BA vs IB
#1
Original Poster
Suspended
Join Date: Jul 2004
Programs: CX Gold MPO
Posts: 1,677
BA vs IB
I need to get from FCO-CDG.
I can do it on BA or IB (part of my DONE4 and Oneworld Visit Pass).
The good thing on IB is that they use ORY (= a lot closer to the city).
However I just want to know how user friendly is BCN?
I think I will have 2 hrs layover in BCN. Is this enough?
As I never travelled on IB before, how is the service on IB (in J and Y Class) Better ot worse than BA?
Thanks
I can do it on BA or IB (part of my DONE4 and Oneworld Visit Pass).
The good thing on IB is that they use ORY (= a lot closer to the city).
However I just want to know how user friendly is BCN?
I think I will have 2 hrs layover in BCN. Is this enough?
As I never travelled on IB before, how is the service on IB (in J and Y Class) Better ot worse than BA?
Thanks
#2
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: May 2000
Location: Little dot in Asia
Programs: AA-PP, HL-DM, MR-LTP, HY-LTG
Posts: 26,017
Originally Posted by newcx12345
I need to get from FCO-CDG.
I can do it on BA or IB (part of my DONE4 and Oneworld Visit Pass).
The good thing on IB is that they use ORY (= a lot closer to the city).
However I just want to know how user friendly is BCN?
I think I will have 2 hrs layover in BCN. Is this enough?
As I never travelled on IB before, how is the service on IB (in J and Y Class) Better ot worse than BA?
Thanks
I can do it on BA or IB (part of my DONE4 and Oneworld Visit Pass).
The good thing on IB is that they use ORY (= a lot closer to the city).
However I just want to know how user friendly is BCN?
I think I will have 2 hrs layover in BCN. Is this enough?
As I never travelled on IB before, how is the service on IB (in J and Y Class) Better ot worse than BA?
Thanks
BA's service in both classes are definitely better IMO than IB. But then again, if you take BA via LHR, just be prepared for delays if you're travelling at peak hours.
You could have opted for the SWISS airpass which you can buy for US$265 for a minimum of 2 coupons within Europe and is not restricted to travelling on LX from overseas. Then you'd be able to fly FCO-ZRH-CDG, and still earn miles (though not status miles).. on Asiamiles.
OR you could have just asked your TA to book you a roundtrip on AF (and throw away the return) for something like US$140 and at least it's DIRECT.
Last edited by Guy Betsy; Oct 25, 2004 at 4:47 am
#3
Original Poster
Suspended
Join Date: Jul 2004
Programs: CX Gold MPO
Posts: 1,677
Originally Posted by Guy Betsy
If it's IB, you stay in the same terminal. BCN is okay. You may use the lounge but bear in mind that even though it's 'non-smoking' throughout the airport... nobody really cares and you'll encounter whiffs of smoke everywhere!
BA's service in both classes are definitely better IMO than IB. But then again, if you take BA via LHR, just be prepared for delays if you're travelling at peak hours.
You could have opted for the SWISS airpass which you can buy for US$265 for a minimum of 2 coupons within Europe and is not restricted to travelling on LX from overseas. Then you'd be able to fly FCO-ZRH-CDG, and still earn miles (though not status miles).. on Asiamiles.
OR you could have just asked your TA to book you a roundtrip on AF (and throw away the return) for something like US$140 and at least it's DIRECT.
BA's service in both classes are definitely better IMO than IB. But then again, if you take BA via LHR, just be prepared for delays if you're travelling at peak hours.
You could have opted for the SWISS airpass which you can buy for US$265 for a minimum of 2 coupons within Europe and is not restricted to travelling on LX from overseas. Then you'd be able to fly FCO-ZRH-CDG, and still earn miles (though not status miles).. on Asiamiles.
OR you could have just asked your TA to book you a roundtrip on AF (and throw away the return) for something like US$140 and at least it's DIRECT.
#4
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Sydney, Aus
Programs: QF WP, Starwood Gold, Hilton Diamond, Marriott Gold, Avis President's Club, Amex Platinum
Posts: 2,880
I prefer IB for breakfast flights - I find the spanish style breakfast infinitely superior to the English fry up they serve in J on BA. Other than that, I think BA is miles ahead in every area from BA, at least in J. Not too sure about the Y comparison as I've never flown IB Y.
#5
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: May 2000
Location: Little dot in Asia
Programs: AA-PP, HL-DM, MR-LTP, HY-LTG
Posts: 26,017
newcx12345 FYI... for your IB flights, credit them to QANTAS FF if you have one as you'll get full 100% mileage credit. Unfortunately on Asiamiles, you won't receive ANY mileage credit on IB flights if it's not in Y or R booking class.
#6
Original Poster
Suspended
Join Date: Jul 2004
Programs: CX Gold MPO
Posts: 1,677
Originally Posted by Guy Betsy
newcx12345 FYI... for your IB flights, credit them to QANTAS FF if you have one as you'll get full 100% mileage credit. Unfortunately on Asiamiles, you won't receive ANY mileage credit on IB flights if it's not in Y or R booking class.
Thanks GB. You are such a wealth of info!
However I think to be safe and do what I am used to. I will take the BA flights instead. I till leave FCO @ 12:15pm and arrive at CDG by 18:15pm
A LONG DAY!
Well at least I will be there in time for dinner! and maybe a quick trip up the Eiffel Tower for dessert.
#7
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: May 2000
Location: Little dot in Asia
Programs: AA-PP, HL-DM, MR-LTP, HY-LTG
Posts: 26,017
Originally Posted by newcx12345
Thanks GB. You are such a wealth of info!
However I think to be safe and do what I am used to. I will take the BA flights instead. I till leave FCO @ 12:15pm and arrive at CDG by 18:15pm
A LONG DAY!
Well at least I will be there in time for dinner! and maybe a quick trip up the Eiffel Tower for dessert.
However I think to be safe and do what I am used to. I will take the BA flights instead. I till leave FCO @ 12:15pm and arrive at CDG by 18:15pm
A LONG DAY!
Well at least I will be there in time for dinner! and maybe a quick trip up the Eiffel Tower for dessert.
#8
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Washington, DC
Posts: 11,242
Originally Posted by Guy Betsy
Just dessert at La Tour Effel? Not without a reservation, you're not!
newcx, that is a rather ridiculous amount of time to fly just to stay on OneWorld. Why not just go the AF route? There's as much likelihood as them losing your luggage as anyone else.
#9
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Aberdeen/London
Posts: 31
Originally Posted by newcx12345
Well at least I will be there in time for dinner! and maybe a quick trip up the Eiffel Tower for dessert.

Anyway back on topic I would recommend the BA option over IB. Have a good trip!
Last edited by JohnW; Oct 25, 2004 at 3:00 pm
#10
Original Poster
Suspended
Join Date: Jul 2004
Programs: CX Gold MPO
Posts: 1,677
Originally Posted by Japhydog
Amex Centurion will get him in.
newcx, that is a rather ridiculous amount of time to fly just to stay on OneWorld. Why not just go the AF route? There's as much likelihood as them losing your luggage as anyone else.
newcx, that is a rather ridiculous amount of time to fly just to stay on OneWorld. Why not just go the AF route? There's as much likelihood as them losing your luggage as anyone else.
It is not because of they loose the luggage (well checking into and from CDG is always a high risk anyway! I lost my luggage there twice on my last trip!)
IT is because on the DONE4 you are allowed 2 piece per person and 30kg per piece, whereas on AF only 20Kgs.
But the AF route does save a lot of time...
For the Eiffel Tower, I did get in last time even without Centurion AMEX. I think towards the end of the evening the demand for tables at Le Jules Verne is not that big.
#11
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Washington, DC
Posts: 11,242
Originally Posted by newcx12345
It is not because of they loose the luggage (well checking into and from CDG is always a high risk anyway! I lost my luggage there twice on my last trip!)
IT is because on the DONE4 you are allowed 2 piece per person and 30kg per piece, whereas on AF only 20Kgs.
But the AF route does save a lot of time...
For the Eiffel Tower, I did get in last time even without Centurion AMEX. I think towards the end of the evening the demand for tables at Le Jules Verne is not that big.
IT is because on the DONE4 you are allowed 2 piece per person and 30kg per piece, whereas on AF only 20Kgs.
But the AF route does save a lot of time...
For the Eiffel Tower, I did get in last time even without Centurion AMEX. I think towards the end of the evening the demand for tables at Le Jules Verne is not that big.
Where are you going after CDG? LON? Take the AF flight, enjoy 6 extra hours in Paris (you can dine instead of just having dessert), and treat yourself to a Eurostar premium cabin to LON.

