You want to rent a car for approximately 92 days in NYC for approximately $31.97 per day, and you think that is not a good rate? NYC is a very expensive rental car city.

HOWEVER, without a lot more information from you, it is not possible to help you. It is very possible to get a lower rate.

In order to help you, please supply the following info:
1) What type of car would you like? (sub compact, compact, intermediate, standard, full, intermediate suv, etc);
2) What is your preferred pick up and drop off location? (airport, in town, or suburbs [cheapest], the price difference will be huge);
3) What AWD numbers are you actually entitled to use and which have you tried?
4) What is your actual budget?