Best tablet?
Jan 24, 2012, 9:48 pm
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Eastern Canada
Programs: OnePass, Aeroplan
Posts: 197
Best tablet?
With the release of the first tablet to run NVidia's Tegra 3 CPU (Transformer Prime) I am serious considering the moving from my personnal 11" netbook (I also carry a big desktop replacement laptop for work) to a tablet however there are so many of them that it is tough to chose so I would welcome some comments from current users.
I'm not a big fan of Apple's closed architecture (work already supplies me with an Iphone) so while I'm not discounting the Ipad2 just yet, it is definitely not at the front of the pack. This being said, it has a massive amount of application available and 10h battery life.... It is also pricy compared to the Android based alternatives...
A lot of the old Tegra 2 based Android tablets have now become very affordable but I am a bit worried at buying into last's year technology and their battery autonomy doesnt seem that great. I'm also wondering whether you can find as much application choice (games, productivity, travel, etc...) in the Android market than you can in Apple's.
The Transformer Prime would be the obvious choice however it is kind of pricey and it is impossible to find one in the city to try it before buying it. It has also been getting mixed review online, from great to terrible due to GPS and wifi issues which seem to plague certain but not all units. One of the clerks at a large computer store also mentionned a rumor according to which the Prime was being discountinued and being replaced by the recently announced TF700 which will be released.... in April... Not sure how much truth there is to that.
I intent to use the device for games, reading books, web and email as well as watching movies. Basically I am looking for an all around computing device with extended battery life; kinda life my current personnal laptop but more lightweight and in tablet form factor.
Which one should I be getting? Or should I keep my mini laptop a bit longer and wait yet again for another generation of tablet? Its technically doing all that I need but its short on battery life a bit (4-6 hours) a bit bulky compared to a tablet.
Max
I'm not a big fan of Apple's closed architecture (work already supplies me with an Iphone) so while I'm not discounting the Ipad2 just yet, it is definitely not at the front of the pack. This being said, it has a massive amount of application available and 10h battery life.... It is also pricy compared to the Android based alternatives...
A lot of the old Tegra 2 based Android tablets have now become very affordable but I am a bit worried at buying into last's year technology and their battery autonomy doesnt seem that great. I'm also wondering whether you can find as much application choice (games, productivity, travel, etc...) in the Android market than you can in Apple's.
The Transformer Prime would be the obvious choice however it is kind of pricey and it is impossible to find one in the city to try it before buying it. It has also been getting mixed review online, from great to terrible due to GPS and wifi issues which seem to plague certain but not all units. One of the clerks at a large computer store also mentionned a rumor according to which the Prime was being discountinued and being replaced by the recently announced TF700 which will be released.... in April... Not sure how much truth there is to that.
I intent to use the device for games, reading books, web and email as well as watching movies. Basically I am looking for an all around computing device with extended battery life; kinda life my current personnal laptop but more lightweight and in tablet form factor.
Which one should I be getting? Or should I keep my mini laptop a bit longer and wait yet again for another generation of tablet? Its technically doing all that I need but its short on battery life a bit (4-6 hours) a bit bulky compared to a tablet.
Max
Jan 24, 2012, 10:01 pm
#2
Join Date: May 2011
Location: BOS
Programs: AA EXP, Morning Calm, Marriott Plat., Hyatt Globalist
Posts: 297
There are two milestones in the near future.
The Macworld iWorld, which apple does not participates but speculation of some unofficial official announcement (well Apple is like that
/ Jan 26th) and the World Mobile Congress (Late Feb 28ish~3/1 IIRC).
Therefore I would personally not chose to purchase anything at this time.
With that said, now-a-days tablets are pretty cheap (compared to what laptops costed only several years ago), so if you need one, go for one.
The Macworld iWorld, which apple does not participates but speculation of some unofficial official announcement (well Apple is like that
/ Jan 26th) and the World Mobile Congress (Late Feb 28ish~3/1 IIRC). Therefore I would personally not chose to purchase anything at this time.
With that said, now-a-days tablets are pretty cheap (compared to what laptops costed only several years ago), so if you need one, go for one.
Jan 24, 2012, 10:06 pm
#3
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Newport Beach, California, USA
Posts: 36,062
OP, games are the wild-card -- some tablets support some better than others. I'm not a gamer, so I can offer no guidance. For everything else you've mentioned, virtually any Android tablet would work just fine. Get something with 32gb of memory (so you can store a library of movies), and a dual-core CPU will help with both movies and games. I have a couple of HP Touchpads that are ported to cyanogenmod Android, and they're perfect for this.
Jan 25, 2012, 10:01 am
#6
Suspended
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Bay Area
Programs: DL SM, UA MP.
Posts: 12,729
Tegra 3 GPU is weak -- strange coming from NVidia.
iPad2 still beats Tegra 3 in some graphics benchmarks.
The rumored Transformer Prime in April is expected to have 1920x1080 resolution.
iPad 3 is expected to have even higher resolution. But Samsung is going to come out with something like a 2500x1600 screen.
If you really want to play games, iPad has better support than any Android tablet.
iPad2 still beats Tegra 3 in some graphics benchmarks.
The rumored Transformer Prime in April is expected to have 1920x1080 resolution.
iPad 3 is expected to have even higher resolution. But Samsung is going to come out with something like a 2500x1600 screen.
If you really want to play games, iPad has better support than any Android tablet.
Jan 25, 2012, 10:25 am
#7
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Eastern Canada
Programs: OnePass, Aeroplan
Posts: 197
Quite frankly I'm not too sure about the game part anymore.
In truth what I am more preoccupied is to make sure that the tablet I choose will have enough horsepower. For example, I would hate to have to re-encode hi resolution movies (say 720p) to a lower resolution just so that the device can read them. Would any Android tablet be able to do that problem free?
As for screen resolution, I am not overly preoccupied by that as the existing Android tablet's I've seen (Iconia tab for example) seem to have more than ample resolution for reading ebooks or watching movies.
If I were to go with the current crop of Tegra 2 based Android tablets, which would be the best one?
Lastly, what about the Playbook? RIM is selling them for dirt cheap now and I hear that the new OS has fixed many of the problems (Android app compatibility and email client for instance).
Thanks for the feedback!
Max
In truth what I am more preoccupied is to make sure that the tablet I choose will have enough horsepower. For example, I would hate to have to re-encode hi resolution movies (say 720p) to a lower resolution just so that the device can read them. Would any Android tablet be able to do that problem free?
As for screen resolution, I am not overly preoccupied by that as the existing Android tablet's I've seen (Iconia tab for example) seem to have more than ample resolution for reading ebooks or watching movies.
If I were to go with the current crop of Tegra 2 based Android tablets, which would be the best one?
Lastly, what about the Playbook? RIM is selling them for dirt cheap now and I hear that the new OS has fixed many of the problems (Android app compatibility and email client for instance).
Thanks for the feedback!
Max
Jan 25, 2012, 10:29 am
#8
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Indianapolis, IN USA
Posts: 2,066
I've used the iPad 1, iPad 2, Samsung Galaxy Tab 7" (2010?), Samsung Galaxy 9" (November 2011) for long periods of time.
The iPad is probably still my recommended tablet. The screen size, speed, display, etc. I only use tablets for reading newspapers, websites, fb, twitter, and various apps (i.e. no gaming) and I find it better then the Samsung Galaxy Tabs.
The nice thing re: Galaxy Tab is you can fit it in your jacket pocket since they are quite a bit smaller then the iPad.
The iPad is probably still my recommended tablet. The screen size, speed, display, etc. I only use tablets for reading newspapers, websites, fb, twitter, and various apps (i.e. no gaming) and I find it better then the Samsung Galaxy Tabs.
The nice thing re: Galaxy Tab is you can fit it in your jacket pocket since they are quite a bit smaller then the iPad.
Jan 25, 2012, 10:42 am
#9
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: PHX
Posts: 3,796
You might wait until after a (potential) iPad 3 announcement, if only that the price of older tablets may go down. If you're simply holding off until something better comes out, there always is something better out soon.
I just got a Toshiba Thrive from a woot.com deal (32GB for $320). I'm pretty happy with it.
I just got a Toshiba Thrive from a woot.com deal (32GB for $320). I'm pretty happy with it.
Jan 25, 2012, 11:44 am
#10
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Los Angeles area
Programs: Delta PLAT + 1K United for 2011, ????? for 2012
Posts: 258
For me a tablet needs to have WiFi, 3G , SD card slot and good speed ,
I am not a gamer , just email , web surfing , streaming video and playing movies from the memory (or SD card)
an IPad has most of these and you can get an adapter for the SD card (not sure how it works)
I have a 32gb HP Touchpad that I have not used mostly because of no 3G connection ,
But right now I am looking for a used iPad 2 with 3G,
Anything else I should look at in the $300 range ?
RB
I am not a gamer , just email , web surfing , streaming video and playing movies from the memory (or SD card)
an IPad has most of these and you can get an adapter for the SD card (not sure how it works)
I have a 32gb HP Touchpad that I have not used mostly because of no 3G connection ,
But right now I am looking for a used iPad 2 with 3G,
Anything else I should look at in the $300 range ?
RB
Jan 25, 2012, 12:00 pm
#12
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: YVR
Programs: AC E75, SPG Plat, HH peon-by-choice (ex Gold)
Posts: 8,090
Personally, whatever I choose (tablet, phone, whatever), I make sure there's an upgrade path.
And, for the long-term, it seems any tablet that can have its bootloader unlocked and be rooted is a sure bet as the Custom ROMs can be used.
I haven't checked recently, but that leaves out the iPad, BB Playbook, Moto Xoom, and a few others.
And, for the long-term, it seems any tablet that can have its bootloader unlocked and be rooted is a sure bet as the Custom ROMs can be used.
I haven't checked recently, but that leaves out the iPad, BB Playbook, Moto Xoom, and a few others.
Jan 25, 2012, 12:37 pm
#14
Join Date: Dec 2011
Posts: 2
Samsung Galaxy note. Small but fantastic for watching movies, does everything and is a world phone and gets Russian gps birds, and the battery lasts forever. I could and, and, and forever. This is the best do it all device available today.
Jan 25, 2012, 12:47 pm
#15
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Somewhere between Singapore and the US
Programs: Qantas Platinum, SQ Krisflyer PPS, UA 1p, Marriot Lifetime Platinum, American EXP
Posts: 988
I guess it is all about what you are going to do with it
The majority of the Apps available for Ipad or Droid hold no interest to me. What I was looking for was a tablet that could allow me to do many of the things I currently use my notebook for. Things that were important to to me were as follows:
Software Side of things
Ability to use MS office file directly without conversion, preferably with software to do this already supplied not a additional purchase. But more specifically Excel PowerPoint and Word. Including the ability to update these documents.
Ability to interface with MS Exchange and RSA key management.
Ability to view any website in the world without issue.
Hardware side of things
USB port to expand storage options both connecting as a Hard Drive to a PC and being able to read a memory stick as a Hard Drive
SD and micro-SD card slots (like to keep my options open)
Blue tooth
Excellent Battery life
HDMI output
and of course wireless
As most can tell you the Ipad can do most of these things naively and they have developed workarounds for others. And the exchange interface with the Ipad is excellent. But as you can see there are some non-starters on this list also.
So which PAD did I choose the Lenovo Thinkpad Tablet, and trust me when I say it is not a less expensive alternative to the Ipad. If you are looking to save money this unit should not be on your list.
Therefore the answer is find out what things mean the most to you and base your decision on that.
Software Side of things
Ability to use MS office file directly without conversion, preferably with software to do this already supplied not a additional purchase. But more specifically Excel PowerPoint and Word. Including the ability to update these documents.
Ability to interface with MS Exchange and RSA key management.
Ability to view any website in the world without issue.
Hardware side of things
USB port to expand storage options both connecting as a Hard Drive to a PC and being able to read a memory stick as a Hard Drive
SD and micro-SD card slots (like to keep my options open)
Blue tooth
Excellent Battery life
HDMI output
and of course wireless
As most can tell you the Ipad can do most of these things naively and they have developed workarounds for others. And the exchange interface with the Ipad is excellent. But as you can see there are some non-starters on this list also.
So which PAD did I choose the Lenovo Thinkpad Tablet, and trust me when I say it is not a less expensive alternative to the Ipad. If you are looking to save money this unit should not be on your list.
Therefore the answer is find out what things mean the most to you and base your decision on that.