FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   United Airlines | MileagePlus (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/united-airlines-mileageplus-681/)
-   -   Pro/Cons of booking flights on partner site vs united.com (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/united-airlines-mileageplus/1791518-pro-cons-booking-flights-partner-site-vs-united-com.html)

Shoredreamer Oct 5, 2018 8:11 pm

Thank you so much for all of these very helpful links I will check them all out. I do understand codeshares as I always must use them flying my typical itineraries from Scandinavia to US as both of my “home” airports (GOT/CPH) are not directly serviced my UA. When I do go on UA site and restrict to UA only flights lots of choices come up but many are really operated entirely by LH. Other than going through the details of all of them, I don’t know any other way to ensure I’m on UA metal which at the moment, is my preference. As for Polaris flights I did see the posts and site for routes but doesn’t seem to show much other than the new planes (not the refitted ones) and only ones I think I saw involving EU go to either SFO or IAD, is this still the case presently? (I was hoping maybe it was updated to include more options. aldo for me PQDs don’t matter because I reside outside of the US but I am trying to go for the lifetime miles when possible. Obviously can only do that when flying US domestic or thtough the EU airports that UA directly services such as Germany or England etc

Again though, thank you SO MUCH for this invaluable info—and so quickly!!! Always a pleasure 😉

WineCountryUA Oct 5, 2018 8:32 pm


Originally Posted by Shoredreamer (Post 30284155)
....When I do go on UA site and restrict to UA only flights lots of choices come up but many are really operated entirely by LH. ...

example please, that is not my experience

Shoredreamer Oct 5, 2018 9:11 pm

Sure. Maybe I am not doing something right but using my most recent searching as an example Got-lax or vice versa, while all options come up saying UA, some say operated by LH and some say operated in part by LH. I certainly realize that due to needing the codeshare I at least must have an LH from Got but then the long haul comes up as UA but in reality some choices are actually LH flights (those saying “operated by LH” rather than those saying “operated in part by LH”) please let me know if there is something I am doing incorrectly as I’d certainly love to learn how to do it, if possible, to eliminate the ones fully operated by LH!

WineCountryUA Oct 19, 2018 1:12 pm


Originally Posted by Shoredreamer (Post 30284261)
Sure. Maybe I am not doing something right but using my most recent searching as an example Got-lax or vice versa, while all options come up saying UA, some say operated by LH and some say operated in part by LH. I certainly realize that due to needing the codeshare I at least must have an LH from Got but then the long haul comes up as UA but in reality some choices are actually LH flights (those saying “operated by LH” rather than those saying “operated in part by LH”) please let me know if there is something I am doing incorrectly as I’d certainly love to learn how to do it, if possible, to eliminate the ones fully operated by LH!

On united.com, you can select UA only operated flights. Try FRA-LAX with and without UA only operated options with Advance Search and you will see the difference.

However since GOT is not serviced by UA, GOT-LAX by UA only yields no options at all. So the UA only option will not work for you. Additionally, as a common connection out of GOT is FRA, and there is no direct FRA-LAX light on UA, united.com will suggest the FRA-LAX non-stop -- thinking most passengers prefer a minimum of connections. Flight search engines are designed to optimize -- price, travel time, connections, .... and a variety of other factors. And likely some preference for UA operated flights.

So what you need is a way to force UA flights on some segments but not all. United.com does not offer that. There are third-party tools, such as ITA Matrix (now owned by Google) that has a powerful command language that can do such searchs (but it does talk some time to learn)
https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/trav...thread-46.html
https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/trav...-lh-lx-tk.html

Shoredreamer Oct 20, 2018 5:04 am

Ok, I understand what you are saying. Perhaps I can spend more time with that tool and at least try to educate myself some although i am sorry to say but I’m far from technical. I do very much appreciate all of your many suggestions and help. Thank you again so much!

WineCountryUA Oct 20, 2018 2:47 pm


Originally Posted by Shoredreamer (Post 30335697)
Ok, I understand what you are saying. Perhaps I can spend more time with that tool and at least try to educate myself some although i am sorry to say but I’m far from technical. I do very much appreciate all of your many suggestions and help. Thank you again so much!

Another option would be use the UA only search for portions of the travel that could be UA only and then find a flight to connect you on the non-UA operated segments -- more tedious and a bit hard to book but it could achieve your desired results.

Shoredreamer Oct 20, 2018 3:20 pm

Thank you again, I’ve actually spent quite a bit of time doing that already but unfortunately pricing changes quite remarkably if I don’t have at least the GOT flight attached to the long haul. I’ve tried all the scenarios even in both directions but cheapest appears to be GOT-LAX with adding the LAX-PHX separately. (GOT-LAX alone is much higher than with the GOT flight added) Ive now flown this a several times already, with LH, TK and now UA and find it quite difficult to get my bags checked in all the way through on my outgoing because even though they’re all star alliance flights, when checking in at GOT, there obviously aren’t any United personnel and the reps that are there whether at LH or TK are typically 3rd party and don’t have the ability to combine my pnr’s correctly. Going back though, when checking in with United at PHX, they are able to manipulate things enough properly so my bags go all the way through. I wish there wasn’t such a sibstantial price difference but unfortunately there is. Guess all I can really do is continue in the way I have because I am enjoying the UA long haul experience more than LH and for whatever reason, most likely fare class (I always do cheapest bsns fare) getting more miles booking/flying with UA but paying more too which I was hoping to not have to do!

lixiaojuventus Dec 28, 2018 8:06 am

Any disadvantages of buying LH group flights on united.com?
 
I will be flying frequently from HKG to Europe in future. Recently I found that united.com actually can sell LH group flights at the same price as lufthansa.com. I am wondering if there are any disadvantages of buying LH group flights from UA? In case of IRROPs who should I contact? Thanks!

mduell Dec 28, 2018 11:37 am

Do you want Light fares?

For IRROPS you always contact the operating carrier.

emcampbe Dec 28, 2018 11:56 am

I'd ask what advantage there is to buying from UA?

The two reasons that would probably be most common are PQD and mileage earning. If you're doing a lot of HKG-EU, are you still a US resident, as if you are living in at a foreign address, the PQD can be waived if you change your address. If not, and you need the PQD, then UA would be the only way to get that.

Mileage earning advantage will depend on the type of fares you are buying - in some cases, UA being $-based earning can be an advantage (mainly higher fares, but potentially also on lower fares where LH will credit, say, 50%) but on others, it will be better with an LH ticket.

I can see some very small other advantages (profile already setup on UA, so no need to re-type your passenger information, for example), but those are so minuscule that its hardly a consideration. For IRROPS, anything any day of would be operating carrier would take care of you. Anything in advance, i.e. schedule change, you'll need to talk to UA as issuing carrier. There can also be some 'pass the buck' here between operating and ticketing carrier. So all else being equal, I'd book directly with LH - generally booking with the operating carrier is going to be easier in terms of changes, etc, so would go with that.

On the other hand, no matter who the ticketing carrier is, the thing that will be the same is flying LH. Not sure what cabin class, but I just got off UA and LH long-hauls a couple of days ago (UA 777 and LH 748), and man, the LH economy seats are narrow. I normally don't notice these things too much, but it was hard not to.

mduell Dec 28, 2018 12:40 pm


Originally Posted by emcampbe (Post 30582441)
On the other hand, no matter who the ticketing carrier is, the thing that will be the same is flying LH. Not sure what cabin class, but I just got off UA and LH long-hauls a couple of days ago (UA 777 and LH 748), and man, the LH economy seats are narrow. I normally don't notice these things too much, but it was hard not to.

UA is working to fix that, going to the same 10 abreast as the 748 on the narrower 777 airframe.

sfo Dec 28, 2018 12:41 pm

If you book with UA you will not be able to pre-select your seat on LH unless you book directly LH

In2ishn Apr 2, 2019 11:08 am

Earning PQD on partner-ticketed Code-shares
 
Hi all!

I swear I searched but did not find answer so I fear the answer is NO

On Delta I can earn PQD (MQD in Delta-speak) on non-Delta ticketed flights. Does UA offer this in any circumstance? I am finding some good prices on SQ

Thanks!

WineCountryUA Apr 2, 2019 11:10 am


Originally Posted by In2ishn (Post 30956850)
....
On Delta I can earn PQD (MQD in Delta-speak) on non-Delta ticketed flights. Does UA offer this in any circumstance? I am finding some good prices on SQ


For UA, to earn PQDs it must be
1) a UA operated flight (any ticket stock)
or
2) A partner operated flight on 016 ticket stock

nothing else

flight numbers mean nothing

BThumme Apr 2, 2019 11:27 am

This is a weak spot of United unfortunately. You have to have a ticket on 016 or be flying a United segment (and will earn only for those United segments) as noted above.

SQ has lots of great fares (I think there's like $900 west coast-Singapore premium economy fares). You will earn some miles but no qualifying dollars. Sucks.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 8:36 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.