Looks like not a lot to offer for EXP that fly paid flights the vast majority of the time.
Definitely a cool deal for many, and I'm glad to see them doing this ^
For an EXP, the priority boarding and free checked bag aren't worth anything (the priority boarding benefit for so many more people just means even longer PA lines). But the double AA miles on AA purchases is nice, and the 10% rebate on award redemptions is nice if you occasionally use award tickets or mileage upgrades.