Chase closed my credit cards
#31
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: DFW
Programs: AA PLT, HH Gold, SPG/Marriott Gold
Posts: 1,091
I believe this is the reason. Also just because Chase found out doesn't mean he/she will stop churning cards with other issuers (still seen as a "potential credit risk").
#32
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Brooklyn, NY, United States
Programs: AA, BA, UA, Spirit, Delta, PC Plat, SPG Gold, HHonors Diamond, Club Carlson Gold, Marriott Gold
Posts: 1,735
But the reason Chase closes accounts is not to deter churning. For one reason or another Chase must consider you a credit risk in order to do that, and in that regard churning is the least of their problems.
How do I know? Before my last application for United I called Chase and asked them directly if I was running a risk of having my accounts closed (holding 6 other Chase cards I believed I had a good reason to fear that). The CSR checked my accounts and said there were no problems with them. She encouraged me to apply and noted they would never close an account without a good reason. What they consider a good reason is unclear, but churning ain't that. On the other hand, I believe that putting cards in a sock after getting bonuses is like asking for trouble. Make small purchases if you must but do make some on a regular basis, because even it they don't monitor this kind of behavior just yet, they certainly will soon enough.
#33
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 1,060
What are the flags that will cause card issuers to close all your accounts?
I've been reading about many reports lately of how Chase goes berserk and close all your accounts for no good reason.
Does anyone know what triggers these kinds of actions? Too much total CL relative to income? Too high a utilization? Opening too many cards per year?
Also, is this phenomenon Chase specific, or has other card issuers been known to go berserk on their customers?
Does anyone know what triggers these kinds of actions? Too much total CL relative to income? Too high a utilization? Opening too many cards per year?
Also, is this phenomenon Chase specific, or has other card issuers been known to go berserk on their customers?
#34
Moderator
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Miami, Mpls & London
Programs: AA & Marriott Perpetual Platinum; DL & HH Gold
Posts: 48,958
No, American Express has a process called a Financial Review which is widely discussed in the Membership Rewards forum. Typical thread here:
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/ameri...on-merged.html
A credit card is an unsecured line of credit. Essentially, American Express requires you to provide evidence that you have the means to continue to pay, which is distinct from having a track record of payment.
Similarly, Citibank asked some Chairman card holders, including me, to provide proof of financial assets to keep the card, but they did not suspend it while waiting for the documentation.
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/ameri...on-merged.html
A credit card is an unsecured line of credit. Essentially, American Express requires you to provide evidence that you have the means to continue to pay, which is distinct from having a track record of payment.
Similarly, Citibank asked some Chairman card holders, including me, to provide proof of financial assets to keep the card, but they did not suspend it while waiting for the documentation.
#36
Join Date: Jan 2011
Programs: SPG GOLD
Posts: 217
> close all your accounts for no good reason.
I doubt banks go around closing accounts "for no good reason". I can think of a lot of reasons why people who habitually spend the minimum to receive the bonus would get blacklisted. Let's say a Visa Signature card's interchange is 2% for simplicity sake. When you get a Chase Sapphire Preferred and spend $3,000 to get $500, Chase has only made $60 interchange through the merchant processor. They gave you $500 bonus which means they have a net loss of $440. In order for them to recoup the $500 bonus payout, you will need to spend $25,000. If Chase does not predict you will do this for the life of the card, then I could see them blacklisting "bonus abusers". The easiest way to predict a "bonus abuser" is someone that spends a little past $3,000 then stops using the card. It'd be easy to calculate a "bonus abuser" score based on spending pattern.
I doubt banks go around closing accounts "for no good reason". I can think of a lot of reasons why people who habitually spend the minimum to receive the bonus would get blacklisted. Let's say a Visa Signature card's interchange is 2% for simplicity sake. When you get a Chase Sapphire Preferred and spend $3,000 to get $500, Chase has only made $60 interchange through the merchant processor. They gave you $500 bonus which means they have a net loss of $440. In order for them to recoup the $500 bonus payout, you will need to spend $25,000. If Chase does not predict you will do this for the life of the card, then I could see them blacklisting "bonus abusers". The easiest way to predict a "bonus abuser" is someone that spends a little past $3,000 then stops using the card. It'd be easy to calculate a "bonus abuser" score based on spending pattern.
#37
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: DFW
Programs: AA PLT, HH Gold, SPG/Marriott Gold
Posts: 1,091
I think sometimes we don't hear the full story of people who get shut down by Chase or others. Just my opinion. Now watch all of my Chase accounts get shut down for no reason after posting this!
#38
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 50
too many rewards
Chase closes all your accts when you take them up on their 5% UNLIMITED cash back for the first 6 months-they close your accts if you receive too much cash back-and they close it right before your statement closes and refuse to honor your rewards! so you lose! Chase is doing this like crazy right now.
#39
Join Date: Dec 2010
Posts: 1,310
Chase closes all your accts when you take them up on their 5% UNLIMITED cash back for the first 6 months-they close your accts if you receive too much cash back-and they close it right before your statement closes and refuse to honor your rewards! so you lose! Chase is doing this like crazy right now.
I'd love to see just one of your credit card statements for that card.
Care to post your transactions for a month?
#40
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Coconut Creek, FL
Programs: AA Lifetime Platinum-2 MM Starwood Plat,Delta DM
Posts: 975
I've been reading about many reports lately of how Chase goes berserk and close all your accounts for no good reason.
Does anyone know what triggers these kinds of actions? Too much total CL relative to income? Too high a utilization? Opening too many cards per year?
Also, is this phenomenon Chase specific, or has other card issuers been known to go berserk on their customers?
Does anyone know what triggers these kinds of actions? Too much total CL relative to income? Too high a utilization? Opening too many cards per year?
Also, is this phenomenon Chase specific, or has other card issuers been known to go berserk on their customers?
#41
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Boston
Posts: 14
I'm on my 2nd CHASE AARP card and have suffered no adverse action to date. Last year I cleared $3700 in 5% cashback. I've used the card primarily for personal expenses and have avoided "red flags" like purchases of gift cards. I'll be paying $40K in estimated taxes with the card this year via payusatax.com and will realize around $1200 cashback ( 5% - 1.89% fee).
Unfortunately, CHASE has closed new applications for the 5% promotion but is still offering 3% cashback on travel expenses and 1% on miscellaneous.
btw, you DON'T have to be an AARP member or be over age 50 to get the card.
Good Luck,
Unfortunately, CHASE has closed new applications for the 5% promotion but is still offering 3% cashback on travel expenses and 1% on miscellaneous.
btw, you DON'T have to be an AARP member or be over age 50 to get the card.
Good Luck,
#42
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: On strike
Posts: 8,135
#43
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: DFW
Programs: AA 1M
Posts: 31,475
This is getting me nervous, I want to apply for the Sapphire card next month. I have 3 Chase accts, one savings and one checking. No inquiries in the past six months.
#45
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Florida
Posts: 29,763
I dont think you have anything to worry about especially you have no inquiry in the past 6 months, and you routinely use your Chase cards. No need to be big usage, just not "put it in the sock drawer" type of treatment. It is always a good practice to use a card every 2 - 3 months to keep it active.