The reason is that Sizzler doesn't rip you off. You basically get what you pay for. You're not paying $46 for a slab of beef, so you dont' expect it to be that amzing. I've eaten at Sizzler, and I must say, it's totally fine. The bread is delicious, and the steak is totally fine for the cheap price. It's when you pay through the nose (like at Smith & Wolensky) and you get mediocre steak that people get angry.

Wow, I thought most people liked Italian food. Especially Americans.