Possible to Join Smith Barney for 3x Redemption?
#16

Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: East Coast
Programs: All major Airlines, Hotel Chains, Credit Cards and Car Rentals
Posts: 1,265
Does anyone know if having the FMA account number with myFi SmithBarney is enough for 3x redemption or FMA checking account number and the FMA card number have to be issued before accessing 3x redemption. I am told that the checks and the FMA card will be issued only after they receive the signed documents back. But even before that, they have to mail out the documents for the signatures which may take 7-10 days. I tried contacting TYN and they cannot find my myFi SmithBarney FMA account although, it shows up online on SmithBarney.com.
#17
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 101
Does anyone know if having the FMA account number with myFi SmithBarney is enough for 3x redemption or FMA checking account number and the FMA card number have to be issued before accessing 3x redemption. I am told that the checks and the FMA card will be issued only after they receive the signed documents back. But even before that, they have to mail out the documents for the signatures which may take 7-10 days. I tried contacting TYN and they cannot find my myFi SmithBarney FMA account although, it shows up online on SmithBarney.com.
#18

Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: East Coast
Programs: All major Airlines, Hotel Chains, Credit Cards and Car Rentals
Posts: 1,265
My myFi FMA account is active on smithbarney.com and it also shows up as one of the linked accounts on the citibank online account. I called TYN and in turn, they transferred me over to SmithBarney. I gave the SmithBarney agent my FMA account number and she located my account but said that it cannot be linked to my TY account as she cannot find any TY account under my FMA account or FMA card (which has not yet been issued). She said I will have to wait until the FMA card has been issued and that it has to be enrolled into TY program for linking to my TY account.
At this stage, I am still waiting for my papers to arrive in the mail which I then have to sign and mail back to their back-office in NY.
Anyone has any suggestions? Can I just called the travel center at TYN and tell the agent who is helping me with the flight booking that I have a SmithBarney account?
At this stage, I am still waiting for my papers to arrive in the mail which I then have to sign and mail back to their back-office in NY.
Anyone has any suggestions? Can I just called the travel center at TYN and tell the agent who is helping me with the flight booking that I have a SmithBarney account?
#19


Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: California
Posts: 601
Does anyone know if SmithBarney do a hard credit inquiry when you open a (1) brokerage account or (2) the FMA account? I've gotten mixed answers from the SB reps.
I'm thinking of doing this for the 3x TYP redemption but i'm also planning to refinance my mortgage soon and don't want to lower my credit score. Thanks.
I'm thinking of doing this for the 3x TYP redemption but i'm also planning to refinance my mortgage soon and don't want to lower my credit score. Thanks.
#20
FlyerTalk Evangelist


Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Florida
Posts: 30,343
Does anyone know if SmithBarney do a hard credit inquiry when you open a (1) brokerage account or (2) the FMA account? I've gotten mixed answers from the SB reps.
I'm thinking of doing this for the 3x TYP redemption but i'm also planning to refinance my mortgage soon and don't want to lower my credit score. Thanks.
I'm thinking of doing this for the 3x TYP redemption but i'm also planning to refinance my mortgage soon and don't want to lower my credit score. Thanks.
#21
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 101
My myFi FMA account is active on smithbarney.com and it also shows up as one of the linked accounts on the citibank online account. I called TYN and in turn, they transferred me over to SmithBarney. I gave the SmithBarney agent my FMA account number and she located my account but said that it cannot be linked to my TY account as she cannot find any TY account under my FMA account or FMA card (which has not yet been issued). She said I will have to wait until the FMA card has been issued and that it has to be enrolled into TY program for linking to my TY account.
At this stage, I am still waiting for my papers to arrive in the mail which I then have to sign and mail back to their back-office in NY.
Anyone has any suggestions? Can I just called the travel center at TYN and tell the agent who is helping me with the flight booking that I have a SmithBarney account?
At this stage, I am still waiting for my papers to arrive in the mail which I then have to sign and mail back to their back-office in NY.
Anyone has any suggestions? Can I just called the travel center at TYN and tell the agent who is helping me with the flight booking that I have a SmithBarney account?
#22
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 101
Does anyone know if SmithBarney do a hard credit inquiry when you open a (1) brokerage account or (2) the FMA account? I've gotten mixed answers from the SB reps.
I'm thinking of doing this for the 3x TYP redemption but i'm also planning to refinance my mortgage soon and don't want to lower my credit score. Thanks.
I'm thinking of doing this for the 3x TYP redemption but i'm also planning to refinance my mortgage soon and don't want to lower my credit score. Thanks.
#23

Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: East Coast
Programs: All major Airlines, Hotel Chains, Credit Cards and Car Rentals
Posts: 1,265
The TY travel agent contacted SmithBarney and they confirmed that I have an FMA account but he would not approve the higher redemption rate. He was arguing that I have to have a TYP earning SB credit card or debit card linked to the TY account. My FMA card has not yet been issued and am not sure if I have enough time. I am yet to receive the papers for signature, then have mail them. Then wait for them to process them only after that they will issue the FMA card which may or may not be linked to TY right away.
I would really appreciate any help or suggestions. Please feel free to PM me if needed.
#25
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 101
Did all this. Called FMA group and confirmed that I have an FMA account. Then called TY for the redemption but still no luck.
The TY travel agent contacted SmithBarney and they confirmed that I have an FMA account but he would not approve the higher redemption rate. He was arguing that I have to have a TYP earning SB credit card or debit card linked to the TY account. My FMA card has not yet been issued and am not sure if I have enough time. I am yet to receive the papers for signature, then have mail them. Then wait for them to process them only after that they will issue the FMA card which may or may not be linked to TY right away.
I would really appreciate any help or suggestions. Please feel free to PM me if needed.
The TY travel agent contacted SmithBarney and they confirmed that I have an FMA account but he would not approve the higher redemption rate. He was arguing that I have to have a TYP earning SB credit card or debit card linked to the TY account. My FMA card has not yet been issued and am not sure if I have enough time. I am yet to receive the papers for signature, then have mail them. Then wait for them to process them only after that they will issue the FMA card which may or may not be linked to TY right away.
I would really appreciate any help or suggestions. Please feel free to PM me if needed.
So REDEEM RIGHT NOW.
#26
FlyerTalk Evangelist


Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Florida
Posts: 30,343
Not surprising as they probably see a glut of new FMA applications, knowing fully they may never see any assets transferred over to SB for management.
Will they then differentiate Chairman MC and Chairman AMEX?
Will they then differentiate Chairman MC and Chairman AMEX?
#27
Suspended
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: USA
Programs: All major programs
Posts: 1,403
#28
FlyerTalk Evangelist


Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Florida
Posts: 30,343
#29

Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: East Coast
Programs: All major Airlines, Hotel Chains, Credit Cards and Car Rentals
Posts: 1,265
just got off the phone with them. Here's the deal - apparently every few days they phase out another group. originally they said just having a SB FMA account or credit card was enough. Then they quietly dropped SB credit card holders. Now the new policy as of a couple of days ago is to have an FMA card that is enrolled in thankyou (probably because they know that by the time the card arrives, the network will already be closed). If that's not bad enough, they said in a couple of days ONLY Chairman cardholders will be able to redeem for the old rates.
So REDEEM RIGHT NOW.
So REDEEM RIGHT NOW.
#30

Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Mid-Atlantic
Programs: AA Plat, UA Silver, DL Silver, Marriott Titanium, etc.
Posts: 4,214
So, it means that come next week and only Chairman card holders will be eligible for the higher cap, correct? If so, then I really have chance of being eligible for the higher cap. Didn't really expect such a behavior from them. They are playing dirty! I am loosing faith (whatever little was remaining) in them. I think I am done with them. I have given them enough business over last several years and its sad to see such a situation. Time to move on and look for another card provider that would value my business.
I've amended my viewpoint somewhat now, and I think there is a measurable risk they'll do some further devaluations or cut off the fixed point redemptions before Feb. 28. I also would recommend that if you don't get the answer you want hang up and call again; call during differnent staff shifts as well. If you get a 3x offer, book immediately, even if it's not an ideal value for you; when you find a flight that works well for you, call and book it immediately, don't wait.

