FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   oneworld (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/oneworld-411/)
-   -   IS this a valid AONE5 routing ex Africa (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/oneworld/1780634-valid-aone5-routing-ex-africa.html)

Dr. HFH Jul 31, 2016 8:45 am


Originally Posted by pandaperth (Post 26992746)
I have booked one with the AA ATW desk - it does backtrack through Europe/Middle East, but it does not have any flights between those two zones, which is what causes AA to refuse to price it.
MPM-xDOH-BKK ... ATL-LHR-MAD-DKR
My other ex-MPM itinerary (I have bought two) does not backtrack at all, so there was no problem there
MPM-xDOH-LHR-HEL-MAD-xDOH-ATL...SYD-JNB
...

Another way to ensure ticketing is to not have the backtrack to Europe in the itinerary. If your itinerary goes West around the world then you can return to Africa at the end with either HKG-JNB or SYD-JNB. Alternatively if your itinerary heads East then you can return to Africa at the end with GRU-JNB

Pandaperth, I'm not sure that I understand. (Actually, I'm quite certain that I don't.) So here are the two options I'm considering:
  • MPM-DOH-CDG-DOH-LHR-DOH-LAX-...-BKK-DOH-MPM
and
  • MPM-DOH-CDG-DOH-LHR-DOH-LAX-...-HKG-JNB
Are you saying that AA will ticket the second but not the first?

2old4coach Jul 31, 2016 9:17 am

Thanks Panda Perth and pdb456!
Just got hold of an experienced AA RTW desk person. What a pleasure!!!
He knew what he was talking about! In fact he was someone I booked a RTW with 10 years ago ( or 12??) ( have it in my notes)
As you said we can transit DOH IB and OB. A long as one is a transit only. Good news as I want to try the QR in F a380 from SYD or BKK to DOH. (The HKG is still Business class, and IMHO CX service has gone down hill in Business class, my last AA flight on an AA 77W had better service in Business class than my last CX MLE-HKG-SFO.)
Thanks for no flames for my very dumb, uninformed questions.
It did not sink in that I could change the routing for only$125!!
I have home work for today: READ THE RULES.
Thanks!

Cheers,
2old4coach

wijibintheair Jul 31, 2016 9:24 am


Originally Posted by Dr. HFH (Post 26993714)
Pandaperth, I'm not sure that I understand. (Actually, I'm quite certain that I don't.) So here are the two options I'm considering:
  • MPM-DOH-CDG-DOH-LHR-DOH-LAX-...-BKK-DOH-MPM
and
  • MPM-DOH-CDG-DOH-LHR-DOH-LAX-...-HKG-JNB
Are you saying that AA will ticket the second but not the first?

Yes, as far as I understand that seems to the the problem with AA (fare department not the booking department). They are still insisting on an old rule, that if you backtrack through Europe that there can be no flights between Europe and the Middle East included in the itinerary.

pandaperth Jul 31, 2016 1:09 pm


Originally Posted by Dr. HFH (Post 26993714)
Pandaperth, I'm not sure that I understand. (Actually, I'm quite certain that I don't.) So here are the two options I'm considering:
  • MPM-DOH-CDG-DOH-LHR-DOH-LAX-...-BKK-DOH-MPM
and
  • MPM-DOH-CDG-DOH-LHR-DOH-LAX-...-HKG-JNB
Are you saying that AA will ticket the second but not the first?

Yes, you understand me

Your second itinerary does NOT backtrack to Europe/Middle East and so AA's issues with what the backtrack restrictions are do not arise (you leave Africa with MPM-DOH, but return with HKG-JNB)

In contrast, your first itinerary does backtrack and so AA's interpretation is No Inter-zone Segments Allowed, and so your DOH-CDG-DOH-LHR-DOH segments will be disallowed (you leave Africa with DOH-MPM and return with DOH-MPM)

2old4coach Jul 31, 2016 3:18 pm

Dr. No at RTW
 
Hi All: The issue of MPM- Doh- west and return from west Doh-MPM was resolved with a RTW agent I know. However this Pm another agent I know always has issues with my routings seems to be picking up the RTW line all the time. I guess he is free because he does not complete bookings, in any event:

The One world tool had no problem processing a similar itinary originating in SYD ( but as we know quite expensive: 30K):

SYD x DFW-SCL-IPC-SCL-LAX-SFO-LHR-MUC-LHR-CDG-DOH-SYD. I ran the routing just to check the validity of the transit of North America with a stop over back in SFO.

However when I called the RTW line I got Dr. NO and he said that:
MPM x DOH-SYD x DFW-SCl-IPC-SCL-LAX-SFO-LHR-CDG-DOH x MPM was not valid. The MPM x DOH were fine but the North American transit into south America with a return to North America was invalid?? The rules say North America and South America are one continent and that 2 entries are OK if one is a transit. Did I misinterpret the rules? Several trips ago I transited MIA on the way to EZE and it was ok. Sara was the agent who booked it under the old rules. Has this changed?
Why does the ex SYD routing allow it? Is this the NEW Africa rule?? Sould I try again another day?

pandaperth Jul 31, 2016 7:08 pm


Originally Posted by 2old4coach (Post 26995066)
Hi All: The issue of MPM- Doh- west and return from west Doh-MPM was resolved with a RTW agent I know. However this Pm another agent I know always has issues with my routings seems to be picking up the RTW line all the time. I guess he is free because he does not complete bookings, in any event:

The One world tool had no problem processing a similar itinary originating in SYD ( but as we know quite expensive: 30K):

SYD x DFW-SCL-IPC-SCL-LAX-SFO-LHR-MUC-LHR-CDG-DOH-SYD. I ran the routing just to check the validity of the transit of North America with a stop over back in SFO.

However when I called the RTW line I got Dr. NO and he said that:
MPM x DOH-SYD x DFW-SCl-IPC-SCL-LAX-SFO-LHR-CDG-DOH x MPM was not valid. The MPM x DOH were fine but the North American transit into south America with a return to North America was invalid?? The rules say North America and South America are one continent and that 2 entries are OK if one is a transit. Did I misinterpret the rules? Several trips ago I transited MIA on the way to EZE and it was ok. Sara was the agent who booked it under the old rules. Has this changed?
Why does the ex SYD routing allow it? Is this the NEW Africa rule?? Sould I try again another day?

Yes, try again and hope to not get Dr No
There has been no change to the North America backtracking rule, and what you want to do there is valid (though your description is wrong - see below).

Your ex-MPM itinerary is valid IMHO but I would expect AA to reject it based on:
  • it backtracks to Europe/Middle East (MPM-DOH at the beginning and DOH-MPM at the end, therefore two visits to the continent of Europe/Middle East)
  • AND it has a segment between the Europe zone and the Middle East zone (CDG-DOH)
  • these are the circumstances that causes AA to reject it

North and South America are not one continent, each is a separate continent according to the rule sheet (Rule 0)
However the rule sheet allows a second visit to the continent of North America, provided one of the visits is a transfer without stopover (Rule 4(e) dot point 1)
So you are correct when you say your SYD-xDFW-SCL...SCL-LAX-SFO-LHR... is allowed: two visits to North America but one is a transfer without stopover

Dr. HFH Jul 31, 2016 7:22 pm


Originally Posted by pandaperth (Post 26994634)
Yes, you understand me

Your second itinerary does NOT backtrack to Europe/Middle East and so AA's issues with what the backtrack restrictions are do not arise (you leave Africa with MPM-DOH, but return with HKG-JNB)

In contrast, your first itinerary does backtrack and so AA's interpretation is No Inter-zone Segments Allowed, and so your DOH-CDG-DOH-LHR-DOH segments will be disallowed (you leave Africa with DOH-MPM and return with DOH-MPM)

BUT.... I was giving Mr. T the specific flights and dates, and he was checking availability as we went along. I got as far as MPM-DOH-CDG-DOH before he stopped me. He had no idea of what my return was at thatpoint in our conversation. Even when I explained it to him, he said that it doesn't matter. HUACA produced the same result.

2old4coach Jul 31, 2016 7:41 pm

Many Thanks
 

Originally Posted by pandaperth (Post 26995859)
Yes, try again and hope to not get Dr No
There has been no change to the North America backtracking rule, and what you want to do there is valid (though your description is wrong - see below).

Your ex-MPM itinerary is valid IMHO but I would expect AA to reject it based on:
  • it backtracks to Europe/Middle East (MPM-DOH at the beginning and DOH-MPM at the end, therefore two visits to the continent of Europe/Middle East)
  • AND it has a segment between the Europe zone and the Middle East zone (CDG-DOH)
  • these are the circumstances that causes AA to reject it

North and South America are not one continent, each is a separate continent according to the rule sheet (Rule 0)
However the rule sheet allows a second visit to the continent of North America, provided one of the visits is a transfer without stopover (Rule 4(e) dot point 1)
So you are correct when you say your SYD-xDFW-SCL...SCL-LAX-SFO-LHR... is allowed: two visits to North America but one is a transfer without stopover

I knew I should have avoided Dr. No. I will be rather upset if the price changes overnight! I think I will try this one: MPM x DOH-SYD x DFW-SCl-IPC-SCL-LAX-SFO-__domestic SFO______LHR-JNB.

After talking to Dr. No ( PM me for his name) I worked on this one also:
MPM X DOH-LHR-SCL-IPC ( Easter Island) -SCL-LAX-SFO-HKG-JNB.
Thanks for your help!

wijibintheair Aug 1, 2016 3:10 am

I suppose still too early in the day - but does anyone know if 1st August has triggered any price increase ex MPM?

Dr. HFH Aug 1, 2016 3:26 am


Originally Posted by wijibintheair (Post 26997083)
I suppose still too early in the day - but does anyone know if 1st August has triggered any price increase ex MPM?

Looks as though there is no fare increase today, at least not posted yet. EF shows slightly different fares from what was displayed yesterday, the difference being currency fluctuation. I can't recall precisely what yesterday's fares were, so I can't say whether they are slight increases or decreases.

JAXBA Aug 1, 2016 7:33 am


Originally Posted by Dr. HFH (Post 26997118)
Looks as though there is no fare increase today, at least not posted yet. EF shows slightly different fares from what was displayed yesterday, the difference being currency fluctuation. I can't recall precisely what yesterday's fares were, so I can't say whether they are slight increases or decreases.

From 22Jul:

Originally Posted by JAXBA (Post 26953257)
The D fares as currently stored in Amadeus, displayed in NUCs:

Code:

FQDMPMMPM/15NOV/VRW/ABA/CD/R,NUC
ROE 58.96300 UP TO 10.00 MZN                                                   
15NOV16**29NOV16/BA MPMMPM/NLX;RW/TPM ...../MPM .....                         
LN FARE BASIS    OW  NUC  RT  B PEN  DATES/DAYS  AP MIN MAX R               
01 DONE4                2752.57 D  -    -    -  @  @ -  12M@R               
02 DGLOB34              2752.57 D  -    -    -  @  @ -  12M@R               
03 DONE5                3137.56 D  -    -    -  @  @ -  12M@R               
04 DONE6                3815.95 D  -    -    -  @  @ -  12M@R               
>                                                PAGE  1/ 1

A DONE4 would be USD2753 plus TFCs, a DONE6 USD3816+

Other booking classes are similarly low...

As of today:
Code:

FQDMPMMPM/15NOV/VRW/ABA/CD/R,NUC
ROE 64.47800 UP TO 10.00 MZN                                                   
15NOV16**29NOV16/BA MPMMPM/NLX;RW/TPM ...../MPM .....                         
LN FARE BASIS    OW  NUC  RT  B PEN  DATES/DAYS  AP MIN MAX R               
01 DONE4                2517.13 D  -    -    -  @  @ -  12M@R               
02 DGLOB34              2517.13 D  -    -    -  @  @ -  12M@R               
03 DONE5                2869.19 D  -    -    -  @  @ -  12M@R               
04 DONE6                3489.56 D  -    -    -  @  @ -  12M@R               
>                                                PAGE  1/ 1

The NUCs have decreased some, but the MZN exchange rate has gone the other way, meaning a DONE4 is still MZN162300 - the fun part will be the MZN to your local currency... USD equivalent fares should see a small decrease...

pandaperth Aug 1, 2016 8:21 am


Originally Posted by JAXBA (Post 26997756)
From 22Jul:


As of today:
Code:

FQDMPMMPM/15NOV/VRW/ABA/CD/R,NUC
ROE 64.47800 UP TO 10.00 MZN                                                   
15NOV16**29NOV16/BA MPMMPM/NLX;RW/TPM ...../MPM .....                         
LN FARE BASIS    OW  NUC  RT  B PEN  DATES/DAYS  AP MIN MAX R               
01 DONE4                2517.13 D  -    -    -  @  @ -  12M@R               
02 DGLOB34              2517.13 D  -    -    -  @  @ -  12M@R               
03 DONE5                2869.19 D  -    -    -  @  @ -  12M@R               
04 DONE6                3489.56 D  -    -    -  @  @ -  12M@R               
>                                                PAGE  1/ 1

The NUCs have decreased some, but the MZN exchange rate has gone the other way, meaning a DONE4 is still MZN162300 - the fun part will be the MZN to your local currency... USD equivalent fares should see a small decrease...

Yes, the MZN continues its decline against the USD - this reflected in your before and after values for ROE in what you posted above
The ROE has declined from 58.963 on July 22nd to 64.478 today - that's a decline of >9% in a very short time.

Maybe the currency is heading towards Zimbabwe Dollar status. And today is actually the anniversary if that currency's final(?) demise - on July 31st 2008 the ZWD traded at a little under 19 billion to the USD. The very next day it collapsed to close to 66 billion to the USD (source xe.com).

Maybe I'll carry some hard currency when I visit next month;)

Dr. HFH Aug 1, 2016 9:44 am


Originally Posted by pandaperth (Post 26997952)
YAnd today is actually the anniversary if that currency's final(?) demise - on July 31st 2008 the ZWD traded at a little under 19 billion to the USD. The very next day it collapsed to close to 66 billion to the USD (source xe.com).

Would make for a pretty cheap AONE6.

christep Aug 1, 2016 10:00 am

I don't have EF these days - what are the AONEn fares ex-MPM?

pandaperth Aug 1, 2016 10:22 am


Originally Posted by christep (Post 26998402)
I don't have EF these days - what are the AONEn fares ex-MPM?

Using EF and XE

AONE4 is 264,500MZN = approx. 3,800USD
AONE5 is 304,500MZN = approx. 4,350USD
AONE6 is 365,000MZN = approx. 5,200USD


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 5:44 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.