The one time I found one that was working I had essentially the same experience. Got one MO out of it. Said oh great lets try that again, second one failed but I was charged for it. Had to go to customer service desk who then after some talking with the manager cut a new MO for me there. Luckily that time I was using my TDGo card with my name on it because they asked to look at the card. If it was a gift card it might have gone worse. Never found another working MO Kate again.