Guides vs Internet
#16
Join Date: Sep 2010
Posts: 3
Hi FT,
First post here.
I am currently living in Buenos Aires, Argentina and came down here with 3 guide books; frommers, fodors, and LP.
In general I was pretty disappointed with them and a lot of the information was outdated. Once I arrived i found a great expat community who suggested an online guide, babible.com - it is free for students and they have an iphone mobile version which is handy. The guide is interesting and worth it since it is free.
The internet has a ton of information, but online guides that can be updated regularly by someone from the specific country is invaluable. Sometimes too much information on the 'nets makes it hard to decide what to do/see/eat.
Quality control in Argentina is a huge issue, thus some "hot" spots quickly become places to skip. Having the flexibility of constantly receiving updates is nice.
Time Out in BA is also a good go to source.
TWG_1
First post here.
I am currently living in Buenos Aires, Argentina and came down here with 3 guide books; frommers, fodors, and LP.
In general I was pretty disappointed with them and a lot of the information was outdated. Once I arrived i found a great expat community who suggested an online guide, babible.com - it is free for students and they have an iphone mobile version which is handy. The guide is interesting and worth it since it is free.
The internet has a ton of information, but online guides that can be updated regularly by someone from the specific country is invaluable. Sometimes too much information on the 'nets makes it hard to decide what to do/see/eat.
Quality control in Argentina is a huge issue, thus some "hot" spots quickly become places to skip. Having the flexibility of constantly receiving updates is nice.
Time Out in BA is also a good go to source.
TWG_1
#17



Join Date: May 2005
Location: London, England, United Kingdom
Programs: Marriott (Lifetime Titantium), whatever other programs as benefits make sense.
Posts: 2,014
Actually, to amend (and slightly retract) what I said before, my Bradt guide for Tanzania was excellent. There was a section on wildlife and what to see on safari that was very informative. So there is a place for guidebooks in my world.
For cities, though, I'm still of the opinion that better resources can be found online or in free magazines and maps available in most hotels.
For cities, though, I'm still of the opinion that better resources can be found online or in free magazines and maps available in most hotels.
#18
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: London, Cayman Islands
Programs: AA EXP, BA GGL/CCR, AMEX Cent, HHonours Diamond, Marriott Tit, Hertz PC
Posts: 492
I've been around the world, since I turned 18 I've been going by myself too. As a solo traveler in a totally foreign land I rely on a few resources to see me through...
Wikipedia. Learn the history, culture, customs and interesting facts about the country. Must know where people come from to understand where they are now
Wikitravel. Great resource for activities, directions to popular landmarks and general information about any destination
TripAdvisor. The forums are invaluable, get the answer to the most specific questions pretty quickly and accurately. Great information on hotels, restaurants and things to do also. English speakers who live in the area can fill you in on things you would never find otherwise
Language. I rarely go anywhere without being able to hold a basic conversation. I highly recommend it, asking somebody in a bar what they like to do is a great way of experiencing the local scene
I don't recommend guide books to anybody, if you are organised there is much better and up to date information available on the web. You just have to pick out the bits that sound interesting to you. Some people prefer the convenience of having the book with them but I put everything in my iPhone or iPad. Recently in Shanghai I met some of my friends from London. I'd been there before but they had not, and the recommendations in their LP guide were absolutely diabolical. It made an obscure mural in an old bank sound like the greatest attraction on the Bund. I confiscated this tome and took them around instead, we had a great time
Wikipedia. Learn the history, culture, customs and interesting facts about the country. Must know where people come from to understand where they are now
Wikitravel. Great resource for activities, directions to popular landmarks and general information about any destination
TripAdvisor. The forums are invaluable, get the answer to the most specific questions pretty quickly and accurately. Great information on hotels, restaurants and things to do also. English speakers who live in the area can fill you in on things you would never find otherwise
Language. I rarely go anywhere without being able to hold a basic conversation. I highly recommend it, asking somebody in a bar what they like to do is a great way of experiencing the local scene
I don't recommend guide books to anybody, if you are organised there is much better and up to date information available on the web. You just have to pick out the bits that sound interesting to you. Some people prefer the convenience of having the book with them but I put everything in my iPhone or iPad. Recently in Shanghai I met some of my friends from London. I'd been there before but they had not, and the recommendations in their LP guide were absolutely diabolical. It made an obscure mural in an old bank sound like the greatest attraction on the Bund. I confiscated this tome and took them around instead, we had a great time
#19
Join Date: May 2008
Location: YYZ
Programs: AC*SE, SPG Gold, HH D
Posts: 1,130
I mix and match. I use a combination of guide books, wikitravel, wikipedia, frommers.com, flyertalk (we do have tons of good info here too!), and whatever else I can google up.
For dead trees, I like Time Out. No specific reasons as to why, just had good luck with them. But the bulk of my exploration and planning is done online.
For dead trees, I like Time Out. No specific reasons as to why, just had good luck with them. But the bulk of my exploration and planning is done online.
#20
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Falkirk, Scotland,VS Red, BA Gold, HH Diamond,UK Amex Plat
Programs: Master of the Privy Purse des Muccis
Posts: 19,258
Hi,
I do a mixture of both.
Pre travel planning on the internet but I take a guidebook with me . I generally do not look at the hotel sections as I have prebooked but I like the larger scale city maps and descriptions in the Guidebooks ( I like the rough guides and the Eyewitness guides by DK). Whilst the information/prices may be a litlle out of date the maps and sight descriptions will be generally good for a few years.
I do not take a laptop or iphone or ipad with me.
Regards
TBS
I do a mixture of both.
Pre travel planning on the internet but I take a guidebook with me . I generally do not look at the hotel sections as I have prebooked but I like the larger scale city maps and descriptions in the Guidebooks ( I like the rough guides and the Eyewitness guides by DK). Whilst the information/prices may be a litlle out of date the maps and sight descriptions will be generally good for a few years.
I do not take a laptop or iphone or ipad with me.
Regards
TBS
#21
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: SE1, London & White River, South Africa
Posts: 24,659
I find the best guidebook varies by author, brand and age. So for one destination it might be LP, another Rough Guide, another In Your Pocket. Hotels and dining are normally researched in depth in advance by Internet and then backed up on the ground.

