Originally Posted by
serfty
Respectfully,
Serfty, you do indeed appear to be adding your personal interpretation to the discussion by citing the wording from the QF web site lounge access footnotes and proposing a reading which stretches credulity.
And also by suggesting that the EK tie-up has some bearing despite the OP's question and some other examples are not directly related to EK scenarios, rather QF, BA, etc.
A OneWorld customer on an economy DONE4 (or similar) could run into all sorts of inconsistent lounge access issues if citing, say, an AA Platinum membership number...
IMHO much speculation afoot.
Surely these sort of questions should be very easy to resolve if QF:
1. Presented its T&Cs in a clear and definitive manner
2. Had the customer relations capacity and competency to answer customer queries in a confident and definitive manner (e.g a "RedRoo" or equivalent simply stepping into a thread and stating the case)