![]() |
Originally Posted by 747FC
(Post 35545550)
But, do double-check your credit card statement: I did the above cautionary measures in Beijing, and Conrad still ended up charging me in RMB.
|
Originally Posted by TWA884
(Post 35546570)
Isn't that you you preferred, to be billed in RMB instead of having the charge DCC'ed to US$?
|
Originally Posted by Majuki
(Post 35545192)
A FlyerTalk member was in Cape Town a couple of days ago. On this day, the Visa rate was 1 ZAR = 0.053999 USD, so it was a 13.15% markup in reality for a savings of $7.60 by declining DCC.
|
On a recent trip to India (Delhi/Golden Triangle)
- hotel, restaurants all had DCC, but in all cases the person asked or handed the terminal to me or proactively selected INR - 8% DCC option presented at two different ATMs |
are you guys disputing these transactions? I had a forced DCC at my hotel in Switzerland. Here is what happened. I was asked to pay CHF 7.50 for a city tax (I had already prepaid for my hotel). The machine gives me the usual CHF or USD options. I choose CHF. However when the receipt prints out it said I accepted DCC and it has applied a 4% markup. I complain to the guy and he says from their side it's charged only CHF 7.50 but that isn't what the receipt says and my posted charge is USD 8.83 which in fact reflects a 4% markup from the official exchange rate. They refuse to correct the error telling me there isn't any error at all and the rate I got is from my bank and they insist that they charged the CHF and nothing more which is of course just pure lies.
So, the card is a Chase United Mileage Explorer... can I call Chase and just dispute the entire transaction telling them that I infact had declined the DCC and the machine has ignored it? It's only 43 cents difference but why should I pay what I don't owe? |
Originally Posted by k374
(Post 35585780)
... It's only 43 cents difference but why should I pay what I don't owe?
|
Originally Posted by k374
(Post 35585780)
are you guys disputing these transactions? I had a forced DCC at my hotel in Switzerland. Here is what happened. I was asked to pay CHF 7.50 for a city tax (I had already prepaid for my hotel). The machine gives me the usual CHF or USD options. I choose CHF. However when the receipt prints out it said I accepted DCC and it has applied a 4% markup. I complain to the guy and he says from their side it's charged only CHF 7.50 but that isn't what the receipt says and my posted charge is USD 8.83 which in fact reflects a 4% markup from the official exchange rate. They refuse to correct the error telling me there isn't any error at all and the rate I got is from my bank and they insist that they charged the CHF and nothing more which is of course just pure lies.
So, the card is a Chase United Mileage Explorer... can I call Chase and just dispute the entire transaction telling them that I infact had declined the DCC and the machine has ignored it? It's only 43 cents difference but why should I pay what I don't owe? |
Originally Posted by 747FC
(Post 35586079)
Dispute the entire transaction, just on principle.
|
I had a particularly egregious case of the DCC scam last week in Switzerland. Used a German card (billed in EUR) and was given the option of paying in CHF (local currency) or USD.
Now, I hate DCC with a passion, but most jurisdictions seem to have nothing against it. But how does the already flimsy rationale of "convenience of paying in your own currency" work in this case? Allow us to convert the local currency (CHF) to a third currency (USD) at a markup, and then your own bank can convert it to your billing currency (EUR)? How's this not illegal? |
Originally Posted by jpdx
(Post 35626896)
I had a particularly egregious case of the DCC scam last week in Switzerland. Used a German card (billed in EUR) and was given the option of paying in CHF (local currency) or USD.
|
Originally Posted by Majuki
(Post 35627839)
I don't know how this one would work in practice. Was the hotel offering to run your card in USD verbally, or was the terminal presenting a USD option?
|
Originally Posted by jpdx
(Post 35629053)
Handheld terminal brought to the restaurant table. Tap card, then the terminal presents option 1=USD, option 2=CHF.
The closest I've seen - although I've never held the terminals - is in Cancun where the hotels where I've stayed run the transaction in USD, at least for USD denominated cards. However, I believe there is a button for MXN if one is using a MXN denominated card. I don't know about other currencies. The itemized hotel bills have have been in MXN with a quoted exchange rate to USD. Since the exchange rate has been almost the same as the real exchange rate, I haven't complained being billed in USD. Furthermore, I've always used an Amex card, so there was no possibility of DCC. |
Originally Posted by Majuki
(Post 35629131)
Furthermore, I've always used an Amex card, so there was no possibility of DCC.
|
Originally Posted by abaheti
(Post 35629807)
Pardon my lack of knowledge, but what do you mean by this? My understanding is that any card can be subject to DCC if the local vendor turns it on. And the Amex website has info on avoiding DCC costs.
|
Originally Posted by Majuki
(Post 35630076)
Only Visa and Mastercard networks support DCC. Other networks do not.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:45 am. |
This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.