Req. for Elite comp - does this have a chance?
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: May 2004
Location: MSP
Programs: NW Gold; HH Diamond; looking at SPG Blue card and sighing longingly
Posts: 63
Req. for Elite comp - does this have a chance?
Until recently, I've never done much business travel. Never earned elite on anyone or even come close. But in the last 6 weeks, I've done MSP-DEN on NWA 5 times. I'll probably do the same route another 25-30 times before '04 lets out, and another 30-40 times in '05.
The route yields a scuzzy 1386 EQM per RT, and I have no recreational travel planned until 12/04, so I need 14 more RT's (19 total) just to claw my way to Silver. In my humble, neophyte opinion, it's a TERRIBLE route for attaining status.
With UAL and Frtr. sitting in Denver, there is beaucoup competition on this route. I've just faxed in a request to NWA to consider my future travel needs and comp me elite status in order to ward off the competition. What are the odds NW will go for this? My guess is not good, given the airline's history of treating Minnesotans like conscripts.
Oh, and am I being a baby to think 19 RT's is a lot to earn Elite status?
Thanks,
TP
The route yields a scuzzy 1386 EQM per RT, and I have no recreational travel planned until 12/04, so I need 14 more RT's (19 total) just to claw my way to Silver. In my humble, neophyte opinion, it's a TERRIBLE route for attaining status.
With UAL and Frtr. sitting in Denver, there is beaucoup competition on this route. I've just faxed in a request to NWA to consider my future travel needs and comp me elite status in order to ward off the competition. What are the odds NW will go for this? My guess is not good, given the airline's history of treating Minnesotans like conscripts.
Oh, and am I being a baby to think 19 RT's is a lot to earn Elite status?
Thanks,
TP
#2


Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: RST
Programs: Delta Diamond; Hilton Diamond; Accor Gold
Posts: 4,844
TP,
Good luck with your request. Often NW will grant you status if you have status with another airline. They basically will offer a challenge (x number of return trip in so many weeks) and then comp you.
You are travelling a lot, but you are right that miles are few. Are these on any fares that give you segment credits? The higher the fares, the more "credits" NW will give you.
Good luck.
BTW, never hurts to ask NW to see what they will grant you. Let us know how it turns out.
Good luck with your request. Often NW will grant you status if you have status with another airline. They basically will offer a challenge (x number of return trip in so many weeks) and then comp you.
You are travelling a lot, but you are right that miles are few. Are these on any fares that give you segment credits? The higher the fares, the more "credits" NW will give you.
Good luck.
BTW, never hurts to ask NW to see what they will grant you. Let us know how it turns out.
#3
FlyerTalk Evangelist

Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Greener Pastures
Posts: 10,515
Originally Posted by TrivialPursuit
Oh, and am I being a baby to think 19 RT's is a lot to earn Elite status?
Welcome to Flyertalk!
#4
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Surf City, USA
Programs: DL-Dirt AA-Plat 0.1MM AMTK-Select IHG-Gold
Posts: 333
Have you considered Delta?
TP:
If you have flexability over your flight planning, you might want to consider taking a few of your MSP-DEN trips on Delta. You will earn 100% EQMs on Delta in all fare buckets and can "enjoy" their fine coach product. Think of the mileage possabilities: MSP-ATL-DEN, MSP-SLC-DEN, MSP-DFW-DEN, MSP-CVG-DEN.
Edited to add: Welcome to FlyerTalk!
If you have flexability over your flight planning, you might want to consider taking a few of your MSP-DEN trips on Delta. You will earn 100% EQMs on Delta in all fare buckets and can "enjoy" their fine coach product. Think of the mileage possabilities: MSP-ATL-DEN, MSP-SLC-DEN, MSP-DFW-DEN, MSP-CVG-DEN.
Edited to add: Welcome to FlyerTalk!
Last edited by NWAMileageSlave; May 7, 2004 at 1:39 pm Reason: Add a welcome message
#5
Original Poster
Join Date: May 2004
Location: MSP
Programs: NW Gold; HH Diamond; looking at SPG Blue card and sighing longingly
Posts: 63
You bet, I've considered Delta. But with so many direct flights available, it's hard to justify spending even more time in airports. My current "personal sanity" standard is that if DLT's price beats NWA's by 75 quid, I'll do the connecting itinerary. Hasn't happened yet, but unless NW surprises me and agrees to comp me to Elite, I'm sure my standards will drop and, I'll be spending some time in SLC and DFW this year.
Or I could do the DEN-LAX Triple EQM mileage run in between meetings
Thanks all, for the welcomes.
TP
Or I could do the DEN-LAX Triple EQM mileage run in between meetings

Thanks all, for the welcomes.
TP
#6
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: Arizona
Programs: MSP raised, Elite since age 17
Posts: 4,723
Consider this:
MSP--LAX is running $99 round trip.
LAX--DEN is running around $100 round trip.
LAX--DEN is giving triple elite mileage
You could fly from MSP--LAX--DEN and back for a bit over $200 per round trip and yield some 4000 elite miles each way.... at 8k elite miles per RT, you'll get to Gold/Plat in no time.
Note the triple mileage promo and the $100ish fares won't last forever--- but if your trip dates are fixed, you may want to buy tickets and plan ahead right now.
Good luck!!
MSP--LAX is running $99 round trip.
LAX--DEN is running around $100 round trip.
LAX--DEN is giving triple elite mileage
You could fly from MSP--LAX--DEN and back for a bit over $200 per round trip and yield some 4000 elite miles each way.... at 8k elite miles per RT, you'll get to Gold/Plat in no time.
Note the triple mileage promo and the $100ish fares won't last forever--- but if your trip dates are fixed, you may want to buy tickets and plan ahead right now.
Good luck!!
#7

Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: Land of 10,000 Upgrades
Posts: 9,459
Originally Posted by Viajero Joven
Consider this:
MSP--LAX is running $99 round trip.
LAX--DEN is running around $100 round trip.
LAX--DEN is giving triple elite mileage
You could fly from MSP--LAX--DEN and back for a bit over $200 per round trip and yield some 4000 elite miles each way.... at 8k elite miles per RT, you'll get to Gold/Plat in no time.
MSP--LAX is running $99 round trip.
LAX--DEN is running around $100 round trip.
LAX--DEN is giving triple elite mileage
You could fly from MSP--LAX--DEN and back for a bit over $200 per round trip and yield some 4000 elite miles each way.... at 8k elite miles per RT, you'll get to Gold/Plat in no time.
#8
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Placentia, CA., USA
Posts: 222
And the terms and conditon of the LAX to DEN promotion states that "Travel on flights between Los Angeles and Denver that include a connection from another flight do not qualify for this promotion. Example, MSP-DEN-LAX itinerary does not qualify.
However, Viajero Joven might have been suggesting the following:
If you want to earn 11,238 miles for $276.40 you can register for the new route promotions on nwa.com - one is from MSP to LAX (double miles) and the one from LAX to DEN (triple miles.) Each ticket is $138.20 if you return to MSP on Monday (if you return on Sunday, the MSP-LAX fare is $158.20).
Example Itinerary:
Friday, June 4 Ticket #1
Lv MSP 7:05 a.m.
Ar LAX 8:52 a.m.
Lv LAX 11:45 a.m. Ticket #2
Ar DEN 2:51 p.m.
Sunday, June 6
Lv DEN 4:00 p.m. Ticket #2
Ar LAX 5:19 p.m.
Monday, June 7
Lv LAX 3:45 p.m. Ticket #1
Ar MSP 9:11 p.m.
Play around with the dates. Register and buy your tickets by May 31 and travel by June 30.
However, Viajero Joven might have been suggesting the following:
If you want to earn 11,238 miles for $276.40 you can register for the new route promotions on nwa.com - one is from MSP to LAX (double miles) and the one from LAX to DEN (triple miles.) Each ticket is $138.20 if you return to MSP on Monday (if you return on Sunday, the MSP-LAX fare is $158.20).
Example Itinerary:
Friday, June 4 Ticket #1
Lv MSP 7:05 a.m.
Ar LAX 8:52 a.m.
Lv LAX 11:45 a.m. Ticket #2
Ar DEN 2:51 p.m.
Sunday, June 6
Lv DEN 4:00 p.m. Ticket #2
Ar LAX 5:19 p.m.
Monday, June 7
Lv LAX 3:45 p.m. Ticket #1
Ar MSP 9:11 p.m.
Play around with the dates. Register and buy your tickets by May 31 and travel by June 30.
Last edited by YesHyM; May 7, 2004 at 6:25 pm Reason: Found another solution
#9

Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: Land of 10,000 Upgrades
Posts: 9,459
Originally Posted by YesHyM
And the terms and conditon of the LAX to DEN promotion states that "Travel on flights between Los Angeles and Denver that include a connection from another flight do not qualify for this promotion. Example, MSP-DEN-LAX itinerary does not qualify.
However, Viajero Joven might have been suggesting the following:
If you want to earn 11,238 miles for $276.40 you can register for the new route promotions on nwa.com - one is from MSP to LAX (double miles) and the one from LAX to DEN (triple miles.) Each ticket is $138.20 if you return to MSP on Monday (if you return on Sunday, the MSP-LAX fare is $158.20).
Example Itinerary:
Friday, June 4 Ticket #1
Lv MSP 7:05 a.m.
Ar LAX 8:52 a.m.
Lv LAX 11:45 a.m. Ticket #2
Ar DEN 2:51 p.m.
Sunday, June 6
Lv DEN 4:00 p.m. Ticket #2
Ar LAX 5:19 p.m.
Monday, June 7
Lv LAX 3:45 p.m. Ticket #1
Ar MSP 9:11 p.m.
Play around with the dates. Register and buy your tickets by May 31 and travel by June 30.
However, Viajero Joven might have been suggesting the following:
If you want to earn 11,238 miles for $276.40 you can register for the new route promotions on nwa.com - one is from MSP to LAX (double miles) and the one from LAX to DEN (triple miles.) Each ticket is $138.20 if you return to MSP on Monday (if you return on Sunday, the MSP-LAX fare is $158.20).
Example Itinerary:
Friday, June 4 Ticket #1
Lv MSP 7:05 a.m.
Ar LAX 8:52 a.m.
Lv LAX 11:45 a.m. Ticket #2
Ar DEN 2:51 p.m.
Sunday, June 6
Lv DEN 4:00 p.m. Ticket #2
Ar LAX 5:19 p.m.
Monday, June 7
Lv LAX 3:45 p.m. Ticket #1
Ar MSP 9:11 p.m.
Play around with the dates. Register and buy your tickets by May 31 and travel by June 30.
And what I am telling you, based on personal experience, is that the June 4 travel would earn neither MSP-LAX double miles nor LAX-DEN triple miles under NW's definition of a "connectiion."
#10
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: MSP - UA 1k, NW Gold, Starwood Gold, Hilton Gold, Marriott Silver
Posts: 93
Originally Posted by TrivialPursuit
The route yields a scuzzy 1386 EQM per RT, and I have no recreational travel planned until 12/04, so I need 14 more RT's (19 total) just to claw my way to Silver. In my humble, neophyte opinion, it's a TERRIBLE route for attaining status.
Oh, and am I being a baby to think 19 RT's is a lot to earn Elite status?
Oh, and am I being a baby to think 19 RT's is a lot to earn Elite status?
#11
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: LGB
Programs: DL DM
Posts: 390
no segments on discount fares
Originally Posted by nomod
It doesn't take 19 RTs to earn elite status - just do it by segments.
#12

Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: Land of 10,000 Upgrades
Posts: 9,459
The definitive answer from NW:
Dear UpgradeMe,
Thank you for contacting Northwest Airlines.
A connection is a flight segment connecting to another flight segment
the same day. Per the rules, the LAX/DEN/LAX must make up the entire
itinerary to qualify for bonus mileage.
Thank you for choosing Northwest/KLM Airlines. We appreciate your
business.
Sincerely,
Susan Curtis
Executive Assistant
Original Message Follows:
-------------------------
Ms. Curtis:
Please do me the courtesy of defining a "connection" for purposes of the
LAXDEN promo. Is it two hours? Four hours? Six hours? Any onward
flight the
same day? Some other definition?
Thank you.
UpgradeMe
Dear UpgradeMe,
Thank you for contacting Northwest Airlines.
A connection is a flight segment connecting to another flight segment
the same day. Per the rules, the LAX/DEN/LAX must make up the entire
itinerary to qualify for bonus mileage.
Thank you for choosing Northwest/KLM Airlines. We appreciate your
business.
Sincerely,
Susan Curtis
Executive Assistant
Original Message Follows:
-------------------------
Ms. Curtis:
Please do me the courtesy of defining a "connection" for purposes of the
LAXDEN promo. Is it two hours? Four hours? Six hours? Any onward
flight the
same day? Some other definition?
Thank you.
UpgradeMe
#13
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: NY, NY;
Programs: DL GM
Posts: 135
aa has a challenge 5k for gold and 10k for platinum. If you can fly AA on several of trips you can get status and NW will match. This seems your fastest bet although if you have other destinations they may be better on aa. MSP > den on aa is quite circuitous.
#14
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: NY, NY;
Programs: DL GM
Posts: 135
another thought would be to fly UA but have miles credited to USair. With 10k prefffered bonus you can get in early 05 for spending 25k on a USair visa you could get silver with them with a few less flights. I don't know if NW will match this particular program however.
#15
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 21
So if I flew MSP-LAX, LAX-MSP, within two hours of each other in the same day, is the second segment considered a connecting flight, voiding me of the double miles bonus?

