Alternatives to AirTags for Android users?
#32

Join Date: Jan 2015
Posts: 3,741
I don't know. I think a beacon would be simpler. You don't include the cell tech.... You can reduce the system requirements... Run something headless... They already have a prototype to base this on.... Apple or someone has in the past used Bluetooth beacons to promote specific products in a retail environment... It'd be cheaper and easier to propagate...
#33


Join Date: Jan 2008
Programs: MR Gold, Hilton Diamond, Mlia Platinum, Hertz PC, Avis PC
Posts: 1,197
I've traveled a lot and our luggage always arrived, although sometimes 2 or 3 days later.
The latest news items, along with our upcoming flight with a transfer in LHR, are making me a little nervous though.
I'm an Android user so AirTags are of no use to me. In this post the only alternative discussed is Tile. Is nobody using other devices, there seem to be plenty of them when I search on Google. Some of them also specifically aimed at luggage.
I just wonder if a device lacking a GPS can properly indicate your bag's location if it's lost in a hall filled to the brim with suitcases. I'm not sure if a Tile user will get close enough to my lost bag if it never makes it to a luggage belt but instead gets lost in the basement at LHR.
The latest news items, along with our upcoming flight with a transfer in LHR, are making me a little nervous though.
I'm an Android user so AirTags are of no use to me. In this post the only alternative discussed is Tile. Is nobody using other devices, there seem to be plenty of them when I search on Google. Some of them also specifically aimed at luggage.
I just wonder if a device lacking a GPS can properly indicate your bag's location if it's lost in a hall filled to the brim with suitcases. I'm not sure if a Tile user will get close enough to my lost bag if it never makes it to a luggage belt but instead gets lost in the basement at LHR.
#34




Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 3,893
I've traveled a lot and our luggage always arrived, although sometimes 2 or 3 days later.
The latest news items, along with our upcoming flight with a transfer in LHR, are making me a little nervous though.
I'm an Android user so AirTags are of no use to me. In this post the only alternative discussed is Tile. Is nobody using other devices, there seem to be plenty of them when I search on Google. Some of them also specifically aimed at luggage.
I just wonder if a device lacking a GPS can properly indicate your bag's location if it's lost in a hall filled to the brim with suitcases. I'm not sure if a Tile user will get close enough to my lost bag if it never makes it to a luggage belt but instead gets lost in the basement at LHR.
The latest news items, along with our upcoming flight with a transfer in LHR, are making me a little nervous though.
I'm an Android user so AirTags are of no use to me. In this post the only alternative discussed is Tile. Is nobody using other devices, there seem to be plenty of them when I search on Google. Some of them also specifically aimed at luggage.
I just wonder if a device lacking a GPS can properly indicate your bag's location if it's lost in a hall filled to the brim with suitcases. I'm not sure if a Tile user will get close enough to my lost bag if it never makes it to a luggage belt but instead gets lost in the basement at LHR.
But yeah, Tile is probably not going to work well in a basement either as you need that one person with Tile app installed to go near it. But that's the ultimate trump card with Airtag. That it has millions and millions of beacons all over the world. The previous few posts were talking about manufacturers setting up beacons at airports, but Apple has done it with the entire world for free using their customers' mobile data, battery and devices.
#35


Join Date: Jan 2008
Programs: MR Gold, Hilton Diamond, Mlia Platinum, Hertz PC, Avis PC
Posts: 1,197
You just need 1 worker with an iPhone to go into the basement. Even if his iPhone doesn't get any mobile signal, wifi, or GPS inside the basement, his phone would pick up the airtag bluetooth. When he got out to somewhere with signal, it will transmit out and you will get the general location.
#36


Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: ORF
Programs: Amex Plat, AA, BA Silver, Marriott Plat, Choice Gold, HHonors Gold, IHG Diamond
Posts: 3,860
As my girlfriend works her way back home, I'm still finding adequate location information with Tile and its app. Not only has the Tile with her computer bag been located at each airport she's flown through, including her current location at DFW, but it's been located several times at other locations, including her hotel Wednesday and on the road from Barstow to Ontario yesterday.
I'll give it one final test this afternoon when I pick her up at the airport. The app is supposed to give off increased signals as the bag gets closer, a nice feature if you're waiting for checked luggage. So far, everything has worked as well as I expected, and I'll definitely use it next month when I go to Scotland. I hope I don't have lost luggage, but it's nice to see that Tile provides me with a tool to help me find it.
I'll give it one final test this afternoon when I pick her up at the airport. The app is supposed to give off increased signals as the bag gets closer, a nice feature if you're waiting for checked luggage. So far, everything has worked as well as I expected, and I'll definitely use it next month when I go to Scotland. I hope I don't have lost luggage, but it's nice to see that Tile provides me with a tool to help me find it.
#37
Suspended
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Watchlisted by the prejudiced, en route to purgatory
Programs: Just Say No to Fleecing and Blacklisting
Posts: 102,077
Tile’s proximity circles are useful to find out how close a bag is, but they lack in directional info unless: a) the tracking device (or perhaps the tracked device) moves in such a way as to try to figure out the direction; and/or b) the sound trigger works to locate the direction of the Tile.
When the proximity indicator circles indicate the Tile is in range of the Bluetooth receiver, then it should also be able to be triggered for an audio ring even if the distance is nearly at its limits.
Briefly borrowing an iPhone/iPad/Mac to set up an AppleID and AirTag would allow for some tracking of an AirTag with a non-Apple device.
When the proximity indicator circles indicate the Tile is in range of the Bluetooth receiver, then it should also be able to be triggered for an audio ring even if the distance is nearly at its limits.
Briefly borrowing an iPhone/iPad/Mac to set up an AppleID and AirTag would allow for some tracking of an AirTag with a non-Apple device.
#38




Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 3,893
Is that true? I know I could use my android phone's browser, put it in desktop mode, login to icloud.com and find my wife and kid's iPhones and iPads. But I read that you can't do the same with Airtag. I think Airtag does not show up on icloud.com.
#39
Suspended
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Watchlisted by the prejudiced, en route to purgatory
Programs: Just Say No to Fleecing and Blacklisting
Posts: 102,077
Apple has kept AirTag locating disabled for iCloud.com. My bad.
#40

Join Date: Jan 2015
Posts: 3,741
It depends on how you look at it. I generally travel with 2-3 phones (my personal, my work and my "away" phone if I have one). If I have am in Asia (for example), I'd have all three, the third could be anything (iphone SE?)... not cheap, but if I can give it multi-functional useage, even better.
#41


Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: ORF
Programs: Amex Plat, AA, BA Silver, Marriott Plat, Choice Gold, HHonors Gold, IHG Diamond
Posts: 3,860
Final report. My girlfriend landed, but the Tile app did not pick up her location until just before I saw her appear around a corner. All the app did at that point was flash "Connecting" on the screen but as she got closer, the app reported the bag's location as the street address for the airport. This experience meshes with Tile's official spec that it works at a radius of 400 feet so I remain satisfied with the results of my test.
Now, I'm hoping I won't need Tile's help next month to find my bag, but I believe I have enough confidence in the way it works that I can hope for some assistance should my airline lose my golf bag.
Now, I'm hoping I won't need Tile's help next month to find my bag, but I believe I have enough confidence in the way it works that I can hope for some assistance should my airline lose my golf bag.
#42


Join Date: Jan 2008
Programs: MR Gold, Hilton Diamond, Mlia Platinum, Hertz PC, Avis PC
Posts: 1,197
I will maybe try to find a cheap second-hand iPhone. Is AirTag something that works with all iPhones or do you need a recent model?
#43



Join Date: Sep 2013
Location: DAL
Posts: 2,231
The iPhone can be an older model such as a 1st gen iPhone SE (March 2016 release) or iPhone 6S (Sept 2015) running iOS 14.5. To use the precise location, the iPhone requires U1 chip which is in the iPhone 11 and newer except for the 2nd gen iPhone SE (no U1 chip).
#44


Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Northern VA
Posts: 152
Maybe I missed it in all the Tile discussion or discussion of buying an iphone just to use for this purpose - but no one has brought up the Galaxy SmartTag+? I dumped my Tiles after several issues and went with this last year.
Used these for the last several trips and they could not be easier to use. Integrates easily into their app. Very simple to us. Already has saved me once after arrival when a bag of our scuba gear did not come out. Tracker showed it was all the way at the other end of the arrival area, walked down there, rang the tag - boom. Not sure how long it would have been for us to get a bag like that out of a huge pile of unclaimed bags.
Anyway - I thought the OP was looking for something Android specific so I have nothing more to add other than they work.
Used these for the last several trips and they could not be easier to use. Integrates easily into their app. Very simple to us. Already has saved me once after arrival when a bag of our scuba gear did not come out. Tracker showed it was all the way at the other end of the arrival area, walked down there, rang the tag - boom. Not sure how long it would have been for us to get a bag like that out of a huge pile of unclaimed bags.
Anyway - I thought the OP was looking for something Android specific so I have nothing more to add other than they work.
Last edited by dcmidnight; Jul 26, 2022 at 9:19 am
#45




Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Oregon
Programs: AA EXP, UA 1MM, HH Diamond, National EE, Hertz PC
Posts: 4,055
On second thought, would the GPS trackers not pick up satellite signals when the bags are unloaded. They will indeed be useless in the basement but wouldn't you be able to see in some kind of log that their last location was at LHR?
I will maybe try to find a cheap second-hand iPhone. Is AirTag something that works with all iPhones or do you need a recent model?
I will maybe try to find a cheap second-hand iPhone. Is AirTag something that works with all iPhones or do you need a recent model?


