FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Practical Travel Safety and Security Issues (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/practical-travel-safety-security-issues-686/)
-   -   What's Your Tipping Point? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/practical-travel-safety-security-issues/1153753-whats-your-tipping-point.html)

Scubatooth Nov 29, 2010 11:08 am


Originally Posted by Saitek (Post 15326227)
Until you drive up upon a TSA Check point.

Yeah and thats likely to cause smokey and the bandit style antics, and or TSA is likely to end up with a glock shoved in there gullet.

Jeano222 Nov 29, 2010 11:17 am

This whole full body scan and invasive patdowns are bogus. If every line at every airport was using full body scan and/or patdowns, I would give the benefit of the doubt, but if TSA is so concerned that security should be stepped up, then they should stop all other forms of security and concentrate on only body scans and patdowns. Am I the only one that feels this way??? I don't believe for a second that this isn't a huge sham. My not flying anymore does not affect anyone except myself, but to think people are not upset about this being an assault on our freedom really concerns me. This is how Big Brother scenario begins.

PartlySunny Nov 29, 2010 11:19 am


Originally Posted by svenskaflicka (Post 15329929)
I also will NOT fly until/unless this brutality stops.

I wonder just how much Obama is being told and what exactly he is being told. I think at this point with all he has on his plate that his trusted (haha) people could could tell him almost anything and he might just go along with them. Pistole must be spinning a huge yarn to Obama because he seems to have his head in the sand as far as all the uproar goes. Hello Mr. President, 2012 is an election year!!! While you are a it President Obama, your motto for your campaign was YES WE CAN (turn things around with change) My suggestion would be to change this TSA and their thugs around now before it's too late and they start running roughshod over even you.

What other organization could treat two million people a day so badly, have the execs insist that the people squawking the loudest are just a few bad apples and insist on the status quo?

Bolded by me:

If he is listening to the media, he is being told that the majority of the people have no problem with the increased security measures, it isn't slowing down lines at the airport, and most flyers feel safer because of it.

LeeAnne Nov 29, 2010 11:24 am


Originally Posted by brendog (Post 15321956)
As someone who has been flying more or less weekly for the past decade, my only thought is what a bunch of whiners we have become. So we have to remove our shoes, dump our bottles of water, and endure the occasional nude-o-scope or rough pat down. This constitutes a Stasi-like security state??? I can't recall the last time the security experience took more than an hour and was anything but tedious at worst.

I seriously hope more whiners decide not to fly, as it means shorter security lines for me and a higher UG percentage. Sheesh... :rolleyes:

I'm a whiner? Yeah okay, clearly you haven't been following any of the stories on this topic. Here's mine: http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/trave...nly-ought.html

I'd like to hear you say to my mother's face that she's a whiner. In fact, let's hear you say that to MY face. Go ahead, tell me I'm a whiner. Tell me I'm a whiner for objecting to having my elderly disabled mother treated like a criminal for the offense of having a metal hip, and wanting to visit her grandchildren. Tell my mother she's a whiner for being made to hold her bladder for almost two hours, then sexually groped, then YELLED AT when her trousers were slightly damp after having been forced to hold her bladder beyond the breaking point then having her crotch squeezed. Go ahead, say it.



Originally Posted by brendog (Post 15322359)
My point is that there are far too many whiny, melodramatic drama queens in this country. The TSA experience, as I previously stated, is tedious and moderately annoying, but nowhere near a violation of any civil rights.

As to those who are disabled, I have seen many, many folks in wheelchairs and/or otherwise encumbered, and all of them seemed to be treated with at least as much respect and dignity as the rest of the flying public.

Is a $12 per hour high school dropout TSA agent doing anything to stop "terrorism"? Likely not, but are they really violating anyone with their silly dog and pony show? Nope.

Either deal with it or travel by alternate, much less convenient means.

Ah, okay, just because you personally haven't seen these abuses, I guess that means they aren't happening.

Yeah, come on over here and tell me that to my face.



Originally Posted by brendog (Post 15324661)
100+ flights for several straight years, never a single issue with security, even though I hand-carry electronic equipment that could be construed as suspicious. I run into far more issues with CBP explaining my international destinations than I do with the TSA.

I've been through countless nude-o-scans and a handful of patdowns, but none of them were ever anything but routine and professional, actually, cursory would be more apt.

Considering the hundreds of millions of passengers passing through US airports on an annual basis, if there really were an issue with the TSA, there would be far more more than a random handful of egregious violations. Again, I think the current security scheme is a woefully inadequate, steaming POS, but I still see no major issues with clearing it on a weekly basis. In a perfect world, the US would adopt a scaled down version of the Israeli security regime, but that would likely fall victim to criticisms of profiling and the like.

Again with the "I haven't seen it, so it's not happening". Open your eyes and try looking outside your perfect little bubble. Oh, but you won't...because then you'd have to admit that you are WRONG. Flat-out, unequivocally, undeniably WRONG. Not to mention selfish, uncaring, self-absorbed.

xamsx Nov 29, 2010 12:41 pm


Originally Posted by Jeano222 (Post 15332444)
My not flying anymore does not affect anyone except myself, but to think people are not upset about this being an assault on our freedom really concerns me. This is how Big Brother scenario begins.

One person not flying may not have an effect, but millions of people not flying (especially FF) will either bankrupt the common carriers (at which time the TSA will be out of business - or do they see that writing on the wall and that is why we have talk of subway, boat and train scanner?) or result in changes.

IMO, the more people opting out of flying, the better. Short term pain for long term gain.

Jeano222 Nov 29, 2010 1:08 pm

Please understand, I am not against security, the metal detectors and carryon scanning is needed and I have no problem with that, but randomly putting people through full scan or patdowns if those same people did not cause an alert is where I draw the line. What purpose does it serve? The day a 90 year old or 5 year old caucasian does the deed will be the day I change my mind. Terrorists will carry stuff internally if they have to. Profiling is needed and also dogs. 11/24 was glaring evidence that TSA doesn't need to use full scans or patdowns. Did they look in a crystal ball and saw that there was no need to use invasive tactics that day? It would be laughable if it wasn't so serious'

LuvAirFrance Nov 29, 2010 1:18 pm

I agree with the sentiment that people just ignoring the gradual erosion of individual autonomy because of FEAR is the most bothersome thing. "I'm just glad I'm SAFE". To my ears/eyes, that seems so lacking in dignity.

Jeano222 Nov 29, 2010 1:38 pm

Right after 9/11 I thought for sure that public traveling would require a passport. I think every single man, woman and child should have a passport if they are going to take a plane, train or ship. Why isn't the government insisting on that? Makes no sense to me.

Gynob001 Nov 29, 2010 1:40 pm

A hypothetical conversation
 
Sir, we saw a mass and you need to go for pat down check. Sir what do we have here...
Hydrocele?
What is that?
Fluid mass.
Don't you know that you can't carry that much fluid? Drink it or throw it trash.
I can't do either. It needs surgery.
Surgery? Are you carrying a blade or knife? You can't travel with those.
Tipping point-let me out of here. I will come back after surgery.
Sorry-we can't let you leave unless you pay $10,000 fine.
It is more than what my surgeon would charge. Can I go for a couple of more radiation? It may burst itself!

gojirasan Nov 29, 2010 1:42 pm


Originally Posted by Jeano222 (Post 15334422)
Right after 9/11 I thought for sure that public traveling would require a passport. I think every single man, woman and child should have a passport if they are going to take a plane, train or ship. Why isn't the government insisting on that? Makes no sense to me.

Because we are not supposed to be a "papers, please" country. It is still perfectly legal to walk outside, ride your bicycle, or be a passenger in a motor vehicle without any ID whatsoever. It is also not needed for riding buses, trains or the subway. Or at least it wasn't. Maybe that was changed recently. It's called "freedom".

BearX220 Nov 29, 2010 1:49 pm


Originally Posted by Jeano222 (Post 15334422)
Right after 9/11 I thought for sure that public traveling would require a passport. I think every single man, woman and child should have a passport if they are going to take a plane, train or ship. Why isn't the government insisting on that? Makes no sense to me.

Are you completely insane? Because then the government can track your movements and deny you freedom of travel. You want to file for permission to fly to Cleveland 30 days in advance and wait for approval from your local passport-stamping TSA cell? It's thinking like this that moves us closer to a police state. If the US does turn into East Germany it'll be with the approval of at least 50 percent of the people. Ye gods.

yknot Nov 29, 2010 4:09 pm

tipping point - I reached it back in 2006 - quit my consulting gig that required tons of travel and have been working locally ever since. I did over 150,000 domestic miles each year. Now I do zero.

Have traveled to Chicago, Toronto and California since then, but never by air.

brendog Nov 29, 2010 6:05 pm


Originally Posted by LeeAnne (Post 15332581)
I'm a whiner? Yeah okay, clearly you haven't been following any of the stories on this topic. Here's mine: http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/trave...nly-ought.html

I'd like to hear you say to my mother's face that she's a whiner. In fact, let's hear you say that to MY face. Go ahead, tell me I'm a whiner, you sick f***. Tell me I'm a whiner for objecting to having my elderly disabled mother treated like a criminal for the offense of having a metal hip, and wanting to visit her grandchildren. Tell my mother she's a whiner for being made to hold her bladder for almost two hours, then sexually groped, then YELLED AT when her trousers were slightly damp after having been forced to hold her bladder beyond the breaking point then having her crotch squeezed. Go ahead, say it.




Ah, okay, just because you personally haven't seen these abuses, I guess that means they aren't happening.

Yeah, come on over here and tell me that to my face.




Again with the "I haven't seen it, so it's not happening". Open your eyes and try looking outside your perfect little bubble. Oh, but you won't...because then you'd have to admit that you are WRONG. Flat-out, unequivocally, undeniably WRONG. Not to mention selfish, uncaring, self-absorbed.

Quite the diatribe. :rolleyes: To summarize, what you are saying is that my extensive experience flying on a weekly basis is wrong and your anecdotal evidence is irrefutably correct? Mmm-hmm...

Again, yes, there are bad apples in the TSA and boundaries do get crossed, but in the vast majority of cases, airport security is little more than a minor annoyance.

My enjoyment of the sky-is-falling vitriol has just about waned. Everyone please do enjoy yourselves while hunkering in your TSA-proof bunkers... :p

Cholula Nov 29, 2010 6:49 pm

Folks, we need to dial way down on the level of discourse back and forth on this issue. We understand that folks are upset over the TSA issues but the discussions here will not proceed any further without dialogue that isn't respectful towards each other.

We've had to delete/edit several posts here and we're closing down the thread as well for now.

_______________________________

Cholula
TS/S Co-Moderator


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 9:15 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.