Reports of increased stops of Westerners in certain Bangkok police jurisdictions
#76
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Snooky
Posts: 2,508
It seemed like they were just stopping every taxi in the lane. They asked for our PPs, we gave them the Xerox & were on our way. No search, no pee. Didn't notice at the time, but the driver complained that he had to give them 500B. When I got stopped by Emporium, they went through my wallet & bag. My expat friends later said they were looking for prescription drugs w/no prescription like Valium, Codeine, & Viagra which were readily available w/out one. Fine was reportedly 1000B or you went back to the police station. 2 guys I know got searched and paid the fine at Ekkamai Bus Station. None of this is recent.
#77
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Bangkok or San Francisco
Programs: United 1k, Marriott Lifetime PE, Former DL Gold, Former SQ Solitaire, HH Gold
Posts: 11,886
Now this incident I believe completely. But it is also completely different than the OP. This is a standard process of the police in Thailand. They set up random checkpoints. Stop everyone. Typically looking for expired DL, red tag plates at night, no seat belt, taxi driver not the one in the license, etc. Typically happens around the first of the month when the cops need rent money. You will see this every month at Wittayu and Rama IV.
But, again, this isn't what the OP was about. The OP said that they police were pulling over taxis specifically because they had foreigners as passengers. That isn't what happened to you. And it is the major reason I objected to the post. That simply doesn't happen.
When I got stopped by Emporium, they went through my wallet & bag. My expat friends later said they were looking for prescription drugs w/no prescription like Valium, Codeine, & Viagra which were readily available w/out one. Fine was reportedly 1000B or you went back to the police station. 2 guys I know got searched and paid the fine at Ekkamai Bus Station. None of this is recent.
In my experience, when these types of "anecdotes" start flying around they turn out to be beer talk. You're sitting down with buddies for a brew on a Friday night, you mention what happened to year near the Emporium a long time ago. The "Topper" next to you says "It happened to me twice". Next guy "Yeah, well it happened to me 3 times plus they made me pee in a cup". By the end of the evening someone got pulled over 7 times in one hour and the cops amputated his leg and barbecued it.
Then one of those guys posts what he heard on a blog somewhere, it goes viral, and we have a thread like this claiming (as per the OP) that the police are regularly stopping taxis solely because they have foreigners as passengers and piss testing them.
I've seen this happen any number of times. It is what happened this time, IMO. It will happen again. And unless someone comes up with strong, verifiable evidence, I won't believe it.
Again.
#79
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Snooky
Posts: 2,508
Thanks.
Now this incident I believe completely. But it is also completely different than the OP. This is a standard process of the police in Thailand. They set up random checkpoints. Stop everyone. Typically looking for expired DL, red tag plates at night, no seat belt, taxi driver not the one in the license, etc. Typically happens around the first of the month when the cops need rent money. You will see this every month at Wittayu and Rama IV.
But, again, this isn't what the OP was about. The OP said that they police were pulling over taxis specifically because they had foreigners as passengers. That isn't what happened to you. And it is the major reason I objected to the post. That simply doesn't happen.
You have apparently spent a lot of time in BKK. You have been stopped once in your entire life. I have never been stopped. None of this supports the claim that it is "common" or "routine", which is the other part of the OP post I objected to.
In my experience, when these types of "anecdotes" start flying around they turn out to be beer talk. You're sitting down with buddies for a brew on a Friday night, you mention what happened to year near the Emporium a long time ago. The "Topper" next to you says "It happened to me twice". Next guy "Yeah, well it happened to me 3 times plus they made me pee in a cup". By the end of the evening someone got pulled over 7 times in one hour and the cops amputated his leg and barbecued it.
Then one of those guys posts what he heard on a blog somewhere, it goes viral, and we have a thread like this claiming (as per the OP) that the police are regularly stopping taxis solely because they have foreigners as passengers and piss testing them.
I've seen this happen any number of times. It is what happened this time, IMO. It will happen again. And unless someone comes up with strong, verifiable evidence, I won't believe it.
Again.
Now this incident I believe completely. But it is also completely different than the OP. This is a standard process of the police in Thailand. They set up random checkpoints. Stop everyone. Typically looking for expired DL, red tag plates at night, no seat belt, taxi driver not the one in the license, etc. Typically happens around the first of the month when the cops need rent money. You will see this every month at Wittayu and Rama IV.
But, again, this isn't what the OP was about. The OP said that they police were pulling over taxis specifically because they had foreigners as passengers. That isn't what happened to you. And it is the major reason I objected to the post. That simply doesn't happen.
You have apparently spent a lot of time in BKK. You have been stopped once in your entire life. I have never been stopped. None of this supports the claim that it is "common" or "routine", which is the other part of the OP post I objected to.
In my experience, when these types of "anecdotes" start flying around they turn out to be beer talk. You're sitting down with buddies for a brew on a Friday night, you mention what happened to year near the Emporium a long time ago. The "Topper" next to you says "It happened to me twice". Next guy "Yeah, well it happened to me 3 times plus they made me pee in a cup". By the end of the evening someone got pulled over 7 times in one hour and the cops amputated his leg and barbecued it.
Then one of those guys posts what he heard on a blog somewhere, it goes viral, and we have a thread like this claiming (as per the OP) that the police are regularly stopping taxis solely because they have foreigners as passengers and piss testing them.
I've seen this happen any number of times. It is what happened this time, IMO. It will happen again. And unless someone comes up with strong, verifiable evidence, I won't believe it.
Again.
Last edited by whackyjacky; Dec 21, 2014 at 5:14 pm
#80
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Truth or Consequences, NM
Programs: HH Diamond, Marriott Titanium, Hertz President's Circle, UA Silver, Mobile Passport Unobtanium
Posts: 6,196
For those who were in denial about searches:
"Following a month of bad publicity regarding police stop and searches around the Asoke / Sukhumvit area of Bangkok, Thonglor Police District have printed a leaflet outlining your rights as a foreigner if stopped by the police.
Officers were seen passing them out in Soi Cowboy on Friday and Saturday night.
The contents of the leaflet covers most of the answers Thonglor chief Pol. Col. Chutrakul Yodmadee outlined in the Police Stop & Search: What You Need To Know list shared on Stickboy 10 days ago with some additional information and useful telephone numbers."
Photos of the leaflets can be seen here:
http://www.stickboybangkok.com/news/...search-policy/
"Following a month of bad publicity regarding police stop and searches around the Asoke / Sukhumvit area of Bangkok, Thonglor Police District have printed a leaflet outlining your rights as a foreigner if stopped by the police.
Officers were seen passing them out in Soi Cowboy on Friday and Saturday night.
The contents of the leaflet covers most of the answers Thonglor chief Pol. Col. Chutrakul Yodmadee outlined in the Police Stop & Search: What You Need To Know list shared on Stickboy 10 days ago with some additional information and useful telephone numbers."
Photos of the leaflets can be seen here:
http://www.stickboybangkok.com/news/...search-policy/
#82
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Bangkok
Posts: 284
There has been a marked increase in the last 2 months of this type of harassment which has been ongoing for years in the Thonglor police district, primarily between Suk soi 22 and Asoke. An increase mainly due to other avenues of income being impacted.
Officially, it is to intercept drug movements between Klong Toey and Sukhumvit who use soi 22. However, those doing it have caused much publicity to such an extent that the TAT had to pressure the Thong Lor police into putting out a leaflet (almost unheard of in Bangkok).
See leaflet here:
http://www.stickboybangkok.com/image...earch-Policy-2
Officially, it is to intercept drug movements between Klong Toey and Sukhumvit who use soi 22. However, those doing it have caused much publicity to such an extent that the TAT had to pressure the Thong Lor police into putting out a leaflet (almost unheard of in Bangkok).
See leaflet here:
http://www.stickboybangkok.com/image...earch-Policy-2
Last edited by aBroadAbroad; Dec 29, 2014 at 8:59 am Reason: Attempted to fix broken image link; converted to regular link
#83
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Snooky
Posts: 2,508
If they want to interdict drug movement they should look within. IMO, Farang don't move a lot of drugs, especially those around 22 & especially Yaba. They should take a look down Sois 1 & 3, but can't - these guys pay protection. This is all about the shakedown.
#84
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Sep 1999
Posts: 12,375
Follow-up/summary article in one of the local English language daily rags...
Sukhumvit shakedown
Random searches and on-the-spot drug tests on foreigners have left many questioning police integrity
http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/spec...mvit-shakedown
Interesting points in the article...
Former Thong Lor Police Superintendent blames issues on "fake", "rogue" or police from other precincts.
And, said police superintendent has been re-assigned to that provincial hot-bed of Ang Thong ("golden bowl", good luck sir in that backwater), presumably because he did such a bang-up job in Thong Lor, not.
Sukhumvit shakedown
Random searches and on-the-spot drug tests on foreigners have left many questioning police integrity
http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/spec...mvit-shakedown
Interesting points in the article...
Former Thong Lor Police Superintendent blames issues on "fake", "rogue" or police from other precincts.
And, said police superintendent has been re-assigned to that provincial hot-bed of Ang Thong ("golden bowl", good luck sir in that backwater), presumably because he did such a bang-up job in Thong Lor, not.
#85
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Truth or Consequences, NM
Programs: HH Diamond, Marriott Titanium, Hertz President's Circle, UA Silver, Mobile Passport Unobtanium
Posts: 6,196
One wonders what took the Post so long to acknowledge the obvious. (:you know why emoticon
Ang Thong, lol. No connection whatsoever.
[content removed by moderator]
Ang Thong, lol. No connection whatsoever.
[content removed by moderator]
Last edited by aBroadAbroad; Feb 18, 2015 at 2:26 am Reason: overly personalized; please refrain from fanning the flames
#86
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Bangkok or San Francisco
Programs: United 1k, Marriott Lifetime PE, Former DL Gold, Former SQ Solitaire, HH Gold
Posts: 11,886
[QUOTE=Diplomatico;24188147]One wonders what took the Post so long to acknowledge the obvious. (:you know why emoticon
Ang Thong, lol. No connection whatsoever.
[content removed by moderator]
Well, let's read the article.
This thread started off with and article that claimed that police were stopping taxis purely because the passenger was a foreigner, taking the passenger out of the taxi and making them do piss tests. And that scenario is what I objected to.
So, this article starts off with "was trying to hail a taxi on Sukhumvit Soi 36" No taxi stop. So this instance doesn't even resemble the original premise.
I also commented that the way people act or dress can draw attention. Back to the article "dressed like a typical foreigner, in a T-shirt, cargo shorts and flip flops"
Sorry, that is not how a typical foreigner dresses. He drew attention to himself.
Then the picture in the article "Two foreigners receive a ticket from police for their riding at Asoke"
Wow! Really??? A traffic ticket??? Foreigners never get traffic tickets in other countries.
And when asked why some foreigners were being stopped, the police chief said "his men are instructed to be on the lookout for drugs at all times, and determining whether or not to stop someone would depend on that person’s behaviour and whether they appeared intoxicated". Which, again, has always been my contention.
I could go on, but you get the gist. The article has *nothing* to do with the claim that started this thread that I disputed. No indication that police were just stopping people "at random". No pulling people out of taxis. No stopping taxis just because there is a foreigner in the taxi. Nothing I can see all that much different than "stop and frisk" which is conducted by most police departments in most cities. As other posters have said, it happens. Foreigners get stopped. But the claims in the original post are still not validated.
Ang Thong, lol. No connection whatsoever.
[content removed by moderator]
Well, let's read the article.
This thread started off with and article that claimed that police were stopping taxis purely because the passenger was a foreigner, taking the passenger out of the taxi and making them do piss tests. And that scenario is what I objected to.
So, this article starts off with "was trying to hail a taxi on Sukhumvit Soi 36" No taxi stop. So this instance doesn't even resemble the original premise.
I also commented that the way people act or dress can draw attention. Back to the article "dressed like a typical foreigner, in a T-shirt, cargo shorts and flip flops"
Sorry, that is not how a typical foreigner dresses. He drew attention to himself.
Then the picture in the article "Two foreigners receive a ticket from police for their riding at Asoke"
Wow! Really??? A traffic ticket??? Foreigners never get traffic tickets in other countries.
And when asked why some foreigners were being stopped, the police chief said "his men are instructed to be on the lookout for drugs at all times, and determining whether or not to stop someone would depend on that person’s behaviour and whether they appeared intoxicated". Which, again, has always been my contention.
I could go on, but you get the gist. The article has *nothing* to do with the claim that started this thread that I disputed. No indication that police were just stopping people "at random". No pulling people out of taxis. No stopping taxis just because there is a foreigner in the taxi. Nothing I can see all that much different than "stop and frisk" which is conducted by most police departments in most cities. As other posters have said, it happens. Foreigners get stopped. But the claims in the original post are still not validated.
Last edited by aBroadAbroad; Feb 18, 2015 at 2:27 am
#87
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Northern California
Programs: UA Premier Gold, 1.5 Million Mile Flyer
Posts: 3,549
IME that is exactly how most Western men dress when in Thailand as tourists, myself included. Well, swap flip flops for sandals. I would certainly call it typical.
#88
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Bangkok or San Francisco
Programs: United 1k, Marriott Lifetime PE, Former DL Gold, Former SQ Solitaire, HH Gold
Posts: 11,886
An adult male wearing shorts in Bangkok is not typical. You will virtually never see a Thai dressed like in Bangkok that unless he needs to for work. Outside of KSR and Nana I rarely see a foreigner dressed like that. It's not rude or anything, but is viewed by Thai as a "low class" way of dressing. Beaches and at home, fine. Bangkok? Not so much.
#89
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Northern California
Programs: UA Premier Gold, 1.5 Million Mile Flyer
Posts: 3,549
Agree completely about Thai men not wearing shorts, and have heard several times that it is viewed by Thai as a "low class" way of dressing. But, from Lumpini park/Lang Suan, to MBK, all the way down Sukhumvit to Asok including Sois 8 & 11 and Terminal 21, and everywhere in between, shorts are the norm for the vast majority of westerners, right or wrong. I just returned from 7 weeks in that area. Also at Chatuchak, the cooking school we attended on Silom, the BTS everywhere, and the river express boats. You really don't see this?
#90
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: body: A stone's throw from SFO, mind: SE Asia
Programs: Some of this 'n some of that
Posts: 17,263
Please.