![]() |
Originally Posted by GinFizz
(Post 34826178)
Indeed - the phrase "under-reporting" is too loaded with meaning. It's much more the case at the moment they simply DHAFC (the first part of that abbreviation is "don't have a" and the last is "clue" - you can fill in the F as you wish). My wife went out earlier today and none of the local testing stations were operating. More than 10% of my wife's team at work have had a fever over the last few days, but less than half of those have been able to get an antigen-test (those that could all tested positive - not that it really matters either way).
Also aren't residents supposed to self report if RAT test positive? In order to get sick leave or to comply with neighbourhood committee regulations. Sooner or later the death toll should come out. If it doesn't, I call scam. |
Originally Posted by percysmith
(Post 34826206)
Sooner or later the death toll should come out. If it doesn't, I call scam.
If the death toll does rise, the numbers can easily be 'manipulated'. Unlike what the 'West' did, where every death was due to Covid-19 if the deceased happened to have Covid-19 at the time of expiry, my guess is here it will be the exact opposite: the official cause of death will be anything other than Covid-19. Mostly. |
Originally Posted by narvik
(Post 34826234)
Unlike what the 'West' did, where every death was due to Covid-19 if the deceased happened to have Covid-19 at the time of expiry.
|
Originally Posted by percysmith
(Post 34826206)
Haven't figures decreased since the new ten relaxations started?
Also aren't residents supposed to self report if RAT test positive? In order to get sick leave or to comply with neighbourhood committee regulations. Sooner or later the death toll should come out. If it doesn't, I call scam. narvik Do you know of ANY country/city that reports cases based on extrapolation (instead of confirmed positives only)? |
Originally Posted by moondog
(Post 34826262)
I don't know of a single person who has ever self-reported a RAT positive. When that happens, de facto SOP is to lay low until you get a negative...then, get a PCR to reset your health code.
narvik Do you know of ANY country/city that reports cases based on extrapolation (instead of confirmed positives only)? 1) you need time off work-sick leave/work from home permission 2) you are planning to travel after recovery and need an alibi to explain why PCR positive on return (residual virus material) (the recovery cert serves as a get out of PCR card for three months). Of course there are people who don’t need either and prefer to lay low as you say, they’re in breach of the law here but if they don’t plan to be in a situation where they might be caught eg presenting oneself as an inbound traveller |
Originally Posted by moondog
(Post 34826262)
narvik Do you know of ANY country/city that reports cases based on extrapolation (instead of confirmed positives only)? Even hospitals will admit with a RAT. There is no place even, where a positive RAT is (or could be) recorded, AFAIK. Many are reporting, when they do call a positive RAT test in, they are told to simply stay home, and isolate, and only leave again, once negative. A PCR is not demanded anymore. I am only trying to convey that the cases of people positive with Covid-19 here in Beijing (either current or past) is astronomical. In the millions by now, is my best guess. |
Originally Posted by percysmith
(Post 34826206)
Haven't figures decreased since the new ten relaxations started?
Also aren't residents supposed to self report if RAT test positive? In order to get sick leave or to comply with neighbourhood committee regulations. Sooner or later the death toll should come out. If it doesn't, I call scam. I think though that you may have missed my point - which is that the scale of the difference in numbers between those "reported" and in real-life is too big to just get by as calling "under-reporting". And also that phrase actually suggests the authorities know the true figure and are hiding it, when it is clear on the ground here in Beijing that they do not. I am one of the very few foreigners in my compound, which is basically off-campus housing for a university in Beijing. After talking with my wife on Sunday morning we figured we should call the local committee to let them know I had a high fever. Their response was basically "Er okay. Join the club - stay at home and drink plenty of fluids". That was it. They didn't want to know. Re: employees I can only speak for the company my wife works for (an investment law company) - everyone is working at home anyway, and certainly no-one needs to produce a RAT result (even they are able to get one*) in order to offload some casework for a few days. *My wife works as a lawyer for several pharmaceutical companies, and reading between the lines at the start of last week she already reached out to a few of them to try and get some, but even with her contacts still no dice. I can understand how unbelievable this sounds - I can also hardly believe how much things have changed in just a few days here in Beijing. What is clear is that there has been also a no-so-subtle shift in the messaging to something along the lines of (I can't recall the exact Chinese phrase) "Everyone is the first person responsible for their health", which is the first step of washing their hands from the fatalities among the elderly non-fully-vaccinated when they come. In terms of numbers based on anecdotal evidence it does seem like this has already affected 10% of the population - though I do find that hard to believe, as with a typical doubling time of 3 days for omicron, and a peak burnout at around 60% of the local population (based on previous waves outside China), that would put the peak here in less than 2 weeks. Who knows though? |
Originally Posted by GinFizz
(Post 34826739)
What is clear is that there has been also a no-so-subtle shift in the messaging to something along the lines of (I can't recall the exact Chinese phrase) "Everyone is the first person responsible for their health", which is the first step of washing their hands from the fatalities among the elderly non-fully-vaccinated when they come.
每个人是自己健康第一责任人
Originally Posted by GinFizz
(Post 34826178)
this should be seen (and I suspect eventually will) as a failure.
…. The next couple of months are going to be unpleasant I feel in many regards, though we have the fact that on the other side, sometime early in 2023 we can all look forward to rejoining the globe again. Anyways I’m happy to share in your prediction for early 2023 and will be a visa applying guinea pig. |
Originally Posted by boat stuck
(Post 34757968)
IIf you have a 10-year visa with a far off expiration date and don't have to travel immediately, I'd recommend waiting until mid-2023 to see if old visas become un-suspended. The consulates are only giving out single-entry visas right now. The worse case would be applying for a new visa, getting a single entry visa with an existing 10-year visa with a 2029 expiration getting cancelled, and then China announces un-suspension of pre-2020 visas a week later.
There's previous precedent for "un-suspension" in that existing residence permits were suspended at the same time as visas but became valid again a few months later. So glad I never tried to get a pandemic visa (which would have canceled my 10-year visa). |
Originally Posted by boat stuck
(Post 34827642)
Following up on my post from a month ago, I predict existing 10-year visas will be reactivated within 60 days. Perhaps within 30 days if the Jan. 9 rumors turn out to be true.
So glad I never tried to get a pandemic visa (which would have canceled my 10-year visa). Residence Permits are quite a bit more involved to obtain, so it wouldn't be too far fetched that they would make a distinction between those and tourist visas. |
Originally Posted by boat stuck
(Post 34827642)
Following up on my post from a month ago, I predict existing 10-year visas will be reactivated within 60 days. Perhaps within 30 days if the Jan. 9 rumors turn out to be true.
So glad I never tried to get a pandemic visa (which would have canceled my 10-year visa). |
Originally Posted by percysmith
(Post 34826065)
Ok, now I’m starting to believe it:
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/artic...d=premium-asia Govt underreporting figures and Beijing looking like HK fifth wave.
Originally Posted by article
Doctors and nurses in at least one Beijing hospital have been asked to keep reporting for duty even if they’ve caught Covid, if their symptoms are mild
Originally Posted by travelinmanS
(Post 34828376)
You're a bit too optimistic IMHO. Border will be easier to cross but they won't open up to tourists so soon. Biz visas will be prioritized and 10 year visas will need to be reapplied for is my guess. I put tourist visas being easily granted as a June/July thing. I don't think they want a bunch of random tourists roaming around as COVID rips through their population this winter.
|
https://www.reuters.com/world/china/...re-2022-12-12/
WASHINGTON, Dec 12 (Reuters) - China’s ambassador to the United States on Monday said he believes China’s COVID-19 measures will be further relaxed in the near future and international travel to the country will become easier. Ambassador Qin Gang told an event staged by the Semafor news platform that China's government was taking a very responsible attitude to protect people from the threat of COVID-19, and said his country's policy had always been "dynamic, not rigid." "Now the measures are being relaxed, and in the near future, I believe that the measures will be further relaxed and international travel will become easier ... from all the directions to China." |
Hong Kong just relaxed restrictions too, and is supposedly doing 0+0 from tomorrow (with proof of a negative test). |
Originally Posted by narvik
(Post 34827859)
I am not too sure about that one. Not saying it's impossible, but I reckon they could just draw the line and say: "everyone re-apply again". At least for tourist visas.
Residence Permits are quite a bit more involved to obtain, so it wouldn't be too far fetched that they would make a distinction between those and tourist visas. |
Originally Posted by tauphi
(Post 34829426)
Both Japan and South Korea have reactivated their suspended visas. China simply copied their suspensions at the start.
|
Originally Posted by moondog
(Post 34829558)
Japan and Korea didn't reduce inbound flights by 95%. I doubt China will be keen on opening the floodgates to tourists until after 40-50% are reinstated, so I wouldn't be surprised to see tourist visas remain crappy for quite a while.
|
Here we go. Need to see the corresponding butcher's bill:
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/artic...p-backup-plans |
Originally Posted by GinFizz
(Post 34826739)
I think though that you may have missed my point - which is that the scale of the difference in numbers between those "reported" and in real-life is too big to just get by as calling "under-reporting". And also that phrase actually suggests the authorities know the true figure and are hiding it, when it is clear on the ground here in Beijing that they do not.
Also you'd have other sources - e.g. tests taken in hospitals and clinics. |
Originally Posted by tauphi
(Post 34829691)
Given the speed of the opening within China, I doubt they're going to hold the borders for too long. The border restrictions were never important politically within China.
Of course China can’t use any of this propaganda anymore now that they’ve let it rip at China speed, but I imagine the full lifting of border restrictions will still take some time. I’d also like to thank the party personally for locking me down in Shanghai for a few months for no reason. Nothing has changed with Covid from April until now, there was no reason not to let it rip then other than just implementing a few months of human suffering just because they could. Maybe they decided to wait until mid winter instead of spring/summer to let it rip to really increase the impact of Covid. |
Originally Posted by percysmith
(Post 34830257)
OK. There may be a possibility they need to recalibrate the reporting from testing station PCR to self-reporting RAT. But this can't be used to explain the low figures for very long.
Also you'd have other sources - e.g. tests taken in hospitals and clinics. |
Originally Posted by travelinmanS
(Post 34828376)
You're a bit too optimistic IMHO. Border will be easier to cross but they won't open up to tourists so soon. Biz visas will be prioritized and 10 year visas will need to be reapplied for is my guess. I put tourist visas being easily granted as a June/July thing. I don't think they want a bunch of random tourists roaming around as COVID rips through their population this winter.
I normally used to travel to China in April and October around the time of the Canton Fair. My (uneducated) guess is April of 2023 is still out; but October is very possible. We will see. |
Originally Posted by MW147
(Post 34830666)
I am sort of hoping that I have to apply for a new 10 year visa. I just got a new passport, but my original visa is good until late 2025. That would mean carrying 2 passports for a couple of years. If I can get a new visa in my new passport the overlap will be a few months and not until 10 years down the road (by which time I will likely be retired anyway!).
I normally used to travel to China in April and October around the time of the Canton Fair. My (uneducated) guess is April of 2023 is still out; but October is very possible. We will see. |
Originally Posted by travelinmanS
(Post 34830476)
SNIP
I’d also like to thank the party personally for locking me down in Shanghai for a few months for no reason. Nothing has changed with Covid from April until now, there was no reason not to let it rip then other than just implementing a few months of human suffering just because they could. Maybe they decided to wait until mid winter instead of spring/summer to let it rip to really increase the impact of Covid. Back on topic, I also don't think they're going to open the border any time soon to anything that resembles pre-Covid two-way travel. They reportedly removed close-up shots of maskless football supporters from the Qatar World Cup TV broadcasts so citizens couldn't witness Covid freedom in the rest of the world. I do not think they will allow citizens pre-Covid levels of international travel any time soon because there's the real risk travellers will learn the rest of the world has been normal for ages and bring that knowledge back to the motherland risking further social unrest. |
Originally Posted by ftrichard
(Post 34832115)
I'm veering slightly off topic here I know but your last sentence did make me wonder: we read a lot about the increasing economic problems China will face from its aging population. If the bosses really want to address this with a crude sledgehammer then letting Covid rip in the cold winter could be a partial answer so the timing is perfect. A few strategic power cuts could complete the job nicely.
Back on topic, I also don't think they're going to open the border any time soon to anything that resembles pre-Covid two-way travel. They reportedly removed close-up shots of maskless football supporters from the Qatar World Cup TV broadcasts so citizens couldn't witness Covid freedom in the rest of the world. I do not think they will allow citizens pre-Covid levels of international travel any time soon because there's the real risk travellers will learn the rest of the world has been normal for ages and bring that knowledge back to the motherland risking further social unrest. |
Originally Posted by narvik
(Post 34832258)
China won't open up to international travel EVER, or January 9th, 2023; whichever comes first. :D
|
Here's an interesting bit of info:
This is allegedly a new sign at Shenzhen North Railway Station, listing various cancelled trains to Hong Kong West Kowloon Station. The fact that the trains to Hong Kong are cancelled isn't new; it's been that way for 3 years. The new part, is that the notice says these trains are cancelled through December 24 or December 25. An optimistic interpretation, therefore, is that the trains to Hong Kong will restart on December 25 or 26. Anyways, take this with a gigantic grain of salt, but if it does happen, you heard it here first! https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.fly...34601c4c00.jpg |
Futian port being lit up too, HK Government told the public to not speculate on the meaning.
|
Originally Posted by travelinmanS
(Post 34830476)
Border restrictions were indeed very important politically in China. Their whole message was that the rest of the world was failing at Covid but thanks to the glorious leadership of Chairman Xi and the party, China is safe from the deadly Covid virus. Foreigners living in China often felt the impact of this as well with people refused entry to places and things like people getting up and moving when a foreigner sat down next to them on the subway.
Of course China can’t use any of this propaganda anymore now that they’ve let it rip at China speed, but I imagine the full lifting of border restrictions will still take some time. I’d also like to thank the party personally for locking me down in Shanghai for a few months for no reason. Nothing has changed with Covid from April until now, there was no reason not to let it rip then other than just implementing a few months of human suffering just because they could. Maybe they decided to wait until mid winter instead of spring/summer to let it rip to really increase the impact of Covid. |
Originally Posted by tauphi
(Post 34832863)
When they reduced quarantine from 14+7 to 7+3 at the height of Zero-Covid there was not a single peep out of the population. I doubt there is any political resistance for going down to 0.
|
Originally Posted by boat stuck
(Post 34837668)
Agreed. Still, the sudden policy shift is truly astounding. Who knows, maybe it's because Xi was actually patient zero for the Beijing outbreak, after he got it from Trudeau while they were squabbling in Bali!
|
Another data point suggesting that the HK/mainland border might open soon
https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/...-shift-towards Hong Kong to send ‘thousands of officers’ to checkpoints along mainland Chinese border ahead of shift towards freer travel
A government source on Thursday said the relevant departments were preparing to test all customs checkpoint clearance systems at the city’s high-speed rail that extends into Guangdong province and along other sections of the border as authorities needed weeks to prepare for the relaxed rules. Another insider said the city’s rail operator was gearing up to resume the service by performing frequent drills. “Despite that most of the border checkpoints have been closed, their operations have remained normal during the past three years with staff working there to provide regular security, checks and maintenance,” the insider said. “For the high-speed rail and other cross-border rail services, there has been a minimum rail service to transport the mainland staff to and from the mainland. To reopen its services, the MTR Corporation only needs to redeploy its staff again for the rail borders.” Most of Hong Kong’s border checkpoints have been closed since the beginning of the Covid-19 pandemic in early 2020, including those at Lok Ma Chau, Heung Yuen Wai and the West Kowloon high-speed rail terminus. Under the current restrictions, travellers can enter the mainland from Hong Kong using the city’s airport, as well as the control points at Shenzhen Bay and the Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macau Bridge. Sources previously told the Post that the city was set to fully reopen its borders with the mainland and resume the high-speed train service to Guangdong from early next month. The expected reopening follows the government’s decision to roll back anti-epidemic restrictions, such as easing entry rules for arrivals and no longer relying on the “Leave Home Safe” risk-exposure app, despite a significant increase recently in Hong Kong’s virus caseloads. Thursday marked the highest number of daily cases since March 18, with health officials reporting 17,080 infections, 831 of which were imported, and 19 additional deaths. The city’s overall tally stands at 2,307,397 cases and 11,075 related fatalities. |
Mainland 2,229 cases yesterday
https://www.i-cable.com/%e6%96%b0%e8...B%98%E5%B3%B0/ https://news.now.com/home/internatio...?newsId=501161 HK has 15K cases today We must be using a different counting system |
Originally Posted by percysmith
(Post 34841475)
Mainland 2,229 cases yesterday
https://www.i-cable.com/%e6%96%b0%e8...B%98%E5%B3%B0/ https://news.now.com/home/internatio...?newsId=501161 HK has 15K cases today We must be using a different counting system |
Originally Posted by maalloc
(Post 34841480)
Didn't mainland officially stop counting asymptomatic cases earlier this week?
The non-counting is at official policy level at the moment, and has little "Ah, gotcha!" effect at this point. Beijing is likely over 10 million cases that have it or just had it. It's predicted to go into the hundreds of millions across all of China soon. Just to be clear, they are not counting most symptomatic cases either. Added; of much graver concern ought to be the apparent complete lack of counting deaths. |
Family reports from Beijing are basically saying that a) it's amazing how everything suddenly disappeared with no comment and b) everyone is now getting COVID to the surprise of also nobody c) everyone is simultaneously relieved and worried
|
Originally Posted by narvik
(Post 34841580)
Yes, not sure why this is still discussed as some kind of big revelation.
The non-counting is at official policy level at the moment, and has little "Ah, gotcha!" effect at this point. Beijing is likely over 10 million cases that have it or just had it. It's predicted to go into the hundreds of millions across all of China soon. Just to be clear, they are not counting most symptomatic cases either. Added; of much graver concern ought to be the apparent complete lack of counting deaths. |
Originally Posted by Smiley90
(Post 34841945)
Family reports from Beijing are basically saying that a) it's amazing how everything suddenly disappeared with no comment and b) everyone is now getting COVID to the surprise of also nobody c) everyone is simultaneously relieved and worried
Or is it like homosexuality in the US military in the Clinton era? Don't ask, don't tell? |
Originally Posted by Smiley90
(Post 34841945)
Family reports from Beijing are basically saying that a) it's amazing how everything suddenly disappeared with no comment and b) everyone is now getting COVID to the surprise of also nobody c) everyone is simultaneously relieved and worried
The flight out of PVG was bizarre: 1) They confiscate hand sanitizer at the security check probably becuse the alcohol based ones are flammable? 2) The flight was 100% masked (maybe not cockpit, don't know). Although it's not required of course, the FAs seemed relieved and were wearing masks also. There was no announcement about masks. |
Originally Posted by Smiley90
(Post 34841945)
Family reports from Beijing are basically saying that a) it's amazing how everything suddenly disappeared with no comment and b) everyone is now getting COVID to the surprise of also nobody c) everyone is simultaneously relieved and worried
The best case scenario is everyone gets flu equivalent for a week over the next three months. But nowhere overseas where we had an off/on scenario: Australia, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore (?) were hospitals not overwhelmed during the transition. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 1:03 am. |
This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.