I opened P2 much more recently. Never ordered the permanent card, so been using just the "Retail Card" as One calls it. Never took any offers on that one, because they never offered anything. Probably because I never set up DD on that one, so I wasn't a "Plus member".

However, one thing I can think of is that I once sent a "One To One" money transfer (I think that's what the called it, can't access the app any more) from P2 to P1. Once they had eyes on my account, they may have traced the "One to One" payment to see who I was in cahoots with, and that put their eyes on P2 account.

This is all just conjecture of course. We'll never know for sure.