Exchange rate question!
#1
Original Poster




Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Los Angeles, CA; Philadelphia, PA
Programs: FA
Posts: 6,482
Exchange rate question!
I was wondering if the published exchange rates on newspaper are the interbank rates (rates that banks charge each other). For example, I recently saw a USD$1 to HKD$7.80 rate published in a newspaper and when I withdrew money from a HK ATM using a US ATM card, the rate I calculated is 1:7.7999. I knew I won't get hit with ATM fees because I checked with my bank already, but I thought (at least I was told by other FTers) that ATM withdrawals are also subjected to the universal 1% foreign currency conversion fee. If the published rates are not interbank rates, then where can I find those numbers? Thanks in advance.
LAX
LAX
#2
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: FLL -> Where The Boyars Are
Programs: AA EXP 1.7 M, Hilton Gold, Hertz 5*, AARP Sophomore, 14-time Croix de Candlestick
Posts: 18,669
Originally Posted by LAX
If the published rates are not interbank rates, then where can I find those numbers?
http://oanda.com/convert/classic
#3
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: south of WAS DC
Posts: 10,131
Credit cards are usually subject to 1-2% surcharge on foreign currency. Most ATM cards are not.
The "interbank"rate is not a fixed rate, but just like the stock market, subject to bid & asked, and fluctuates continously through the day.
The newspaper reported rate is the rate at some particular time.
I recently withdrew a ton of euro in venice, and my wife, standing behind me informed me she was planning to go shopping, so I withdrew another ton of euro. The two transactions, same amount, same machine, within however fast one can enter pin #, was at a significiently different(for euro-dollar exchange) rate.
The "interbank"rate is not a fixed rate, but just like the stock market, subject to bid & asked, and fluctuates continously through the day.
The newspaper reported rate is the rate at some particular time.
I recently withdrew a ton of euro in venice, and my wife, standing behind me informed me she was planning to go shopping, so I withdrew another ton of euro. The two transactions, same amount, same machine, within however fast one can enter pin #, was at a significiently different(for euro-dollar exchange) rate.
Last edited by slawecki; Mar 24, 2005 at 10:21 am
#4
Original Poster




Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Los Angeles, CA; Philadelphia, PA
Programs: FA
Posts: 6,482
With this little exercise, I think I have confirmed that my ATM card is not subjected to the 1% conversion fee. I guess I will continue to use my ATM card (thus cash) for most of my purchases rather than my credit card. I have had second thoughts about this ever since I read a thread on here that said ATM cards are not immune to the fee.
By the way, I have heard from some where (not here on FT) that MC will do away with the conversion fee. Anyone else heard this?
LAX
By the way, I have heard from some where (not here on FT) that MC will do away with the conversion fee. Anyone else heard this?
LAX
#6
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Atlanta, GA, USA
Programs: DL estranged 1MMer and lifetime gold, F9/CO/NW/UA/AA once gold/plat now dust, Spirit RIP
Posts: 42,185
LOTS of gripes related to credit cards and foreign currencies, and recent changes have been WAY underreported by the consumer media.
Visa, for example, recently decided to change its exchange rates to ones it decides on, rather than wholesale or government rates. Then the banks like Wells Fargo or Citibank will pile on 2%, 3% or flat fees, sometimes both.
It's yet another case of big banks inventing fees and then trying to see how much customers will tolerate. None of it is even remotely driven by costs (the industry has been a declining cost industry for years, with all technology investments well offset by labor cost savings).
Fortunately my credit union doesn't play along. I can do unlimited Visa cash advances outside the U.S. with no cash advance fee and no "conversion fees."
I think CapitalOne is also still a major holdout on not charging the "conversion fees," as are many smaller issuers. On the ATM side, check out online banks like State Farm Bank, which can do unlimited ATMs with no fees from their side and even rebates (up to a limit) if the ATM surcharges.
Definitely vote with your feet. In my case if I had the same activity with a company like Citibank the extra cost would be like having to pay about a $200 annual fee on the card!
Visa, for example, recently decided to change its exchange rates to ones it decides on, rather than wholesale or government rates. Then the banks like Wells Fargo or Citibank will pile on 2%, 3% or flat fees, sometimes both.
It's yet another case of big banks inventing fees and then trying to see how much customers will tolerate. None of it is even remotely driven by costs (the industry has been a declining cost industry for years, with all technology investments well offset by labor cost savings).
Fortunately my credit union doesn't play along. I can do unlimited Visa cash advances outside the U.S. with no cash advance fee and no "conversion fees."
I think CapitalOne is also still a major holdout on not charging the "conversion fees," as are many smaller issuers. On the ATM side, check out online banks like State Farm Bank, which can do unlimited ATMs with no fees from their side and even rebates (up to a limit) if the ATM surcharges.
Definitely vote with your feet. In my case if I had the same activity with a company like Citibank the extra cost would be like having to pay about a $200 annual fee on the card!
Last edited by RustyC; Mar 24, 2005 at 5:44 pm
#7
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: south of WAS DC
Posts: 10,131
Originally Posted by Gajules
My husband has had a $5 charge using his ATM card in Rotterdam and in Montreal. It seems there are a lot of banks starting to charge a flat fee.
I think anyone who wants can pretty much charge a fee, and it is not easy to tell who did it.
I got a $20(approximate) charge for using a particular ATM in Florence. I don't know who regulates non-US ATM's.
#8




Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: LAX
Programs: OW, *A, Bonvoy, WOH
Posts: 810
Originally Posted by LAX
With this little exercise, I think I have confirmed that my ATM card is not subjected to the 1% conversion fee.
In addition to Capital One, MBNA doesn't charge conversion fees either (above and beyond the 1% Visa charges by default). I use it exclusively for international travel.
#9




Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: Circle City
Posts: 3,568
Originally Posted by LAX
I was wondering if the published exchange rates on newspaper are the interbank rates (rates that banks charge each other). For example, I recently saw a USD$1 to HKD$7.80 rate published in a newspaper and when I withdrew money from a HK ATM using a US ATM card, the rate I calculated is 1:7.7999.

