can't use cooking spray on them. They come in just about every size you would need, if you treat them well, they will do the same, if you don't, they will last a few months.
2) Cast Iron. For many years it was a simple cast iron skillet, when we redid the kitchen it could not be used on the new stove, so we got another one (enameled) that can be used on the stove. For bacon I would always reach for the cast iron.
We also have a no name non stick large fry pan from a restaurant supply house, no brand name, made in Korea, non stick over aluminum. I want to say twelve years or so now, and it's still in great shape.
If you have a choice, the professional pans usually do a much better job if you stove can handle them.
#26
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Either at the shooting range or anywhere good beer can be found...
Posts: 52,788
For bacon and such, I use our rather large frying pan that we purchased at Sam's Club 3 years ago or so. It's heavy-duty, non-stick, has a lid that goes with it, and is very large. I have to use the large dual burner on the stove when using it. It's still in great shape. It was probably $30, if that, and it was made in the US. I also use it for grilled cheese sandwiches and such, and can fit about 4 sandwiches in it at one time.
#27
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: ORD
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 16,934
For Calphalon, be careful of the sets you and buy at Target and other similar stores, they are a lower end product and won't perform or last we well.
We bought most of our calphalon piece by piece from Bloomingdale's during a period where they seemed to have something on sale for like $29 bucks each week. We quickly had the pieces we needed.
Our most recent purchase was a giant roasting pan that we got for a steal at one of Calphalon's outlet stores.
My pots and pans never, ever, see the inside of my dishwasher, and the omelet pan never sees soap/water, just a quick wipe down.
We bought most of our calphalon piece by piece from Bloomingdale's during a period where they seemed to have something on sale for like $29 bucks each week. We quickly had the pieces we needed.
Our most recent purchase was a giant roasting pan that we got for a steal at one of Calphalon's outlet stores.
My pots and pans never, ever, see the inside of my dishwasher, and the omelet pan never sees soap/water, just a quick wipe down.
#29


Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Washington D.C. via Sao Paulo via Houston via Washington D.C. via Boston via New York
Posts: 1,172
I use this for pretty much a lot of egg cookery...http://www.bedbathandbeyond.com/prod...p?SKU=13015392 I love all these people talking up cast iron...it's a pain to clean/wash and keep...you have to keep oiling it up after you wash it...it's annoying for my set I have this: http://www.bedbathandbeyond.com/prod...p?SKU=16619191 plus another 10 inch frying pan
#30




Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Northern California
Programs: UA Premier Gold, 1.5 Million Mile Flyer
Posts: 3,696
I use this for pretty much a lot of egg cookery...http://www.bedbathandbeyond.com/prod...p?SKU=13015392 I love all these people talking up cast iron...it's a pain to clean/wash and keep...you have to keep oiling it up after you wash it...it's annoying for my set I have this: http://www.bedbathandbeyond.com/prod...p?SKU=16619191 plus another 10 inch frying pan


