Originally Posted by
Cargojon
You lost me when you brought LH into the conversation. They have a few scattered premium products that are nice, but it's not consistently available (crap shoot based on aircraft/route). Their Y is garbage.
I agree that it's inconsistent, though I think the last of the crappy J and old F should be phased out shortly. Catering lightyears ahead on Lufthansa in both J and F. J lounges better than anything United puts forth and the F terminal is the stuff of legends. I've found Y on Lufthansa to be at least tolerable, with professional service. US airlines are hit or miss.
Again perhaps not the best airline in the world, but I think Lufthansa on the whole (and on average) absolutely compares favorably to United on the whole.