Definitive "Booking Japan Airlines (JL) Using AS Miles" Thread (2023-24)
#61
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: PHX
Programs: AA, SPG, UR
Posts: 329
Experiencing a very strange issue with AS, curious if anyone also noticed.
Example 1: SIN-HND-LAX
Segment by Segment
SIN-HND = UNAVAILABLE
HND-LAX = AVAILABLE
SIN-HND-KIX = AVAILABLE
(sin-hnd is all same flight and date)
Multi city search:
SIN-HND-KIX + HND-LAX = AVAILABLE
SIN-HND + HND LAX = UNAVAILABLE
Thinking it is phantom inventory, I booked SIN-HND-KIX + HND-LAX and the booking system TICKETED the reservation lol. So right now I may have to fly this strange itinerary (its fine because it gives me 20 hrs in osaka before i need to get a $100 domestic ticket to HND.
Example 2: LAX to TYO
LAX-HND = UNAVAILABLE
SFO-LAX-HND = AVAILABLE (same tpac flight date and #)
I'm not extremely motivated to book a flight to reposition from LAX to SFO just to fly back to LAX again but I guess I can do that if need be if desparate times comes to desparate measures, but has anyone worked their way around these strange inventory issues?
Example 1: SIN-HND-LAX
Segment by Segment
SIN-HND = UNAVAILABLE
HND-LAX = AVAILABLE
SIN-HND-KIX = AVAILABLE
(sin-hnd is all same flight and date)
Multi city search:
SIN-HND-KIX + HND-LAX = AVAILABLE
SIN-HND + HND LAX = UNAVAILABLE
Thinking it is phantom inventory, I booked SIN-HND-KIX + HND-LAX and the booking system TICKETED the reservation lol. So right now I may have to fly this strange itinerary (its fine because it gives me 20 hrs in osaka before i need to get a $100 domestic ticket to HND.
Example 2: LAX to TYO
LAX-HND = UNAVAILABLE
SFO-LAX-HND = AVAILABLE (same tpac flight date and #)
I'm not extremely motivated to book a flight to reposition from LAX to SFO just to fly back to LAX again but I guess I can do that if need be if desparate times comes to desparate measures, but has anyone worked their way around these strange inventory issues?
Wonder if other than trying to book dummy itins daily to see when one goes through, if there is any other way to get alerted when the issue is fixed
Last edited by FT-hss; Jan 29, 2023 at 2:30 pm
#63
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: bay area, ca
Programs: UA plat, , aa plat, marriott LT titanium
Posts: 4,833
Experiencing a very strange issue with AS, curious if anyone also noticed.
Example 1: SIN-HND-LAX
Segment by Segment
SIN-HND = UNAVAILABLE
HND-LAX = AVAILABLE
SIN-HND-KIX = AVAILABLE
(sin-hnd is all same flight and date)
Multi city search:
SIN-HND-KIX + HND-LAX = AVAILABLE
SIN-HND + HND LAX = UNAVAILABLE
Thinking it is phantom inventory, I booked SIN-HND-KIX + HND-LAX and the booking system TICKETED the reservation lol. So right now I may have to fly this strange itinerary (its fine because it gives me 20 hrs in osaka before i need to get a $100 domestic ticket to HND.
Example 2: LAX to TYO
LAX-HND = UNAVAILABLE
SFO-LAX-HND = AVAILABLE (same tpac flight date and #)
I'm not extremely motivated to book a flight to reposition from LAX to SFO just to fly back to LAX again but I guess I can do that if need be if desparate times comes to desparate measures, but has anyone worked their way around these strange inventory issues?
Example 1: SIN-HND-LAX
Segment by Segment
SIN-HND = UNAVAILABLE
HND-LAX = AVAILABLE
SIN-HND-KIX = AVAILABLE
(sin-hnd is all same flight and date)
Multi city search:
SIN-HND-KIX + HND-LAX = AVAILABLE
SIN-HND + HND LAX = UNAVAILABLE
Thinking it is phantom inventory, I booked SIN-HND-KIX + HND-LAX and the booking system TICKETED the reservation lol. So right now I may have to fly this strange itinerary (its fine because it gives me 20 hrs in osaka before i need to get a $100 domestic ticket to HND.
Example 2: LAX to TYO
LAX-HND = UNAVAILABLE
SFO-LAX-HND = AVAILABLE (same tpac flight date and #)
I'm not extremely motivated to book a flight to reposition from LAX to SFO just to fly back to LAX again but I guess I can do that if need be if desparate times comes to desparate measures, but has anyone worked their way around these strange inventory issues?
#64
Join Date: May 2006
Location: KSNA/KLAX
Programs: IML GOLD, Bonvoy LTPE, WOH Globalist, AAEXPLT
Posts: 646
#65
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: bay area, ca
Programs: UA plat, , aa plat, marriott LT titanium
Posts: 4,833
What class was this? I'm interested b/c I tried to book bkk-hnd-kix to connect to hnd-sfo (because the legs were available separately but was told they had to be ticketed as separate awards and kix and hnd were not co-terminals - so for some reason they wouldn't allow it. Didn't allow as open jaw for me ?!? even tho I have done bkk-tyo-sfo with a 7 day stay at tyo.
#66
Join Date: Feb 2019
Posts: 5,867
What class was this? I'm interested b/c I tried to book bkk-hnd-kix to connect to hnd-sfo (because the legs were available separately but was told they had to be ticketed as separate awards and kix and hnd were not co-terminals - so for some reason they wouldn't allow it. Didn't allow as open jaw for me ?!? even tho I have done bkk-tyo-sfo with a 7 day stay at tyo.
#67
Join Date: May 2019
Location: Chicago, IL
Programs: AS MVPG, DL Gold, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 141
Sorry guys, newbie but hopefully someone can help. I'm trying to plan a trip from ORD-BKK next year and have a couple questions.
Is the best way to do it often a multi city, like ORD-TOKYO-BKK (with a same day connecting flight), or do one ways work better? Half the time one is better, half the time it's the other. It's super challenging bc of all the partners to actually find certain flight availability (for example, a connecting Narita-BKK rarely has available business) - doesn't seem as though JAL is on ExpertFlyer.
I also checked Cathay Pacific thru HKG (doesn't even show up) and would prefer not to fly Korean as they seem to have an inferior product.
Edit -- Lastly, is it a safe bet to wait and assume award space opens within 2 weeks? Thinking of just booking business as a placeholder and hoping that some F appears later - though now I'm noticing that ORD-TOKYO opens up 2 weeks in advance more widely whereas TOKYO-BKK opens up only far in advance... ugh!
Is the best way to do it often a multi city, like ORD-TOKYO-BKK (with a same day connecting flight), or do one ways work better? Half the time one is better, half the time it's the other. It's super challenging bc of all the partners to actually find certain flight availability (for example, a connecting Narita-BKK rarely has available business) - doesn't seem as though JAL is on ExpertFlyer.
I also checked Cathay Pacific thru HKG (doesn't even show up) and would prefer not to fly Korean as they seem to have an inferior product.
Edit -- Lastly, is it a safe bet to wait and assume award space opens within 2 weeks? Thinking of just booking business as a placeholder and hoping that some F appears later - though now I'm noticing that ORD-TOKYO opens up 2 weeks in advance more widely whereas TOKYO-BKK opens up only far in advance... ugh!
Last edited by whitf00t; Jan 30, 2023 at 4:16 pm Reason: updated
#68
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: bay area, ca
Programs: UA plat, , aa plat, marriott LT titanium
Posts: 4,833
if it is priced separately it would be 25 for bkk-kix in J plus the hnd-sfo - which was exactly why I wanted them to ticket on one ticket (pnr) which they would not do - so in my case it cost an extra 20k miles
#69
Join Date: Feb 2019
Posts: 5,867
That would be 85k then if priced separately (60k for the hnd-sfo portion). But OP said 65 so we know it's J class although it's possible the bkk-hnd-kix was in Y if OP couldn't find J availability for that segment.
#70
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: SEA, but up and down the coast a lot
Programs: Oceanic Airlines Gold Elite
Posts: 20,397
LOL. KIX and HND aren't coterminals because they're over 250 miles apart and serve different cities. That's like LGA and DCA being coterminals. AS's booking engine is notorious for just doing dumb things like thinking BKK-SIN-LHR(stop)-SIN-HKG is an intra-Asia SQ award (they fixed that), and that + JL doing a lot of married segment inventory probably explains OP's result, but it doesn't make KIX an an alternate for TYO the same way NRT and HND are.
Last edited by eponymous_coward; Jan 30, 2023 at 7:02 pm
#72
Join Date: Jan 2010
Programs: UA, AS
Posts: 2,393
Sorry guys, newbie but hopefully someone can help. I'm trying to plan a trip from ORD-BKK next year and have a couple questions.
Is the best way to do it often a multi city, like ORD-TOKYO-BKK (with a same day connecting flight), or do one ways work better? Half the time one is better, half the time it's the other. It's super challenging bc of all the partners to actually find certain flight availability (for example, a connecting Narita-BKK rarely has available business) - doesn't seem as though JAL is on ExpertFlyer.
I also checked Cathay Pacific thru HKG (doesn't even show up) and would prefer not to fly Korean as they seem to have an inferior product.
Edit -- Lastly, is it a safe bet to wait and assume award space opens within 2 weeks? Thinking of just booking business as a placeholder and hoping that some F appears later - though now I'm noticing that ORD-TOKYO opens up 2 weeks in advance more widely whereas TOKYO-BKK opens up only far in advance... ugh!
Is the best way to do it often a multi city, like ORD-TOKYO-BKK (with a same day connecting flight), or do one ways work better? Half the time one is better, half the time it's the other. It's super challenging bc of all the partners to actually find certain flight availability (for example, a connecting Narita-BKK rarely has available business) - doesn't seem as though JAL is on ExpertFlyer.
I also checked Cathay Pacific thru HKG (doesn't even show up) and would prefer not to fly Korean as they seem to have an inferior product.
Edit -- Lastly, is it a safe bet to wait and assume award space opens within 2 weeks? Thinking of just booking business as a placeholder and hoping that some F appears later - though now I'm noticing that ORD-TOKYO opens up 2 weeks in advance more widely whereas TOKYO-BKK opens up only far in advance... ugh!
Booking a year out at the edge of the window is a good time to look for availability so long as you are not traveling in a peak travel period. Make sure you are familiar with the calendar trick and when it is useful, and if you have extra miles it may also be helpful to familiarize yourself with the reverse round-trip workaround.
If you cannot find ORD-BKK it may help (availability wise) to create a stopover in TYO for a day or two. This may allow you to connect up availability on different days that may not be available without a stopover. Since AS allows free stopovers this can be a good strategy if you don't mind spending a day or two in TYO. You can search multi-city ORD-TYO and TYO-BKK. Use the TYO code to pick up availability for both HND and NRT.
Don't discount looking from other gateways. Possibly SEA.
#74
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: bay area, ca
Programs: UA plat, , aa plat, marriott LT titanium
Posts: 4,833
LOL. KIX and HND aren't coterminals because they're over 250 miles apart and serve different cities. That's like LGA and DCA being coterminals. AS's booking engine is notorious for just doing dumb things like thinking BKK-SIN-LHR(stop)-SIN-HKG is an intra-Asia SQ award (they fixed that), and that + JL doing a lot of married segment inventory probably explains OP's result, but it doesn't make KIX an an alternate for TYO the same way NRT and HND are.