FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   TalkBoard Topics (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/talkboard-topics-382/)
-   -   Suggestion: Allow post counts in Omni PR (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/talkboard-topics/1219013-suggestion-allow-post-counts-omni-pr.html)

Mary2e May 25, 2011 11:12 am


Originally Posted by General_Flyer (Post 16448002)
May I ask exactly which one fractures the community? :confused:

They all do.

OTOH, I posted in the Community lounge as part of my daily activity and its just nice to meet people there. Please note that not all posts are as worthless as people tends to have it said. Its a nice place to just hang out and talk to people not necessarily engaging in other topics.
There was a time this all took place in Omni - the place for OT discussions. People from all programs used to visit there on a daily basis, as part of their daily routine, to shoot the breeze and hang out and talk. This all took place in various threads, most of them not too long.

Now we have single threads in some forums with thousands of posts in them, and it's nearly impossible to go in there and figure out what is being discussed.

As well, some grow by hundreds of posts overnight. Not everyone has the time to sift through that many useless "good morning/evening" posts.

Moderator2 May 25, 2011 11:13 am

Prior moderation activities and related technologies are not a subject of discussion. If you have any questions about moderation policies, please send a private message to Carol, the Community Director.

General_Flyer May 25, 2011 11:22 am


Originally Posted by Mary2e (Post 16448045)
They all do.

Then I might have to differ from your viewpoint. :)


Originally Posted by Mary2e (Post 16448045)
There was a time this all took place in Omni - the place for OT discussions. People from all programs used to visit there on a daily basis, as part of their daily routine, to shoot the breeze and hang out and talk. This all took place in various threads, most of them not too long.

As well, some grow by hundreds of posts overnight. Not everyone has the time to sift through that many useless "good morning/evening" posts.

So I would guess we should differentiate which lounges are useless and which ones are not? :rolleyes:

Just a thought.. ;)

Mary2e May 25, 2011 11:25 am

Actually, all lounges are useless if they are in the core forums of FT. I believe OT posts are generally deleted or moved to the appropriate forums. Only lounge threads remain.

The content isn't any more useless than some Omni posts - they are just in the wrong place and too many of them together.

No one is going to stop you from shooting the breeze in Omni with all your usual friends and who knows, you may make a few more who don't visit the lounge threads.

And there are more people than you think who don't visit or think they're appropriate in core forums.

G_G May 25, 2011 11:28 am


Originally Posted by Mary2e (Post 16448045)
They all do.

it is a very convincing argument and unstoppable :rolleyes:

Mary2e May 25, 2011 11:37 am


Originally Posted by G_G (Post 16448166)
it is a very convincing argument and unstoppable :rolleyes:

:confused:

I think I clearly presented my argument in various posts.

However, I fully expect, and was even warned, that the denizens of these threads would start to come out in full force once word got out their playgrounds might be in jeopardy.

However, if you read through everything here, it's about getting post counts in Omni, which is off-topic, and people getting them for lounge threads, which are even more off-topic (good morning, breakfast, weather) than Omni.

I'm interested in conversing with people who post in all areas of FT, not just those who frequent one particular forum.

G_G May 25, 2011 11:38 am


Originally Posted by Mary2e (Post 16448134)
No one is going to stop you from shooting the breeze in Omni with all your usual friends and who knows, you may make a few more who don't visit the lounge threads.

And there are more people than you think who don't visit or think they're appropriate in core forums.

you are feeling at ease in Omni and other people are feeling at ease in lounges : that's called choice freedom.
If the count of your posts is so important at your eyes, I could only understand
that you'd ask that lounges' posts don't count anymore, not your affirmation about lounges not being core of FT.

Mary2e May 25, 2011 11:43 am


Originally Posted by G_G (Post 16448256)
you are feeling at ease in Omni and other people are feeling at ease in lounges : that's called choice freedom.

No, it's called moderators making the call to allow OT posts in core forums.


If the count of your posts is so important at your eyes, I could only understand that you'd ask that lounges' posts don't count anymore, not your affirmation about lounges not being core of FT.
It is not about my post count or anyone else's. It's about treating all members fairly. Right now, lounge posts count, and most of them are nonsense, yet information-filled Omni posts don't count.

Either make every contribution to FT count or none of them.

However, I can say that the only people who care for lounge threads are those who participate. Anyone else I've spoken with feels they're a total waste and shouldn't be permitted in core forums.

What is the issue of doing exactly the same thing you're doing in lounge threads in Omni? After all, you all click on Community, why can't you click on Omni to find the same thread?

G_G May 25, 2011 11:44 am


Originally Posted by Mary2e (Post 16448252)
:confused:

I think I clearly presented my argument in various posts.

However, I fully expect, and was even warned, that the denizens of these threads would start to come out in full force once word got out their playgrounds might be in jeopardy.

However, if you read through everything here, it's about getting post counts in Omni, which is off-topic, and people getting them for lounge threads, which are even more off-topic (good morning, breakfast, weather) than Omni.

I'm interested in conversing with people who post in all areas of FT, not just those who frequent one particular forum.

Were you the one who was predicting the end of world's day ?:D
Of course if we don't post in the same threads as yours we're only plebs ;)

Mary2e May 25, 2011 11:48 am

No, I was laughing about it :D :D :D

And you're more than welcome to post in any thread. Newbies are always welcome.

You know, I recently had a conversation with a longtime FTer who acknowledged just how much good/accurate information/help is posted in Omni. Far better than you would find in just about any other BBS. The demographics are much higher and often you get an accurate and heartfelt response in minutes from a myriad of people.

The next time you need to buy a major appliance, or fix a leak, or buy jewelry, ask in Omni and I guarantee you'll have a good, honest answer in a very short period of time.

GUWonder May 25, 2011 12:43 pm

To my eyes, the OMNI forum threads have a higher information/entertainment ratio than the lounge threads; so if anything the OMNI forum posts should be valued at least as much or more than the posts in the lounge forums. Yet the "redheaded stepchild" stigma applies far more to the OMNI posts than to the lounge posts.

dhammer53 May 25, 2011 1:00 pm


Originally Posted by General_Flyer (Post 16448110)

So I would guess we should differentiate which lounges are useless and which ones are not? :rolleyes:

Just a thought.. ;)

All the lounge threads are useless. You'll have more fun in Chat. ;)


Originally Posted by Mary2e (Post 16448134)
Actually, all lounges are useless if they are in the core forums of FT.


Originally Posted by GUWonder (Post 16448691)
To my eyes, the OMNI forum threads have a higher information/entertainment ratio than the lounge threads

The tone of this thread is much too serious for the topic. :confused:

dh

kipper May 25, 2011 1:02 pm


Originally Posted by Mary2e (Post 16448045)
They all do.
There was a time this all took place in Omni - the place for OT discussions. People from all programs used to visit there on a daily basis, as part of their daily routine, to shoot the breeze and hang out and talk. This all took place in various threads, most of them not too long.

Now we have single threads in some forums with thousands of posts in them, and it's nearly impossible to go in there and figure out what is being discussed.

As well, some grow by hundreds of posts overnight. Not everyone has the time to sift through that many useless "good morning/evening" posts.

Mary, you and I are in agreement about yet another thing (which really does make me wonder if the end of the world is near! :D). I spent about 10 minutes trying to figure out what was being discussed in the Community Lounge thread a while back, and finally gave up. It seemed far too much like a semi-private club, and with the sheer number of posts each day, I knew that in no time, I'd have no clue what was being discussed again. Sorry, but I don't have time to sift through all of the hundreds of posts there to figure out what is being dicussed each day.

Originally Posted by Mary2e (Post 16448287)
No, it's called moderators making the call to allow OT posts in core forums.

It is not about my post count or anyone else's. It's about treating all members fairly. Right now, lounge posts count, and most of them are nonsense, yet information-filled Omni posts don't count.

Either make every contribution to FT count or none of them.

However, I can say that the only people who care for lounge threads are those who participate. Anyone else I've spoken with feels they're a total waste and shouldn't be permitted in core forums.

What is the issue of doing exactly the same thing you're doing in lounge threads in Omni? After all, you all click on Community, why can't you click on Omni to find the same thread?

^ Either have all posts count, or don't allow the lounge threads.

Originally Posted by GUWonder (Post 16448691)
To my eyes, the OMNI forum threads have a higher information/entertainment ratio than the lounge threads; so if anything the OMNI forum posts should be valued at least as much or more than the posts in the lounge forums. Yet the "redheaded stepchild" stigma applies far more to the OMNI posts than to the lounge posts.

^ I agree with this too. I've gleaned quite a bit of useful information from OMNI, and have participated in many entertaining threads there.

Mary2e May 25, 2011 1:07 pm


Originally Posted by kipper (Post 16448827)
Mary, you and I are in agreement about yet another thing (which really does make me wonder if the end of the world is near! :D).

Frightening, no? :D :D :D

Crazyhotelguy May 25, 2011 1:13 pm


Originally Posted by Mary2e (Post 16448287)
No, it's called moderators making the call to allow OT posts in core forums.

It is not about my post count or anyone else's. It's about treating all members fairly. Right now, lounge posts count, and most of them are nonsense, yet information-filled Omni posts don't count.

Either make every contribution to FT count or none of them.

However, I can say that the only people who care for lounge threads are those who participate. Anyone else I've spoken with feels they're a total waste and shouldn't be permitted in core forums.

What is the issue of doing exactly the same thing you're doing in lounge threads in Omni? After all, you all click on Community, why can't you click on Omni to find the same thread?

+1. On this we AGREE! :)


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 5:36 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.