FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Credit Card Programs (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/credit-card-programs-599/)
-   -   3% or better on Grocery forever? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/credit-card-programs/2051059-3-better-grocery-forever.html)

ptatohed Dec 28, 2021 4:20 pm


Originally Posted by sciconf (Post 33850365)
Thanks - you guys rock. I did obtain Bicycle club membership. BTW, I even forgot that I started this thread!

I cancelled and then applied for membership - will they again ask for Loan ref when I apply for the CC?

It's hard to say. They did not for me. But if they did for you the first time you applied, they may ask again. Technically a credit card is a loan. In the case of the Visa Signature, a $5,000 minimum loan. However, I am not totally sure what a loan reference is? How's your credit score and credit profile? I'm hoping that once you have established membership, opened a savings account, and wait a little while, it will be easier for you to apply for the card.

sciconf Dec 28, 2021 4:25 pm


Originally Posted by ptatohed (Post 33850476)
It's hard to say. They did not for me. But if they did for you the first time you applied, they may ask again. Technically a credit card is a loan. In the case of the Visa Signature, a $5,000 minimum loan. However, I am not totally sure what a loan reference is? How's your credit score and credit profile? I'm hoping that once you have established membership, opened a savings account, and wait a little while, it will be easier for you to apply for the card.

Over 800

What interest are they offering for the Savings a/c - it does not say on their web?


Originally Posted by yugi (Post 33775073)
Still not as good as my grandfathered Priceline 3.33% everywhere, or USB AR, which is 4.5% everywhere, if using mobile payment, which is almost everywhere.

What is USB AR? Still around? Link?

ptatohed Dec 28, 2021 4:37 pm

The Ralph's card is 5% mobile wallet.

https://www.ralphsmastercard.com/cre...SourceCode2sec

ptatohed Dec 28, 2021 5:38 pm


Originally Posted by sciconf (Post 33850486)
Over 800

What interest are they offering for the Savings a/c - it does not say on their web?


What is USB AR? Still around? Link?


That's a good score but credit score and credit profile are different. How many credit cards do you have? What are their ages? Their limits? What is your utilization rate compared to your overall available credit? How old is your credit? Is it varied - cards, mortgage, loans, etc.?



US Bank Altitude card has a $400 annual fee. I'd give up a body part before I'd pay that!

https://www.usbank.com/credit-cards/...edit-card.html

toofast Dec 28, 2021 9:28 pm


Originally Posted by ptatohed (Post 33850682)

US Bank Altitude card has a $400 annual fee. I'd give up a body part before I'd pay that!

After the $375 rebate for travel and restaurant purchases, it's really only $75/year. Also most people seem to get a retention offer of 5k or 10k points, which further brings the cost down.

I rate it as one of the very best cards out there, and also one of the most under-rated.

ptatohed Dec 29, 2021 1:19 am


Originally Posted by toofast (Post 33851136)
After the $375 rebate for travel and restaurant purchases, it's really only $75/year. Also most people seem to get a retention offer of 5k or 10k points, which further brings the cost down.

I rate it as one of the very best cards out there, and also one of the most under-rated.

Not for me. I hate AFs. I hate "points".

mia Dec 29, 2021 7:07 am


Originally Posted by ptatohed (Post 33851421)
I hate AFs. I hate "points".

Please tell us why. It's the reasoning that's interesting to others, not the conclusion.

yugi Dec 29, 2021 7:44 am


Originally Posted by ptatohed (Post 33851421)
Not for me. I hate AFs. I hate "points".

Each point is 1.5c. Even if you don't get retention bonus, you need to spend over $5k per year in order to break even with a 3% card.
I need to spend $6429 in order to break even with Priceline card, but I still have AR, which I consider one of the best cards around.

toofast Dec 29, 2021 8:19 am


Originally Posted by ptatohed (Post 33851421)
Not for me. I hate AFs. I hate "points".

Fair enough on the AF. The points are just the same (if not better than) cash though.

5,000 points = $50 cash at the basic 1% cash-out, or $75 if you redeem against your travel purchases
10,000 points = $100 cash at the basic 1% cash-out, or $150 if you redeem against your travel purchases

ptatohed Dec 29, 2021 10:31 am


Originally Posted by mia (Post 33851874)
Please tell us why. It's the reasoning that's interesting to others, not the conclusion.

I don't think I need to explain why I don't like annual fees, right? ;) As for "points", I don't like them because oftentimes you have no idea what they are worth. I know exactly what a % cash back is worth. A lot of the time, you are forced to use your points on particular purchases in order to get max value. I just want cash back, plain and simple. 3% - 5% CB on everything charged. :)




Originally Posted by yugi (Post 33851955)
Each point is 1.5c. Even if you don't get retention bonus, you need to spend over $5k per year in order to break even with a 3% card.
I need to spend $6429 in order to break even with Priceline card, but I still have AR, which I consider one of the best cards around.

1.5c if you spend the way they tell you. I like cash back. I don't understand what you mean by I have to spend $5k per year to break even with a 3% card. Break even with what? My 3% AOD card has no AF. No need to 'break even'.





Originally Posted by toofast (Post 33852060)
Fair enough on the AF. The points are just the same (if not better than) cash though.

5,000 points = $50 cash at the basic 1% cash-out, or $75 if you redeem against your travel purchases
10,000 points = $100 cash at the basic 1% cash-out, or $150 if you redeem against your travel purchases

I understand this is a 'flyer' forum, lol, but I rarely travel. I want straight cash back, period. No annual fee. Everything I charge should fall (and does) into the 3% - 5% CB range. It comes out to $hundreds per year. :)

toofast Dec 29, 2021 11:21 am


Originally Posted by ptatohed (Post 33852434)
I don't think I need to explain why I don't like annual fees, right? ;) As for "points", I don't like them because oftentimes you have no idea what they are worth. I know exactly what a % cash back is worth. A lot of the time, you are forced to use your points on particular purchases in order to get max value. I just want cash back, plain and simple. 3% - 5% CB on everything charged. :)

Yes, this is understandable. The majority of my 'normal' friends think it's crazy that I have multiple cards, for different types of spending!

I don't like AF's either. I do the math for each card to see if the benefit for me outweighs the fee. Without the yearly retention deal, this card would move to being a possible keep for me. With the retention deal though it's a no-brainer, as it's all profit.


1.5c if you spend the way they tell you. I like cash back. I don't understand what you mean by I have to spend $5k per year to break even with a 3% card. Break even with what? My 3% AOD card has no AF. No need to 'break even'.
I also had to read that a couple of times to understand! The poster is saying they have to spend $5k on the AR card in order to match what you earn with your straight 3% card, eg:

$5k * 3% = $150
$5k x 4.5% = $225
$225 - $150 = $75 (the annual fee for AR card if no retention deals)

ptatohed Dec 29, 2021 12:02 pm


Originally Posted by toofast (Post 33852556)
Yes, this is understandable. The majority of my 'normal' friends think it's crazy that I have multiple cards, for different types of spending!

I don't like AF's either. I do the math for each card to see if the benefit for me outweighs the fee. Without the yearly retention deal, this card would move to being a possible keep for me. With the retention deal though it's a no-brainer, as it's all profit.



I also had to read that a couple of times to understand! The poster is saying they have to spend $5k on the AR card in order to match what you earn with your straight 3% card, eg:

$5k * 3% = $150
$5k x 4.5% = $225
$225 - $150 = $75 (the annual fee for AR card if no retention deals)

Thanks. Are we not talking about the US Bank Altitude Reserve card with a *gulp* $400 AF? Oh! I see what you are doing. You are deducting the $325 credits. I don't totally know how credits work but I trust you that the $325 is easily obtainable and guaranteed.

https://www.usbank.com/credit-cards/...edit-card.html

yugi Dec 29, 2021 12:21 pm


Originally Posted by ptatohed (Post 33852434)
1.5c if you spend the way they tell you. I like cash back. I don't understand what you mean by I have to spend $5k per year to break even with a 3% card. Break even with what? My 3% AOD card has no AF. No need to 'break even'.

You can redeem using Realtime rewards, which gives you 1.5cpp. Pure cash. Break even 4.5% against 3%, based on $75 AF.

ptatohed Dec 29, 2021 12:58 pm


Originally Posted by yugi (Post 33852719)
You can redeem using Realtime rewards, which gives you 1.5cpp. Pure cash. Break even 4.5% against 3%, based on $75 AF.

Ok, thank you. Much of my spending gets 5% CB. 3% is the minimum (AOD). Between Nusenda, Freedom, Disco-it, and Custom Cash, I get 5% basically every quarter in at least the 3 big ones for me - gas, dining, and grocery. I haven't done the math but you can say I average 4.X% CB. All with no annual fees.

toofast Dec 29, 2021 2:30 pm


Originally Posted by ptatohed (Post 33852830)
Ok, thank you. Much of my spending gets 5% CB. 3% is the minimum (AOD). Between Nusenda, Freedom, Disco-it, and Custom Cash, I get 5% basically every quarter in at least the 3 big ones for me - gas, dining, and grocery. I haven't done the math but you can say I average 4.X% CB. All with no annual fees.

I actually have a similar strategy to you. My spending is currently made in this order:

1. 5% CB on Freedom or Discover (Rotating categories)
2. 4.5% CB on USB AR (Travel & mobile wallet)
3. Any spending if I'm working towards an SUB on a card
4. 3% CB on US Alliance (if I'm in the US)
5. 2.5% CB on Alliant (if I'm overseas)

I'm currently working on getting the AOD card in order to replace 4 and 5 on my list (due to 3% CB with no FTF).

I also didn't know about the Nusenda card, so thanks for the tip on that.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:58 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.