Laptops at customs
#1
Original Poster


Join Date: May 2008
Location: Minneapolis
Programs: AA EXP, Hyatt Diamond, SPG Gold, GlobalEntry, Admirals Club, United Club
Posts: 2,095
Laptops at customs
im not sure if this is the right place to ask this, but i couldn't think of a different place on here so here it goes:
About a year ago there was an article in the washington post about travelers laptops being searched for files when they came into the country. then feingold introduced a bill that didnt get out of committee and then after the new administration took over he said he was going to re-introduce the bill.
i was just wondering if anyone on here knew what was going on, if he did reintroduce the bill, if they are still searching and confiscating laptops, etc...
About a year ago there was an article in the washington post about travelers laptops being searched for files when they came into the country. then feingold introduced a bill that didnt get out of committee and then after the new administration took over he said he was going to re-introduce the bill.
i was just wondering if anyone on here knew what was going on, if he did reintroduce the bill, if they are still searching and confiscating laptops, etc...
#2

Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: SJO
Programs: CO Gold
Posts: 1,230
I am trying to find the proper link but I do know that there was a ruling to make this an official 'policy' as opposed to before when it was all 'shady and not really clear'
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology...uting.security
Personally my laptop is fully encrypted and inside the laptop there is yet another layer of encryption.......
In about 50 border crossings noone has asked a thing about it.....I would imagine they would have to suspect something in order to do so (and this probably would be after you are sent to secondary inspection)
The Canadians however do bother me a hell of a lot more as they want you to boot your computer and they actively stare at your 'my pictures' folder in search of child pornography.........can we be any more
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology...uting.security
Personally my laptop is fully encrypted and inside the laptop there is yet another layer of encryption.......
In about 50 border crossings noone has asked a thing about it.....I would imagine they would have to suspect something in order to do so (and this probably would be after you are sent to secondary inspection)
The Canadians however do bother me a hell of a lot more as they want you to boot your computer and they actively stare at your 'my pictures' folder in search of child pornography.........can we be any more
#3
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 1,849
#4
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: MCI
Programs: AA Gold 1MM, AS MVP, UA Silver, WN A-List, Marriott LT Titanium, HH Diamond
Posts: 53,010
I've crossed many borders with a laptop - no one has ever wanted to look at it. In fact, no one has ever even asked me if I'm carrying a laptop. This includes US, UK, and Canada.
I don't download pr0n...don't most people who do that do something more sophisticated than leave the material in "My Pictures"?
I don't download pr0n...don't most people who do that do something more sophisticated than leave the material in "My Pictures"?
#5

Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: SJO
Programs: CO Gold
Posts: 1,230
as yyzvoyageur accurately said ....
you'd be surprised.......I would love to boot my computer into linux or even something more exotic and look at their faces....."uh uh....eh eh"
that reminds me of the guy from the FARC (Colombian guerilla) who suposedly had a laptop with zero encryption and bunches of important stuff ..........
Last edited by wolfie_cr; Oct 16, 2009 at 7:49 pm
#6
Original Poster


Join Date: May 2008
Location: Minneapolis
Programs: AA EXP, Hyatt Diamond, SPG Gold, GlobalEntry, Admirals Club, United Club
Posts: 2,095
I am trying to find the proper link but I do know that there was a ruling to make this an official 'policy' as opposed to before when it was all 'shady and not really clear'
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology...uting.security
Personally my laptop is fully encrypted and inside the laptop there is yet another layer of encryption.......
In about 50 border crossings noone has asked a thing about it.....I would imagine they would have to suspect something in order to do so (and this probably would be after you are sent to secondary inspection)
The Canadians however do bother me a hell of a lot more as they want you to boot your computer and they actively stare at your 'my pictures' folder in search of child pornography.........can we be any more
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology...uting.security
Personally my laptop is fully encrypted and inside the laptop there is yet another layer of encryption.......
In about 50 border crossings noone has asked a thing about it.....I would imagine they would have to suspect something in order to do so (and this probably would be after you are sent to secondary inspection)
The Canadians however do bother me a hell of a lot more as they want you to boot your computer and they actively stare at your 'my pictures' folder in search of child pornography.........can we be any more

#7
Original Poster


Join Date: May 2008
Location: Minneapolis
Programs: AA EXP, Hyatt Diamond, SPG Gold, GlobalEntry, Admirals Club, United Club
Posts: 2,095
I've crossed many borders with a laptop - no one has ever wanted to look at it. In fact, no one has ever even asked me if I'm carrying a laptop. This includes US, UK, and Canada.
I don't download pr0n...don't most people who do that do something more sophisticated than leave the material in "My Pictures"?
I don't download pr0n...don't most people who do that do something more sophisticated than leave the material in "My Pictures"?

#8
Join Date: Jul 2008
Programs: Via Preference Privilege, AC*A, Fairmont Plat, SPG Gold
Posts: 1,334
Customs has the right to inspect anything you bring with you into the country, including laptops. If the laptop is encrypted and you refused/couldn't decrypt it they would most likely seize it and severely delay you.
Gutmann is a method of wiping hard discs to make there data as unrecoverable as possible. In practice I don't recall any commercial companies advertising data recovery from a single over write never mind the 30 or so the Gutmann method uses. Who knows about the NSA
Canadian customs inspected my netbook during a secondary, I didn't even have MP3's on there never mind anything else.
Gutmann is a method of wiping hard discs to make there data as unrecoverable as possible. In practice I don't recall any commercial companies advertising data recovery from a single over write never mind the 30 or so the Gutmann method uses. Who knows about the NSA
Canadian customs inspected my netbook during a secondary, I didn't even have MP3's on there never mind anything else.
#9

Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: SJO
Programs: CO Gold
Posts: 1,230
i havent yet travelled out of the country, but im about to. my laptop is encrypted with like gutmann or something like that, but ive heard they can "force" you to give them the password/keyfile and some people have even had their laptops taken and not returned apparently (this was before the post article). theres no child porn on there, but its a company laptop so i just want to know my rights before-nothing will probably happen, but if something does, i want to know what to do. since i didnt do any of the actual encrypting, i don't know exactly how it works and whether or not the gov't can crack it. when i asked our IT guy he had never heard of this, but he said it would be difficult for the gov't to crack it and would probably take months if they really wanted to.
a) I would voluntarily decrypt the first level (which would allow the computer to boot)
b) the chances of them bothering with the 2nd layer are low and if they find it they have no way of proving that the file actually contains anything (it can just be a huge /corrupted file......)
I don't think you have any rights .....which is why many executives are issued CLEAN laptops everytime they travel to the US (I have heard of some companies doing this )
In my case I do have an old laptop that can be used for travel....and if you are truly paranoid ..the problem is that this becomes quite inconvenient
one way to solve this is leave your laptop at home and log into it remotely .....but not everyone has the know how/resources to do this in a secure way (you could use logmein ....that would be the easiest I can think of but I just dont use that service)
as far as some open source encrypting tools (like truecrypt.....or pgp) they are EXTREMELY SOLID.........can there be ways to decrypt it ? yes.....but its very very unlikely............normally it would require a huge amount of resources and if they want you THAT BAD they probably have a reason
#10
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 38,543
Neither the US nor China has ever so much as glanced at my laptop at customs.
However, I've never been coming from a sex tourism destination and as an adult I've never crossed the border without my wife being right next to me.
However, I've never been coming from a sex tourism destination and as an adult I've never crossed the border without my wife being right next to me.
#11




Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Australia
Programs: NZ Elite
Posts: 6,518
My main destination is the US.. and I always have my laptop with me...
Never even been ASKED a question about it... In fact I am consistently asked ONE question... whether I have any food items.
Coming from a country with very stringent quarantine controls that seems fair enough to me... and they don't care about the Tim Tams I routinely bring for my now-addicted American friends..
Mmmmmm... Tim Tams....)
Never even been ASKED a question about it... In fact I am consistently asked ONE question... whether I have any food items.
Coming from a country with very stringent quarantine controls that seems fair enough to me... and they don't care about the Tim Tams I routinely bring for my now-addicted American friends..
Mmmmmm... Tim Tams....)
#12
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 38,543
My main destination is the US.. and I always have my laptop with me...
Never even been ASKED a question about it... In fact I am consistently asked ONE question... whether I have any food items.
Coming from a country with very stringent quarantine controls that seems fair enough to me... and they don't care about the Tim Tams I routinely bring for my now-addicted American friends..
Mmmmmm... Tim Tams....)
Never even been ASKED a question about it... In fact I am consistently asked ONE question... whether I have any food items.
Coming from a country with very stringent quarantine controls that seems fair enough to me... and they don't care about the Tim Tams I routinely bring for my now-addicted American friends..
Mmmmmm... Tim Tams....)
#13
Join Date: Apr 2009
Posts: 85
They can search your laptop in Canada....
A Bishop was just arrested in Ottawa after customs found child p0rn on his laptop. Seems his previous travel alerted the customs officer and then evasive answers and behaviour led to a secondary search, including his laptop, then a search warrant etc....
http://www.ottawacitizen.com/news/Bi...846/story.html
http://www.ottawacitizen.com/news/Bi...846/story.html
#15
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 3
Hello
I used to work for Customs in New Zealand. SO I can tell you what we do here, but obviously our laws are different to other countries.
If a traveler has a laptop and I was searching them I didn't automatically look at the laptop, it would depend what I was searching them for.
My pictures is great, people store pictures of themselves smoking weed, doing lines of coke etc. Always a good way to start a conversation. Lots of people dont even think about what is on their laptop when going through customs.
But as for what we can do. I can examine the laptop whatever way I wish. So I can turn it on, if it needs a password I ask for one, if you decline my request I send your laptop to be examined by our computer lab and it is then returned to you within a reasonable time frame. Reasonable is of course debatable. If you are suspected of having child pornography we don't even attempt to turn it on, we detain all electronic media and send it to the computer lab. So laptops, mp3 players, cell phones. Which could be a nightmare if you are traveling on business.
Anyway, just for your interest that's what we do in NZ.
I used to work for Customs in New Zealand. SO I can tell you what we do here, but obviously our laws are different to other countries.
If a traveler has a laptop and I was searching them I didn't automatically look at the laptop, it would depend what I was searching them for.
My pictures is great, people store pictures of themselves smoking weed, doing lines of coke etc. Always a good way to start a conversation. Lots of people dont even think about what is on their laptop when going through customs.
But as for what we can do. I can examine the laptop whatever way I wish. So I can turn it on, if it needs a password I ask for one, if you decline my request I send your laptop to be examined by our computer lab and it is then returned to you within a reasonable time frame. Reasonable is of course debatable. If you are suspected of having child pornography we don't even attempt to turn it on, we detain all electronic media and send it to the computer lab. So laptops, mp3 players, cell phones. Which could be a nightmare if you are traveling on business.
Anyway, just for your interest that's what we do in NZ.

