FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Travel Technology (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/travel-technology-169/)
-   -   eSIM thread (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/travel-technology/1954827-esim-thread.html)

GUWonder May 18, 2023 12:27 pm


Originally Posted by CheckInPeach (Post 35259784)
The situation gets more complicated/intransparent with eSIMS issued by Airalo and such. They use all kinds of providers and third party roaming partners, depending on country. When I used Airalo in Tanzania last month, all data was routed through the US. Last year it was routed through Israel. Whoever gives them the best deal I guess.

Last year too, it was only some of their eSIMs that routed via Israel. For each national, regional and the global data eSIM type, it seems like the country whose operator is used for the eSIM at time of purchase varies based on what Airalo thinks works for it. Then that eSIM operator uses its own roaming partners to keep us connected. They are playing some kind of arbitrage game this way, and I do like it if they can keep it going and these throttling and offlining issues start to drop off in frequency for my purposes.

Last year, I saw at least three countries ‘ operators being the backbone of some of the Airalo eSIMs.

username May 20, 2023 3:33 am

More stupid questions on eSIMs that route through their home country...

1 - if I use a VPN on my device, how would my IP be presented? I guess the path is Device -> Local Cellular Network -> Provider Gateway -> VPN On Ramp -> Destination?
2 - I know some providers detect irregularity by looking at where you are. So, if my phone comes in on one side of the world but my computer connecting to a local Wifi is from another city, that could cause problems, right?

Thanks.

Aachsoo May 20, 2023 6:02 am

eSIM for Alaska
 
What is the most cost effective way to get data plan for my week-long visit to Alaska?

I wanted to just get eSIM like Airalo or even Tello, but quick Google suggests that on Alaska I should go with AT&T.
I saw couple eSIM providers that explicitly uses AT&T (RedTeaMobile, BNESIM, Nomad), are they good to go?

What would you use?

der_saeufer May 20, 2023 7:50 am


Originally Posted by username (Post 35264540)
More stupid questions on eSIMs that route through their home country...

1 - if I use a VPN on my device, how would my IP be presented? I guess the path is Device -> Local Cellular Network -> Provider Gateway -> VPN On Ramp -> Destination?
2 - I know some providers detect irregularity by looking at where you are. So, if my phone comes in on one side of the world but my computer connecting to a local Wifi is from another city, that could cause problems, right?

1. Same as any other time you're using the VPN: your public IP is the VPN exit point regardless of how you got there.
2. Not really, I do it all the time. Other than services that are looking at all your devices at once (think Google Maps) whatever service you're using only sees the connection you're using to access it. You do get some weirdness from ad trackers though, e.g. ads for stuff in Hong Kong on your computer in Whereverstan because your phone has a HK IP address.


Originally Posted by Aachsoo (Post 35264693)
What is the most cost effective way to get data plan for my week-long visit to Alaska?

I wanted to just get eSIM like Airalo or even Tello, but quick Google suggests that on Alaska I should go with AT&T.
I saw couple eSIM providers that explicitly uses AT&T (RedTeaMobile, BNESIM, Nomad), are they good to go?

What would you use?

Last time I used Airalo in the U.S. their carrier roamed on AT&T. 3HK will also work--they have roaming agreements with both AT&T and T-Mobile.

TGarza May 20, 2023 8:23 am


Originally Posted by Aachsoo (Post 35264693)
What is the most cost effective way to get data plan for my week-long visit to Alaska?

I wanted to just get eSIM like Airalo or even Tello, but quick Google suggests that on Alaska I should go with AT&T.
I saw couple eSIM providers that explicitly uses AT&T (RedTeaMobile, BNESIM, Nomad), are they good to go?

What would you use?

Red Pocket is an AT&T MVNO with esim support. I have used several times for short term service. RP also supports T Mobile and Verizon. Pure Talk is another AT&T MVNO with esim support.

richarddd May 20, 2023 8:49 am


Originally Posted by Aachsoo (Post 35264693)
What is the most cost effective way to get data plan for my week-long visit to Alaska?

I wanted to just get eSIM like Airalo or even Tello, but quick Google suggests that on Alaska I should go with AT&T.
I saw couple eSIM providers that explicitly uses AT&T (RedTeaMobile, BNESIM, Nomad), are they good to go?

What would you use?

I have a BNESIM eSIM for backup data and it's worked fine.

Aachsoo May 20, 2023 11:39 am


Originally Posted by der_saeufer (Post 35264865)
1. Same as any other time you're using the VPN: your public IP is the VPN exit point regardless of how you got there.

Last time I used Airalo in the U.S. their carrier roamed on AT&T. 3HK will also work--they have roaming agreements with both AT&T and T-Mobile.

Airalo seems to have changed that to T-Mobile/Verizon only now:

For 3HK.. stupid question: are those prices in HKD or USD? They seem to really high. (3GB - $138)


Originally Posted by TGarza (Post 35264923)
Red Pocket is an AT&T MVNO with esim support. I have used several times for short term service. RP also supports T Mobile and Verizon. Pure Talk is another AT&T MVNO with esim support.

RP's $20 looks good! Do I have to activate it after land in US, or before is possible (it needs internet right)?
PureTalk seems to only support iPhone for eSIM, and I have only Android.
Thanks for all suggestions.


Originally Posted by richarddd (Post 35264962)
richarddd

I have a BNESIM eSIM for backup data and it's worked fine.

I have BNESIM physical sim actually, I can also get the eSIM, but do you know/can you please check if you get US-based IP?
Also what speed/latency should I expect? I'm fine as long it is usable for Google Maps, Uber, etc.

username May 20, 2023 8:28 pm


Originally Posted by Aachsoo (Post 35265310)
For 3HK.. stupid question: are those prices in HKD or USD? They seem to really high. (3GB - $138)

Yes.

der_saeufer May 20, 2023 9:53 pm


Originally Posted by Aachsoo (Post 35265310)
Airalo seems to have changed that to T-Mobile/Verizon only now:

For 3HK.. stupid question: are those prices in HKD or USD? They seem to really high. (3GB - $138)



RP's $20 looks good! Do I have to activate it after land in US, or before is possible (it needs internet right)?
PureTalk seems to only support iPhone for eSIM, and I have only Android.
Thanks for all suggestions.

Prices are in HKD, so the 30 day plan with 10GB for US/CA/UK etc. or 3GB "worldwide" is ~18 USD.

You should be able to install the Red Pocket eSIM and pay for service before you leave but it likely won't fully activate until you can hit a network where it has service. Worst case you'll need to access wifi while in the U.S. but that shouldn't be hard to do on arrival at the airport.

lsquare May 20, 2023 10:18 pm


Originally Posted by der_saeufer (Post 35266210)
Prices are in HKD, so the 30 day plan with 10GB for US/CA/UK etc. or 3GB "worldwide" is ~18 USD.

You should be able to install the Red Pocket eSIM and pay for service before you leave but it likely won't fully activate until you can hit a network where it has service. Worst case you'll need to access wifi while in the U.S. but that shouldn't be hard to do on arrival at the airport.

Did you buy a 3HK SIM? I'm thinking of buying a physical one when I get back to HK later this year.

der_saeufer May 21, 2023 2:55 am


Originally Posted by lsquare (Post 35266241)
Did you buy a 3HK SIM? I'm thinking of buying a physical one when I get back to HK later this year.

I've used their eSIMs for a couple years now but never had any reason to buy a physical one.

mistytalon May 22, 2023 7:41 pm


Originally Posted by Aachsoo (Post 35264693)
What is the most cost effective way to get data plan for my week-long visit to Alaska?

I wanted to just get eSIM like Airalo or even Tello, but quick Google suggests that on Alaska I should go with AT&T.
I saw couple eSIM providers that explicitly uses AT&T (RedTeaMobile, BNESIM, Nomad), are they good to go?

What would you use?

Assuming you haven't done them before, I would look into the trial eSIMs offered by various US MVNOs.

Aachsoo May 22, 2023 11:31 pm


Originally Posted by mistytalon (Post 35271227)
Assuming you haven't done them before, I would look into the trial eSIMs offered by various US MVNOs.

I have, even the ones offered normal operators not only MVNO.

1. Verizon: won't let me download the app, US Play Store only. Require US number.
2. T-Mobile: will try it once I land, but no guarantee roaming in Alaska's GCI will work for trial/not capped to 200mb
3. Cricket: iPhone only
4. US SIM: wants US number to port over.

danib62 May 23, 2023 7:13 am


Originally Posted by Aachsoo (Post 35264693)
What is the most cost effective way to get data plan for my week-long visit to Alaska?

I wanted to just get eSIM like Airalo or even Tello, but quick Google suggests that on Alaska I should go with AT&T.
I saw couple eSIM providers that explicitly uses AT&T (RedTeaMobile, BNESIM, Nomad), are they good to go?

What would you use?

I would go with Visible. You can get a 15 day free trial with unlimited data, talk, and text. That should cover your entire trip. https://www.visible.com/free-trial/

TGarza May 23, 2023 8:56 am


Originally Posted by danib62 (Post 35272122)
I would go with Visible. You can get a 15 day free trial with unlimited data, talk, and text. That should cover your entire trip. https://www.visible.com/free-trial/

Visible doesn’t have good coverage in Alaska. AT&T has the best coverage for a cruise in Alaska.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 8:26 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.