Originally Posted by
channa
but we were actually discussing whether US F is comparable to CO F at this point, as both carriers have their pros and cons.
Did you get another one of your legendary op-ups to US F? The same US F that no one buys, which is why they (theoretically) op-up alliance elites?
You can debate all you want about whether US and CO F are comparable (heck, on short pretzel only routes US is actually better from a service standpoint). The fundamental difference is I don't fly (anyone) for the amenities.
I travel to get places. Within a reasonable window of when I was scheduled to arrive there. US fails at that.