Jewish man removed from airplane for praying
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Sep 2005
Programs: LH M&L, CO OP, LY
Posts: 136
Jewish man removed from airplane for praying
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/montreal/st...eronplane.html
Jewish man removed from airplane for praying
Last Updated: Tuesday, September 5, 2006 | 11:12 PM ET
Some fellow passengers are questioning why an Orthodox Jewish man was removed from an Air Canada Jazz flight in Montreal last week for praying.
The man was a passenger on a Sept. 1 flight from Montreal to New York City when the incident happened.
The airplane was heading toward the runway at the Pierre Elliott Trudeau International Airport when eyewitnesses said the Orthodox man began to pray.
"He was clearly a Hasidic Jew," said Yves Faguy, a passenger seated nearby. "He had some sort of cover over his head. He was reading from a book.
"He wasn't exactly praying out loud but he was lurching back and forth," Faguy added.
The action didn't seem to bother anyone, Faguy said, but a flight attendant approached the man and told him his praying was making other passengers nervous.
"The attendant actually recognized out loud that he wasn't a Muslim and that she was sorry for the situation but they had to ask him to leave," Faguy said.
The man, who spoke neither English nor French, was escorted off the airplane.
Air Canada Jazz termed the situation "delicate," but says it received more than one complaint about the man's behaviour.
The crew had to act in the interest of the majority of passengers, said Jazz spokeswoman Manon Stewart.
"The passenger did not speak English or French, so we really had no choice but to return to the gate to secure a translator," she said.
The airline is not saying if the man was told he was not allowed to pray, but a spokesperson said the man was back on board the next flight to New York.
Jewish leaders in Montreal criticized the move as insensitive, saying the flight attendants should have explained to the other passengers that the man was simply praying and doing no harm.
Hasidic Rabbi Ronny Fine said he often prays on airplanes, but typically only gets curious stares.
"If it's something that you're praying in your own seat and not taking over the whole plane, I don't think it should be a problem," said Fine.
The Jewish group B'nai Brith Canada has offered to help give Air Canada crews sensitivity training.
Jewish man removed from airplane for praying
Last Updated: Tuesday, September 5, 2006 | 11:12 PM ET
Some fellow passengers are questioning why an Orthodox Jewish man was removed from an Air Canada Jazz flight in Montreal last week for praying.
The man was a passenger on a Sept. 1 flight from Montreal to New York City when the incident happened.
The airplane was heading toward the runway at the Pierre Elliott Trudeau International Airport when eyewitnesses said the Orthodox man began to pray.
"He was clearly a Hasidic Jew," said Yves Faguy, a passenger seated nearby. "He had some sort of cover over his head. He was reading from a book.
"He wasn't exactly praying out loud but he was lurching back and forth," Faguy added.
The action didn't seem to bother anyone, Faguy said, but a flight attendant approached the man and told him his praying was making other passengers nervous.
"The attendant actually recognized out loud that he wasn't a Muslim and that she was sorry for the situation but they had to ask him to leave," Faguy said.
The man, who spoke neither English nor French, was escorted off the airplane.
Air Canada Jazz termed the situation "delicate," but says it received more than one complaint about the man's behaviour.
The crew had to act in the interest of the majority of passengers, said Jazz spokeswoman Manon Stewart.
"The passenger did not speak English or French, so we really had no choice but to return to the gate to secure a translator," she said.
The airline is not saying if the man was told he was not allowed to pray, but a spokesperson said the man was back on board the next flight to New York.
Jewish leaders in Montreal criticized the move as insensitive, saying the flight attendants should have explained to the other passengers that the man was simply praying and doing no harm.
Hasidic Rabbi Ronny Fine said he often prays on airplanes, but typically only gets curious stares.
"If it's something that you're praying in your own seat and not taking over the whole plane, I don't think it should be a problem," said Fine.
The Jewish group B'nai Brith Canada has offered to help give Air Canada crews sensitivity training.
#3
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: CLE
Programs: UA GS+LT UC, AA EXP+LT PLT, Fairmont LT PLT, Marriott PLT, Hilton DIA, Hyatt Glob, Avis CHM
Posts: 4,671
Originally Posted by Xcheckme
Is god more likely to listen if you do lurch back and forth while praying?
Of course theres no difference to G-d if you lurch back and forth while praying.
Naturally an orthodox jew "shuckles" back and forth while praying. Its explained that one's soul is like a candle which always flickers because it yearns to go up to the source of fire above, so too the soul wishes to go up to it's creator, and this is expressed openly in the physical body while praying...
At any rate it's disgusting that one can be taken off a plane for praying, I've prayed many times on a plane without incident...
#4
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: CLE
Programs: UA GS+LT UC, AA EXP+LT PLT, Fairmont LT PLT, Marriott PLT, Hilton DIA, Hyatt Glob, Avis CHM
Posts: 4,671
By the way here's a great pre-9/11 story of an orthodox jew praying on a plane with a great ending!
http://www.lchaimweekly.org/lchaim/5...0.htm#caption3
http://www.lchaimweekly.org/lchaim/5...0.htm#caption3
#5
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Mar 2001
Posts: 55,189
This was brought up already in Omni and being discussed at length there: http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/showthread.php?t=598645
The moderator may want to merge this thread with the one in Omni? I'm not sure if that can be done.
The moderator may want to merge this thread with the one in Omni? I'm not sure if that can be done.
#6
Suspended
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Watchlisted by the prejudiced, en route to purgatory
Programs: Just Say No to Fleecing and Blacklisting
Posts: 102,095
Originally Posted by Analise
This was brought up already in Omni and being discussed at length there: http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/showthread.php?t=598645
The moderator may want to merge this thread with the one in Omni? I'm not sure if that can be done.
The moderator may want to merge this thread with the one in Omni? I'm not sure if that can be done.
#7
In Memoriam, FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Southern California
Programs: DL: 3.8 MM, Marriott: Lifetime Titanium
Posts: 24,575
Originally Posted by GUWonder
It was discussed in Newstand and/or Travel Safety & Security too.
I thought of transferring it here rather than OMNI but, after looking at this Forum's description, I thought OMNI was the better venue.
Religious Travelers
This forum is open to members of all religions who have contributions which are both travel and faith-oriented. There is but one Golden Rule: We're not here to debate religion.
This forum is open to members of all religions who have contributions which are both travel and faith-oriented. There is but one Golden Rule: We're not here to debate religion.
#8
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: United States
Programs: UA, AA, DL, Amtrak
Posts: 4,647
Originally Posted by cohenyf
"The attendant actually recognized out loud that he wasn't a Muslim and that she was sorry for the situation but they had to ask him to leave," Faguy said.
#10
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Seattle
Programs: Alaska Airlines
Posts: 1,037
Originally Posted by ctownflyer
By the way here's a great pre-9/11 story of an orthodox jew praying on a plane with a great ending!
http://www.lchaimweekly.org/lchaim/5...0.htm#caption3
http://www.lchaimweekly.org/lchaim/5...0.htm#caption3
#12
Join Date: Dec 2006
Programs: DL PM
Posts: 20
Knowing how to pray
For example, a Jew can pray shachrit (morning prayers) in one's seat without standing up for the sections of the service that one normally stands up for. One can even pray without tallit and tefillin and arrange to put those items on later in the day upon arrival.
There have been numerous times where I have taken a day trip and have put on tallit and tefillin in the parking lot so I don't have to bring them along; and then have prayed theh full service at my seat.